Comparison of animal and human blood for in vitro dynamic thrombogenicity testing of biomaterials.

BACKGROUND: To determine suitable alternatives to human blood for in vitro dynamic thrombogenicity testing of biomaterials, four different animal blood sources (ovine, bovine, and porcine blood from live donors, and abattoir porcine blood) were compared to fresh human blood. METHODS: To account for blood coagulability differences between individual donors and species, each blood pool was heparinized to a donor-specific concentration immediately before testing in a dynamic flow loop system. The target heparin level was established using a static thrombosis pre-test. For dynamic testing, whole blood was recirculated at room temperature for 1 h at 200 ml/min through a flow loop containing a single test material. Four materials with varying thrombotic potentials were investigated: latex (positive control), polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE) (negative control), silicone (intermediate thrombotic potential), and high-density polyethylene (HDPE) (historically thromboresistant). Thrombus weight and surface area coverage on the test materials were quantified, along with platelet count reduction in the blood. RESULTS: While donor-specific heparin levels varied substantially from 0.6 U/ml to 7.0 U/ml among the different blood sources, each source was able to differentiate between the thrombogenic latex and the thromboresistant PTFE and HDPE materials (p < 0.05). However, only donor ovine and bovine blood were sensitive enough to differentiate an increased response for the intermediate thrombotic silicone material compared to PTFE and HDPE. CONCLUSIONS: These results demonstrated that multiple animal blood sources (particularly donor ovine and bovine blood) may be suitable alternatives to fresh human blood for dynamic thrombogenicity testing when appropriate control materials and donor-specific anticoagulation levels are used.

Effect of Temperature on Thrombogenicity Testing of Biomaterials in an In Vitro Dynamic Flow Loop System.

To develop and standardize a reliable in vitro dynamic thrombogenicity test protocol, the key test parameters that could impact thrombus formation need to be investigated and understood. In this study, we evaluated the effect of temperature on the thrombogenic responses (thrombus surface coverage, thrombus weight, and platelet count reduction) of various materials using an in vitro blood flow loop test system. Whole blood from live sheep and cow donors was used to assess four materials with varying thrombogenic potentials: negative-control polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE), positive-control latex, silicone, and high-density polyethylene (HDPE). Blood, heparinized to a donor-specific concentration, was recirculated through a polyvinyl chloride tubing loop containing the test material at room temperature (22-24°C) for 1 hour, or at 37°C for 1 or 2 hours. The flow loop system could effectively differentiate a thrombogenic material (latex) from the other materials for both test temperatures and blood species ( p < 0.05). However, compared with 37°C, testing at room temperature appeared to have slightly better sensitivity in differentiating silicone (intermediate thrombogenic potential) from the relatively thromboresistant materials (PTFE and HDPE, p < 0.05). These data suggest that testing at room temperature may be a viable option for dynamic thrombogenicity assessment of biomaterials and medical devices.

Platelet and leukocyte count assay for thrombogenicity screening of biomaterials and medical devices: Evaluation and improvement of ASTM F2888 test standard.

An appropriate preclinical thrombogenicity evaluation of a blood-contacting device is important to reduce thrombosis and thromboembolism risks to patients. The in vitro platelet and leukocyte count assay, as described in the ASTM F2888 test standard, aims to assess thrombogenic potentials of blood-contacting materials. The goals of this study were to evaluate whether this standardized test method can effectively differentiate materials with different thrombogenic potentials and to investigate the impact of anticoagulation conditions on test sensitivity. Using human blood with various anticoagulation conditions, we performed the platelet and leukocyte count assays on four biomaterials and three positive control materials. We found that the use of sodium citrate anticoagulation as stipulated in the 2013 version of the ASTM F2888 standard cannot differentiate materials with different thrombogenic potentials. The modification to use low-concentration heparin, either with recalcified citrated blood or with direct heparinization, substantially improved the test sensitivity and enabled the assay to distinguish platelet count reduction between the positive controls and commonly used biomaterials. Leukocyte count was shown to be a much less sensitive indicator than platelet count for thrombogenicity evaluations of biomaterials. The findings from this study have been incorporated in the recent 2019 version of the ASTM F2888 standard.

An In Vitro Blood Flow Loop System for Evaluating the Thrombogenicity of Medical Devices and Biomaterials.

