Ethical Issues in the Use of Suboptimal Kidneys for Transplants: An Italian Point of View.

The shortage of organs leads to the need for utilizing suboptimal kidneys for transplantation. The distinction between optimal, marginal, and suboptimal kidneys leads surgeons to face not only technical problems but also ethical and legal issues related to clinical advantages offered by the transplant of a nonstandard kidney and the acquisition of consent. Between 1999 and 2015, we performed 658 transplants, 49 (7.5%) using suboptimal kidneys. All patients were alive and with vital graft throughout follow-up. We did not encounter any major surgical complications. From a technical point of view, our experience and literature review confirm that transplant of suboptimal kidney leads to good clinical results but exposes patients to a increased risks of surgical complications. Therefore, these interventions must take place in hospitals fully prepared for this type of surgery and performed by experienced transplant surgeons with proper matching between organ and recipient. Considering the insufficient resources available, from an ethical and legal point of view, doctors play an essential role in optimizing the use of these kidneys by avoiding wastage of organs, ensuring that transplants are done in suitable patients, and that patients are fully informed and aware of the risks and benefits associated with the specific suboptimal kidney being transplanted. We believe that, in highly specialized centers, the number of suboptimal kidney transplants should be increased, as their use has shown good clinical results and carries fewer ethical issues compared with marginal kidneys. Further, suboptimal kidneys may also be proposed for use in young patients with end-stage renal disease.

Prevention of fluid effusion in kidney transplantation with the use of hemostatic biomaterials.

BACKGROUND: Fluid effusion (blood, lymph, or urine) in kidney transplantation may give rise to several complications, directly, such as hematoma, seroma, lymphocele, and/or urinoma, or consequently, such as increased infection risk, longer hospital stay, graft compression--with or without functional impairment--and necessity of further hospitalizations. The aim of this study was to evaluate effectiveness of hemostatic biomaterials in prevention of fluid effusions, especially lymphocele in kidney transplant patients. METHODS: We selected 40 patients who underwent kidney transplantation from 2009 to 2012 in which we used hemostatic biomaterials, and compared their results with those of other transplant patients from our center in which we did not used these biomaterials. Evaluated parameters were: fluid effusion, graft function, quality and quantity of drainage, blood count, and operative time. RESULTS: There was no difference in operative time. The incidence of complications on which biomaterials can have a role decreased; particularly, we observed a reduction from 24.21% to 7.5% of fluid effusions (lymphocele). There was no evidence of complications due to biomaterials. CONCLUSIONS: Hemostasis is important in surgery, and in kidney transplantations lymphostasis also has a significant role. In addition to the traditional hemostatic methods, recently some biomaterials, with the purpose of providing atraumatic hemostasis, were added. In our experience they are easy to use, and their use has proved to be effective for both hemostasis and lymphostasis with consequent reduction of fluid effusions.

In situ elongation patch in right kidney transplantation.

BACKGROUND: A short right renal vein complicates transplantation causing traction and difficulties during anastomosis. When we perform a kidney transplantation from a cadaveric donor, this problem may be resolved by using the vena cava to create a venous duct. This elongation technique is proposed to be performed during bench surgery. We propose a small change in the technique: execution of an "elongation patch" during harvesting and under cold perfusion. MATERIALS AND METHODS: From January 2004 to June 2006, we performed 12 in situ (during the harvesting procedure) vena cava elongation patches. In these cases, the right renal vein was too short. The elongation patch was used in only 8 transplantations. In the other 4 cases we sacrificed the patch to perform a direct venous anastomosis due to favorable recipient anatomical characteristics. RESULTS: The 8 transplantations performed with the elongation patch did not show vascular complications and the venous anastomosis was easy to perform. CONCLUSIONS: The "extension patch" was not associated with a greater incidence of vascular complications. Using the elongation patch during the harvest showed some advantages: performed during cold perfusion with a reduction in bench ischemia; the anatomical relationships are preserved so we can perform a calibrated suture; the perfusion of the organ allows us to observe the integrity of the anastomosis. This technique did not significantly increase the harvesting time.

The finding of vascular and urinary anomalies in the harvested kidney for transplantation.

