Exploratory assessment of dose proportionality: review of current approaches and proposal for a practical criterion.

This article reviews currently used approaches for establishing dose proportionality in Phase I dose escalation studies. A review of relevant literature between 2002 and 2006 found that the power model was the preferred choice for assessing dose proportionality in about one-third of the articles. This article promotes the use of the power model and a conceptually appealing extension, i.e. a criterion based on comparing the 90% confidence interval for the ratio of predicted mean values from the extremes of the dose range (R(dnm)) to pre-defined equivalence criterion (theta(L),theta(U)). The choice of bioequivalence default values of theta(L)=0.8 and theta(U)=1.25 seems reasonable for dose levels only a doubling apart but are impractically strict when applied over the complete dose range. Power calculations are used to show that this prescribed criterion lacks power to conclude dose proportionality in typical Phase I dose-escalation studies. A more lenient criterion with values theta(L)=0.5 and theta(U)=2 is proposed for exploratory dose proportionality assessments across the complete dose range.

Respiratory function in rats restrained for extended periods: assessment of the effects of bethanecol.

INTRODUCTION: The ICH guideline S7A recommends that the effects of drugs on the respiratory system are evaluated in laboratory mammals prior to administration in man. Previously, animals have been placed in plethysmography chambers for short durations. This study investigates the possibility of restraining animals in chambers for a longer duration to assess respiratory function over extended periods. METHODS: Respiratory function in conscious rats was assessed using plethysmography chambers where the rat body was enclosed in a sealed chamber while the head was free. Thoracic movements were measured by pressure transducers linked to a Buxco amplifier system and respiratory parameters were captured and analyzed by the Notocord HEM data acquisition system. Each animal was subjected to 5 acclimatization sessions of escalating duration (1, 2, 4, 5, and 6 hours (h)) over 5 days prior to testing, with a baseline recording session conducted the day prior to dosing. Animals (8 males/group) were dosed subcutaneously with saline or bethanecol (3, 10, or 30 mg/kg) and placed in the chambers for 6 h of continuous recording. Additionally, a recording session was conducted at 24 h post-dose. RESULTS: Subcutaneous administration of 30 mg/kg bethanecol decreased respiration rate by up to 33% during the first 1.5 h post-dose and increased tidal volume by up to 46% from 0.25 to 1.25 h post-dose when compared to vehicle group data. A decrease in minute volume of up to 33% was observed 0.25 h following administration of the 10 and 30 mg/kg doses. DISCUSSION: These data show a respiratory depression caused by the cholinergic agonist bethanecol, an effect partially compensated for by an increase in tidal volume. This also demonstrates the ability to continuously restrain and record respiratory parameters in conscious rats for up to 6 h without any negative impact on the quality of the data.