Inhibition of hyperprogressive cancer disease induced by immune-checkpoint blockade upon co-treatment with meta-tyrosine and p38 pathway inhibitor.

BACKGROUND: Although immune-checkpoint inhibitors (ICI) are overall promissory for cancer treatment, they entail, in some cases, an undesired side-effect called hyperprogressive-cancer disease (HPD) associated with acceleration of tumor growth and shortened survival. METHODS: To understand the mechanisms of HPD we assayed the ICI therapy on two murine tumors widely different regarding immunogenicity and, subsequently, on models of local recurrences and metastases of these tumors. To potentiate the immune response (IR), we combined ICI with meta-tyrosine-that counteracts immune-suppressive signals-and a selective inhibitor of p38 pathway that proved to counteract the phenomenon of tumor-immunostimulation. RESULTS: ICI were therapeutically effective against both tumor models (proportionally to their immunogenicity) but only when they faced incipient tumors. In contrast, ICI produced acceleration of large and residual tumors. The combined treatment strongly inhibited the growth of large tumors and it managed to cure 80% of mice with local recurrences and 60% of mice bearing residual metastases. CONCLUSIONS: Tumor enhancement was paradoxically correlated to a weak increase of the antitumor IR suggesting that a weak IR - different from a strong tumor-inhibitory one-may produce stimulation of tumor growth, mimicking the HPD observed in some clinical settings.

Improvement of Antitumor Therapies Based on Vaccines and Immune-Checkpoint Inhibitors by Counteracting Tumor-Immunostimulation.

Immune-checkpoint inhibitors and antitumor vaccines may produce both tumor-inhibitory and tumor-stimulatory effects on growing tumors depending on the stage of tumor growth at which treatment is initiated. These paradoxical results are not necessarily incompatible with current tumor immunology but they might better be explained assuming the involvement of the phenomenon of tumor immunostimulation. This phenomenon was originally postulated on the basis that the immune response (IR) evoked in Winn tests by strong chemical murine tumors was not linear but biphasic, with strong IR producing inhibition and weak IR inducing stimulation of tumor growth. Herein, we extended those former observations to weak spontaneous murine tumors growing in pre-immunized, immune-competent and immune-depressed mice. Furthermore, we demonstrated that the interaction of specifical T cells and target tumor cells at low stimulatory ratios enhanced the production of chemokines aimed to recruit macrophages at the tumor site, which, upon activation of toll-like receptor 4 and p38 signaling pathways, would recruit and activate more macrophages and other inflammatory cells which would produce growth-stimulating signals leading to an accelerated tumor growth. On this basis, the paradoxical effects achieved by immunological therapies on growing tumors could be explained depending upon where the therapy-induced IR stands on the biphasic IR curve at each stage of tumor growth. At stages where tumor growth was enhanced (medium and large-sized tumors), counteraction of the tumor-immunostimulatory effect with anti-inflammatory strategies or, more efficiently, with selective inhibitors of p38 signaling pathways enabled the otherwise tumor-promoting immunological strategies to produce significant inhibition of tumor growth.

Resistencia concomitante antitumoral: un posible mecanismo de control de las metástasis / 1 CONCOMITANT TUMOR RESISTANCE: A POSIBLE CONTROL MECHANISM OF THE GROWTH OF METASTASES

