Recombination of replicon and helper RNAs and the emergence of propagation-competent vectors upon Sindbis virus vector production.

Sindbis vectors have shown remarkable antitumor efficacy and tumor-targeting capacity in animal models and hold promise for cancer therapy. Different packaging systems are used to produce propagation-incompetent Sindbis vectors. However, the vectors produced using either DH-BB single helper RNA or split helper RNA can spread in permissive cell cultures. We investigated the mechanisms of vector spreading and show, here, that recombination occurs between the replicon and DH-BB helper RNA, leading to formation of the full-length virus genome. Split helper RNA may not completely prevent wild-type reversion, although the frequency is greatly reduced. Contrary to propagation of Sindbis DH-BB vectors, Sindbis split helper vectors were frequently able to spread without cytopathic effect (CPE), a feature that was linked to wild-type reversion. Our results support the hypothesis that the non-cytopathic local spreading constantly observed with Sindbis split helper vector results from unspecific packaging of helper RNAs into vector particles and co-infection with particles containing replicon and helper RNAs. Several malignant cell lines with defective interferon responses were found to be permissive for non-cytopathic spreading of the Sindbis split helper vector. Interferon-α suppressed the spreading providing a possible option to control the vector.

Microscale freeze-drying with Raman spectroscopy as a tool for process development.

Until recently, the freeze-drying process and formulation development have suffered from a lack of microscale analytical tools. Using such an analytical tool should decrease the required sample volume and also shorten the duration of the experiment compared to a laboratory scale setup. This study evaluated the applicability of Raman spectroscopy for in-line monitoring of a microscale freeze-drying process. The effect of cooling rate and annealing step on the solid-state formation of mannitol was studied. Raman spectra were subjected to principal component analysis to gain a qualitative understanding of the process behavior. In addition, mannitol solid-state form ratios were semiquantitatively analyzed during the process with a classical least-squares regression. A standard cooling rate of 1 °C/min with or without an annealing step at -10 °C resulted in a mixture of α, ß, δ, and amorphous forms of mannitol. However, a standard cooling rate induced the formation of mannitol hemihydrate, and a secondary drying temperature of +60 °C was required to transform the hemihydrate form to the more stable anhydrous polymorphs. A fast cooling rate of 10 °C/min mainly produced δ and amorphous forms of mannitol, regardless of annealing. These results are consistent with those from larger scale equipment. In-line monitoring the solid-state form of a sample is feasible with a Raman spectrometer coupled microscale freeze-drying stage. These results demonstrate the utility of a rapid, in-line, low sample volume method for the semiquantitative analysis of the process and formulation development of freeze-dried products on the microscale.

Inducible expression of antizyme 1 in prostate cancer cell lines after lentivirus mediated gene transfer.

The prostate has the highest level of polyamines among all tissues, and it is the only tissue in which polyamines are purposely synthesized for export. It has been suggested that the high local polyamine concentrations suppress cell growth of primary prostatic carcinomas and that this growth control is lost when cancer cells metastasize. It has also been shown that the sensitivity to polyamine-induced growth arrest correlates with antizyme induction in prostate carcinoma cell lines. In this study, we evaluated the sensitivity of poorly metastatic (LNCaP) and highly metastatic (DU145) prostate cancer cell lines to conditional antizyme 1 over-expression. Antizyme 1 induction resulted in a marked loss of ODC activity and polyamine uptake in both cell lines. However, the proliferation of LNCaP cells was repressed by antizyme 1 induction, whereas the proliferation of DU 145 cells was not affected. Neither cell line showed any reduction in polyamine pools after manipulation nor did polyamine addition into the medium save the LNCaP cells from the growth retardation. The growth inhibition of LNCaP cells was accompanied by accumulation of cells in the G1 phase and depletion of cyclin E1 protein. These results confirm that different prostate cancer cell lines show diverse sensitivities to antizyme 1 which may not be directly polyamine related. The high gene transfer capacity of the used lentiviral vector makes the present approach a useful tool to study the therapeutic potential of antizyme 1 both in cell cultures and experimental animals.

Dexamethasone-induced apoptosis and up-regulation of Bim is dependent on glycogen synthase kinase-3.

