RESUMEN
Antisemitism, the hatred of or prejudice against Jews, was a core component of the Nazi regime's ideology. We review the chronology of events against the Jews and Jewish physicians in Germany and their conquered territories from 1933 to 1945. The complicit role that German physicians played in these events and the devastating impact on Jewish dermatologists and our specialty will be recounted. Finally, we will address the antisemitism in the United States during that same approximate period and now.
Asunto(s)
Dermatología , Judíos , Nacionalsocialismo , Nacionalsocialismo/historia , Historia del Siglo XX , Alemania , Dermatología/historia , Judíos/historia , Humanos , Estados Unidos , Prejuicio/historiaAsunto(s)
Ética Médica , Historia de la Medicina , Racismo , Justicia Social , Humanos , Historia del Siglo XIX , Historia del Siglo XX , Racismo/historia , Justicia Social/historia , Estados Unidos , Historia del Siglo XXI , Edición/ética , Edición/historia , Medicina , Prejuicio/historia , Esclavización/etnología , Esclavización/historia , Indio Americano o Nativo de Alaska , Negro o Afroamericano , Massachusetts , Ética Médica/historiaAsunto(s)
Ética , Nacionalsocialismo , Prejuicio , Edición , Humanos , Ética/historia , Ética Médica/historia , Alemania , Historia del Siglo XX , Medicina , Nacionalsocialismo/historia , Prejuicio/ética , Prejuicio/etnología , Prejuicio/historia , Propaganda , Edición/ética , Edición/historia , Edición/normas , Ciencia/ética , Ciencia/historia , Racismo Sistemático/ética , Racismo Sistemático/etnología , Racismo Sistemático/historia , Estados Unidos , Derechos Humanos/ética , Derechos Humanos/historiaRESUMEN
Speeches by modern-day White supremacists often include such statements as "Jews will not replace us." In 1934, the French-speaking medical interns of Montreal's Roman Catholic hospitals went on strike because, they alleged, a Jew "replaced" a Roman Catholic French Canadian. Anti-Semitic social and economic boycotts and educational quotas were in existence in Canada from the 19th through the mid-20th century. There were particularly strong anti-immigrant and anti-Semitic feelings in the first half of the 20th century in Quebec, along with anti-Semitic pro-fascist political parties. In 1934, Montreal's Hôpital Notre-Dame (HND), a teaching hospital of the Université de Montréal (UM) medical school, was unable to hire a full complement of medical interns from among the newly graduated French-speaking Roman Catholic medical students. The hospital hired a French-speaking Jewish graduate of UM, Samuel Rabinovitch. The prospective interns at HND submitted a petition demanding that Rabinovitch be fired, stating, "We do not want him because he is a Jew." On 14 and 15 June 1934, HND's interns went on strike to prevent Rabinovitch from taking up his duties. The strike spread to multiple hospitals in Montreal. A Jewish urology trainee at the Hôtel Dieu hospital, Abram Stilman, was also targeted. Rabinovitch resigned in order to bring the strike to an end. The strike buttressed the case in the first half of the 20th century for American and Canadian Jewish hospitals and medical schools to ensure the education of Jewish physicians, reminds us of the origins of the slogans of modern White supremacists, and reinforces the historical basis of efforts to promote diversity and inclusion in medical education.
Asunto(s)
Internado y Residencia/historia , Judíos/historia , Prejuicio/historia , Canadá , Historia del Siglo XX , Hospitales de Enseñanza/historia , HumanosRESUMEN
In the 1930s and 1940s, the medical profession reacted with hostility and erected formidable barriers to refugee physicians from Nazi-dominated Europe who sought to practice medicine in the United States. Yet, refugee physicians ultimately succeeded, with 77% of them working as doctors by 1945 and 98.6% by 1947. Although physician skills are readily transferable, and the United States had a genuine need for doctors after World War II drew 55 000 physicians into the military, refugee physicians' success can be attributed to the courageous physician leaders who lobbied on their behalf and the creation of the National Committee for the Resettlement of Foreign Physicians-an organization that helped immigrant physicians pass licensing examinations, identify locations for employment, and overcome barriers to integration into American society.
