Establishment of Cardiac Laterality.

Formation of the vertebrate heart with its complex arterial and venous connections is critically dependent on patterning of the left-right axis during early embryonic development. Abnormalities in left-right patterning can lead to a variety of complex life-threatening congenital heart defects. A highly conserved pathway responsible for left-right axis specification has been uncovered. This pathway involves initial asymmetric activation of a nodal signaling cascade at the embryonic node, followed by its propagation to the left lateral plate mesoderm and activation of left-sided expression of the Pitx2 transcription factor specifying visceral organ asymmetry. Intriguingly, recent work suggests that cardiac laterality is encoded by intrinsic cell and tissue chirality independent of Nodal signaling. Thus, Nodal signaling may be superimposed on this intrinsic chirality, providing additional instructive cues to pattern cardiac situs. The impact of intrinsic chirality and the perturbation of left-right patterning on myofiber organization and cardiac function warrants further investigation. We summarize recent insights gained from studies in animal models and also some human clinical studies in a brief overview of the complex processes regulating cardiac asymmetry and their impact on cardiac function and the pathogenesis of congenital heart defects.

Tissue-intrinsic beta-catenin signals antagonize Nodal-driven anterior visceral endoderm differentiation.

The anterior-posterior axis of the mammalian embryo is laid down by the anterior visceral endoderm (AVE), an extraembryonic signaling center that is specified within the visceral endoderm. Current models posit that AVE differentiation is promoted globally by epiblast-derived Nodal signals, and spatially restricted by a BMP gradient established by the extraembryonic ectoderm. Here, we report spatially restricted AVE differentiation in bilayered embryo-like aggregates made from mouse embryonic stem cells that lack an extraembryonic ectoderm. Notably, clusters of AVE cells also form in pure visceral endoderm cultures upon activation of Nodal signaling, indicating that tissue-intrinsic factors can restrict AVE differentiation. We identify ß-catenin activity as a tissue-intrinsic factor that antagonizes AVE-inducing Nodal signals. Together, our results show how an AVE-like population can arise through interactions between epiblast and visceral endoderm alone. This mechanism may be a flexible solution for axis patterning in a wide range of embryo geometries, and provide robustness to axis patterning when coupled with signal gradients.

Axis formation in annual killifish: Nodal and ß-catenin regulate morphogenesis without Huluwa prepatterning.

Axis formation in fish and amphibians typically begins with a prepattern of maternal gene products. Annual killifish embryogenesis, however, challenges prepatterning models as blastomeres disperse and then aggregate to form the germ layers and body axes. We show that huluwa, a prepatterning factor thought to break symmetry by stabilizing ß-catenin, is truncated and inactive in Nothobranchius furzeri. Nuclear ß-catenin is not selectively stabilized on one side of the blastula but accumulates in cells forming the aggregate. Blocking ß-catenin activity or Nodal signaling disrupts aggregate formation and germ layer specification. Nodal signaling coordinates cell migration, establishing an early role for this signaling pathway. These results reveal a surprising departure from established mechanisms of axis formation: Huluwa-mediated prepatterning is dispensable, and ß-catenin and Nodal regulate morphogenesis.

Nodal negatively regulates osteoclast differentiation by inducing STAT1 phosphorylation.

Several members of the transforming growth factor beta (TGF-ß) superfamily regulate the proliferation, differentiation, and function of bone-forming osteoblasts and bone-resorbing osteoclasts. However, it is still unknown whether Nodal, a member of the TGF-ß superfamily, serves a function in bone cells. In this study, we found that Nodal did not have any function in osteoblasts but instead negatively regulated osteoclast differentiation. Nodal inhibited RANKL-induced osteoclast differentiation by downregulating the expression of pro-osteoclastogenic genes, including c-fos, Nfatc1, and Blimp1, and upregulating the expression of antiosteoclastogenic genes, including Bcl6 and Irf8. Nodal activated STAT1 in osteoclast precursor cells, and STAT1 downregulation significantly reduced the inhibitory effect of Nodal on osteoclast differentiation. These findings indicate that Nodal activates STAT1 to downregulate or upregulate the expression of pro-osteoclastogenic or antiosteoclastogenic genes, respectively, leading to the inhibition of osteoclast differentiation. Moreover, the inhibitory effect of Nodal on osteoclast differentiation contributed to the reduction of RANKL-induced bone loss in vivo.

Subtype and Lineage-Mediated Protocol for Standardizing Activin/Nodal and BMP Signaling for hiPSC-Derived Cardiomyocyte Differentiation.

