High-throughput screens identify a lipid nanoparticle that preferentially delivers mRNA to human tumors in vivo.

Lipid nanoparticles (LNPs) are a clinically relevant way to deliver therapeutic mRNA to hepatocytes in patients. However, LNP-mRNA delivery to end-stage solid tumors such as head and neck squamous cell carcinoma (HNSCC) remains more challenging. While scientists have used in vitro assays to evaluate potential nanoparticles for HNSCC delivery, high-throughput delivery assays performed directly in vivo have not been reported. Here we use a high-throughput LNP assay to evaluate how 94 chemically distinct nanoparticles delivered nucleic acids to HNSCC solid tumors in vivo. DNA barcodes were used to identify LNPHNSCC, a novel LNP for systemic delivery to HNSCC solid tumors. Importantly, LNPHNSCC retains tropism to HNSCC solid tumors while minimizing off-target delivery to the liver.

Nanoparticle stereochemistry-dependent endocytic processing improves in vivo mRNA delivery.

Stereochemistry can alter small-molecule pharmacokinetics, safety and efficacy. However, it is unclear whether the stereochemistry of a single compound within a multicomponent colloid such as a lipid nanoparticle (LNP) can influence its activity in vivo. Here we report that LNPs containing stereopure 20α-hydroxycholesterol (20α) delivered mRNA to liver cells up to 3-fold more potently than LNPs containing a mixture of both 20α- and 20ß-hydroxycholesterols (20mix). This effect was not driven by LNP physiochemical traits. Instead, in vivo single-cell RNA sequencing and imaging revealed that 20mix LNPs were sorted into phagocytic pathways more than 20α LNPs, resulting in key differences between LNP biodistribution and subsequent LNP functional delivery. These data are consistent with the fact that nanoparticle biodistribution is necessary, but not sufficient, for mRNA delivery, and that stereochemistry-dependent interactions between LNPs and target cells can improve mRNA delivery.

The Transcriptional Response to Lung-Targeting Lipid Nanoparticles in Vivo.

Lipid nanoparticles (LNPs) have delivered RNA to hepatocytes in patients, underscoring the potential impact of nonliver delivery. Scientists can shift LNP tropism to the lung by adding cationic helper lipids; however, the biological response to these LNPs remains understudied. To evaluate the hypothesis that charged LNPs lead to differential cellular responses, we quantified how 137 LNPs delivered mRNA to 19 cell types in vivo. Consistent with previous studies, we observed helper lipid-dependent tropism. After identifying and individually characterizing three LNPs that targeted different tissues, we studied the in vivo transcriptomic response to these using single-cell RNA sequencing. Out of 835 potential pathways, 27 were upregulated in the lung, and of these 27, 19 were related to either RNA or protein metabolism. These data suggest that endogenous cellular RNA and protein machinery affects mRNA delivery to the lung in vivo.

Substituting racemic ionizable lipids with stereopure ionizable lipids can increase mRNA delivery.

Lipid nanoparticles (LNPs) have delivered siRNA and mRNA drugs in humans, underscoring the potential impact of improving the therapeutic window of next-generation LNPs. To increase the LNP therapeutic window, we applied lessons from small-molecule chemistry to ionizable lipid design. Specifically, given that stereochemistry often influences small-molecule safety and pharmacokinetics, we hypothesized that the stereochemistry of lipids within an LNP would influence mRNA delivery. We tested this hypothesis in vivo using 128 novel LNPs that included stereopure derivatives of C12-200, an ionizable lipid that when formulated into LNPs delivers RNA in mice and non-human primates but is not used clinically due to its poor tolerability. We found that a novel C12-200-S LNP delivered up to 2.8-fold and 6.1-fold more mRNA in vivo than its racemic and C12-200-R controls, respectively. To identify the potential causes leading to increased delivery, we quantified LNP biophysical traits and concluded that these did not change with stereochemistry. Instead, we found that stereopure LNPs were better tolerated than racemic LNPs in vivo. These data suggest that LNP-mediated mRNA delivery can be improved by designing LNPs to include stereopure ionizable lipids.