Asunto(s)
Médicos Graduados Extranjeros/historia , Judaísmo/historia , Nacionalsocialismo/historia , Prejuicio/historia , Refugiados/historia , Alemania , Historia del Siglo XX , Humanos , Licencia Médica/historia , Estados Unidos , Segunda Guerra MundialRESUMEN
In the current pandemic times, medical physicists may not be aware that there is an interesting story on two significant discoveries related to the coronavirus. One is the invention of the polymerase chain reaction (PCR) and the other is the first electron microscopic observation and identification of the coronavirus. Both of them were disregarded by the reviewers and major journals declined to publish these discoveries. These days, PCR, for example, is a widespread method for analyzing DNA, having a profound effect on healthcare, especially now during the Covid-19 pandemic. Prejudice or perhaps ignorance prevail in every aspect of our society, and there is no exception in scientific research. We need to, however, learn from these two stories and be open-minded about novel discoveries and findings - as they may be just disruptive in the "right" way to lead to an unexpected breakthrough.
Asunto(s)
Coronavirus , Publicaciones Periódicas como Asunto/historia , Prejuicio/historia , Comunicación Académica/historia , COVID-19 , Coronavirus/clasificación , Coronavirus/ultraestructura , Infecciones por Coronavirus , Historia del Siglo XX , Humanos , Microscopía Inmunoelectrónica/historia , Pandemias , Neumonía Viral , Reacción en Cadena de la Polimerasa/historiaRESUMEN
This essay uses the case of the fin-de-siècle Vienna embryologist Samuel Leopold Schenk to analyze the factors at play in allegations of misconduct. In 1898, Schenk published a book titled Theorie Schenk. Einfluss auf das Geschlechtsverhältnis (Schenk's theory. Influence on the sex ratio). The book argued that, by changing their diet, women trying to conceive could influence egg maturation and consequently select the sex of their offspring. This cross between a scientific monograph and a popular advice book received enormous publicity but also spurred first the Vienna Medical Association and then the Senate of the University of Vienna to accuse Schenk of poor science, self-advertisement, quack medical practice, and wrong publisher choice. Formal proceedings against Schenk ended in 1900 with the unusually harsh punishment of early retirement. Schenk died two years later. I examine the elements of the case, from the science of sex determination and selection, to the growth of print media and advertising within the changing demographic and political landscape of Vienna. I argue that the influence of the public, via the growing media, upon science was the main driver of the case against Schenk, but also that the case would have had a more limited impact were it not for the volatile political moment rife with anti-Semitism, nationalism, and xenophobia. I draw the attention to the importance of setting cases of misconduct in the broader political history and against the key social concerns of the moment.
Asunto(s)
Embriología/historia , Preselección del Sexo/historia , Austria-Hungría , Embriología/ética , Embriología/legislación & jurisprudencia , Femenino , Historia del Siglo XIX , Humanos , Judíos/historia , Periodismo Médico/historia , Masculino , Política , Prejuicio/historia , Publicaciones/ética , Publicaciones/historia , Charlatanería/historia , Charlatanería/legislación & jurisprudencia , Facultades de Medicina/historia , Procesos de Determinación del Sexo , Preselección del Sexo/métodosRESUMEN
American physician Emanuel Libman (1872-1946) was a generalist with Sherlockian diagnostic skills ("secret-divining eyes" according to Einstein) whose achievements were recognized by the scientific community and the public. Personal aspects of Libman were revealed in an oral history conducted with psychiatrist George L. Engel, a nephew who was raised in his house, and show Libman to be an intensely private person, contrasting with the image of him as a mentor and teacher. Yet Libman as a young physician and investigator remains absent in these opposing biographical reflections. His papers housed at the National Library of Medicine contain a series of letters sent home from his year of postgraduate study in Europe in 1897. These letters, which have not been previously described in the medical literature, create a window into the experiences of a young American physician abroad. Libman's letters create a framework for understanding a typical European course of study for American physicians while tracing his career and personal development. Specifically, his correspondence highlights foundational experiences in bacteriology and pathology and explores his encounters with European anti-Semitism. The letters reveal a young doctor interested in history and sightseeing, awed by medical luminaries, concerned about establishing a career, and increasingly aware of intolerance.
