Performance of acoustic radiation force impulse ultrasound imaging for carotid plaque characterization with histologic validation.

OBJECTIVE: Stroke is commonly caused by thromboembolic events originating from ruptured carotid plaque with vulnerable composition. This study assessed the performance of acoustic radiation force impulse (ARFI) imaging, a noninvasive ultrasound elasticity imaging method, for delineating the composition of human carotid plaque in vivo with histologic validation. METHODS: Carotid ARFI images were captured before surgery in 25 patients undergoing clinically indicated carotid endarterectomy. The surgical specimens were histologically processed with sectioning matched to the ultrasound imaging plane. Three radiologists, blinded to histology, evaluated parametric images of ARFI-induced peak displacement to identify plaque features such as necrotic core (NC), intraplaque hemorrhage (IPH), collagen (COL), calcium (CAL), and fibrous cap (FC) thickness. Reader performance was measured against the histologic standard using receiver operating characteristic curve analysis, linear regression, Spearman correlation (ρ), and Bland-Altman analysis. RESULTS: ARFI peak displacement was two-to-four-times larger in regions of NC and IPH relative to regions of COL or CAL. Readers detected soft plaque features (NC/IPH) with a median area under the curve of 0.887 (range, 0.867-0.924) and stiff plaque features (COL/CAL) with median area under the curve of 0.859 (range, 0.771-0.929). FC thickness measurements of two of the three readers correlated with histology (reader 1: R2 = 0.64, ρ = 0.81; reader 2: R2 = 0.89, ρ = 0.75). CONCLUSIONS: This study suggests that ARFI is capable of distinguishing soft from stiff atherosclerotic plaque components and delineating FC thickness.

Validation of a combined ultrasound and bioluminescence imaging system with magnetic resonance imaging in orthotopic pancreatic murine tumors.

Preclinical mouse solid tumor models are widely used to evaluate efficacy of novel cancer therapeutics. Recent reports have highlighted the need for utilizing orthotopic implantation to represent clinical disease more accurately, however the deep tissue location of these tumors makes longitudinal assessment challenging without the use of imaging techniques. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the performance of a new multi-modality high-throughput in vivo imaging system that combines bioluminescence imaging (BLI) with robotic, hands-free ultrasound (US) for evaluating orthotopic mouse models. Long utilized in cancer research as independent modalities, we hypothesized that the combination of BLI and US would offer complementary advantages of detection sensitivity and quantification accuracy, while mitigating individual technological weaknesses. Bioluminescent pancreatic tumor cells were injected into the pancreas tail of C57BL/6 mice and imaged weekly with the combination system and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) to serve as a gold standard. BLI photon flux was quantified to assess tumor activity and distribution, and US and MRI datasets were manually segmented for gross tumor volume. Robotic US and MRI demonstrated a strong agreement (R2 = 0.94) for tumor volume measurement. BLI showed a weak overall agreement with MRI (R2 = 0.21), however, it offered the greatest sensitivity to detecting the presence of tumors. We conclude that combining BLI with robotic US offers an efficient screening tool for orthotopic tumor models.

Development of a Robotic Shear Wave Elastography System for Noninvasive Staging of Liver Disease in Murine Models.

Shear wave elastography (SWE) is an ultrasound-based stiffness quantification technology that is used for noninvasive liver fibrosis assessment. However, despite widescale clinical adoption, SWE is largely unused by preclinical researchers and drug developers for studies of liver disease progression in small animal models due to significant experimental, technical, and reproducibility challenges. Therefore, the aim of this work was to develop a tool designed specifically for assessing liver stiffness and echogenicity in small animals to better enable longitudinal preclinical studies. A high-frequency linear array transducer (12-24 MHz) was integrated into a robotic small animal ultrasound system (Vega; SonoVol, Inc., Durham, NC) to perform liver stiffness and echogenicity measurements in three dimensions. The instrument was validated with tissue-mimicking phantoms and a mouse model of nonalcoholic steatohepatitis. Female C57BL/6J mice (n = 40) were placed on choline-deficient, L-amino acid-defined, high-fat diet and imaged longitudinally for 15 weeks. A subset was sacrificed after each imaging timepoint (n = 5) for histological validation, and analyses of receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curves were performed. Results demonstrated that robotic measurements of echogenicity and stiffness were most strongly correlated with macrovesicular steatosis (R2  = 0.891) and fibrosis (R2  = 0.839), respectively. For diagnostic classification of fibrosis (Ishak score), areas under ROC (AUROCs) curves were 0.969 for ≥Ishak1, 0.984 for ≥Ishak2, 0.980 for ≥Ishak3, and 0.969 for ≥Ishak4. For classification of macrovesicular steatosis (S-score), AUROCs were 1.00 for ≥S2 and 0.997 for ≥S3. Average scanning and analysis time was <5 minutes/liver. Conclusion: Robotic SWE in small animals is feasible and sensitive to small changes in liver disease state, facilitating in vivo staging of rodent liver disease with minimal sonographic expertise.