La Resistencia Concomitante Antitumoral (RC) es el fenómeno según el cual un individuo portador de un tumor inhibe o retarda el crecimiento de implantes tumorales secundarios. Este fenómeno ha sido descripto en animales y en seres humanos y puede ser inducido tanto por tumores inmunogénicos como no-inmunogénicos. El estudio de la RC puede darnos indicios sobre mecanismos de control de las metástasis desde que las metástasis son, de hecho, implantes secundarios naturales desarrollados espontáneamente durante el crecimiento de un tumor primario. En este sentido la experiencia clínica y numerosos datos experimentales han revelado que la extirpación quirúrgica de un tumor puede ser seguida por una abrupta aceleración del crecimiento metastásico sugiriendo que, bajo ciertas circunstancias, un tumor puede ejercer un control inhibitorio sobre sus propias metástasis. En nuestro laboratorio hemos estudiado la RC asociada al crecimiento de numerosos tumores de ratón de diferente origen, tipo histológico e inmunogenicidad. Nuestros resultados demostraron que durante el crecimiento de un tumor primario se generan dos eventos temporalmente separados de RC. El primer evento es producido sólo por tumores inmunogénicos de pequeño tamaño (<500 mm3 ), es específico de tumor y es producido por mecanismos inmunológicos dependientes del timo. Por otro lado, el segundo evento de RC es inducido tanto por tumores inmunogénicos como no-inmunogénicos de gran tamaño (≥ 2000 mm3 ), no es específico de tumor, es timo independiente y correlaciona con la presencia de un factor sérico de bajo peso molecular que demostró tener capacidad para inhibir la proliferación de células tumorales tanto in vitro como in vivo. Cuando esta actividad antitumoral no estaba presente en el suero ­en nuestros modelos, los dos únicos casos estuvieron asociados a tumores altamente metastásicos­ el segundo evento de RC no se producía. Estos resultados sugieren una correlación directa entre la actividad sérica antitumoral, el segundo evento de RC y la capacidad para restringir el crecimiento metastásico.Aunque el primer evento de RC es producido, como dijimos arriba, por una respuesta inmunológica convencional mediada por células T, la naturaleza química del factor sérico asociado a la más universal manifestación de la RC (esto es, el segundo evento de RC), permaneció siendo un enigma por muchos años. En un trabajo reciente, identificamos ese factor sérico antitumoral como una mezcla de metatirosina y orto-tirosina, dos isómeros de tirosina que no están presentes en proteínas normales. Ambos isómeros fueron capaces de inhibir el crecimiento de diferentes tumores murinos que generan RC y restringieron el crecimiento de metástasis establecidas producidas por tumores que no generan RC pero son sensibles a la RC generada por otros tumores. A su vez, y tan significativo como lo anterior, estos efectos antitumorales se lograron sin ningún efecto colateral indeseado Una comprensión más profunda de los mecanismos moleculares asociados con el efecto antitumoral de estos isómeros de tirosina podría, eventualmente, ayudar a desarrollar métodos nuevos y menos tóxicos para combatir las enfermedades malignas; en particular para limitar el crecimiento acelerado de las metástasis después de la extirpación quirúrgica del tumor primario o después del padecimiento de traumas o estresores que pudieran ­despertar­ metástasis de su estado de ­tumor dormido­.

Concomitant tumor resistance (CR) is a phenomenon in which a tumor-bearing host is resistant to the growth of secondary tumor implants. This phenomenon has been described in human and animal systems and it can be generated by both immunogenic and non-immunogenic tumors. The relevance of CR to the mechanisms of metastases control has been highlighted by numerous observations showing that the removal of human and murine tumors may be followed by an abrupt increase in metastatic growth, suggesting that, upon certain circumstances, a primary tumor exerts a controlling action on its metastases which could be considered as secondary tumor implants developed spontaneously during the primary tumor growth. In our laboratory we have studied the CR induced by many murine tumors widely different in origin, histologic type and immunogenicity. Our results support the idea that during the primary tumor growth, there exist two temporally separate events of CR: the first one was exhibited only by small (<500 mm3 ) immunogenic tumors, it was tumor-specific and mediated by classical T-dependent immunological mechanisms. The second event was induced by both im munogenic and nonimmunogenic large (≥ 2000 mm3 ) tumors; it was non-tumor specific, thymus independent and correlated with the presence of a serum factor of low molecular weight that inhibited the in vitro and in vivo proliferation of tumor cells. When this anti-tumor serum activity was absent ­ in our hands, the only two cases were associated with highly metastatic tumors ­ the second event of CR did not exist, suggesting a direct correlation between the anti-tumor serum activity, the second event of CR and the ability to restrain metastatic growth. Although the mechanism associated with the first event of CR has, as said above, been elucidated as T cell­dependent, the molecular nature of the antitumor serum factor(s), which is at the root of the most universal manifestation of CR (that is, the second event of CR), remained an enigma for many years. In a recently published paper, we identified that antitumor serum factor(s) as a mixture of meta-tyrosine and ortho-tyrosine, two isomers of tyrosine that are not present in normal proteins. Both meta- and ortho-tyrosine inhibited the growth of different murine models of cancer that generate CR and could also block established spontaneous metastases produced by other murine models that do not generate CR but are very sensitive to the CR induced by other tumors. In addition, and most importantly, these anti-tumor effects were achieved without any collateral damage to the organism. A more profound understanding of the molecular mechanisms associated with the anti-tumor effects mediated by meta- and ortho-tyrosine could contribute to develop new and more harmless means to manage malignant diseases, especially by limiting the development of metastases that arise after resection of primary tumors or after other stressors that may promote the escape of metastases from dormancy.

B cells inhibit the antitumor immunity against an established murine fibrosarcoma.