Asunto(s)
Bacteriología/historia , Patólogos/historia , Médicos/historia , Prejuicio/historia , Europa (Continente) , Historia del Siglo XIX , Estados UnidosRESUMEN
At the end of World War II anti-Semitism was pervasive in the United States. Quotas to limit the number of Jewish students were put in place at most U.S. medical schools in the 1920s and were well-entrenched by 1945. By 1970 the quota was gone. Why? Multiple factors contributed to the end of the quota. First, attitudes toward Jews shifted as Americans recoiled from the horrors of the Holocaust and over half a million Jewish GIs returned home from World War II. Many entered the higher education system. Second, governmental and private investigations in New York City, New York State and Philadelphia exposed the quota. Third, New York State, led by Governor Thomas E. Dewey, established 4 publicly supported nondiscriminatory medical schools. These schools adsorbed many New York Jewish applicants. Fourth, from the 1920s through the 1960s some medical schools consistently or intermittently ignored the quota. Finally, the federal and several state governments passed nondiscrimination in higher education legislation. The quotas ended because of a combination of changing societal attitudes and government and private social action. This remarkable social change may be instructive as higher education now grapples with allegations of a quota system for Asian-Americans.
Asunto(s)
Educación Médica , Judíos/educación , Prejuicio , Facultades de Medicina , Asiático/educación , Educación Médica/ética , Educación Médica/historia , Educación Médica/legislación & jurisprudencia , Historia del Siglo XX , Humanos , Prejuicio/historia , Prejuicio/legislación & jurisprudencia , Facultades de Medicina/ética , Facultades de Medicina/legislación & jurisprudencia , Facultades de Medicina/organización & administración , Estados UnidosRESUMEN
Anti-Semitic quotas to restrict access to medical school, graduate medical education and hospital privileges were common in the United States from the 1920s to the 1960s. In Brooklyn, New York, medical education prejudice resulted in violence. In 1916 a Jewish intern at Kings County Hospital, Matthew Olstein, was bound and gagged by Christian interns, put on a train at Grand Central Station, and warned that if he returned he would be thrown in the East River. Olstein died in combat in World War I as an Army physician. In 1927 3 Jewish interns at Kings County Hospital were assaulted, bound, dumped in tubs of water and covered in black fluid. Six gentile physicians were charged with assault. Criminal proceedings and public investigations followed. These attacks are the only known episodes of violence associated with American medical education anti-Semitism.
Asunto(s)
Educación Médica/historia , Internado y Residencia , Médicos/historia , Prejuicio/historia , Historia del Siglo XX , Judíos , New YorkAsunto(s)
Estado de Salud , Hostilidad , Grupos Minoritarios/psicología , Rol del Médico , Política , Prejuicio , Conducta Social , Adulto , Emigrantes e Inmigrantes/psicología , Personal de Salud , Cardiopatías/historia , Cardiopatías/psicología , Historia del Siglo XIX , Historia del Siglo XX , Historia del Siglo XXI , Humanos , Prejuicio/historia , Prejuicio/psicología , Racismo/psicología , Rol , Estados UnidosRESUMEN
In this article, I examine how African American soldiers and veterans experienced and shaped federally sponsored health care during and after World War I. Building on studies of the struggles of Black leaders and health care providers to win professional and public health advancement in the 1920s and 1930s, and of advocates to mobilize for health care rights in the mid-20th century, I focus primarily on the experiences and activism of patients in the interwar years. Private and government correspondence, congressional testimony, and reports from Black newspapers reveal that African American soldiers and veterans communicated directly with policymakers and bureaucrats regarding unequal treatment, assuming roles as "policy actors" who viewed health and medical care as "politics by other means." In the process, they drew attention to the paradoxes inherent in expanding government entitlements in the era of Jim Crow, and helped shape a veterans' health system that emerged in the 1920s and remained in place for the following century. They also laid the groundwork for the system's precedent-setting desegregation, referred to by advocates of the time as "a shining example to the rest of the country."