The adept and systematic differentiation of embryonic stem cells (ESCs) and human-induced pluripotent stem cells (hiPSCs) to diverse lineage-prone cell types involves crucial step-by-step process that mimics the vital strategic commitment phase that is usually observed during the process of embryo development. The development of precise tissue-specific cell types from these stem cells indeed plays an important role in the advancement of imminent stem cell-based therapeutic strategies. Therefore, the usage of hiPSC-derived cell types for subsequent cardiovascular disease modeling, drug screening, and therapeutic drug development undeniably entails an in-depth understanding of each and every step to proficiently stimulate these stem cells into desired cardiomyogenic lineage. Thus, to accomplish this definitive and decisive fate, it is essential to efficiently induce the mesoderm or pre-cardiac mesoderm, succeeded by the division of cells into cardiovascular and ultimately ensuing with the cardiomyogenic lineage outcome. This usually commences from the earliest phases of pluripotent cell induction. In this chapter, we discuss our robust and reproducible step-wise protocol that will describe the subtype controlled, precise lineage targeted standardization of activin/nodal, and BMP signaling molecules/cytokines, for the efficient differentiation of ventricular cardiomyocytes from hiPSCs via the embryoid body method. In addition, we also describe techniques to dissociate hiPSCs, hiPSC-derived early cardiomyocytes for mesoderm and pre-cardiac mesoderm assessment, and hiPSC-derived cardiomyocytes for early and mature markers assessment.

Robust axis elongation by Nodal-dependent restriction of BMP signaling.

Embryogenesis results from the coordinated activities of different signaling pathways controlling cell fate specification and morphogenesis. In vertebrate gastrulation, both Nodal and BMP signaling play key roles in germ layer specification and morphogenesis, yet their interplay to coordinate embryo patterning with morphogenesis is still insufficiently understood. Here, we took a reductionist approach using zebrafish embryonic explants to study the coordination of Nodal and BMP signaling for embryo patterning and morphogenesis. We show that Nodal signaling triggers explant elongation by inducing mesendodermal progenitors but also suppressing BMP signaling activity at the site of mesendoderm induction. Consistent with this, ectopic BMP signaling in the mesendoderm blocks cell alignment and oriented mesendoderm intercalations, key processes during explant elongation. Translating these ex vivo observations to the intact embryo showed that, similar to explants, Nodal signaling suppresses the effect of BMP signaling on cell intercalations in the dorsal domain, thus allowing robust embryonic axis elongation. These findings suggest a dual function of Nodal signaling in embryonic axis elongation by both inducing mesendoderm and suppressing BMP effects in the dorsal portion of the mesendoderm.

Uterine Nodal expression supports maternal immunotolerance and establishment of the FOXP3+ regulatory T cell population during the preimplantation period.

Pregnancy success is dependent on the establishment of maternal tolerance during the preimplantation period. The immunosuppressive function of regulatory T cells is critical to limit inflammation arising from implantation of the semi-allogeneic blastocyst. Insufficient maternal immune adaptations to pregnancy have been frequently associated with cases of female infertility and recurrent implantation failure. The role of Nodal, a secreted morphogen of the TGFß superfamily, was recently implicated during murine pregnancy as its conditional deletion (NodalΔ/Δ) in the female reproductive tract resulted in severe subfertility. Here, it was determined that despite normal preimplantation processes and healthy, viable embryos, NodalΔ/Δ females had a 50% implantation failure rate compared to NodalloxP/loxP controls. Prior to implantation, the expression of inflammatory cytokines MCP-1, G-CSF, IFN-γ and IL-10 was dysregulated in the NodalΔ/Δ uterus. Further analysis of the preimplantation leukocyte populations in NodalΔ/Δ uteri showed an overabundance of infiltrating, pro-inflammatory CD11bhigh Ly6C+ macrophages coupled with the absence of CD4+ FOXP3+ regulatory T cells. Therefore, it is proposed that uterine Nodal expression during the preimplantation period has a novel role in the establishment of maternal immunotolerance, and its dysregulation should be considered as a potential contributor to cases of female infertility and recurrent implantation failure.

Nodal flow transfers polycystin to determine mouse left-right asymmetry.