Despite the classic role of B cells in favoring the immune response, an inhibitory action of B lymphocytes in tumor immunity has emerged in certain studies. In methylcolanthrene-induced murine fibrosarcoma (MCC), the loss of immunogenicity and the establishment of tolerance are paralleled by systemic immune suppression and the appearance of B+IL-10+ cells in tumor-draining lymph nodes. The present study aimed to assess the role of the B+IL-10+ cell population in the immune evasion and tolerance induced by MCC through the depletion of B cells in mice at various times of tumor progression: Prior to or subsequent to tumor implantation. Tumor growth and immunological parameters were evaluated. B cell depletion prior to tumor inoculum enhanced tumor growth, initiating the onset of the tumor-induced systemic immune response; however, an increase in the T regulatory cells (Tregs) at the tumor-draining lymph node could account for tumor exacerbation. B cell depletion once the tumor was established resulted in decreased tumor growth and a delayed onset of tolerance. Additionally, B cell absence exacerbated T cell dependent-tumor rejection, reduced Tregs and increased cytotoxic CD8+ T cells. In vitro analysis showed a direct effect of B cells upon T cell proliferation. In conclusion, B cell depletion exerts opposite effects when performed prior to or subsequent to tumor implantation. In this initially immunogenic tumor, B cell absence would delay the establishment of immunological tolerance probably by unmasking a pre-existing antitumor response. The present findings elucidate the convenience of modulating B cells in the development of future and more effective immunotherapies against cancer.

Meta-tyrosine. A powerful anti-metastatic factor with undetectable toxic-side effects.

Concomitant tumor resistance (CR) is a phenomenon in which a tumor-bearing host is resistant to the growth of secondary tumor implants and metastasis. While former studies have indicated that T-cell dependent processes mediate CR in hosts bearing immunogenic small tumors, the most universal manifestation of CR induced by immunogenic and non-immunogenic large tumors had been associated with an antitumor serum factor that remained an enigma for many years. In a recent paper, we identified that elusive factor(s) as an equi-molar mixture of meta-tyrosine and ortho-tyrosine, two isomers of tyrosine that are not present in normal proteins and that proved to be responsible for 90% and 10%, respectively, of the total serum anti-tumor activity. In this work, we have extended our previous findings demonstrating that a periodic intravenous administration of meta-tyrosine induced a dramatic reduction of lung and hepatic metastases generated in mice bearing two different metastatic murine tumors and decreased the rate of death from 100% up to 25% in tumor-excised mice that already exhibited established metastases at the time of surgery. These anti-metastatic effects were achieved even at very low concentrations and without displaying any detectable toxic-side effects, suggesting that the use of meta-tyrosine may help to develop new and less harmful means of managing malignant diseases, especially those aimed to control the growth of metastases that is the most serious problem in cancer pathology.

Meta-tyrosine: A powerful anti-metastatic factor with undetectable toxic-side effects

Concomitant tumor resistance (CR) is a phenomenon in which a tumor-bearing host is resistant to the growth of secondary tumor implants and metastasis. While former studies have indicated that T-cell dependent processes mediate CR in hosts bearing immunogenic small tumors, the most universal manifestation of CR induced by immunogenic and non-immunogenic large tumors had been associated with an antitumor serum factor that remained an enigma for many years. In a recent paper, we identified that elusive factor(s) as an equi-molar mixture of meta-tyrosine and ortho-tyrosine, two isomers of tyrosine that are not present in normal proteins and that proved to be responsible for 90% and 10%, respectively, of the total serum anti-tumor activity. In this work, we have extended our previous findings demonstrating that a periodic intravenous administration of meta-tyrosine induced a dramatic reduction of lung and hepatic metastases generated in mice bearing two different metastatic murine tumors and decreased the rate of death from 100% up to 25% in tumor-excised mice that already exhibited established metastases at the time of surgery. These anti-metastatic effects were achieved even at very low concentrations and without displaying any detectable toxic-side effects, suggesting that the use of meta-tyrosine may help to develop new and less harmful means of managing malignant diseases, especially those aimed to control the growth of metastases that is the most serious problem in cancer pathology.