Glucocorticoids are commonly used in the treatment of lymphoid malignancies. In this study, we show that apoptosis induced by dexamethasone (Dex), a synthetic glucocorticoid, was dependent on mitochondria, since overexpression of Bcl-X(L) prevented Dex-induced apoptotic changes. Dominant negative (DN) caspase-9 also prevented Dex-induced apoptotic changes including the loss of mitochondrial membrane potential indicating that caspase-9 controls mitochondrial changes. In addition, we evaluated the role of glycogen synthase kinase (GSK3) in Dex-induced apoptosis. Inhibition of GSK3 attenuated Dex-induced up-regulation of Bim, loss of mitochondrial membrane potential, release of cyt c and DNA fragmentation. These results indicate that GSK3 contributes to Dex-induced apoptosis by controlling up-regulation of Bim.

The involvement of mitochondria and the caspase-9 activation pathway in rituximab-induced apoptosis in FL cells.

Despite the wide use of anti-CD20 antibody rituximab in the cancer treatment of B cell malignancies, the signalling pathways of CD20-induced apoptosis are still not understood. By using dominant negative (DN)-caspase-9 overexpressing follicular lymphoma cells we demonstrated that the activation of caspase-9 was essential for rituximab-mediated apoptosis. The death receptor pathway mediated by caspase-8 activation was not involved in rituximab-mediated apoptosis since overexpression of FLIP(short) or FLIP(long) proteins, inhibitors of caspase-8 activation, could not inhibit rituximab-induced apoptosis. However, the death receptor pathway activation by anti-Fas antibodies showed an additive effect on rituximab-induced apoptosis. The stabilisation of the mitochondrial outer membrane by Bcl-x(L) overexpression inhibited cell death, showing the important role of mitochondria in rituximab-induced apoptosis. Interestingly, the rituximab-induced release of cytochrome c and collapse of mitochondrial membrane potential were regulated by caspase-9. We suggest that caspase-9 and downstream caspases may feed back to mitochondria to amplify mitochondrial disruption during intrinsic apoptosis.

PDTC enables type I TRAIL signaling in type II follicular lymphoma cells.

Based on Bcl-X(L) overexpression studies we identified type I and type II follicular lymphoma cell lines in response to TRAIL. We demonstrate here that either amount of caspase-8 activation or Bid cleavage could not define the dependence on mitochondria. Furthermore, an inhibitor of NF-kappaB, PDTC, enabled TRAIL to activate type I apoptotic pathway in type II cells. However, an inhibitor of IKK did not switch apoptosis to type I pathway in type II cells, indicating that NF-kappaB might not be responsible for the switch.

Oncolytic Semliki forest virus vector as a novel candidate against unresectable osteosarcoma.

Oncolytic viruses are a promising tool for treatment of cancer. We studied an oncolytic Semliki Forest virus (SFV) vector, VA7, carrying the enhanced green fluorescent protein gene (EGFP), as a novel virotherapy candidate against unresectable osteosarcoma. The efficiency and characteristics of the VA7-EGFP treatment were compared with a widely studied oncolytic adenovirus, Ad5Delta24, both in vitro and in vivo. VA7-EGFP resulted in more rapid oncolysis and was more efficient at low multiplicities of infection (MOI) when compared with Ad5Delta24 in vitro. Yet, in MG-63 cells, a subpopulation resistant to the VA7-EGFP vector emerged. In subcutaneous human osteosarcoma xenografts in nude mice treatment with either vector reduced tumor size, whereas tumors in control mice expanded quickly. The VA7-EGFP-treated tumors were either completely abolished or regressed to pinpoint size. The efficacy of VA7-EGFP vector was studied also in an orthotopic osteosarcoma nude mouse model characterized by highly aggressive tumor growth. Treatment with oncolytic SFV extended survival of the animals significantly (P < 0.01), yet none of the animals were finally cured. Sera from SFV-treated mice contained neutralizing antibodies, and as nude mice are not able to establish IgG response, the result points out the role of IgM class antibodies in clearance of virus from peripheral tumors. Furthermore, biodistribution analysis at the survival end point verified the presence of virus in some of the brain samples, which is in line with previous studies demonstrating that IgG is required for clearance of SFV from central nervous system.

Replication competent Semliki Forest virus prolongs survival in experimental lung cancer.