Left-dominant [Ca2+]i elevation on the left margin of the ventral node furnishes the initial laterality of mouse embryos. It depends on extracellular leftward fluid flow (nodal flow), fibroblast growth factor receptor (FGFR)/sonic hedgehog (Shh) signaling, and the PKD1L1 polycystin subunit, of which interrelationship is still elusive. Here, we show that leftward nodal flow directs PKD1L1-containing fibrous strands and facilitates Nodal-mediated [Ca2+]i elevation on the left margin. We generate KikGR-PKD1L1 knockin mice in order to monitor protein dynamics with a photoconvertible fluorescence protein tag. By imaging those embryos, we have identified fragile meshwork being gradually transferred leftward involving pleiomorphic extracellular events. A portion of the meshwork finally bridges over the left nodal crown cells in an FGFR/Shh-dependent manner. As PKD1L1 N-term is predominantly associated with Nodal on the left margin and that PKD1L1/PKD2 overexpression significantly augments cellular Nodal sensitivity, we propose that leftward transfer of polycystin-containing fibrous strands determines left-right asymmetry in developing embryos.

Chronic demyelination and myelin repair after spinal cord injury in mice: A potential link for glutamatergic axon activity.

Our prior work examining endogenous repair after spinal cord injury (SCI) in mice revealed that large numbers of new oligodendrocytes (OLs) are generated in the injured spinal cord, with peak oligodendrogenesis between 4 and 7 weeks post-injury (wpi). We also detected new myelin formation over 2 months post-injury (mpi). Our current work significantly extends these results, including quantification of new myelin through 6 mpi and concomitant examination of indices of demyelination. We also examined electrophysiological changes during peak oligogenesis and a potential mechanism driving OL progenitor cell (OPC) contact with axons. Results reveal peak in remyelination occurs during the 3rd mpi, and that myelin generation continues for at least 6 mpi. Further, motor evoked potentials significantly increased during peak remyelination, suggesting enhanced axon potential conduction. Interestingly, two indices of demyelination, nodal protein spreading and Nav1.2 upregulation, were also present chronically after SCI. Nav1.2 was expressed through 10 wpi and nodal protein disorganization was detectable throughout 6 mpi suggesting chronic demyelination, which was confirmed with EM. Thus, demyelination may continue chronically, which could trigger the long-term remyelination response. To examine a potential mechanism that may initiate post-injury myelination, we show that OPC processes contact glutamatergic axons in the injured spinal cord in an activity-dependent manner. Notably, these OPC/axon contacts were increased 2-fold when axons were activated chemogenetically, revealing a potential therapeutic target to enhance post-SCI myelin repair. Collectively, results show the surprisingly dynamic nature of the injured spinal cord over time and that the tissue may be amenable to treatments targeting chronic demyelination.

Characterization of the patients with antibodies against nodal-paranodal junction proteins in chronic inflammatory demyelinating polyneuropathy.

OBJECTIVE: Antibodies against nodal-paranodal junction proteins have been detected in some patients with chronic inflammatory demyelinating polyradiculoneuropathy (CIDP), which is a crucial step to define the most effective treatment strategies. In this paper, we tested the positive rates of these antibodies in CIDP and characterized the clinical and electrophysiological features of the antibodies-positive patients. METHODS: We prospectively recruited 47 patients with CIDP. We detected IgG antibodies against human neurofascin-155 (NF155), neurofascin-186 (NF186), contactin-1 (CNTN1), contactin-2 (CNTN2) and contactin-associated protein-1 (Caspr1), and identified the IgG isotype with cell-based assay (CBA). We collected the demographic, clinical, laboratory, and electrophysiological information of the patients that were seropositive. RESULTS: Five patients (10.6 %) had IgG against NF155, 3 (6.4 %) against Caspr1, 2 (4.3 %) against NF186 and 1 (2.1 %) against CNTN1. All the 11 antibody-positive patients (8 males and 3 females) presented with typical clinical features. Five of them needed assistance in walking, 5 had cranial nerve impairments and 3 had autonomic disturbances. The age at onset of the patients that were anti-NF155-positive was younger (19.60 ± 9.02 years vs. 55.33 ± 11.93 years, P = 0.003) than those that were anti-Caspr1-positive. No significant difference in the functional status was observed between these two groups. The action potentials of 11/79 (13.9 %) motor nerves and 62/93 (66.7 %) sensory nerves exhibited no response. Moreover, 16/68 (23.5 %) nerves presented conduction block and 13/68 (19.1 %) nerves presented temporal dispersion. Distal motor latency (DML) of ulnar nerve and tibial nerve tended to be longer (p = 0.008 and p = 0.006, respectively) in anti-NF155-positive patients than that in anti-Caspr1-positive patients. Of the 11 patients that were antibody-positive patients, corticosteroids were effective in 3/7 (42.9 %), intravenous immunoglobins (IVIG) were effective in 1/7 (14.3 %), and rituximab was effective in 6/8 (75.0 %). CONCLUSIONS: Our findings validate the previous observation on the clinico-serological correlation between CIDP and antibodies against nodal-paranodal proteins. Of note, the damage on nerves is more severe in anti-NF155-positive patients than that in anti-Caspr1-positive patients during electrophysiological diagnosis.