INTRODUCTION: In kidney transplantation, anatomical vascular and excretory anomalies may represent causes of failure. Today's surgical techniques have made the most of the organs with anatomic anomalies and iatrogenic injury successfully used for transplantation. MATERIALS AND METHODS: From January 2000 to June 2006, we harvested 230 kidneys, of including 88 kidneys (20%) with vascular, urinary, or vascular-urinary anomalies; 64 kidneys were implanted and 15 were sent to other transplantation centers. Only 9 kidneys were not appropriate for transplantation. RESULTS: All patients who received kidneys with the above-mentioned anomalies were carefully examined after the transplantation and short-term and long-term complications were evaluated with respect to controls without anomalies. DISCUSSION: Renal anatomic anomalies are frequently observed during kidney transplantation and may produce postsurgical complications. However, the presence of these anomalies does not necessarily imply the impossibility of using the kidney for a transplant, especially because of improved surgical techniques. Our experience in transplantation procedures showed that even if kidneys present the above-mentioned anomalies they can still be considered appropriate for transplantation when we perform a correct harvesting/back-table transplant surgery. So vascular and urinary anomalies have to be considered always an incentive to research new surgical solutions and to perform a careful surgical technique.

Transplantation and young surgeons in Italy.

The relation between young surgeons and transplantation has always been a "love and hate" one. Until a few years ago this branch of surgery was seen as pioneering, with extreme and and extensive training, and was reserved to few elected members. Nowadays things are different. In this article we try to understand the true reasons that young Italian surgeons avoid transplantation surgery.

[Biliodigestive anastomosis: case series and technical notes]. / Anastomosi bilio-digestive. Casistica e note di tecnica.

AIM: Biliodigestive anastomoses are widely used in the treatment of biliary obstruction. METHODS: A survey is presented of the personal case series treated during the last 5 years. Thirty biliodigestive anastomose have been performed both for neoplastic disease and for benign lesions. RESULTS: The biliodigestive anastomosis has been performed with the Blumgart's technique both for benign and malignant tumors. CONCLUSIONS: The authors point out that experience is of the utmost importance for the operation success. Major attention is paid to the surgical technique used for the biliodigestive anastomosis and a retrospective analysis is made.

Suboptimal kidney: the experience of a single transplant unit.

Not all kidneys are suitable for transplantation. In 2001 in Italy, only 1530 of 1748 organs were transplanted. This difference (-12.5%) not only represents organs harvested from marginal donors considered not suitable, but also kidneys that, although collected from standard donors, had a vascular, parenchymal, or urologic anomaly that made them unsuitable for transplantation. In our center, we established a procedure that defined the characteristics of suboptimal kidneys and allowed us to specifically select the appropriate recipient. We considered as suboptimal all organs with complex arterial anomalies (more than 2 arteries although on a single patch or separated such as to need a double anastomosis or a bench reconstruction); organs with noticeable parenchymal damage (macroscopic sclerosis areas or sutured polar branches accidentally damaged during removal), and organs with complex anomalies of the excretory tract (complete double district). The organs were not considered as suboptimal if they had venous anomalies revised on the bench or if they had a double artery with a single patch <2.5 cm. Such organs were transplanted to recipients who were between 55 and 60 years of age with a body weight of at least 20% less than the donor, and female.

Hemodynamic and pulmonary changes during open, carbon dioxide pneumoperitoneum and abdominal wall-lifting cholecystectomy. A prospective, randomized study.