We evaluated the therapeutic potential of the replication competent vector VA7-EGFP, which is based on the avirulent Semliki Forest virus (SFV) strain A7 (74) carrying the EGFP marker gene in an orthotopic lung cancer tumor model in nude mice. We have previously shown that this oncolytic vector destroys tumor cells efficiently in vitro and in vivo (in subcutaneous tumor model). Tumor growth in animals with orthotopically implanted adenocarcinoma cells (A549) were monitored during the study with small animal CT. We show that locally administered virotherapy with VA7-EGFP increased survival rate in experimental lung cancer significantly (p < 0.001) comparable to results obtained with the second generation conditionally replicating adenoviral vector Ad5-Delta24TK-GFP, used for comparison. The limited efficacy in systemically administered oncolytic viruses is the essential problem in oncolytic virotherapy and also in this study we were not able to elicit significant response with systemic administration route. Despite the fact that tumor microenvironment in orthotopic lung cancer is more optimal, viruses failed to home to the tumors and were unable to initiate efficient intratumoral replication. Clearly, the efficacy of virotherapy is influenced by many factors such as the route of virus administration, immunological and physiological barriers and cancer cell-specific features (IFN-responsiveness).

HOX-GFP and WOX-GFP lentivirus vectors for inner ear gene transfer.

CONCLUSION: GFP transgene was expressed in the lining cells of the perilymphatic space. Lentivirus vectors are safe and cause only minimal inflammatory reaction. Transgene products can be delivered into the perilymph by utilizing lentivirus vectors. OBJECTIVES: To analyze the efficiency and safety of lentiviral vectors HOX-GFP and WOX-GFP in intracochlear gene transfer. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Lentivirus vectors were tested for their transduction efficiency in vivo in CD-1 mice. Half of the animals were pretreated with kanamycin. Lentivirus vector or saline (1 microl) was injected into the inner ear. All the animals were sacrificed 14 days after the surgery and the cochleae and selected organs were analyzed immunohistochemically. RESULTS: HOX-GFP and WOX-GFP expression was restricted to the lining cells of the scala tympani and scala vestibuli. No GFP expression was seen in the organ of Corti or the spiral ganglion. Aminoglycoside treatment had no effect on the expression of these vectors. The distant spread of lentivirus vectors was minimal; only the liver of one animal showed some GFP expression. Inflammatory reaction caused by these vectors was mild. Few inflammatory cells were found in the perilymphatic space of the cochlea and in the vestibular organ.

Evaluation of cancer virotherapy with attenuated replicative Semliki forest virus in different rodent tumor models.

Semliki Forest virus (SFV) is one of the latest candidates for a virotherapeutic agent against cancer, and recent studies have demonstrated its efficacy in tumor models. In the present study, we examined the antitumor efficacy of an avirulent SFV strain A7(74) and its derivative, a replication-competent SFV vector VA7-EGFP, in a partially immunodeficient mouse tumor model (subcutaneous A549 human lung adenocarcinoma in NMRI nu/nu mouse) and in an immunocompetent rat tumor model (intracranial BT4C glioma in BDIX rat). When subcutaneous mouse tumors were injected 3 times with VA7-EGFP, intratumorally treated animals showed almost complete inhibition of tumor growth, while systemically treated mice displayed only delayed tumor growth (intravenous injection) or no response at all (intraperitoneal injection). This was at least partially due to a strong type I interferon (IFN) response in the tumors. The animals did not display any signs of abnormal behavior or encephalitis, even though SFV-positive foci were detected in the brain after the initial blood viremia. Intracranial rat tumors were injected directly with SFV A7(74) virus and monitored with magnetic resonance imaging. Tumor growth was significantly reduced (p < 0.05) with one virus injection, but the tumor size continued to increase after a lag period and none of the treated animals survived. Three virus injections or T-cell suppression with dexamethasone did not significantly improve treatment efficacy. It appeared that the local virotherapy induced extensive production of neutralizing anti-SFV antibodies that most likely contributed to the insufficient treatment efficacy. In conclusion, we show here that SFV A7(74) is a potential oncolytic agent for cancer virotherapy, but major immunological hurdles may need to be overcome before the virus can be clinically tested.

Type I interferon response against viral and non-viral gene transfer in human tumor and primary cell lines.

