Toward Memory in a DNA Brush: Site-Specific Recombination Responsive to Polymer Density, Orientation, and Conformation.

Site-specific recombination is a cellular process for the integration, inversion, and excision of DNA segments that could be tailored for memory transactions in artificial cells. Here, we demonstrate the compartmentalization of cascaded gene expression reactions in a DNA brush, starting from the cell-free synthesis of a unidirectional recombinase that exchanges information between two DNA molecules, leading to gene expression turn-on/turn-off. We show that recombination yield in the DNA brush was responsive to gene composition, density, and orientation, with kinetics faster than in a homogeneous dilute bulk solution reaction. Recombination yield scaled with a power law greater than 1 with respect to the fraction of recombining DNA polymers in a dense brush. The exponent approached either 1 or 2, depending on the intermolecular distance in the brush and the position of the recombination site along the DNA contour length, suggesting that a restricted-reach effect between the recombination sites governs the recombination yield. We further demonstrate the ability to encode the DNA recombinase in the same DNA brush with its substrate constructs, enabling multiple spatially resolved orthogonal recombination transactions within a common reaction volume. Our results highlight the DNA brush as a favorable compartment to study DNA recombination, with unique properties for encoding autonomous memory transactions in DNA-based artificial cells.

Computational analysis of protein synthesis, diffusion, and binding in compartmental biochips.

Protein complex assembly facilitates the combination of individual protein subunits into functional entities, and thus plays a crucial role in biology and biotechnology. Recently, we developed quasi-twodimensional, silicon-based compartmental biochips that are designed to study and administer the synthesis and assembly of protein complexes. At these biochips, individual protein subunits are synthesized from locally confined high-density DNA brushes and are captured on the chip surface by molecular traps. Here, we investigate single-gene versions of our quasi-twodimensional synthesis systems and introduce the trap-binding efficiency to characterize their performance. We show by mathematical and computational modeling how a finite trap density determines the dynamics of protein-trap binding and identify three distinct regimes of the trap-binding efficiency. We systematically study how protein-trap binding is governed by the system's three key parameters, which are the synthesis rate, the diffusion constant and the trap-binding affinity of the expressed protein. In addition, we describe how spatially differential patterns of traps modulate the protein-trap binding dynamics. In this way, we extend the theoretical knowledge base for synthesis, diffusion, and binding in compartmental systems, which helps to achieve better control of directed molecular self-assembly required for the fabrication of nanomachines for synthetic biology applications or nanotechnological purposes.

Synchrony and pattern formation of coupled genetic oscillators on a chip of artificial cells.

Understanding how biochemical networks lead to large-scale nonequilibrium self-organization and pattern formation in life is a major challenge, with important implications for the design of programmable synthetic systems. Here, we assembled cell-free genetic oscillators in a spatially distributed system of on-chip DNA compartments as artificial cells, and measured reaction-diffusion dynamics at the single-cell level up to the multicell scale. Using a cell-free gene network we programmed molecular interactions that control the frequency of oscillations, population variability, and dynamical stability. We observed frequency entrainment, synchronized oscillatory reactions and pattern formation in space, as manifestation of collective behavior. The transition to synchrony occurs as the local coupling between compartments strengthens. Spatiotemporal oscillations are induced either by a concentration gradient of a diffusible signal, or by spontaneous symmetry breaking close to a transition from oscillatory to nonoscillatory dynamics. This work offers design principles for programmable biochemical reactions with potential applications to autonomous sensing, distributed computing, and biomedical diagnostics.

Cellular heterogeneity mediates inherent sensitivity-specificity tradeoff in cancer targeting by synthetic circuits.

Synthetic gene circuits are emerging as a versatile means to target cancer with enhanced specificity by combinatorial integration of multiple expression markers. Such circuits must also be tuned to be highly sensitive because escape of even a few cells might be detrimental. However, the error rates of decision-making circuits in light of cellular variability in gene expression have so far remained unexplored. Here, we measure the single-cell response function of a tunable logic AND gate acting on two promoters in heterogeneous cell populations. Our analysis reveals an inherent tradeoff between specificity and sensitivity that is controlled by the AND gate amplification gain and activation threshold. We implement a tumor-mimicking cell-culture model of cancer cells emerging in a background of normal ones, and show that molecular parameters of the synthetic circuits control specificity and sensitivity in a killing assay. This suggests that, beyond the inherent tradeoff, synthetic circuits operating in a heterogeneous environment could be optimized to efficiently target malignant state with minimal loss of specificity.