BACKGROUND: Carbon dioxide (CO2) pneumoperitoneum effects are still controversial. The aim of this study was to investigate cardiopulmonary changes in patients subjected to different surgical procedures for cholecystectomy. METHODS: In this study, 15 patients were assigned randomly to three groups according to the surgical procedure to be used: open cholecystectomy (OC), CO2 pneumoperitoneum cholecystectomy (PP), and laparoscopic gasless cholecystectomy (abdominal wall lifting [AWL]), respectively. A pulmonary artery catheter was used for hemodynamic monitoring in all patients. A subcutaneous multiplanar device (Laparo Tenser) was used for abdominal wall lifting. To avoid misinterpretation of results, conventional anesthesia was performed with all parameters, and the position of the patients held fixed throughout surgery. The following parameters were analyzed: mean arterial pressure (MAP), heart rate (HR), cardiac output (CO), cardiac index (CI), stroke volume index (SVI), central venous pressure (CVP), systemic vascular resistances index (SVRI), mean pulmonary arterial pressure (MPAP), pulmonary capillary wedge pressure (PCWP), pulmonary vascular resistances index (PVRI), peak inspiratory pressure (PIP), end-tidal CO2 pressure (ETCO)2, CO2 arterial pressure (PaCO2), and arterial pH. RESULTS: All the operations were completed successfully. The Laparo Tenser allowed good exposition of the surgical field. A slight impairment of the cardiopulmonary functions, with reduction of SVRI, MAP, and CI and elevation of pulmonary pressures and vascular resistance, followed induction of anesthesia. However, these effects tended to normalize in the OC and AWL groups over time. In contrast, CO2 insufflation produced a complex hemodynamic and pulmonary syndrome resulting in increased right- and left side filling pressures, significant cardiac index reduction, derangement of the respiratory mechanics, and respiratory acidosis. All of these effects normalized after desufflation. CONCLUSIONS: Cardiopulmonary adverse effects of general anesthesia were significant but transitory and normalized during surgery. Carbon dioxide pneumoperitoneum caused a significant impairment in cardiopulmonary functions. In high-risk patients, gasless laparoscopy may be preferred for reliability and absence of cardiopulmonary alterations.

[Ectopic thyroid: report of a case]. / Tiroide ectopica: a proposito di un caso clinico.

The development of thyroid tissue can occur in any moment of the migration of the thyroid along the thyroglossal duct from the tongue, resulting in lingual (at tongue base), sublingual (below the tongue), prelaryngeal (in front of the larynx), and substernal (in the mediastinum) ectopy. Thyroglossal duct cyst is the most common type of clinical abnormality related to thyroid ectopy. Surgical removal of such ectopic tissue is justified since some Authors describe thyroid cancer arising from aberrant thyroid tissue. The Authors report a case of thyroid ectopy in a patient who underwent 20 years before a left thyroid resection with isthmectomy; during the operation the surgeon described a hypertrophic pyramidal lobe which was left in situ and the patients did not receive any hormone suppressing therapy.

[Biliary ileus: a review of the literature and report of a clinical case treated by minilaparotomy]. / Ileo biliare: revisione della letteratura e presentazione di un caso clinico trattato con minilaparotomia.

OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the diagnostic and therapeutic approach to gallstone ileus. MATERIAL AND METHODS: A gallstone ileus report, diagnosed by integrated radiological approach, treated by minilaparotomy plus enterolithotomy and followed up for two years. RESULTS: Traditional radiologic findings, ultrasonography and computed tomography showed both the stone in the bowel lumen and the cholecystoduodenal fistula with air in the biliary tract. The enterolithotomy alone worked out the obstruction and no complication was observed. DISCUSSION: Integrated radiologic examinations are indicated in defining nature, site and seriousness of gallstone ileus. In most cases surgical treatment is mandatory to work out both the bowel occlusion and bilioenteric illness even though it is often wiser to perform an operation of enterolithotomy alone owing to the general and local conditions of the patient. After this surgical approach, bilioenteric fistula disappears in most cases with no residual lithiasis; in the cases in which fistula and/or lithiasis persist, a decisive surgical operation can be performed in a second step.

Retroperitoneal abscess after retained stones during laparoscopic cholecystectomy.

Laparoscopic cholecystectomy is associated with a significant risk of gallbladder perforations with bile and stone spillage. The retrieval of dropped stones is sometimes impossible, and intraperitoneally retained stones can be the source of serious complications, such as inflammatory masses or abscesses. The authors describe a patient in whom a large retroperitoneal abscess developed as a result of missed stone fragments during cholecystectomy. Although several cases of intraperitoneal abscess have been reported in the literature, retroperitoneal collection is very uncommon. Crushed and infected stones seem to be the essential prerequisite for abscess formation. Therefore, every attempt should be made to avoid stone spillage and intra-abdominally retained stones. Conversion to open surgery has to be considered in the presence of adverse factors, such as primary acute cholecystitis or cholecystitis induced by previous sphincterotomy, or bilirubinate stones believed to be infected. Abdominal abscess treatment requires removal of missed stones by surgical incision or new laparoscopic procedure because simple percutaneous drainage is usually unsuccessful.