The Extent to Which Lipid Nanoparticles Require Apolipoprotein E and Low-Density Lipoprotein Receptor for Delivery Changes with Ionizable Lipid Structure.

Lipid nanoparticles (LNPs) have delivered therapeutic RNA to hepatocytes in humans. Adsorption of apolipoprotein E (ApoE) onto these clinical LNP-mRNA drugs has been shown to facilitate hepatocyte entry via the low-density lipoprotein receptor (LDLR). Since ApoE-LDLR trafficking is conserved in mice, non-human primates, and humans, characterizing this mechanism eased clinical transition. Recently, LNPs have delivered mRNA to non-hepatocytes in mice and non-human primates, suggesting they can target new cell types via ApoE- and LDLR-independent pathways. To test this hypothesis, we quantified how 60 LNPs delivered mRNA with cell type resolution in wild-type mice and three knockout mouse strains related to lipid trafficking: ApoE-/-, LDLR-/-, and PCSK9-/-. These data suggest that the hydrophobic tail length of diketopiperazine-based lipids can be changed to drive ApoE- and LDLR-independent delivery in vivo. More broadly, the results support the hypothesis that endogenous LNP trafficking can be tuned by modifying lipid chemistry.

Piperazine-derived lipid nanoparticles deliver mRNA to immune cells in vivo.

In humans, lipid nanoparticles (LNPs) have safely delivered therapeutic RNA to hepatocytes after systemic administration and to antigen-presenting cells after intramuscular injection. However, systemic RNA delivery to non-hepatocytes remains challenging, especially without targeting ligands such as antibodies, peptides, or aptamers. Here we report that piperazine-containing ionizable lipids (Pi-Lipids) preferentially deliver mRNA to immune cells in vivo without targeting ligands. After synthesizing and characterizing Pi-Lipids, we use high-throughput DNA barcoding to quantify how 65 chemically distinct LNPs functionally delivered mRNA (i.e., mRNA translated into functional, gene-editing protein) in 14 cell types directly in vivo. By analyzing the relationships between lipid structure and cellular targeting, we identify lipid traits that increase delivery in vivo. In addition, we characterize Pi-A10, an LNP that preferentially delivers mRNA to the liver and splenic immune cells at the clinically relevant dose of 0.3 mg/kg. These data demonstrate that high-throughput in vivo studies can identify nanoparticles with natural non-hepatocyte tropism and support the hypothesis that lipids with bioactive small-molecule motifs can deliver mRNA in vivo.

Nanoparticle single-cell multiomic readouts reveal that cell heterogeneity influences lipid nanoparticle-mediated messenger RNA delivery.

Cells that were previously described as homogeneous are composed of subsets with distinct transcriptional states. However, it remains unclear whether this cell heterogeneity influences the efficiency with which lipid nanoparticles (LNPs) deliver messenger RNA therapies in vivo. To test the hypothesis that cell heterogeneity influences LNP-mediated mRNA delivery, we report here a new multiomic nanoparticle delivery system called single-cell nanoparticle targeting-sequencing (SENT-seq). SENT-seq quantifies how dozens of LNPs deliver DNA barcodes and mRNA into cells, the subsequent protein production and the transcriptome, with single-cell resolution. Using SENT-seq, we have identified cell subtypes that exhibit particularly high or low LNP uptake as well as genes associated with those subtypes. The data suggest that cell subsets have distinct responses to LNPs that may affect mRNA therapies.

Species-dependent in vivo mRNA delivery and cellular responses to nanoparticles.