BACKGROUND: Type I interferon (IFN-alpha/beta) response is one of the major host defence mechanisms against viruses. Some recent reports suggest that IFNs may interfere with the efficacy of both non-viral and virus-vector-mediated therapeutic gene transfer. METHODS: The type I IFN response upon different gene transfer methods in human tumor and primary cell lines was studied by analysing IFN-beta mRNA expression, secretion of type I IFNs and accumulation of IFN-alpha/beta-induced MxA protein (myxovirus resistance protein A). RESULTS: Infection with avirulent Semliki Forest virus A7[74] induced MxA protein accumulation and increased the IFN-beta mRNA level, whereas none of the studied virus vectors (adenovirus, CRAd, lentivirus or AAV) induced IFN response. However, plasmid DNA induced the accumulation of MxA protein when transfected with several commercial transfection reagents. RNA transfection appeared to be an efficient inducer of type I IFN response: replicating alphaviral RNA, eukaryotic total RNA, or mRNA all induced both MxA protein accumulation and IFN-beta expression. siRNA transfection failed to induce MxA response. CONCLUSIONS: The non-viral gene transfer methods have gained more interest in recent years due to their better safety profiles when compared to their viral counterparts. However, the efficiency of non-viral gene transfer is well below those reached by viral vector systems. The type I interferon response induced by non-viral methods may in part contribute to this inefficiency, while most currently used viral gene transfer vectors fail to induce or are able to suppress type I IFN response.

Transcriptional targeting of virus-mediated gene transfer by the human hexokinase II promoter.

The efficacy of the most commonly used form of suicide gene therapy, the HSV-TK/GCV method, utilizing herpes simplex virus thymidine kinase (HSV-TK) and antiviral drug ganciclovir (GCV) has been demonstrated in clinical trials. However, safer delivery of the therapeutic gene and more controlled regulation of the transgene expression, the essential prerequisites for successful therapeutic use, are still needed. We describe improved suicide gene therapy against cancer through transcripitional targeting by a strong and selective tumor-specific human hexokinase II promoter (hHKII). We examined the targeting properties of the human hHKII promoter in different human non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC) and other human cancer cell lines using self-inactivating, VSV-G pseudotyped lentiviral vector. To confirm accurate transcriptional targeting of the hHKII promoter, the lack of transgene expression was verified in human primary bronchial epithelial and bronchial fibroblast cells. Furthermore, tissue-specific expression of the promoter was confirmed using transgenic mouse lines carrying the hHKII promoter driven luciferase reporter gene. We also tested the efficacy of the HSV-TK/GCV suicide gene therapy with the hHKII targeted lentiviral vector to NSCLC cells. Our results show that the hHKII promoter is strongly expressed in cancer cells. The targeted vector with the shortest hHKII promoter fragment (352 bp) appeared to have the best targeting properties because it efficiently governed the expression of the therapeutic gene in cancer cell lines, especially in certain non-small cell lung cancer cell lines, the transgene expression in human primary cells was virtually undetectable, and expression of the proximal hHKII promoter in transgenic mice was very low in most tissues. Also, the anti-cancer efficacy of HSV-TK/GCV therapy with the hHKII-targeted vector was comparable to that obtained with the control vector that utilized a commonly used constitutive promoter from the human elongation factor 1 alpha (hEF1alpha) gene. In conclusion, the transcriptionally targeted lentivirus vector with hHKII promoter can successfully direct HSV-TK/GCV suicide gene therapy to non-small cell lung cancer and other tumor cell types. These results warrant further studies with orthotopic animal tumor models and primary human cancer material.

Polyamine-regulated unproductive splicing and translation of spermidine/spermine N1-acetyltransferase.

Spermidine/spermine N1-acetyltransferase (SSAT), the rate-controlling enzyme in the interconversion of spermidine and spermine, is regulated by polyamines and their analogs at many levels of gene expression. Recently, SSAT pre-mRNA has been shown to undergo alternative splicing by inclusion of an exon that contains premature termination codons. In the present study, we show that alterations in the intracellular polyamine level resulted in a change in the relative abundance of SSAT transcripts. Addition of polyamines or their N-diethylated analogs reduced the amount of the variant transcript, whereas polyamine depletion by 2-difluoromethylornithine or MG-132 enhanced the exon inclusion. Experiments performed with protein synthesis inhibitors and siRNA-mediated down-regulation of Upf1 protein verified that the variant transcript was degraded by nonsense-mediated mRNA decay (NMD). Interestingly, several proteins have been shown to regulate their expression by alternative splicing-coupled NMD, termed regulated unproductive splicing and translation (RUST). Our present results suggest that in the case of SSAT, RUST is mediated by polyamines, and this system functions to fine-tune the polyamine metabolism.