Two-dimensional flow of driven particles: a microfluidic pathway to the non-equilibrium frontier.

We discuss the basic physics of the flow of micron-scale droplets in 2D geometry. Our focus is on the use of droplet ensembles to look into fundamental questions of non-equilibrium systems, such as the emergence of dynamic patterns and irreversibility. We review recent research in these directions, which demonstrate that 2D microfluidics is uniquely set to study complex out-of-equilibrium phenomena thanks to the simplicity of the underlying Stokes flow and the accessibility of lab-on-chip technology.

Gene Expression on DNA Biochips Patterned with Strand-Displacement Lithography.

Lithographic patterning of DNA molecules enables spatial organization of cell-free genetic circuits under well-controlled experimental conditions. Here, we present a biocompatible, DNA-based resist termed "Bephore", which is based on commercially available components and can be patterned by both photo- and electron-beam lithography. The patterning mechanism is based on cleavage of a chemically modified DNA hairpin by ultraviolet light or electrons, and a subsequent strand-displacement reaction. All steps are performed in aqueous solution and do not require chemical development of the resist, which makes the lithographic process robust and biocompatible. Bephore is well suited for multistep lithographic processes, enabling the immobilization of different types of DNA molecules with micrometer precision. As an application, we demonstrate compartmentalized, on-chip gene expression from three sequentially immobilized DNA templates, leading to three spatially resolved protein-expression gradients.

Entropy-driven collective interactions in DNA brushes on a biochip.

Cell-free gene expression in localized DNA brushes on a biochip has been shown to depend on gene density and orientation, suggesting that brushes form compartments with partitioned conditions. At high density, the interplay of DNA entropic elasticity, electrostatics, and excluded volume interactions leads to collective conformations that affect the function of DNA-associated proteins. Hence, measuring the collective interactions in dense DNA, free of proteins, is essential for understanding crowded cellular environments and for the design of cell-free synthetic biochips. Here, we assembled dense DNA polymer brushes on a biochip along a density gradient and directly measured the collective extension of DNA using evanescent fluorescence. DNA of 1 kbp in a brush undergoes major conformational changes, from a relaxed random coil to a stretched configuration, following a universal function of density to ionic strength ratio with scaling exponent of 1/3. DNA extends because of the swelling force induced by the osmotic pressure of ions, which are trapped in the brush to maintain local charge neutrality, in competition with the restoring force of DNA entropic elasticity. The measurements reveal in DNA crossover between regimes of osmotic, salted, mushroom, and quasineutral brush. It is surprising to note that, at physiological ionic strength, DNA density does not induce collective stretch despite significant chain overlap, which implies that excluded volume interactions in DNA are weak.

Emergent properties of dense DNA phases toward artificial biosystems on a surface.