Nanoparticles are tested in mice and non-human primates before being selected for clinical trials. Yet the extent to which mRNA delivery, as well as the cellular response to mRNA drug delivery vehicles, is conserved across species in vivo is unknown. Using a species-independent DNA barcoding system, we have compared how 89 lipid nanoparticles deliver mRNA in mice with humanized livers, primatized livers and four controls: mice with 'murinized' livers as well as wild-type BL/6, Balb/C and NZB/BlNJ mice. We assessed whether functional delivery results in murine, non-human primate and human hepatocytes can be used to predict delivery in the other species in vivo. By analysing in vivo hepatocytes by RNA sequencing, we identified species-dependent responses to lipid nanoparticles, including mRNA translation and endocytosis. These data support an evidence-based approach to making small-animal preclinical nanoparticle studies more predictive, thereby accelerating the development of RNA therapies.

Augmented lipid-nanoparticle-mediated in vivo genome editing in the lungs and spleen by disrupting Cas9 activity in the liver.

Systemically delivered lipid nanoparticles are preferentially taken up by hepatocytes. This hinders the development of effective, non-viral means of editing genes in tissues other than the liver. Here we show that lipid-nanoparticle-mediated gene editing in the lung and spleen of adult mice can be enhanced by reducing Cas9-mediated insertions and deletions in hepatocytes via oligonucleotides disrupting the secondary structure of single-guide RNAs (sgRNAs) and also via their combination with short interfering RNA (siRNA) targeting Cas9 messenger RNA (mRNA). In SpCas9 mice with acute lung inflammation, the systemic delivery of an oligonucleotide inhibiting an sgRNA targeting the intercellular adhesion molecule 2 (ICAM-2), followed by the delivery of the sgRNA, reduced the fraction of ICAM-2 indels in hepatocytes and increased that in lung endothelial cells. In wild-type mice, the lipid-nanoparticle-mediated delivery of an inhibitory oligonucleotide, followed by the delivery of Cas9-degrading siRNA and then by Cas9 mRNA and sgRNA, reduced the fraction of ICAM-2 indels in hepatocytes but not in splenic endothelial cells. Inhibitory oligonucleotides and siRNAs could be used to modulate the cell-type specificity of Cas9 therapies.

Optimization of lipid nanoparticles for the delivery of nebulized therapeutic mRNA to the lungs.

Lipid nanoparticles (LNPs) for the efficient delivery of drugs need to be designed for the particular administration route and type of drug. Here we report the design of LNPs for the efficient delivery of therapeutic RNAs to the lung via nebulization. We optimized the composition, molar ratios and structure of LNPs made of lipids, neutral or cationic helper lipids and poly(ethylene glycol) (PEG) by evaluating the performance of LNPs belonging to six clusters occupying extremes in chemical space, and then pooling the lead clusters and expanding their diversity. We found that a low (high) molar ratio of PEG improves the performance of LNPs with neutral (cationic) helper lipids, an identified and optimal LNP for low-dose messenger RNA delivery. Nebulized delivery of an mRNA encoding a broadly neutralizing antibody targeting haemagglutinin via the optimized LNP protected mice from a lethal challenge of the H1N1 subtype of influenza A virus, and delivered mRNA more efficiently than LNPs previously optimized for systemic delivery. A cluster approach to LNP design may facilitate the optimization of LNPs for other administration routes and therapeutics.

Therapeutic RNA Delivery for COVID and Other Diseases.

RNA can alter the expression of endogenous genes and can be used to express therapeutic proteins. As a result, RNA-based therapies have recently mitigated disease in patients. Yet most potential RNA therapies cannot currently be developed, in large part because delivering therapeutic quantities of RNA drugs to diseased cells remains difficult. Here, recent studies focused on the biological hurdles that make in vivo drug delivery challenging are described. Then RNA drugs that have overcome these challenges in humans, focusing on siRNA to treat liver disease and mRNA to vaccinate against COVID, are discussed. Finally, research centered on improving drug delivery to new tissues is highlighted, including the development of high-throughput in vivo nanoparticle DNA barcoding assays capable of testing over 100 distinct nanoparticles in a single animal.

Nanoparticles containing constrained phospholipids deliver mRNA to liver immune cells in vivo without targeting ligands.