Single-molecule tracking of Nodal and Lefty in live zebrafish embryos supports hindered diffusion model.

The hindered diffusion model postulates that the movement of a signaling molecule through an embryo is affected by tissue geometry and binding-mediated hindrance, but these effects have not been directly demonstrated in vivo. Here, we visualize extracellular movement and binding of individual molecules of the activator-inhibitor signaling pair Nodal and Lefty in live developing zebrafish embryos using reflected light-sheet microscopy. We observe that diffusion coefficients of molecules are high in extracellular cavities, whereas mobility is reduced and bound fractions are high within cell-cell interfaces. Counterintuitively, molecules nevertheless accumulate in cavities, which we attribute to the geometry of the extracellular space by agent-based simulations. We further find that Nodal has a larger bound fraction than Lefty and shows a binding time of tens of seconds. Together, our measurements and simulations provide direct support for the hindered diffusion model and yield insights into the nanometer-to-micrometer-scale mechanisms that lead to macroscopic signal dispersal.

Regulation of Nodal signaling propagation by receptor interactions and positive feedback.

During vertebrate embryogenesis, the germ layers are patterned by secreted Nodal signals. In the classical model, Nodals elicit signaling by binding to a complex comprising Type I/II Activin receptors (Acvr) and the co-receptor Tdgf1. However, it is currently unclear whether receptor binding can also affect the distribution of Nodals themselves through the embryo, and it is unknown which of the putative Acvr paralogs mediate Nodal signaling in zebrafish. Here, we characterize three Type I (Acvr1) and four Type II (Acvr2) homologs and show that - except for Acvr1c - all receptor-encoding transcripts are maternally deposited and present during zebrafish embryogenesis. We generated mutants and used them together with combinatorial morpholino knockdown and CRISPR F0 knockout (KO) approaches to assess compound loss-of-function phenotypes. We discovered that the Acvr2 homologs function partly redundantly and partially independently of Nodal to pattern the early zebrafish embryo, whereas the Type I receptors Acvr1b-a and Acvr1b-b redundantly act as major mediators of Nodal signaling. By combining quantitative analyses with expression manipulations, we found that feedback-regulated Type I receptors and co-receptors can directly influence the diffusion and distribution of Nodals, providing a mechanism for the spatial restriction of Nodal signaling during germ layer patterning.

Building a body is complicated. Cells must organise themselves head-to-tail, belly-to-back, and inside-to-outside. They do this by laying down a chemical map, which is made up of gradients of molecular signals, high in some places and lower in others. The amount of signal each cell receives helps to decide which part of the body it will become. One of the essential signals in developing vertebrates is Nodal. It helps cells to tell inside from outside and left from right. Cells detect Nodal using an activin receptor and co-receptor complex, which catch hold of passing Nodal proteins and transmit developmental signals into cells. An important model to study Nodal signals is the zebrafish embryo, but the identity of the activin receptors and their exact role in this organism has been unclear. To find out more, Preiß, Kögler, Mörsdorf et al. studied the activin receptors Acvr1 and Acvr2 in zebrafish embryos. The experiments revealed that two putative Acvr1 and four Acvr2 receptors were present during early development. To better understand their roles, Preiß et al. eliminated them one at a time, and in combination. Losing single activin receptors had no effect. But losing both Acvr1 receptors together stopped Nodal signalling and changed the distribution of the Nodal gradient. Loss of all Acvr2 receptors also caused developmental problems, but they were partly independent of Nodal. This suggests that Acvr1s seem to be able to transmit signals and to shape the Nodal gradient, and that Acvr2s might have another, so far unknown, role. Nodal signals guide the development of all vertebrates. Understanding how they work in a model species like zebrafish could shed light on their role in other species, including humans. A clearer picture could help to uncover what happens at a molecular level when development goes wrong.

Pitx2 patterns an accelerator-brake mechanical feedback through latent TGFß to rotate the gut.

