Structural specificity of chloroquine-hematin binding related to inhibition of hematin polymerization and parasite growth.

Considerable data now support the hypothesis that chloroquine (CQ)-hematin binding in the parasite food vacuole leads to inhibition of hematin polymerization and parasite death by hematin poisoning. To better understand the structural specificity of CQ-hematin binding, 13 CQ analogues were chosen and their hematin binding affinity, inhibition of hematin polymerization, and inhibition of parasite growth were measured. As determined by isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC), the stoichiometry data and exothermic binding enthalpies indicated that, like CQ, these analogues bind to two or more hematin mu-oxo dimers in a cofacial pi-pi sandwich-type complex. Association constants (K(a)'s) ranged from 0.46 to 2.9 x 10(5) M(-1) compared to 4.0 x 10(5) M(-1) for CQ. Remarkably, we were not able to measure any significant interaction between hematin mu-oxo dimer and 11, the 6-chloro analogue of CQ. This result indicates that the 7-chloro substituent in CQ is a critical structural determinant in its binding affinity to hematin mu-oxo dimer. Molecular modeling experiments reinforce the view that the enthalpically favorable pi-pi interaction observed in the CQ-hematin mu-oxo dimer complex derives from a favorable alignment of the out-of-plane pi-electron density in CQ and hematin mu-oxo dimer at the points of intermolecular contact. For 4-aminoquinolines related to CQ, our data suggest that electron-withdrawing functional groups at the 7-position of the quinoline ring are required for activity against both hematin polymerization and parasite growth and that chlorine substitution at position 7 is optimal. Our results also confirm that the CQ diaminoalkyl side chain, especially the aliphatic tertiary nitrogen atom, is an important structural determinant in CQ drug resistance. For CQ analogues 1-13, the lack of correlation between K(a) and hematin polymerization IC(50) values suggests that other properties of the CQ-hematin mu-oxo dimer complex, rather than its association constant alone, play a role in the inhibition of hematin polymerization. However, there was a modest correlation between inhibition of hematin polymerization and inhibition of parasite growth when hematin polymerization IC(50) values were normalized for hematin mu-oxo dimer binding affinities, adding further evidence that antimalarial 4-aminoquinolines act by this mechanism.

An assessment of drug-haematin binding as a mechanism for inhibition of haematin polymerisation by quinoline antimalarials.

Chloroquine is thought to exert its antimalarial activity by preventing the polymerisation of toxic haematin released during proteolysis of haemoglobin in the Plasmodium digestive vacuole. However, the molecular mechanisms by which this inhibition occurs and the universality of this mechanism for other quinoline antimalarials remain to be established. We demonstrate here a correlation for eight antimalarial quinolines between inhibition of haematin polymerisation in vitro and inhibition of P. falciparum growth in culture, confirming haematin polymerisation as the likely target of quinoline blood schizonticides. Furthermore, using isothermal titration microcalorimetry, a correlation was observed between the haematin binding constant of these compounds and their ability to inhibit haematin polymerisation, suggesting that these compounds mediate their activity through binding to haematin. It was also observed that the compounds bind primarily to the mu-oxo dimer form of haematin rather than the monomeric form. It is postulated that this binding inhibits haematin polymerisation by shifting the haematin dimerisation equilibrium to the mu-oxo dimer, thus reducing the availability of monomeric haematin for incorporation into haemozoin. These data reconcile the haematin polymerisation theory with the Fitch hypothesis, which states that chloroquine mediates its activity through binding to haematin.

A comparison and analysis of several ways to promote haematin (haem) polymerisation and an assessment of its initiation in vitro.

We compared several methods for producing haematin polymerisation at physiological temperatures (i.e., 37 degrees) and found that a trophozoite lysate-mediated reaction was inappropriate for measuring compound inhibition of haematin polymerisation. Using this method, we obtained significantly higher IC50 values (concentration inhibiting haematin polymerisation by 50%) for certain compounds than when other methods were used, including a food vacuole lysate-mediated reaction. This difference was probably due to the binding of these compounds to cytosolic parasite proteins, as proteinase K treatment of the trophozoite lysate reversed this effect. The initiation of haematin polymerisation was also investigated using several assays. It was found that haematin polymerisation occurred spontaneously, in the absence of preformed haemozoin, over a period of several days, but that the process was more rapid when an acetonitrile extract of malarial trophozoites was added. This extract contained no detectable protein, and its activity could be replicated using an extract from uninfected erythrocytes and by using lipids. We therefore postulate that no protein or parasite-specific material is absolutely required for the initiation of haematin polymerisation. The formation of beta-haematin de novo using the acetonitrile extract is more pH-dependent than the generation of newly synthesised beta-haematin from preformed haemozoin and cannot proceed much above pH = 6. We postulate that the initiation of haematin polymerisation is more sensitive to the equilibrium of haematin between its monomeric and mu-oxo dimer form and requires a higher concentration of monomer than for the elongation phase of polymerisation.