Once inside the cytoplasm of a cell, mRNA can be used to treat disease by upregulating the expression of any gene. Lipid nanoparticles (LNPs) can deliver mRNA to hepatocytes in humans, yet systemic non-hepatocyte delivery at clinical doses remains difficult. We noted that LNPs have historically been formulated with phospholipids containing unconstrained alkyl tails. Based on evidence that constrained adamantyl groups have unique properties that can improve small molecule drug delivery, we hypothesized that a phospholipid containing an adamantyl group would facilitate mRNA delivery in vivo. We quantified how 109 LNPs containing "constrained phospholipids" delivered mRNA to 16 cell types in mice, then using a DNA barcoding-based analytical pipeline, related phospholipid structure to in vivo delivery. By analyzing delivery mediated by constrained phospholipids, we identified a novel LNP that delivers mRNA to immune cells at 0.5 mg/kg. Unlike many previous LNPs, these (a) did not preferentially target hepatocytes and (b) delivered mRNA to immune cells without targeting ligands. These data suggest constrained phospholipids may be useful LNP components.

Mild Innate Immune Activation Overrides Efficient Nanoparticle-Mediated RNA Delivery.

Clinical mRNA delivery remains challenging, in large part because how physiology alters delivery in vivo remains underexplored. For example, mRNA delivered by lipid nanoparticles (LNPs) is being considered to treat inflammation, but whether inflammation itself changes delivery remains understudied. Relationships between immunity, endocytosis, and mRNA translation lead to hypothesize that toll-like receptor 4 (TLR4) activation reduced LNP-mediated mRNA delivery. Therefore, LNP uptake, endosomal escape, and mRNA translation with and without TLR4 activation are quantified. In vivo DNA barcoding is used to discover a novel LNP that delivers mRNA to Kupffer cells at clinical doses; unlike most LNPs, this LNP does not preferentially target hepatocytes. TLR4 activation blocks mRNA translation in all tested cell types, without reducing LNP uptake; inhibiting TLR4 or its downstream effector protein kinase R improved delivery. The discrepant effects of TLR4 on i) LNP uptake and ii) translation suggests TLR4 activation can "override" LNP targeting, even after mRNA is delivered into target cells. Given near-future clinical trials using mRNA to modulate inflammation, this highlights the need to understand inflammatory signaling in on- and off-target cells. More generally, this suggests an LNP which delivers mRNA to one inflammatory disease may not deliver mRNA to another.

Cell Subtypes Within the Liver Microenvironment Differentially Interact with Lipid Nanoparticles.

INTRODUCTION: Lipid nanoparticles (LNPs) tend to accumulate in the liver due to physiological factors. Whereas the biological mechanisms that promote LNP delivery to hepatocytes have been reported, the mechanisms that promote delivery to other cell types within the liver microenvironment are poorly understood. Single cell profiling studies have recently identified subsets of Kupffer cells and hepatic endothelial cells with distinct gene expression patterns and biological phenotypes; we hypothesized these subtypes would differentially interact with nanoparticles. METHODS: To test the hypothesis, we quantified nucleic acid (i) biodistribution and (ii) functional mRNA delivery within the liver microenvironment using two clinically relevant LNPs in vivo. RESULTS: We found that these LNPs distribute nucleic acids distribute to Kupffer cells and liver endothelial cells as efficiently as they distribute to hepatocytes, yet result in more functional mRNA delivery to endothelial cells. Additionally, we found these LNPs differentially accumulate in Kupffer and endothelial cell subsets. CONCLUSIONS: These data suggest subsets of liver microenvironmental cells can differentially interact with nanoparticles in vivo, thereby altering LNP delivery. More generally, the data suggest that nucleic acid biodistribution is not sufficient to predict functional nucleic acid delivery in vivo.

Constrained Nanoparticles Deliver siRNA and sgRNA to T Cells In Vivo without Targeting Ligands.