La resistencia concomitante antitumoral (RC) es el fenómeno según el cual un individuo portador de tumor inhibe el crecimiento de implantes tumorales secundarios y metástasis. Si bien desde hace tiempo se sabe que la RC inducida por tumores inmunogénicos de pequeño tamaño es generada por mecanismos inmunológicos dependientes de células T, por otro lado, la manifestación más universal de la RC, generada tanto por tumores inmunogénicos como no-inmunogénicos de gran tamaño, había sido asociada con un (unos) factor sérico antitumoral cuya naturaleza permaneció elusiva por años. En un trabajo reciente, nuestro grupo de trabajo identificó este factor como la mezcla equi-molar de meta-tirosina y orto-tirosina, dos isómeros de tirosina que no están presentes en proteínas normales y que demostraron ser responsables del 90% y 10%, respectivamente, de la actividad antitumoral total del suero. En este trabajo, continuamos nuestras investigaciones demostrando que la administración periódica de meta-tirosina reducía drásticamente el número de metástasis pulmonares y hepáticas en ratones portadores de dos tumores murinos altamente metastásicos y disminuía dramáticamente la mortandad (de 100% a 25%) de ratones con metástasis ya establecidas al momento de la extirpación quirúrgica del tumor. Estos efectos anti-metastásicos se lograron aun con muy bajas concentraciones de meta-tirosina y sin efectos tóxicos perceptibles, lo que sugiere que su uso puede ayudar a diseñar nuevas y menos nocivas estrategias para el tratamiento del cáncer, especialmente aquellas destinadas a controlar el crecimiento metastásico, que es el problema más grave en la enfermedad oncológica.

Concomitant tumor resistance.

Concomitant tumor resistance (CR) is a phenomenon in which a tumor-bearing host is resistant to the growth of secondary tumor implants. This phenomenon has been described in human and animal systems and it can be generated by both immunogenic and non-immunogenic tumors. The relevance of CR to the mechanisms of metastases control has been highlighted by numerous observations showing that the removal of human and murine tumors may be followed by an abrupt increase in metastatic growth, suggesting that a primary tumor may exert a controlling action on its metastases which could be considered as secondary tumor implants developed spontaneously during the primary tumor growth. A more profound understanding of the different mechanisms claimed to be associated with the phenomenon of CR could contribute to develop new and more harmless means to manage malignant diseases, especially by limiting the development of metastases that arise after resection of primary tumors or after other stressors that may promote the escape of metastases from dormancy.

Concomitant tumor resistance: the role of tyrosine isomers in the mechanisms of metastases control.

Concomitant tumor resistance (CR) is a phenomenon in which a tumor-bearing host is resistant to the growth of secondary tumor implants and metastasis. Although previous studies indicated that T-cell-dependent processes mediate CR in hosts bearing immunogenic small tumors, manifestations of CR induced by immunogenic and nonimmunogenic large tumors have been associated with an elusive serum factor. In a recently published study, we identified this factor as meta-tyrosine and ortho-tyrosine, 2 isomers of tyrosine that would not be present in normal proteins. In 3 different murine models of cancer that generate CR, both meta- and ortho-tyrosine inhibited tumor growth. Additionally, we showed that both isoforms of tyrosine blocked metastasis in a fourth model that does not generate CR but is sensitive to CR induced by other tumors. Mechanistic studies showed that the antitumor effects of the tyrosine isomers were mediated in part by early inhibition of the MAP/ERK pathway and inactivation of STAT3, potentially driving tumor cells into a state of dormancy in G(0)-phase. Other mechanisms, putatively involving the activation of an intra-S-phase checkpoint, would also inhibit tumor proliferation by accumulating cells in S-phase. By revealing a molecular basis for the classical phenomenon of CR, our findings may stimulate new generalized approaches to limit the development of metastases that arise after resection of primary tumors or after other stressors that may promote the escape of metastases from dormancy, an issue that is of pivotal importance to oncologists and their patients.

On the immunostimulatory hypothesis of cancer.

There is a rather generalized belief that the worst possible outcome for the application of immunological therapies against cancer is a null effect on tumor growth. However, a significant body of evidence summarized in the immunostimulatory hypothesis of cancer suggests that, upon certain circumstances, the growth of incipient and established tumors can be accelerated rather than inhibited by the immune response supposedly mounted to limit tumor growth. In order to provide more compelling evidence of this proposition, we have explored the growth behavior characteristics of twelve murine tumors -most of them of spontaneous origin- arisen in the colony of our laboratory, in putatively immunized and control mice. Using classical immunization procedures, 8 out of 12 tumors were actually stimulated in "immunized" mice while the remaining 4 were neither inhibited nor stimulated. Further, even these apparently non-antigenic tumors could reveal some antigenicity if more stringent than classical immunization procedures were used. This possibility was suggested by the results obtained with one of these four apparently non-antigenic tumors: the LB lymphoma. In effect, upon these stringent immunization pretreatments, LB was slightly inhibited or stimulated, depending on the titer of the immune reaction mounted against the tumor, with higher titers rendering inhibition and lower titers rendering tumor stimulation. All the above results are consistent with the immunostimulatory hypothesis that entails the important therapeutic implications -contrary to the orthodoxy- that, anti-tumor vaccines may run a real risk of doing harm if the vaccine-induced immunity is too weak to move the reaction into the inhibitory part of the immune response curve and that, a slight and prolonged immunodepression -rather than an immunostimulation- might interfere with the progression of some tumors and thus be an aid to cytotoxic therapies.