Use of 3D Robotic Ultrasound for In Vivo Analysis of Mouse Kidneys.

Common modalities for in vivo imaging of rodents include positron emission tomography (PET), computed tomography (CT), magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), and ultrasound (US). Each method has limitations and advantages, including availability, ease of use, cost, size, and the use of ionizing radiation or magnetic fields. This protocol describes the use of 3D robotic US for in vivo imaging of rodent kidneys and heart, subsequent data analysis, and possible research applications. Practical applications of robotic US are the quantification of total kidney volume (TKV), as well as the measurement of cysts, tumors, and vasculature. Although the resolution is not as high as other modalities, robotic US allows for more practical high throughput data collection. Furthermore, using US M-mode imaging, cardiac function may be quantified. Since the kidneys receive 20%-25% of the cardiac output, assessing cardiac function is critical to the understanding of kidney physiology and pathophysiology.

Carotid Plaque Fibrous Cap Thickness Measurement by ARFI Variance of Acceleration: In Vivo Human Results.

This study evaluates the performance of an acoustic radiation force impulse (ARFI)-based outcome parameter, the decadic logarithm of the variance of acceleration, or log(VoA), for measuring carotid fibrous cap thickness. Carotid plaque fibrous cap thickness measurement by log(VoA) was compared to that by ARFI peak displacement (PD) in patients undergoing clinically indicated carotid endarterectomy using a spatially-matched histological validation standard. Fibrous caps in parametric log(VoA) and PD images were automatically segmented using a custom clustering algorithm, and a pathologist with expertise in atherosclerosis hand-delineated fibrous caps in histology. Over 10 fibrous caps, log(VoA)-derived thickness was more strongly correlated to histological thickness than PD-derived thickness, with Pearson correlation values of 0.98 for log(VoA) compared to 0.89 for PD. The log(VoA)-derived cap thickness also had better agreement with histology-measured thickness, as assessed by the concordance correlation coefficient (0.95 versus 0.62), and, by Bland-Altman analysis, was more consistent than PD-derived fibrous cap thickness. These results suggest that ARFI log(VoA) enables improved discrimination of fibrous cap thickness relative to ARFI PD and further contributes to the growing body of evidence demonstrating ARFI's overall relevance to delineating the structure and composition of carotid atherosclerotic plaque for stroke risk prediction.

Use of 3-D Contrast-Enhanced Ultrasound to Evaluate Tumor Microvasculature After Nanoparticle-Mediated Modulation.

A cost-effective method for serial in vivo imaging of tumor microvasculature has been developed. We evaluated acoustic angiography (AA) for visualizing and assessing non-small cell lung tumor (A549) microvasculature in mice before and after tumor vascular disruption by vascular-targeted gold nanoparticles and radiotherapy. Standard B-mode and microbubble-enhanced AA images were acquired at pre- and post-treatment time points. Using these modes, a new metric, 50% vessel penetration depth, was developed to characterize the 3-D spatial heterogeneity of microvascular networks. We observed an increase in tumor perfusion after radiation-induced vascular disruption, relative to control animals. This was also visualized in vessel morphology mode, which revealed a loss in vessel integrity. We found that tumors with poorly perfused vasculature at day 0 exhibited a reduced growth rate over time. This suggested a new method to reduce in-group treatment response variability using pre-treatment microvessel maps to objectively identify animals for study removal.

Assessing Polycystic Kidney Disease in Rodents: Comparison of Robotic 3D Ultrasound and Magnetic Resonance Imaging.