T cells help regulate immunity, which makes them an important target for RNA therapies. While nanoparticles carrying RNA have been directed to T cells in vivo using protein- and aptamer-based targeting ligands, systemic delivery to T cells without targeting ligands remains challenging. Given that T cells endocytose lipoprotein particles and enveloped viruses, two natural systems with structures that can be similar to lipid nanoparticles (LNPs), it is hypothesized that LNPs devoid of targeting ligands can deliver RNA to T cells in vivo. To test this hypothesis, the delivery of siRNA to 9 cell types in vivo by 168 nanoparticles using a novel siGFP-based barcoding system and bioinformatics is quantified. It is found that nanomaterials containing conformationally constrained lipids form stable LNPs, herein named constrained lipid nanoparticles (cLNPs). cLNPs deliver siRNA and sgRNA to T cells at doses as low as 0.5 mg kg-1 and, unlike previously reported LNPs, do not preferentially target hepatocytes. Delivery occurs via a chemical composition-dependent, size-independent mechanism. These data suggest that the degree to which lipids are constrained alters nanoparticle targeting, and also suggest that natural lipid trafficking pathways can promote T cell delivery, offering an alternative to active targeting approaches.

Nanoparticles Containing Oxidized Cholesterol Deliver mRNA to the Liver Microenvironment at Clinically Relevant Doses.

Using mRNA to produce therapeutic proteins is a promising approach to treat genetic diseases. However, systemically delivering mRNA to cell types besides hepatocytes remains challenging. Fast identification of nanoparticle delivery (FIND) is a DNA barcode-based system designed to measure how over 100 lipid nanoparticles (LNPs) deliver mRNA that functions in the cytoplasm of target cells in a single mouse. By using FIND to quantify how 75 chemically distinct LNPs delivered mRNA to 28 cell types in vivo, it is found that an LNP formulated with oxidized cholesterol and no targeting ligand delivers Cre mRNA, which edits DNA in hepatic endothelial cells and Kupffer cells at 0.05 mg kg-1 . Notably, the LNP targets liver microenvironmental cells fivefold more potently than hepatocytes. The structure of the oxidized cholesterols added to the LNP is systematically varied to show that the position of the oxidative modification may be important; cholesterols modified on the hydrocarbon tail associated with sterol ring D tend to outperform cholesterols modified on sterol ring B. These data suggest that LNPs formulated with modified cholesterols can deliver gene-editing mRNA to the liver microenvironment at clinically relevant doses.

Nanoparticles That Deliver RNA to Bone Marrow Identified by in Vivo Directed Evolution.

Bone marrow endothelial cells (BMECs) regulate their microenvironment, which includes hematopoietic stem cells. This makes BMECs an important target cell type for siRNA or gene editing (e.g., CRISPR) therapies. However, siRNA and sgRNA have not been delivered to BMECs using systemically administered nanoparticles. Given that in vitro nanoparticle screens have not identified nanoparticles with BMEC tropism, we developed a system to quantify how >100 different nanoparticles deliver siRNA in a single mouse. This is the first barcoding system capable of quantifying functional cytosolic siRNA delivery (where the siRNA drug is active), distinguishing it from in vivo screens that quantify biodistribution (where the siRNA drug went). Combining this approach with bioinformatics, we performed in vivo directed evolution, and identified BM1, a lipid nanoparticle (LNP) that delivers siRNA and sgRNA to BMECs. Interestingly, chemical analysis revealed BMEC tropism was not related to LNP size; tropism changed with the structure of poly(ethylene glycol), as well as the presence of cholesterol. These results suggest that significant changes to vascular targeting can be imparted to a LNP by making simple changes to its chemical composition, rather than using active targeting ligands. BM1 is the first nanoparticle to efficiently deliver siRNA and sgRNA to BMECs in vivo, demonstrating that this functional in vivo screen can identify nanoparticles with novel tropism in vivo. More generally, in vivo screening may help reveal the complex relationship between nanoparticle structure and tropism, thereby helping scientists understand how simple chemical changes control nanoparticle targeting.