Tyrosine isomers mediate the classical phenomenon of concomitant tumor resistance.

Concomitant tumor resistance (CR) is a phenomenon originally described in 1906 in which a tumor-bearing host is resistant to the growth of secondary tumor implants and metastasis. Although recent studies have indicated that T-cell-dependent processes mediate CR in hosts bearing immunogenic small tumors, manifestations of CR induced by immunogenic and nonimmunogenic large tumors have been associated with an elusive serum factor. In this study, we identify this serum factor as tyrosine in its meta and ortho isoforms. In three different murine models of cancer that generate CR, both meta-tyrosine and ortho-tyrosine inhibited tumor growth. In addition, we showed that both isoforms of tyrosine blocked metastasis in a fourth model that does not generate CR but is sensitive to CR induced by other tumors. Mechanistic studies showed that the antitumor effects of the tyrosine isoforms were mediated, in part, by early inhibition of mitogen-activated protein/extracellular signal-regulated kinase pathway and inactivation of STAT3, potentially driving tumor cells into a state of dormancy. By revealing a molecular basis for the classical phenomenon of CR, our findings may stimulate new generalized approaches to limit the development of metastases that arise after resection of primary tumors, an issue of pivotal importance to oncologists and their patients.

Lymphadenectomy exacerbates tumor growth while lymphadenectomy plus the adoptive transfer of autologous cytotoxic cells and low-dose cyclophosphamide induces regression of an established murine fibrosarcoma.

Tumor-draining lymph node (TDLN) ablation is routinely performed in the management of cancer; nevertheless, its usefulness is at present a matter of debate. TDLN are central sites where T cell priming to tumor antigens and onset of the antitumor immune response occur. However, tumor-induced immunosuppression has been demonstrated at TDLN, leading to downregulation of antitumor reaction and tolerance induction. Tolerance in turn is a main impairment for immunotherapy trials. We used a murine immunogenic fibrosarcoma that evolves to a tolerogenic state, to study the cellular and molecular mechanisms underlying tolerance induction at the level of TDLN and to design an appropriate immunotherapy. We determined that following a transient activation, the established tumor induces signs of immunosuppression at TDLN that coexist with local and systemic evidences of antitumor response. Therefore, we evaluated the feasibility of removing TDLN in order to eliminate a focus of immunosuppression and favor tumor rejection; but instead, a marked exacerbation of tumor growth was induced. Combining TDLN ablation with the in vivo depletion of regulatory cells by low-dose cyclophosphamide and the restoring of the TDLN-derived cells into the donor mouse by adoptive transference, resulted in lowered tumor growth, enhanced survival and a considerable degree of tumor regression. Our results demonstrate that important antitumor elements can be eliminated by lymphadenectomy and proved that the concurrent administration of low-dose chemotherapy along with the reinoculation of autologous cytotoxic cells provides protection. We suggest that this protocol may be useful, especially in the cases where lymphadenectomy is mandatory.

Biphasic effect of a primary tumor on the growth of secondary tumor implants.

BACKGROUND: The phenomenon of hormesis is characterized by a biphasic dose-response, exhibiting opposite effects in the low- and high-dose zones. In this study, we explored the possibility that the hormesis concept may describe the interactions between two tumors implanted in a single mouse, such that the resulting tumors are of different sizes. MATERIALS AND METHODS: We used two murine tumors of spontaneous origin and undetectable immunogenicity growing in BALB/c mice. A measure of cell proliferation was obtained by immunostaining for Ki-67 protein and by using the [(3)H] thymidine uptake assay. For serum fractionation, we utilized dialysis and chromatography on Sephadex G-15. RESULTS: The larger primary tumor induced inhibitory or stimulatory effects on the growth of the smaller secondary one, depending on the ratio between the mass of the larger tumor relative to that of the smaller one, with high ratios rendering inhibition and low ratios inducing stimulation of the secondary tumor. CONCLUSION: Since metastases can be considered as natural secondary tumor implants in a tumor-bearing host and that they constitute the main problem in cancer pathology, the use of the concept of hormesis to describe those biphasic effects might have significant clinical implications. In effect, if the tumor-bearing host were placed in the inhibitory window, tumor extirpation could enhance the growth of distant metastases and, reciprocally, if placed in the stimulatory window, tumor extirpation would result not only in a reduction or elimination of primary tumor load but also in a slower growth or inhibition of metastases.

