A biomechanical in-vitro study on an alternative fixation technique of the pubic symphysis for open book injuries of the pelvis.

PURPOSE: Implant failure rates remain high after plate fixation in pelvic ring injuries. The aim of this study was to compare an alternative fixation technique with suture-button devices and anterior plate fixation in partially stable open-book injuries. MATERIAL AND METHODS: We acquired 16 human fresh frozen anatomic pelvic specimens. The sacrospinous, sacrotuberous, and anterior sacroiliac ligaments were bilaterally released, and the pubic symphysis transected to simulate a partially stable open-book (AO/OTA 61-B3.1) injury. The specimens were randomly assigned to the two fixation groups. In the first group two suture-button devices were placed in a criss-crossed position through the symphysis. In second group a six-hole plate with standard 3.5 unlocked bicortical screws was used for fixation. Biomechanical testing was performed on a servo-hydraulic apparatus simulating bilateral stance, as described by Hearn and Varga. Cyclic compression loading with a progressively increasing peak load (0.5 N/cycle) was applied until failure. The failure mode, the load and the number of cycles at failure and the proximal and distal distance of the symphysis during testing were compared. RESULTS: There was no implant failure in either of the two groups. Failures occurred in nine pelvises (56.2%) at the fixation between the sacrum and the mounting jig and in seven pelvises (43.8%) in the sacroiliac joint. Neither the ultimate load nor the number of cycles at failure differed between the surgical techniques (p = 0.772; p = 0.788, respectively). In the suture button group the mean ultimate load was 874.5 N and the number of cycles at failure was 1907.9. In the plate group values were 826.1 N and 1805.6 cycles, respectively. No significant differences at proximal and distal diastasis of the symphysis were monitored during the whole loading process. CONCLUSION: The fixation with suture button implants showed comparable results to anterior plate fixation in open-book injuries of the pelvis.