CONSPECTUS: The expression of genes in a cell in response to external signals or internal programs occurs within an environment that is compartmentalized and dense. Reconstituting gene expression in man-made systems is relevant for the basic understanding of gene regulation, as well as for the development of applications in bio- and nanotechnology. DNA polymer brushes assembled on a surface emulate a dense cellular environment. In a regime of significant chain overlap, the highly charged nature of DNA, its entropic degrees of freedom, and its interaction with transcription/translation machinery lead to emergent collective biophysical and biochemical properties, which are summarized in this Account. First, we describe a single-step photolithographic biochip on which biomolecules can be immobilized. Then, we present the assembly of localized DNA brushes, a few kilo-base pairs long, with spatially varying density, reaching a DNA concentration of ∼10(7) base pairs/µm(3), which is comparable to the value in E. coli. We then summarize the response of brush height to changes in density and mono- and divalent ionic strength. The balance between entropic elasticity and swelling forces leads to a rich phase behavior. At no added salt, polymers are completely stretched due to the osmotic pressure of ions, and at high salt they assume a relaxed coil conformation. Midrange, the brush height scales with ratio of density and ionic strength to the third power, in agreement with the general theory of polyelectrolyte brushes. In response to trivalent cations, DNA brushes collapse into macroscopic dendritic condensates with hysteresis, coexistence, and a hierarchy of condensation with brush density. We next present an investigation of RNA transcription in the DNA brush. In general, the brush density entropically excludes macromolecules, depleting RNA polymerase concentration in the brush compared to the bulk, therefore reducing transcription rate. The orientation of transcription promoters with respect to the surface also affects the rate with a lower value for outward compared to inward transcription, likely due to local changes of RNA polymerase concentrations. We hypothesize that equalizing the macromolecular osmotic pressure between bulk and brush with the addition of inert macromolecules would overcome the entropic exclusion of DNA associated proteins, and lead to enhanced biochemical activity. Finally, we present protein synthesis cascades in DNA brushes patterned at close proximity, as a step toward biochemical signaling between brushes. Examining the synthesis of proteins polymerizing into crystalline tubes suggests that on-chip molecular traps serve as nucleation sites for protein assembly, thereby opening possibilities for reconstituting nanoscale protein assembly pathways.

Dendritic and nanowire assemblies of condensed DNA polymer brushes.

We investigated the collective conformational response of DNA polymer brushes to condensation induced by the trivalent cation spermidine. DNA brushes, a few kilobase-pairs long, undergo a striking transition into macroscopic domains of collapsed chains with fractal dendritic morphology. Condensation is initiated by focal nucleation of a towerlike bundle, which laterally expands in a chain-reaction cascade of structural chain-to-chain collapse onto the surface. The transition exhibits the hallmarks of a first-order phase transition with grain boundaries, hysteresis, and coexistence between condensed and uncondensed phases. We found that an extended DNA conformation is maintained throughout the transition and is a prerequisite for the formation of large-scale dendritic domains. We identified a critical DNA density above which the nucleation propensity and growth rate sharply increase. We hypothesize that the ability of DNA-scaffolding proteins to modify the local DNA density within a genome may act as a dynamic and sensitive mechanism for spatial regulation of DNA transactions in vivo by selective condensation of chromosomal territories. By assembling a DNA brush along a patterned line narrower than twice the DNA contour length and tuning the local surface densities, we were able to initiate nucleation at a predefined location and induced growth of a single condensed nanowire over a distance 2 orders of magnitude longer than the single-chain contour. Our results demonstrate spatial control of condensation as a new tool for constructing DNA-based synthetic systems with important implications for regulation of DNA transactions on surfaces.

A genetic circuit on a single DNA molecule as an autonomous dissipative nanodevice.

Realizing genetic circuits on single DNA molecules as self-encoded dissipative nanodevices is a major step toward miniaturization of autonomous biological systems. A circuit operating on a single DNA implies that genetically encoded proteins localize during coupled transcription-translation to DNA, but a single-molecule measurement demonstrating this has remained a challenge. Here, we use a genetically encoded fluorescent reporter system with improved temporal resolution and observe the synthesis of individual proteins tethered to a DNA molecule by transient complexes of RNA polymerase, messenger RNA, and ribosome. Against expectations in dilute cell-free conditions where equilibrium considerations favor dispersion, these nascent proteins linger long enough to regulate cascaded reactions on the same DNA. We rationally design a pulsatile genetic circuit by encoding an activator and repressor in feedback on the same DNA molecule. Driven by the local synthesis of only several proteins per hour and gene, the circuit dynamics exhibit enhanced variability between individual DNA molecules, and fluctuations with a broad power spectrum. Our results demonstrate that co-expressional localization, as a nonequilibrium process, facilitates single-DNA genetic circuits as dissipative nanodevices, with implications for nanobiotechnology applications and artificial cell design.

Compartmentalization by directional gene expression.