HIV-1 TAT protein transduction domain mediates enhancement of enzyme prodrug cancer gene therapy in vitro: a study with TAT-TK-GFP triple fusion construct.

Protein transduction domain (PTD) from HIV-1 TAT protein has been reported to translocate across the mammalian cell membrane, also as a part of fusion proteins. However, the true nature of TAT-mediated intercellular spreading is still under debate because it has been claimed to be a fixation artifact. To study the spreading of TAT fusion proteins and their potency to enhance thymidine kinase/ ganciclovir (HSV-TK/GCV) cancer gene therapy, we constructed a novel triple fusion protein containing TAT PTD, HSV-TK and green fluorescent protein (TAT-TK-GFP). This fusion protein has three functional domains in the same polypeptide, allowing reliable determination of the relationship between transduction rate and cell killing efficiency. TAT-TK-GFP was cloned into a lentivirus vector and used for analyses of TAT-mediated protein translocation and enhancement of HSV-TK/GCV cytotoxicity. The triple fusion protein was expressed correctly in vitro, but cell-to-cell translocation was not observed in rat glioma cells (BT4C). However, TAT-TK-GFP made BT4C and SKOV3.ip1 (human ovarian carcinoma) cells significantly more sensitive to ganciclovir than TK-GFP, whereas the effect in PC-3 human prostate carcinoma cells was more subtle. It was also observed that growth in lower serum concentration (2.5-5%) abolished the enhancement in BT4C cells, suggesting that high proliferation rate is one of the factors that contribute to TAT PTD-mediated enhancement of cytotoxicity. In summary, our results indicate that TAT PTD fusion proteins do not translocate intercellularly at detectable levels, but enhancement of the HSV-TK/GCV cytotoxicity can be detected in rat and human tumor cell lines in vitro.

Ozone-induced programmed cell death in the Arabidopsis radical-induced cell death1 mutant.

Short, high-concentration peaks of the atmospheric pollutant ozone (O(3)) cause the formation of cell death lesions on the leaves of sensitive plants. Numerous similarities between the plant responses to O(3) and pathogens suggest that O(3) triggers hypersensitive response-like programmed cell death (PCD). We examined O(3) and superoxide-induced cell death in the O(3)-sensitive radical-induced cell death1 (rcd1) mutant. Dying cells in O(3)-exposed rcd1 exhibited several of the typical morphological characteristics of the hypersensitive response and PCD. Double-mutant analyses indicated a requirement for salicylic acid and the function of the cyclic nucleotide-gated ion channel AtCNGC2 in cell death. Furthermore, a requirement for ATPases, kinases, transcription, Ca(2+) flux, caspase-like proteolytic activity, and also one or more phenylmethylsulfonyl fluoride-sensitive protease activities was shown for the development of cell death lesions in rcd1. Furthermore, mitogen-activated protein kinases showed differential activation patterns in rcd1 and Columbia. Taken together, these results directly demonstrate the induction of PCD by O(3).

Cancer cells as targets for lentivirus-mediated gene transfer and gene therapy.

Lentiviruses have been used as gene transfer vectors for almost 10 years and their utility has been demonstrated in a variety of different applications. However, their value in cancer gene therapy has not been studied thoroughly. Here we show that VSV-G pseudotyped HIV-1-based lentiviruses are efficient vectors for human tumor cells in vitro and in vivo. Lentiviral gene transfer efficiency was demonstrated by transducing 42 different cell lines, representing 10 different human tumor types. It was shown that most of the cell lines were good or excellent targets for lentiviral transduction, allowing 50-95% gene transfer efficiency. These results were comparable to those obtained with an E1/E3 deleted, serotype 5 adenovirus vector. Analysis of lentivirus vector structure revealed that virus particles devoid of HIV-1 accessory proteins appeared to be more efficient, but the presence of enhancing elements cPPT and WPRE did not play a major role in transduction efficiency to four different human tumor cell lines. However, their effect on the gene expression level in these cells was apparent. To examine the impact of lentiviral gene expression level on suicide gene therapy approach, human osteosarcoma cells were transduced with lentivirus- or adenovirus vectors carrying the fusion gene HSV-TK-GFP and exposed to ganciclovir. Cell viability analysis after the treatment revealed that both vector types induced similar level of cytotoxicity, suggesting that lentiviral expression of a suicide gene is adequate for tumor cell destruction. Finally, in vivo transduction studies with subcutaneous tumors showed that lentivirus vectors can yield similar gene transfer efficiency than adenovirus vector, despite three orders of magnitude lower titer of the lentiviral preparation. In conclusion, these data show that lentiviruses are efficient gene transfer vehicles for human tumor cells and justify their use in further preclinical cancer gene therapy studies.