[Unveiling antigens in a non-immunogenic spontaneous murine tumor using a dendritic cell based vaccine]. / Hallazgo de antígenos en un tumor murino espontáneo no inmunogénico mediante el uso de una vacuna basada en células dendríticas.

Up to date, most attempts to use immunotherapy to cause the regression of animal and human established tumors have not been successful. Former experiments have postulated that this failure could be attributed, at least in part, to a lack of immunogenicity of spontaneous tumors. In this paper, we have investigated whether this lack of immunogenicity can be attributed to the absence of tumor antigens or to the existence of tolerogenic mechanisms preventing such antigens from initiating an antitumor immune response. We have used two murine tumors a non-immunogenic spontaneous lymphoma (LB) and a strongly immunogenic methylcholanthrene-induced fibrosarcoma (MC-C) together with a vaccination strategy based on the inoculation of dendritic cells (DC) loaded with a tumor lysate. When DC were pulsed with LB lysate (DC+LB), no maturation of DC was achieved in vitro and no protection against LB implants after DC+LB inoculation was observed in vivo. On the other hand, when DC were pulsed with MC-C lysate (DC+MC-C), maturation of DC was observed along with a strong protection against MC-C implants after DC+MC-C inoculaton. Finally, when DC were pulsed with both LB and MC-C lysates (DC+LB+MC-C), maturation of DC and protection against LB implants were achieved. Since no immune cross reaction between MC-C and LB was ever observed, the most likely interpretation is that LB bears specific tumor antigens but lacks other signals to achieve DC maturation. These signals would be provided by MC-C which would enable DC to mature and to initiate an effective anti-LB immune response.

Anti-inflammatory pretreatment enables an efficient dendritic cell-based immunotherapy against established tumors.

Although animals can be immunized against the growth of some tumor implants, most of the attempts to use immunotherapy to cause the regression of animal and human tumors once they have become established have been disappointing even when strongly immunogenic tumors were used as target. In this paper, we demonstrate that the failure to achieve an efficient immunological treatment against an established strongly immunogenic murine fibrosarcoma was paralleled with the emergence of a state of immunological unresponsiveness (immunological eclipse) against tumor antigens observed when the tumor surpassed the critical size of 500 mm(3). In turn, the onset of the immunological eclipse was coincidental with the onset of a systemic inflammatory condition characterized by a high number of circulating and splenic polymorphonucleated neutrophils (PMN) displaying activation and Gr1(+)Mac1(+) phenotype and an increasing serum concentration of the pro-inflammatory cytokines TNF-alpha, IL-1beta and IL-6 cytokines and C-reactive protein (CRP) and serum A amyloid (SAA) phase acute proteins. Treatment of tumor-bearing mice with a single low dose (0.75 mg/kg) of the synthetic corticoid dexamethasone (DX) significantly reduced all the systemic inflammatory parameters and simultaneously reversed the immunological eclipse, as evidenced by the restoration of specific T-cell-dependent concomitant immunity, ability of spleen cells to transfer anti-tumor activity and recovery of T-cell signal transduction molecules. Two other anti-inflammatory treatments by using indomethacin or dimeric TNF-alpha receptor, also partially reversed the immunological eclipse although the effect was not as striking as that observed with DX. The reversion of the immunological eclipse was not enough on its own to inhibit the primary growing tumor. However, when we used the two-step strategy of inoculating DX to reverse the eclipse and then dendritic cells loaded with tumor antigens (DC) as an immunization booster, a significant inhibition of the growth of both established tumors and remnant tumor cells after excision of large established tumors was observed, despite the fact that the vaccination alone (DC) had no effect or even enhanced tumor growth in certain circumstances. The two-step strategy of tumor immunotherapy that we present is based on the rationale that it is necessary to eliminate or ameliorate the immunological eclipse as a precondition to allow an otherwise ineffective anti-tumor immunological therapy to have a chance to be successful.

Therapeutic anti-tumor vaccines: from tumor inhibition to enhancement.