The vertebrate intestine forms by asymmetric gut rotation and elongation, and errors cause lethal obstructions in human infants. Rotation begins with tissue deformation of the dorsal mesentery, which is dependent on left-sided expression of the Paired-like transcription factor Pitx2. The conserved morphogen Nodal induces asymmetric Pitx2 to govern embryonic laterality, but organ-level regulation of Pitx2 during gut asymmetry remains unknown. We found Nodal to be dispensable for Pitx2 expression during mesentery deformation. Intestinal rotation instead required a mechanosensitive latent transforming growth factor-ß (TGFß), tuning a second wave of Pitx2 that induced reciprocal tissue stiffness in the left mesentery as mechanical feedback with the right side. This signaling regulator, an accelerator (right) and brake (left), combines biochemical and biomechanical inputs to break gut morphological symmetry and direct intestinal rotation.

A Nodal enhanced micropeptide NEMEP regulates glucose uptake during mesendoderm differentiation of embryonic stem cells.

TGF-ß family proteins including Nodal are known as central regulators of early development in metazoans, yet our understanding of the scope of Nodal signaling's downstream targets and associated physiological mechanisms in specifying developmentally appropriate cell fates is far from complete. Here, we identified a highly conserved, transmembrane micropeptide-NEMEP-as a direct target of Nodal signaling in mesendoderm differentiation of mouse embryonic stem cells (mESCs), and this micropeptide is essential for mesendoderm differentiation. We showed that NEMEP interacts with the glucose transporters GLUT1/GLUT3 and promotes glucose uptake likely through these interactions. Thus, beyond expanding the scope of known Nodal signaling targets in early development and showing that this target micropeptide augments the glucose uptake during mesendoderm differentiation, our study provides a clear example for the direct functional impact of altered glucose metabolism on cell fate determination.

Hypoxia induced-disruption of lncRNA TUG1/PRC2 interaction impairs human trophoblast invasion through epigenetically activating Nodal/ALK7 signalling.

Inadequate trophoblastic invasion is considered as one of hallmarks of preeclampsia (PE), which is characterized by newly onset of hypertension (>140/90 mmHg) and proteinuria (>300 mg in a 24-h urine) after 20 weeks of gestation. Accumulating evidence has indicated that long noncoding RNAs are aberrantly expressed in PE, whereas detailed mechanisms are unknown. In the present study, we showed that lncRNA Taurine upregulated 1 (TUG1) were downregulated in preeclamptic placenta and in HTR8/SVneo cells under hypoxic conditions, together with reduced enhancer of zeste homolog2 (EZH2) and embryonic ectoderm development (EED) expression, major components of polycomb repressive complex 2 (PRC2), as well as activation of Nodal/ALK7 signalling pathway. Mechanistically, we found that TUG1 bound to PRC2 (EZH2/EED) in HTR8/SVneo cells and weakened TUG1/PRC2 interplay was correlated with upregulation of Nodal expression via decreasing H3K27me3 mark at the promoter region of Nodal gene under hypoxic conditions. And activation of Nodal signalling prohibited trophoblast invasion via reducing MMP2 levels. Overexpression of TUG1 or EZH2 significantly attenuated hypoxia-induced reduction of trophoblastic invasiveness via negative modulating Nodal/ALK7 signalling and rescuing expression of its downstream target MMP2. These investigations might provide some evidence for novel mechanisms responsible for inadequate trophoblastic invasion and might shed some light on identifying future therapeutic targets for PE.

Proteomic analysis of the IPF mesenchymal progenitor cell nuclear proteome identifies abnormalities in key nodal proteins that underlie their fibrogenic phenotype.

IPF is a progressive fibrotic lung disease whose pathogenesis remains incompletely understood. We have previously discovered pathologic mesenchymal progenitor cells (MPCs) in the lungs of IPF patients. IPF MPCs display a distinct transcriptome and create sustained interstitial fibrosis in immune deficient mice. However, the precise pathologic alterations responsible for this fibrotic phenotype remain to be uncovered. Quantitative mass spectrometry and interactomics is a powerful tool that can define protein alterations in specific subcellular compartments that can be implemented to understand disease pathogenesis. We employed quantitative mass spectrometry and interactomics to define protein alterations in the nuclear compartment of IPF MPCs compared to control MPCs. We identified increased nuclear levels of PARP1, CDK1, and BACH1. Interactomics implicated PARP1, CDK1, and BACH1 as key hub proteins in the DNA damage/repair, differentiation, and apoptosis signaling pathways respectively. Loss of function and inhibitor studies demonstrated important roles for PARP1 in DNA damage/repair, CDK1 in regulating IPF MPC stemness and self-renewal, and BACH1 in regulating IPF MPC viability. Our quantitative mass spectrometry studies combined with interactomic analysis uncovered key roles for nuclear PARP1, CDK1, and BACH1 in regulating IPF MPC fibrogenicity.