Non-small cell lung cancer as a target disease for herpes simplex type 1 thymidine kinase-ganciclovir gene therapy.

Lung cancer is a group of diseases that are difficult to cure and new treatment modalities, like gene therapy are actively tested to find alternatives for currently used strategies. Herpes simplex virus thymidine kinase/ganciclovir (HSV-TK/GCV) method is one of the most frequently utilized forms of gene therapy and it has been tested on lung cancer, but no systematic study with comparison of different lung cancer types has been published. In this study, we examined in vitro and in vivo how good targets non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC) cell lines representing adenocarcinoma, squamous cell lung cancer and large cell lung cancer are for adenovirus-mediated HSV-TK/GCV gene therapy. By using an adenovirus vector carrying a fusion gene of HSV-TK and green fluorescent protein (GFP), we found that: a) adenoviruses were efficient gene transfer vehicles for all types of NSCLCs; b) all adenocarcinoma and large cell lung cancer cells were good targets for HSV-TK/GCV therapy, whereas one of the squamous cell carcinoma cell lines was not responsive to the treatment; c) bystander effect played a major role in the success of this gene therapy form; d) subcutaneous tumors representing all three NSCLC types were efficiently treated with adenovirus-mediated HSV-TK/GCV gene therapy. In summary, this form of gene therapy appeared to be efficient treatment for human NSCLC and these results warrant further studies with primary lung cancer cells and orthotopic lung tumor models.

Changes in hydrogen peroxide homeostasis trigger an active cell death process in tobacco.

In transgenic tobacco plants with reduced catalase activity, high levels of hydrogen peroxide (H2O2) can accumulate under photorespiratory conditions. Such a perturbation in H2O2 homeostasis induced cell death in clusters of palisade parenchyma cells, primarily along the veins. Ultrastructural alterations, such as chromatin condensation and disruption of mitochondrial integrity, took place before cell death. Furthermore, enhanced transcript levels of mitochondrial defense genes accompanied these mitochondrial changes. Pharmacological data indicated that the initiation and execution of cell death require de novo protein synthesis and that the signal transduction pathway leading to cell death involved changes in ion homeostasis, (de)phosphorylation events and an oxidative burst, as observed during hypersensitive responses. This oxidase-dependent oxidative burst is essential for cell death, but it is not required for the accumulation of defense proteins, suggesting a more prominent role for the oxidative burst in abiotic stress-induced cell death.

Hydrogen peroxide activates cell death and defense gene expression in birch.

The function of hydrogen peroxide (H(2)O(2)) as a signal molecule regulating gene expression and cell death induced by external stresses was studied in birch (Betula pendula). Ozone (O(3)), Pseudomonas syringae pv syringae (Pss), and wounding all induced cell death of various extents in birch leaves. This was temporally preceded and closely accompanied by H(2)O(2) accumulation at, and especially surrounding, the lesion sites. O(3) and Pss, along with an artificial H(2)O(2) producing system glucose (Glc)/Glc oxidase, elicited elevated mRNA levels corresponding to genes encoding reactive oxygen species detoxifying enzymes, Pal, Ypr10, and mitochondrial phosphate translocator 1. In addition to the regulation of gene expression, Glc/Glc oxidase also induced endogenous H(2)O(2) production in birch leaves, accompanied by cell death that resembled O(3) and Pss damage. Wound-induced gene expression differed from that induced by O(3) and Pss. Thus, it appears that at least two separate defense pathways can be activated in birch leaves by stress factors, even though the early H(2)O(2) accumulation response is common among them all.