[The usefulness of lateral internal sphincterotomy combined with hemorrhoidectomy in the treatment of hemorrhoids: a randomized prospective study]. / Utilità della sfinterotomia laterale interna associata alla emorroidectomia nel trattamento delle emorroidi: studio prospettico randomizzato.

The aim of this prospective randomized study was to investigate anorectal manometric findings in hemorrhoid patients and to evaluate the clinical benefits and physiological consequences of additioning a lateral internal sphincterotomy (LIS) to haemorrhoidectomy. Anorectal manometry was preoperatively performed in forty-eight consecutive patients with prolapsed piles; resting and squeeze pressures, sphincter length and rectoanal inhibitory reflex were recorded. Ten healthy volunteers served as controls. Six patients were excluded because no raised and pressures were found. Forty-two patients were randomised: Group 1 (n = 22) patients underwent haemorrhoidectomy plus LIS; Group 2 (n = 20) patients underwent haemorrhoidectomy alone. Postoperative course was carefully evaluated; all patients were questioned about continence and anorectal manometry was repeated twice. Sphincter anomalies were found in 87.5% of patients. Haemorrhoidectomy alone did not affect anal pressures, which returned into the normal ranges after sphincterotomy. Postoperative course was better in LIS group. Anal stricture was seen in four patients without sphincterotomy; no patients with LIS experienced and incontinence. This study shows that high and pressures are very frequent in hemorrhoid patients; they are not due to hypertensive and cushions and might have a pathogenetic role. Anorectal manometry is very useful to identify patients with raised anal pressures; in these cases additioning a lateral internal sphincterotomy to haemorrhoidectomy seems justified; it significantly improves postoperative course and can be safely performed.

Lateral internal sphincterotomy together with haemorrhoidectomy for treatment of haemorrhoids: a randomised prospective study.

OBJECTIVE: To investigate anorectal manometric findings in patients with haemorrhoids and to evaluate the clinical effects and physiological consequences of adding a lateral internal sphincterotomy (LIS) to haemorrhoidectomy. DESIGN: Randomised prospective study. SETTING: Teaching hospital, Naples. PATIENTS: 48 consecutive patients with prolapsed piles who had anorectal manometry; 10 healthy volunteers served as controls. INTERVENTIONS: Resting and squeeze pressures, sphincter length and rectoanal inhibitory reflex were recorded. 6 patients were excluded because anal pressures were not raised, so 42 patients were randomised. 22 patients had haemorrhoidectomy plus LIS; and 20 had haemorrhoidectomy alone. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Morbidity, continence, and anorectal manometry. RESULTS: Sphincter anomalies were found in 87.5% (n = 42) of patients. Haemorrhoidectomy alone did not affect anal pressures, which returned to the normal ranges after sphincterotomy. Those who had LIS did better postoperatively than those who had did not. 4 patients who did not have a sphincterotomy developed anal strictures. No patient who had LIS developed incontinence of faeces. CONCLUSIONS: High anal pressures are common in patients with haemorrhoids suggesting that they may have a pathogenetic role; anorectal manometry is useful in the investigation of anal pressure patterns; and when indicated, lateral sphincterotomy avoids pain, urinary retention, and stenosis, and is safe.

[Hereditary colonic cancer. Analysis of 3 families at risk]. / Il cancro del colon eredo-familiare. Analisi di tre famiglie a rischio.