High-throughput in vivo screen of functional mRNA delivery identifies nanoparticles for endothelial cell gene editing.

Dysfunctional endothelium causes more disease than any other cell type. Systemically administered RNA delivery to nonliver tissues remains challenging, in large part because there is no high-throughput method to identify nanoparticles that deliver functional mRNA to cells in vivo. Here we report a system capable of simultaneously quantifying how >100 lipid nanoparticles (LNPs) deliver mRNA that is translated into functional protein. Using this system (named FIND), we measured how >250 LNPs delivered mRNA to multiple cell types in vivo and identified 7C2 and 7C3, two LNPs that efficiently deliver siRNA, single-guide RNA (sgRNA), and mRNA to endothelial cells. The 7C3 delivered Cas9 mRNA and sgRNA to splenic endothelial cells as efficiently as hepatocytes, distinguishing it from LNPs that deliver Cas9 mRNA and sgRNA to hepatocytes more than other cell types. These data demonstrate that FIND can identify nanoparticles with novel tropisms in vivo.

Modifying a Commonly Expressed Endocytic Receptor Retargets Nanoparticles in Vivo.

Nanoparticles are often targeted to receptors expressed on specific cells, but few receptors are (i) highly expressed on one cell type and (ii) involved in endocytosis. One unexplored alternative is manipulating an endocytic gene expressed on multiple cell types; an ideal gene would inhibit delivery to cell type A more than cell type B, promoting delivery to cell type B. This would require a commonly expressed endocytic gene to alter nanoparticle delivery in a cell type-dependent manner in vivo; whether this can occur is unknown. Based on its microenvironmental regulation, we hypothesized Caveolin 1 (Cav1) would exert cell type-specific effects on nanoparticle delivery. Fluorescence was not sensitive enough to investigate this question, and as a result, we designed a platform named QUANT to study nanoparticle biodistribution. QUANT is 108× more sensitive than fluorescence and can be multiplexed. By measuring how 226 lipid nanoparticles (LNPs) delivered nucleic acids to multiple cell types in vivo in wild-type and Cav1 knockout mice, we found Cav1 altered delivery in a cell-type specific manner. Cav1 knockout did not alter LNP delivery to lung and kidney macrophages but substantially reduced LNP delivery to Kupffer cells, which are liver-resident macrophages. These data suggest caveolin-mediated endocytosis of nanomedicines by macrophages varies with tissue type. These results suggest manipulating receptors expressed on multiple cell types can tune drug delivery.

Analyzing 2000 in Vivo Drug Delivery Data Points Reveals Cholesterol Structure Impacts Nanoparticle Delivery.

Lipid nanoparticles (LNPs) are formulated using unmodified cholesterol. However, cholesterol is naturally esterified and oxidized in vivo, and these cholesterol variants are differentially trafficked in vivo via lipoproteins including LDL and VLDL. We hypothesized that incorporating the same cholesterol variants into LNPs-which can be structurally similar to LDL and VLDL-would alter nanoparticle targeting in vivo. To test this hypothesis, we quantified how >100 LNPs made with six cholesterol variants delivered DNA barcodes to 18 cell types in wild-type, LDLR-/-, and VLDLR-/- mice that were both age-matched and female. By analyzing ∼2000 in vivo drug delivery data points, we found that LNPs formulated with esterified cholesterol delivered nucleic acids more efficiently than LNPs formulated with regular or oxidized cholesterol when compared across all tested cell types in the mouse. We also identified an LNP containing cholesteryl oleate that efficiently delivered siRNA and sgRNA to liver endothelial cells in vivo. Delivery was as-or more-efficient as the same LNP made with unmodified cholesterol. Moreover, delivery to liver endothelial cells was 3 times more efficient than delivery to hepatocytes, distinguishing this oleate LNP from hepatocyte-targeting LNPs. RNA delivery can be improved by rationally selecting cholesterol variants, allowing optimization of nanoparticle targeting.