Polycystic kidney disease (PKD) is an inherited disorder characterized by renal cyst formation and enlargement of the kidney. PKD severity can be staged noninvasively by measuring total kidney volume (TKV), a promising biomarker that has recently received regulatory qualification. In preclinical mouse models, where the disease is studied and potential therapeutics are evaluated, the most popular noninvasive method of measuring TKV is magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). Although MRI provides excellent 3D resolution and contrast, these systems are expensive to operate, have long acquisition times, and, consequently, are not heavily used in preclinical PKD research. In this study, a new imaging instrument, based on robotic ultrasound (US), was evaluated as a complementary approach for assessing PKD in rodent models. The objective was to determine the extent to which TKV measurements on the robotic US scanner correlated with both in vivo and ex vivo reference standards (MRI and Vernier calipers, respectively). A cross-sectional study design was implemented that included both PKD-affected mice and healthy wild types, spanning sex and age for a wide range of kidney volumes. It was found that US-derived TKV measurements and kidney lengths were strongly associated with both in vivo MRI and ex vivo Vernier caliper measurements (R 2=0.94 and 0.90, respectively). In addition to measuring TKV, renal vascular density was assessed using acoustic angiography (AA), a novel contrast-enhanced US methodology. AA image intensity, indicative of volumetric vascularity, was seen to have a strong negative correlation with TKV (R 2=0.82), suggesting impaired renal vascular function in mice with larger kidneys. These studies demonstrate that robotic US can provide a rapid and accurate approach for noninvasively evaluating PKD in rodent models.

Image-Based Methods for Phase Estimation, Gating, and Temporal Superresolution of Cardiac Ultrasound.

OBJECTIVE: Ultrasound is an effective tool for rapid noninvasive assessment of cardiac structure and function. Determining the cardiorespiratory phases of each frame in the ultrasound video and capturing the cardiac function at a much higher temporal resolution are essential in many applications. Fulfilling these requirements is particularly challenging in preclinical studies involving small animals with high cardiorespiratory rates, requiring cumbersome and expensive specialized hardware. METHODS: We present a novel method for the retrospective estimation of cardiorespiratory phases directly from the ultrasound videos. It transforms the videos into a univariate time series preserving the evidence of periodic cardiorespiratory motion, decouples the signatures of cardiorespiratory motion with a trend extraction technique, and estimates the cardiorespiratory phases using a Hilbert transform approach. We also present a robust nonparametric regression technique for respiratory gating and a novel kernel-regression model for reconstructing images at any cardiac phase facilitating temporal superresolution. RESULTS: We validated our methods using two-dimensional echocardiography videos and electrocardiogram (ECG) recordings of six mice. Our cardiac phase estimation method provides accurate phase estimates with a mean-phase-error range of 3%-6% against ECG derived phase and outperforms three previously published methods in locating ECGs R-wave peak frames with a mean-frame-error range of 0.73-1.36. Our kernel-regression model accurately reconstructs images at any cardiac phase with a mean-normalized-correlation range of 0.81-0.85 over 50 leave-one-out-cross-validation rounds. CONCLUSION AND SIGNIFICANCE: Our methods can enable tracking of cardiorespiratory phases without additional hardware and reconstruction of respiration-free single cardiac-cycle videos at a much higher temporal resolution.

Delineation of Human Carotid Plaque Features In Vivo by Exploiting Displacement Variance.

While in vivo acoustic radiation force impulse (ARFI)-induced peak displacement (PD) has been demonstrated to have high sensitivity and specificity for differentiating soft from stiff plaque components in patients with carotid plaque, the parameter exhibits poorer performance for distinguishing between plaque features with similar stiffness. To improve discrimination of carotid plaque features relative to PD, we hypothesize that signal correlation and signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) can be combined, outright or via displacement variance. Plaque feature detection by displacement variance, evaluated as the decadic logarithm of the variance of acceleration and termed "log(VoA)," was compared to that achieved by exploiting SNR, cross correlation coefficient, and ARFI-induced PD outcome metrics. Parametric images were rendered for 25 patients undergoing carotid endarterectomy, with spatially matched histology confirming plaque composition and structure. On average, across all plaques, log(VoA) was the only outcome metric with values that statistically differed between regions of lipid-rich necrotic core (LRNC), intraplaque hemorrhage (IPH), collagen (COL), and calcium (CAL). Further, log(VoA) achieved the highest contrast-to-noise ratio (CNR) for discriminating between LRNC and IPH, COL and CAL, and grouped soft (LRNC and IPH) and stiff (COL and CAL) plaque components. More specifically, relative to the previously demonstrated ARFI PD parameter, log(VoA) achieved 73% higher CNR between LRNC and IPH and 59% higher CNR between COL and CAL. These results suggest that log(VoA) enhances the differentiation of LRNC, IPH, COL, and CAL in human carotid plaques, in vivo, which is clinically relevant to improving stroke risk prediction and medical management.