Establishment and interpretation of NODAL and BMP signaling gradients in early vertebrate development.

Transforming growth factor ß (TGF-ß) family ligands play crucial roles in orchestrating early embryonic development. Most significantly, two family members, NODAL and BMP form signaling gradients and indeed in fish, frogs and sea urchins these two opposing gradients are sufficient to organize a complete embryonic axis. This review focuses on how these gradients are established and interpreted during early vertebrate development. The review highlights key principles that are emerging, in particular the importance of signaling duration as well as ligand concentration in both gradient generation and their interpretation. Feedforward and feedback loops involving other signaling pathways are also essential for providing spatial and temporal information downstream of the NODAL and BMP signaling pathways. Finally, new data suggest the existence of buffering mechanisms, whereby early signaling defects can be readily corrected downstream later in development, suggesting that signaling gradients do not have to be as precise as previously thought.

A network of transcription factors governs the dynamics of NODAL/Activin transcriptional responses.

SMAD2, an effector of the NODAL/Activin signalling pathway, regulates developmental processes by sensing distinct chromatin states and interacting with different transcriptional partners. However, the network of factors that controls SMAD2 chromatin binding and shapes its transcriptional programme over time is poorly characterised. Here, we combine ATAC-seq with computational footprinting to identify temporal changes in chromatin accessibility and transcription factor activity upon NODAL/Activin signalling. We show that SMAD2 binding induces chromatin opening genome wide. We discover footprints for FOXI3, FOXO3 and ZIC3 at the SMAD2-bound enhancers of the early response genes, Pmepa1 and Wnt3, respectively, and demonstrate their functionality. Finally, we determine a mechanism by which NODAL/Activin signalling induces delayed gene expression, by uncovering a self-enabling transcriptional cascade whereby activated SMADs, together with ZIC3, induce the expression of Wnt3. The resultant activated WNT pathway then acts together with the NODAL/Activin pathway to regulate expression of delayed target genes in prolonged NODAL/Activin signalling conditions. This article has an associated First Person interview with the first author of the paper.

Biological Role of Nodal Modulator: A Comprehensive Review of the Last Two Decades.

Nodal modulator (NOMO) is a type I transmembrane protein that is conserved in various human tissues. Humans have three highly similar NOMO proteins, namely NOMO1, NOMO2, and NOMO3. These three proteins are closely related and may have similar functions. NOMO has been identified as a part of a protein complex that mediates a wide range of biological processes such as tumor formation, bone and cartilage formation, embryo formation, facial asymmetry, and development of congenital heart disease. To date, a few studies have focused on the role of NOMO; however, the mechanism underlying its effects remains unknown. To improve our understanding regarding NOMO, we reviewed the role of NOMO in different diseases and investigated the mechanism underlying its effects.

Differential impact of TGFß/SMAD signaling activity elicited by Activin A and Nodal on endoderm differentiation of epiblast stem cells.

Allocation of cells to an endodermal fate in the gastrulating embryo is driven by Nodal signaling and consequent activation of TGFß pathway. In vitro methodologies striving to recapitulate the process of endoderm differentiation, however, use TGFß family member Activin in place of Nodal. This is despite Activin not known to have an in vivo role in endoderm differentiation. In this study, five epiblast stem cell lines were subjected to directed differentiation using both Activin A and Nodal to induce endodermal fate. A reporter line harboring endoderm markers FoxA2 and Sox17 was further analyzed for TGFß pathway activation and WNT response. We demonstrated that Activin A-treated cells remain more primitive streak-like when compared to Nodal-treated cells that have a molecular profile suggestive of more advanced differentiation. Activin A elicited a robust TGFß/SMAD activity, enhanced WNT signaling activity and promoted the generation of DE precursors. Nodal treatment resulted in lower TGFß/SMAD activity, and a weaker, sustained WNT response, and ultimately failed to upregulate endoderm markers. This is despite signaling response resembling more closely the activity seen in vivo. These findings emphasize the importance of understanding the downstream activities of Activin A and Nodal signaling in directing in vitro endoderm differentiation of primed-state epiblast stem cells.