A reliable in vitro dynamic test method to evaluate device thrombogenicity is very important for the improvement of the design and safety of blood-contacting medical devices, while reducing the use of animal studies. In this study, a recirculating flow loop system was developed for thrombogenicity testing, using donor sheep blood anticoagulated with Anticoagulant Citrate Dextrose Solution A (ACDA) and used within 24-36 hr postdraw. Immediately before testing, the blood was recalcified and heparinized to a donor-specific target concentration. The heparinization level was based on a static pretest, in which latex tubes were incubated at room temperature for 30 min in blood with a series of heparin concentrations and evaluated for thrombus deposition. For dynamic testing, blood was recirculated at room temperature through a polyvinyl chloride (PVC) tubing loop containing a test material for 1 hr at 200 ml/min using a roller pump. Nine materials were investigated: a negative control (polytetrafluoroethylene [PTFE]), a positive control (latex), and seven commonly used biomaterials including PVC, two silicones with different formulations (Q-Sil and V-Sil), nylon, polyurethane (PU), high-density polyethylene (HDPE), and polyether block amide (PEBAX). The results showed that latex was significantly more thrombogenic than all the other materials (p < 0.05), PVC and Q-Sil exhibited intermediate thrombogenicity with significantly more thrombus surface coverage and thrombus weight than PTFE (p < 0.05), whereas PTFE and the rest of the biomaterials had little to no thrombus deposition. In summary, the test loop system was able to effectively differentiate materials with different thrombogenic potentials.

Effects of nanotopography on the in vitro hemocompatibility of nanocrystalline diamond coatings.

Nanocrystalline diamond (NCD) coatings have been investigated for improved wear resistance and enhanced hemocompatibility of cardiovascular devices. The goal of this study was to evaluate the effects of NCD surface nanotopography on in vitro hemocompatibility. NCD coatings with small (NCD-S) and large (NCD-L) grain sizes were deposited using microwave plasma chemical vapor deposition and characterized using scanning electron microscopy, atomic force microscopy, contact angle testing, and Raman spectroscopy. NCD-S coatings exhibited average grain sizes of 50-80 nm (RMS 5.8 nm), while NCD-L coatings exhibited average grain sizes of 200-280 nm (RMS 23.1 nm). In vitro hemocompatibility testing using human blood included protein adsorption, hemolysis, nonactivated partial thromboplastin time, platelet adhesion, and platelet activation. Both NCD coatings demonstrated low protein adsorption, a nonhemolytic response, and minimal activation of the plasma coagulation cascade. Furthermore, the NCD coatings exhibited low thrombogenicity with minimal platelet adhesion and aggregation, and similar morphological changes to surface-bound platelets (i.e., activation) in comparison to the HDPE negative control material. For all assays, there were no significant differences in the blood-material interactions of NCD-S versus NCD-L. The two tested NCD coatings, regardless of nanotopography, had similar hemocompatibility profiles compared to the negative control material (HDPE) and should be further evaluated for use in blood-contacting medical devices. © 2016 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. J Biomed Mater Res Part A: 105A: 253-264, 2017.

Centrifugation assay for measuring adhesion of serially passaged bovine chondrocytes to polystyrene surfaces.

A major obstacle in chondrocyte-based therapy for cartilage repair is the limited availability of cells that maintain their original phenotype. Propagation of chondrocytes as monolayer cultures on polystyrene surfaces is used extensively for amplifying cell numbers. However, chondrocytes undergo a phenotypic shift when propagated in this manner and display characteristics of more adherent fibroblastic cells. Little information is available about the effect of this phenotypic shift on cellular adhesion properties. We evaluated changes in adhesion property as bovine chondrocytes were serially propagated up to five passages in monolayer culture using a centrifugation cell adhesion assay, which was based on counting of cells before and after being exposed to centrifugal dislodgement forces of 120 and 350 g. Chondrocytes proliferated well in a monolayer culture with doubling times of 2-3 days, but they appeared more fibroblastic and exhibited elongated cell morphology with continued passage. The centrifugation cell adhesion assay showed that chondrocytes became more adhesive with passage as the percentage of adherent cells after centrifugation increased and was not statistically different from the adhesion of the fibroblast cell line, L929, starting at passage 3. This increased adhesiveness correlated with a shift to a fibroblastic morphology and increased collagen I mRNA expression starting at passage 2. Our findings indicate that the centrifugation cell adhesion assay may serve as a reproducible tool to track alterations in chondrocyte phenotype during their extended propagation in culture.