The coalescence of basic biochemical reactions into compartments is a major hallmark of a living cell. Using surface-bound DNA and a transcription reaction, we investigate the conditions for boundary-free compartmentalization. The DNA self-organizes into a dense and ordered phase with coding sequences aligned at well-defined distances and orientation relative to the surface, imposing directionality on transcription. Unique to the surface in comparison to dilute homogeneous DNA solution, the reaction slows down early, is inhibited with increased DNA density, is favorable for surface-oriented promoters, and is robust against DNA condensation. We interpret these results to suggest that macromolecules (RNA polymerase and RNA), but not solutes (ions and nucleotides), are partitioned between immobilized DNA and the reservoir. Without any physical barrier, a nonequilibrium directional DNA transaction forms macromolecular gradients that define a compartment, thus offering a boundary-free approach to the assembly of a synthetic cell.

Collective conformations of DNA polymers assembled on surface density gradients.

To study dense double-stranded DNA (dsDNA) polymer phases, we fabricated continuous density gradients of binding sites for assembly on a photochemical interface and measured both dsDNA occupancy and extension using evanescent fluorescence. Despite the abundance of available binding sites, the dsDNA density saturates after occupation of only a fraction of the available sites along the gradient. The spatial position at which the density saturates marks the onset of collective stretching of dsDNA, a direct manifestation of balancing entropic and excluded-volume interactions. The methodology presented here offers a new means to investigate dense dsDNA compartments.

Cell-Free Gene Expression from DNA Brushes.

Linear double-stranded DNA polymers coding for synthetic genes immobilized on a surface form a brush as a center for cell-free gene expression, with DNA density 102-103 fold higher than in bulk solution reactions. A brush localizes the transcription-translation machinery in cell extracts or in cell-free reconstituted reactions from purified components, creating a concentrated source of RNA and proteins. Newly synthesized molecules can form circuits regulating gene expression in the same brush or adjacent ones. They can also assemble into functional complexes and machines such as ribosomal units, then analyzed by capture on prepatterned antibodies or by cascaded reactions. DNA brushes are arranged as a single center or multiple ones on a glass coverslip, in miniaturized compartments carved in silicon wafers, or in elastomeric microfluidic devices. Brushes create genetically programmable artificial cells with steady-state dynamics of protein synthesis. Here, we provide the basic procedure for surface patterning, DNA immobilization, capture of protein products on antibody traps and fluorescent imaging. The method of DNA brush surface patterning enables simple parallelization of cell-free gene expression reactions for high throughput studies with increased imaging sensitivity.

A tunable dual-promoter integrator for targeting of cancer cells.

Precise discrimination between similar cellular states is essential for autonomous decision-making scenarios, such as in vivo targeting of diseased cells. Discrimination could be achieved by delivering an effector gene expressed under a highly active context-specific promoter. Yet, a single-promoter approach has linear response and offers limited control of specificity and efficacy. Here, we constructed a dual-promoter integrator, which expresses an effector gene only when the combined activity of two internal input promoters is high. A tunable response provides flexibility in choosing promoter inputs and effector gene output. Experiments using one premalignant and four cancer cell lines, over a wide range of promoter activities, revealed a digital-like response of input amplification following a sharp activation threshold. The response function is cell dependent with its overall magnitude increasing with degree of malignancy. The tunable digital-like response provides robustness, acts to remove input noise minimizing false-positive identification of cell states, and improves targeting precision and efficacy.

Coarse-grained dynamics of protein synthesis in a cell-free system.

A complete gene expression reaction is reconstituted in a cell-free system comprising the entire endogenous transcription, translation, as well as mRNA and protein degradation machinery of E. coli. In dissecting the major reaction steps, we derive a coarse-grained enzymatic description of biosynthesis and degradation, from which ten relevant rate constants and concentrations are determined. Governed by zeroth-order degradation, protein expression follows a sharp transition from undetectable levels to constant-rate accumulation, without reaching steady state.

Boundary-Free Ribosome Compartmentalization by Gene Expression on a Surface.