Ultrasound Measurement of Vascular Density to Evaluate Response to Anti-Angiogenic Therapy in Renal Cell Carcinoma.

BACKGROUND: Functional and molecular changes often precede gross anatomical changes, so early assessment of a tumor's functional and molecular response to therapy can help reduce a patient's exposure to the side effects of ineffective chemotherapeutics or other treatment strategies. OBJECTIVE: Our intent was to test the hypothesis that an ultrasound microvascular imaging approach might provide indications of response to therapy prior to assessment of tumor size. METHODS: Mice bearing clear-cell renal cell carcinoma xenograft tumors were treated with antiangiogenic and Notch inhibition therapies. An ultrasound measurement of microvascular density was used to serially track the tumor response to therapy. RESULTS: Data indicated that ultrasound-derived microvascular density can indicate response to therapy a week prior to changes in tumor volume and is strongly correlated with physiological characteristics of the tumors as measured by histology ([Formula: see text]). Furthermore, data demonstrated that ultrasound measurements of vascular density can determine response to therapy and classify between-treatment groups with high sensitivity and specificity. CONCLUSION/SIGNIFICANCE: Results suggests that future applications utilizing ultrasound imaging to monitor tumor response to therapy may be able to provide earlier insight into tumor behavior from metrics of microvascular density rather than anatomical tumor size measurements.

A new preclinical ultrasound platform for widefield 3D imaging of rodents.

Noninvasive in vivo imaging technologies enable researchers and clinicians to detect the presence of disease and longitudinally study its progression. By revealing anatomical, functional, or molecular changes, imaging tools can provide a near real-time assessment of important biological events. At the preclinical research level, imaging plays an important role by allowing disease mechanisms and potential therapies to be evaluated noninvasively. Because functional and molecular changes often precede gross anatomical changes, there has been a significant amount of research exploring the ability of different imaging modalities to track these aspects of various diseases. Herein, we present a novel robotic preclinical contrast-enhanced ultrasound system and demonstrate its use in evaluating tumors in a rodent model. By leveraging recent advances in ultrasound, this system favorably compares with other modalities, as it can perform anatomical, functional, and molecular imaging and is cost-effective, portable, and high throughput, without using ionizing radiation. Furthermore, this system circumvents many of the limitations of conventional preclinical ultrasound systems, including a limited field-of-view, low throughput, and large user variability.

ARFI variance of acceleration (VoA) for noninvasive characterization of human carotid plaques in vivo.

Rather than degree of stenosis, assessing plaque structure and composition is relevant to discerning risk for plaque rupture with downstream ischemic event. The structure and composition of carotid plaque has been assessed noninvasively using Acoustic Radiation Force Impulse (ARFI) ultrasound imaging. In particular, ARFI-derived peak displacement (PD) estimations have been demonstrated for discriminating soft (lipid rich necrotic core (LRNC) or intraplaque hemorrhage (IPH)) from stiff (collagen (COL) or calcium (CAL)) plaque features; however, PD did not differentiate LRNC from IPH or COL from CAL. The purpose of this study is to evaluate a new ARFI-based measurement, the variance of acceleration (VoA), for differentiating among soft and stiff plaque components. Both PD and VoA results were obtained in vivo for a human carotid plaque acquired in a previous study and matched to a histological standard analyzed by a pathologist. With VoA, plaque feature contrast was increased by an average of 60% in comparison to PD.

On the Feasibility of Quantifying Fibrous Cap Thickness With Acoustic Radiation Force Impulse (ARFI) Ultrasound.