Hereditary colorectal cancer is a clearly identified entity today; it is transmitted as a dominant autosomal heritage, and represents about 25% of large bowel malignancies. The poor prognosis of this tumor, one of the most frequent in Western Countries, despite the improvements in therapeutic field, is due to a delated diagnosis that affects an advanced stage of disease in which the results of treatment are significantly worse, whereas cumulative 5-year survival rate is 35% vs 95% in early stage tumors. Existence of an inherited cancer, even in the absence, at present, of specific biomarkers, allows to identify a high risk population in which early diagnosis of colorectal cancer is possible, on the basis of anamnestic and clinical features. Only in this way, with the extension of the results to general population, prognosis of colorectal cancer will be improved.

DNA ploidy as a significant prognostic factor after radical resection for large bowel carcinoma: a prospective study.

It is controversial whether cell DNA measurement is a reliable method to predict prognosis in radically resected large bowel carcinomas. A study using strict rules was undertaken on 54 consecutive patients to clarify the usefulness of DNA ploidy by image cytometric analysis as a prognostic indicator. The tumors were 39% diploid and 61% aneuploid. DNA ploidy was not related to more advanced stages and it, with histological grade and Dukes' stage, was an independent covariate and influenced both disease-free and overall survival. Aneuploid tumors showed the worse prognosis in all Dukes' stages. This prospective study shows that DNA ploidy is an important independent prognostic indicator of clinical outcome and recurrence rate, and it should be used to both select high-risk patients and guide postoperative treatments, particularly in early-stage large bowel carcinomas.

Comparison between the biofragmentable anastomosis ring and stapled anastomoses in the extraperitoneal rectum: a prospective, randomized study.

Serious complications can be carried by intestinal anastomoses, particularly in the distal and proximal part of the gastrointestinal tract. The biofragmentable anastomosis ring (BAR) has been shown to be a safe anastomotic technique, but its clinical applicability in the extraperitoneal rectum has not yet been completely established. This study compared BAR anastomoses and stapled anastomoses in the middle rectum. Thirty-six consecutive patients initially suitable for elective colorectal anastomosis in the middle rectum were enrolled into this study. All patients had intraperitoneal rectum carcinoma, and 31 underwent a colorectal anastomosis in the middle extraperitoneal rectum. They were randomly allocated to a stapled technique or BAR anastomosis. Intraoperative findings and technical drawbacks, tumor behavior, and postoperative course were recorded. All patients were followed up, and late stenosis rate was investigated by endoscopy. The procedure was carried out in each of the 15 patients randomized to receiving a BAR anastomosis. No major difficulties were encountered, and the time needed was even less than that required for a stapled anastomosis. One patient in the stapled group had an early bleeding that required a further laparotomy. No significant differences in postoperative complications were noted between the two groups, although one patient with stapled anastomosis experienced a clinical leakage that needed loop colostomy. Biofragmentability was regular; buttons were eliminated in 3 weeks without any bowel disturbance. BAR ring insertion in the deep pelvis did not produce a shorter colonic resection. The late stenosis rate was similar between the groups. This study shows that in extraperitoneal middle rectum BAR anastomosis is as feasible and safe as the stapled method. The latter is more expensive, and manual suture is more difficult. Therefore the BAR is now the method of choice for this anastomosis in the authors' unit.

[Multidisciplinary treatment of hepatocarcinoma]. / Il trattamento multidisciplinare dell'epatocarcinoma.

Radical treatment of the hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) is complete surgical removal; it may be done by resection or total hepatectomy. Although multicentric carcinogenesis predicts that liver transplantation is likely adequate to treat both the hepatoma and the underlying cirrhosis, it doesn't seem justified in the advanced stages or in absence of end-stage liver disease and therefore liver resection remains the treatment of choice for radical cure of HCC. However, low resectability and high recurrence rate make surgery alone ineffective. Unresectable HCC may be converted to resectable by multimodality radiation/chemotherapy, and embolization of portal branch feeding tumour, improving the function of the nonembolized liver, can extend the surgical indications for HCC. Adjuvant chemoembolization has already shown to reduce recurrence rate after radical resection and it should be widely applied. In unresectable or not converted HCCs as well as in postoperative recurrence, alternative therapies, particularly as multimodality treatment, can improve survival rate. To date, multidisciplinary treatment of hepatocellular carcinoma, waiting for further studies on newer modalities (prevention and gene therapy, especially), represents the best way to improve long-term results.