The design of artificial cell models based on minimal surface-bound transcription-translation reactions aims to mimic the compartmentalization facilitated by organelles and inner interfaces in living cells. Dense DNA brushes as localized sources of RNA and proteins serve as synthetic operons that have recently proven useful for the autonomous synthesis and assembly of cellular machines. Here, we studied ribosome compartmentalization in a minimal gene-expression reaction on a surface in contact with a macroscopic reservoir. We first observed the accumulation and colocalization of RNA polymerases, ribosomes, nascent RNAs and proteins, in dense DNA brushes using evanescent field fluorescence, showing transcription-translation coupling in the brush. Fluorescence recovery after photobleaching showed that ribosomes engaged in translation in the brush had a 4-fold slower diffusion constant. In addition, ribosomes in the brush had over a 10-fold higher local concentration relative to free ribosomes, creating a boundary-free functional ribosome-rich compartment. To decouple translation from transcription, we immobilized dense phases of ribosomes next to DNA brushes. We demonstrated that immobilized ribosomes were capable of protein synthesis, forming 2D subcompartments of active ribosome patterns induced and regulated by DNA brush layout of coding and inhibitory genes. Localizing additional molecular components on the surface will further compartmentalize gene-expression reactions.

Spatially resolved DNA brushes on a chip: gene activation by enzymatic cascade.

We assemble on a chip spatially resolved DNA polymer brushes with density that can be controlled along continuous gradients, from dilute to dense packing, with 20-30 nm between DNA molecules. Investigation of DNA digestion in a approximately 1 kb DNA brush showed that endonucleases can digest within the brush, yet their activity is impeded at high DNA density and for restriction sites near the bottom. Local gene activation-a form of switch-was then demonstrated by a digestion-ligation cascade between two spatially resolved DNA brushes, leading to the in situ expression of green fluorescent protein upon a diffusion-controlled DNA swapping.

From deterministic to fuzzy decision-making in artificial cells.

Building autonomous artificial cells capable of homeostasis requires regulatory networks to gather information and make decisions that take time and cost energy. Decisions based on few molecules may be inaccurate but are cheap and fast. Realizing decision-making with a few molecules in artificial cells has remained a challenge. Here, we show decision-making by a bistable gene network in artificial cells with constant protein turnover. Reducing the number of gene copies from 105 to about 10 per cell revealed a transition from deterministic and slow decision-making to a fuzzy and rapid regime dominated by small-number fluctuations. Gene regulation was observed at lower DNA and protein concentrations than necessary in equilibrium, suggesting rate enhancement by co-expressional localization. The high-copy regime was characterized by a sharp transition and hysteresis, whereas the low-copy limit showed strong fluctuations, state switching, and cellular individuality across the decision-making point. Our results demonstrate information processing with low-power consumption inside artificial cells.

Autonomous synthesis and assembly of a ribosomal subunit on a chip.

Ribosome biogenesis is an efficient and complex assembly process that has not been reconstructed outside a living cell so far, yet is the most critical step for establishing a self-replicating artificial cell. We recreated the biogenesis of Escherichia coli's small ribosomal subunit by synthesizing and capturing all its ribosomal proteins and RNA on a chip. Surface confinement provided favorable conditions for autonomous stepwise assembly of new subunits, spatially segregated from original intact ribosomes. Our real-time fluorescence measurements revealed hierarchal assembly, cooperative interactions, unstable intermediates, and specific binding to large ribosomal subunits. Using only synthetic genes, our methodology is a crucial step toward creation of a self-replicating artificial cell and a general strategy for the mechanistic investigation of diverse multicomponent macromolecular machines.

Programming multi-protein assembly by gene-brush patterns and two-dimensional compartment geometry.

The assembly of protein machines in cells is precise, rapid, and coupled to protein synthesis with regulation in space and time. The assembly of natural and synthetic nanomachines could be similarly controlled by genetic programming outside the cell. Here, we present quasi-two-dimensional (2D) silicon compartments that enable programming of protein assembly lines by local synthesis from surface-immobilized DNA brushes. Using this platform, we studied the autonomous synthesis and assembly of a structural complex from a bacteriophage and a bacterial RNA-synthesizing machine. Local synthesis and surface capture of complexes provided high assembly yield and sensitive detection of spatially resolved assembly intermediates, with the 3D geometry of the compartment and the 2D pattern of brushes dictating the yield and mode of assembly steps. Localized synthesis of proteins in a single gene brush enhances their interactions, and displacement of their genes in separated brushes leads to step-by-step surface assembly. This methodology enables spatial regulation of protein synthesis, and deciphering, reconstruction and design of biological machine assembly lines.