Asunto(s)
Negro o Afroamericano/historia , Hospitales Militares/historia , Personal Militar/historia , Defensa del Paciente/historia , Prejuicio/historia , Veteranos/historia , Política de Salud/historia , Historia del Siglo XX , Humanos , Masculino , Estados Unidos , Primera Guerra MundialRESUMEN
In 1902, the Berlin Jewish urologist James Israel was nominated for the Nobel Prize in physiology or medicine. Taking scholar, social, and political aspects into consideration, this biographical essay traces how James Israel gained a sound scientific reputation especially in kidney surgery within Imperial Germany and its antisemitic attitude and how he promoted urology to become a specialty in its own right.
Asunto(s)
Judíos/historia , Nefrectomía/historia , Premio Nobel , Prejuicio/historia , Enfermedades Urológicas/historia , Urología/historia , Historia del Siglo XIX , Historia del Siglo XX , HumanosRESUMEN
At least 564,500 Hungarian Jews perished during the Holocaust, including many physicians. Exactly how many Jewish dermatologists were killed is not known. We have identified 62 Hungarian Jewish dermatologists from this period: 19 of these dermatologists died in concentration camps or were shot in Hungary, 3 committed suicide, and 1 died shortly after the Holocaust, exhausted by the War. Fortunately, many Hungarian Jewish dermatologists survived the Holocaust. Some had fled Europe before the Nazi takeover, as was described in Part 1 of this contribution. Two Holocaust survivors, Ferenc Földvári and Ödön Rajka, became presidents of the Hungarian Dermatologic Society and helped rebuild the profession of dermatology in Hungary after the War. This contribution provides one of the first accounts of the fate of Hungarian Jewish dermatologists during the Holocaust and serves as a remembrance of their suffering and ordeal.
Asunto(s)
Dermatólogos/historia , Holocausto/historia , Judíos/historia , Sobrevivientes/historia , Segunda Guerra Mundial , Campos de Concentración/historia , Historia del Siglo XX , Humanos , Hungría , Judíos/legislación & jurisprudencia , Prejuicio/historia , Suicidio/historiaAsunto(s)
Negro o Afroamericano/historia , Centros Comunitarios de Salud/historia , Agentes Comunitarios de Salud/historia , Salud Pública/instrumentación , Accesibilidad a los Servicios de Salud/historia , Disparidades en el Estado de Salud , Historia del Siglo XX , Humanos , Massachusetts , Pobreza/historia , Prejuicio/historia , Racismo , Problemas Sociales/historia , Estados UnidosRESUMEN
The physician and psychologist Dr. Fredy Quadfasel, born in East Prussia, was trained in neuropsychiatry by Kurt Goldstein in Frankfurt/Main and by Karl Bonhoeffer at the Charité in Berlin. After he was detained by the Gestapo due to political opposition, he was probably denounced for offending the so-called Malicious Practices Act (Heimtückegesetz) from March 1933, and imprisoned for 2-3 months. In 1934/35 he emigrated to the USA via England and Canada, where he initially ran a neuropsychiatry office in New York. Very soon he was able to take on an academic post and became an instructor in neurology. After medical military service in 1944-1947 at the Cushing General Hospital in Framingham near Boston, he was appointed head of the neurological department. Later he moved on to the Boston Veterans Administration Hospital. His academic positions included being an instructor in neurology at Harvard Medical School and associate professor at the Boston University School of Medicine. He had a considerable impact on neurology, especially on the locally emerging discipline of neuropsychology represented by Harold Goodglass and Norman Geschwind. Despite a lack of personal records of Quadfasel, a chequered reconstruction of his life and work was possible due to many archival documents with which it was possible to trace the career of a highly esteemed neurologist in Germany and the USA.