Numerous immunization trials have proved successful in preventing the growth of experimental animal tumors and human hepatocarcinomas induced by hepatitis B virus. These results have prompted researchers and physicians to use vaccines in a therapeutic mode but the results have, in general, been disappointing even when strongly immunogenic murine tumors were concerned. Data presented herein suggest that immunotherapy induced by a single dose of a dendritic cell-based vaccine against a murine established tumor or against residual tumor cells after debulking the primary tumor, can render not only inhibitory or null but also stimulatory effects on tumor growth. These different effects might be dependent on where the system is located in the immune response curve that relates the quantity of the immune response to the quantity of target tumor cells. We suggest that high ratios render tumor inhibition, medium and very low ratios render null effects and low ratios-between medium and very low ones-render tumor stimulation. Since the magnitude of these ratios would depend on the antigenic profile of the tumor, the immunogenic strength of the vaccine used and the immunological state of the host, studies aimed to determine the magnitude of these variables in each particular case, seem to be necessary as a pre-condition to design rational immunotherapeutic approaches to cancer. In contrast, if these studies are neglected, the worst thing that an immunotherapist could face is not merely a null effect but enhancement of tumor growth.

[Systemic inflammation and experimental cancer in a murine model]. / Cáncer experimental e inflamación sistémica en un modelo murino.

The link between cancer and inflammation in an organ or tissue has firmly been established on the basis that cancer tends to occur at sites of chronic inflammation and that local inflammatory processes can accelerate the growth of preexisting tumors in both animals and human beings. In contrast, the relationship between cancer and systemic inflammation has been less studied. In this work, we demonstrated that the growth of the murine fibrosarcoma MC-C, was accompanied by manifestations of systemic inflammation, as demonstrated by an increase in both the number of circulating polymorphonuclear neutrophils (PMN) and the serum concentration of the proinflammatory cytokines interleukin-1beta (IL-1beta), interleukin-6 (IL-6) and tumor necrosis factor-alpha (TNF-alpha) and the acute phase proteins C reactive (CRP) and serum A amyloid (SAA). Two temporally separate peaks of systemic inflammation were detected during tumor development. The first was displayed during the first week after tumor inoculation. The second peak began around day 14 and its intensity was proportional to tumor size. In mice bearing a large MC-C tumor, a high number of circulating PMN and myeloid precursors were evident. Most of these cells exhibited activation evidenced by an increased reactive oxygen species generation and high expression of the Gr1+/Mac1+ markers. Inoculation of thioglycolate -which generates a transient systemic inflammation-accelerated the growth of MC-C tumor and reciprocally, inhibition of such systemic inflammation by using indomethacin, prevented that enhancing effect. This suggests that the systemic inflammation that the tumor generates on its own, could be part of its growth strategy.

Cáncer experimental e inflamación sistémica en un modelo murino / Systemic inflammation and experimental cancer in a murine model

La asociación entre cáncer e inflamación en un órgano o tejido se encuentra sólidamente establecida. En efecto, se sabe que en sitios de inflamación crónica, existe una mayor probabilidad de que se origine un tumor y que procesos inflamatorios locales pueden acelerar el crecimiento de tumores preexistentes en animales y seres humanos. Por otro lado, la relación entre cáncer e inflamación sistémica ha sido menos estudiada. En este trabajo, demostramos que el crecimiento de un fibrosarcoma de ratón (MC-C) fue acompañado por inflamación sistémica, evidenciada por neutrofilia y por un aumento de la concentración sérica de las citoquinas pro-inflamatorias interleuquina-1 beta (IL-1 beta), interleuquina-6 (IL-6) y factor de necrosis tumoral-alfa (TNF-alfa) y de las proteínas de fase aguda C reactiva (CRP) y A amieloide (SAA). Hubo un pico de estas moléculas poco después de la inoculación del tumor, que cayó a valores normales después de la primera semana, para luego comenzar a incrementarse progresivamente en función del tamaño tumoral. Una variación similar fue vista en el porcentaje de neutrófilos polimorfonucleares (PMN) circulantes. En ratones portadores de tumores grandes la mayoría de los PMN exhibían activación evidenciada por aumento en la generación de especies reactivas del oxígeno y alta expresión de los marcadores Gr1+/Mac1+. La inoculación de tioglicolato, que produce una inflamación sistémica transitoria, aceleró el crecimiento de MC-C, mientras que el tratamiento anti-inflamatorio con indometacina revirtió ese efecto. Esto sugiere que MC-C podría utilizar el fenómeno de inflamación sistémica que genera por sí mismo, como parte de su estrategia de crecimiento.