Artemether administered together with haemin damages schistosomes in vitro.

We conducted experiments in vitro to assess the effect of artemether in combination with haemin on adult Schistosoma japonicum, S. mansoni and S. haematobium. When schistosomes were maintained in a medium containing artemether at concentrations of 20 micrograms/mL or less for 72 h, no apparent effect on the schistosomes was seen. When the medium contained 50 or 100 micrograms/mL haemin as well as artemether, the schistosomes showed decreased motor activity 2-24 h after exposure, which was followed by the staining of the whole worm body a reddish-yellow colour, dilatation of the intestine, and extensive vesiculation of the tegument. Some of the schistosomes died 24 h after exposure, and almost all died within 48-72 h. When schistosomes were exposed to the same concentrations of haemin alone, they were stained a light yellow colour but there was no apparent effect on their survival. Our findings suggest that artemether interacts with haemin to exert a toxic effect on the worms, which might be of importance in the further elucidation of the mechanism of action of artemether on schistosomes.

Malarial haemozoin/beta-haematin supports haem polymerization in the absence of protein.

Malarial parasites growing inside erythrocytes digest up to 80% of the host cell's haemoglobin within a lysosomal organelle, the digestive vacuole. They sequester the potentially toxic haem (Fe (II) protohaematoporphyrin) that is released during this process into an insoluble pigment called haemozoin, which consists of polymerized Fe (III) protohaematoporphyrin subunits. We have studied this process of haem polymerization, which was previously reported to be enzyme-mediated and the target of the quinoline antimalarial drugs chloroquine and quinine. Here we show that, rather than being enzyme-mediated, haem polymerization is actually a chemical process, dependent only on the presence of haem-derived material associated with haemozoin and not on protein. This discovery does not invalidate haem polymerization as a target for drug intervention and the mechanism by which haemozoin formation is initiated is still not understood, but our view of this process and of the action of choroquine must be reconsidered.

A common mechanism for blockade of heme polymerization by antimalarial quinolines.

The antimalarial quinolines are believed to work by blocking the polymerization of toxic heme released during hemoglobin proteolysis in intraerythrocytic Plasmodium falciparum. In the presence of free heme, chloroquine and quinidine associate with the heme polymer. We have proposed that this association of the quinoline-heme complex with polymer caps the growing heme polymer, preventing further sequestration of additional heme that then accumulates to levels that kill the parasite. In this work results of binding assays demonstrate that the association of quinoline-heme complex with heme polymer is specific, saturable, and high affinity and that diverse quinoline analogs can compete for binding. The relative quinoline binding affinity for heme polymer rather than free heme correlates with disruption of heme polymerization. Mefloquine, another important antimalarial quinoline, associated with polymer in a similar fashion, both in cultured parasites and in the test tube. In parasite culture, blocking heme release with protease inhibitor was antagonistic to mefloquine action, as it is to chloroquine action. These data suggest a common mechanism for quinoline antimalarial action dependent on drug interaction with both heme and heme polymer.

Hematin polymerization assay as a high-throughput screen for identification of new antimalarial pharmacophores.

Hematin polymerization is a parasite-specific process that enables the detoxification of heme following its release in the lysosomal digestive vacuole during hemoglobin degradation, and represents both an essential and a unique pharmacological drug target. We have developed a high-throughput in vitro microassay of hematin polymerization based on the detection of (14)C-labeled hematin incorporated into polymeric hemozoin (malaria pigment). The assay uses 96-well filtration microplates and requires 12 h and a Wallac 1450 MicroBeta liquid scintillation counter. The robustness of the assay allowed the rapid screening and evaluation of more than 100, 000 compounds. Random screening was complemented by the development of a pharmacophore hypothesis using the "Catalyst" program and a large amount of data available on the inhibitory activity of a large library of 4-aminoquinolines. Using these methods, we identified "hit" compounds belonging to several chemical structural classes that had potential antimalarial activity. Follow-up evaluation of the antimalarial activity of these compounds in culture and in the Plasmodium berghei murine model further identified compounds with actual antimalarial activity. Of particular interest was a triarylcarbinol (Ro 06-9075) and a related benzophenone (Ro 22-8014) that showed oral activity in the murine model. These compounds are chemically accessible and could form the basis of a new antimalarial medicinal chemistry program.