The link between cancer and inflammation in an organ or tissue has firmly been established on the basis that cancer tends to occur at sites of chronic inflammation and that local inflammatory processes can accelerate the growth of preexisting tumors in both animals and human beings. In contrast, the relationship between cancer and systemic inflammation has been less studied. In this work, we demonstrated that the growth of the murine fibrosarcoma MC-C, was accompanied by manifestations of systemic inflammation, as demonstrated by an increase in both the number of circulating polymorphonuclear neutrophils (PMN) and the serum concentration of the proinflammatory cytokines interleukin-1 beta (IL-1 beta), interleukin-6 (IL-6) and tumor necrosis factor-alpha (TNF-alpha) and the acute phase proteins C reactive (CRP) and serum A amyloid (SAA). Two temporally separate peaks of systemic inflammation were detected during tumor development. The first was displayed during the first week after tumor inoculation. The second peak began around day 14 and its intensity was proportional to tumor size. In mice bearing a large MC-C tumor, a high number of circulating PMN and myeloid precursors were evident. Most of these cells exhibited activation evidenced by an increased reactive oxygen species generation and high expression of the Gr1+/Mac1+ markers. Inoculation of thioglycolate -which generates a transient systemic inflammation- accelerated the growth of MC-C tumor and reciprocally, inhibition of such systemic inflammation by using indomethacin, prevented that enhancing effect. This suggests that the systemic inflammation that the tumor generates on its own, could be part of its growth strategy.

Immune complexes inhibit differentiation, maturation, and function of human monocyte-derived dendritic cells.

The interaction between immune complexes (IC) and the receptors for the Fc portion of IgG (FcgammaRs) triggers regulatory and effector functions in the immune system. In this study, we investigated the effects of IC on differentiation, maturation, and functions of human monocyte-derived dendritic cells (DC). When IC were added on day 0, DC generated on day 6 (IC-DC) showed lower levels of CD1a and increased expression of CD14, MHC class II, and the macrophage marker CD68, as compared with normally differentiated DC. The use of specific blocking FcgammaR mAbs indicated that the effect of IC was exerted mainly through their interaction with FcgammaRI and to a lesser extend with FcgammaRII. Immature IC-DC also expressed higher levels of CD83, CD86, and CD40 and the expression of these maturation markers was not further regulated by LPS. The apparent lack of maturation following TLR stimulation was associated with a decreased production of IL-12, normal secretion of IL-10 and CCL22, and increased production of CXCL8 and CCL2. IC-DC displayed low endocytic activity and a reduced ability to induce allogeneic T cell proliferation both at basal and LPS-stimulated conditions. Altogether, these data reveal that IC strongly affect DC differentiation and maturation. Skewing of DC function from Ag presentation to a proinflammatory phenotype by IC resembles the state of activation observed in DC obtained from patients with chronic inflammatory autoimmune disorders, such as systemic lupus erythematosus disease and arthritis. Therefore, the altered maturation of DC induced by IC may be involved in the pathogenesis of autoimmune diseases.

[Reversion of the immunological eclipse and therapeutic vaccination against cancer in an experimental model]. / Reversion del eclipse inmunologico y vacunacion terapeutica contra el cancer en un modelo experimental.

Although animals can be prophylactically immunized against the growth of tumor implants, most of the attempts to use immunotherapy to cause the regression of animal and human tumors once they become established have been unsuccessful. To understand the nature of this refractoriness we have studied a methylcholanthrene-induced and strongly immunogenic murine fibrosarcoma. In our model, the onset of this refractoriness was associated with the beginning of an immunosuppressive state known as "immunological eclipse" characterized by a loss of the antitumor immune response when tumor grows beyond a critical size. This immunological eclipse was accompanied by the emergence of a systemic inflammatory condition. Treatment of tumor-bearing mice with a single dose of a synthetic corticosteroid, dexamethasone (DX), reduced significantly all parameters of systemic inflammation and simultaneously reversed the immunological eclipse. The reversion of the eclipse upon DX treatment was not curative itself, but allowed an immunological therapy based in dendritic cells pulsed with tumor antigens, which was itself absolutely ineffective, to exert a significant inhibitory effect against an established growing tumor. The two-step schedule using an anti-inflammatory treatment to reverse the immunological eclipse plus a dendritic cell-based vaccination strategy aimed to stimulate the antitumor immune response, could serve eventually as a model of immunotherapy against animal and human tumors.