Acute cerebrovascular accidents are associated with the rupture of vulnerable atherosclerotic plaques in the carotid arteries. Fibrous cap (FC) thickness has been shown to be an important predictor of plaque rupture but has been challenging to measure accurately with clinical noninvasive imaging modalities. The goals of this investigation were first, to evaluate the feasibility of using transcutaneous acoustic radiation force impulse (ARFI) ultrasound to quantify FC thickness and second, to optimize both imaging and motion-tracking parameters to support such measurements. FCs with varying thickness (0.1-1.0 mm) were simulated using a simple-layered geometry, and their mechanical response to an impulse of radiation force was solved using finite-element method (FEM) modeling. Ultrasound tracking of FEM displacements was performed in Field II utilizing three center frequencies (6, 9, and 12 MHz) and eight motion-tracking kernel lengths ( 0.5λ-4λ). Additionally, FC thickness in two carotid plaques imaged in vivo was measured with ARFI and compared to matched histology. The results of this study demonstrate that 1) tracking pulse frequencies around 12 MHz are necessary to resolve caps around 0.2 mm; 2) large motion-tracking kernel sizes introduce bias into thickness measurements and overestimate the true cap thickness; and 3) color saturation settings on ARFI peak displacement images can impact thickness measurement accuracy substantially.

Design, Fabrication, and Characterization of a Bifrequency Colinear Array.

Ultrasound imaging with high resolution and large penetration depth has been increasingly adopted in medical diagnosis, surgery guidance, and treatment assessment. Conventional ultrasound works at a particular frequency, with a [Formula: see text] fractional bandwidth of [Formula: see text], limiting the imaging resolution or depth of field. In this paper, a bifrequency colinear array with resonant frequencies of 8 and 20 MHz was investigated to meet the requirements of resolution and penetration depth for a broad range of ultrasound imaging applications. Specifically, a 32-element bifrequency colinear array was designed and fabricated, followed by element characterization and real-time sectorial scan (S-scan) phantom imaging using a Verasonics system. The bifrequency colinear array was tested in four different modes by switching between low and high frequencies on transmit and receive. The four modes included the following: 1) transmit low, receive low; 2) transmit low, receive high; 3) transmit high, receive low; and 4) transmit high, receive high. After testing, the axial and lateral resolutions of all modes were calculated and compared. The results of this study suggest that bifrequency colinear arrays are potential aids for wideband fundamental imaging and harmonic/subharmonic imaging.

Non-invasive in vivo characterization of human carotid plaques with acoustic radiation force impulse ultrasound: comparison with histology after endarterectomy.

Ischemic stroke from thromboembolic sources is linked to carotid artery atherosclerotic disease with a trend toward medical management in asymptomatic patients. Extent of disease is currently diagnosed by non-invasive imaging techniques that measure luminal stenosis, but it has been suggested that a better biomarker for determining risk of future thromboembolic events is plaque morphology and composition. Specifically, plaques that are composed of mechanically soft lipid/necrotic regions covered by thin fibrous caps are the most vulnerable to rupture. An ultrasound technique that non-invasively interrogates the mechanical properties of soft tissue, called acoustic radiation force impulse (ARFI) imaging, has been developed as a new modality for atherosclerotic plaque characterization using phantoms and atherosclerotic pigs, but the technique has yet to be validated in vivo in humans. In this preliminary study, in vivo ARFI imaging is presented in a case study format for four patients undergoing clinically indicated carotid endarterectomy and compared with histology. In two type Va plaques, characterized by lipid/necrotic cores covered by fibrous caps, mean ARFI displacements in focal regions were high relative to the surrounding plaque material, suggesting soft features were covered by stiffer layers within the plaques. In two type Vb plaques, characterized by heavy calcification, mean ARFI peak displacements were low relative to the surrounding plaque and arterial wall, suggesting stiff tissue. This pilot study illustrates the feasibility and challenges of transcutaneous ARFI for characterizing the material and structural composition of carotid atherosclerotic plaques via mechanical properties, in humans, in vivo.

Experimental validation of displacement underestimation in ARFI ultrasound.

Acoustic radiation force impulse (ARFI) imaging is an elastography technique that uses ultrasonic pulses to displace and track tissue motion. Previous modeling studies have shown that ARFI displacements are susceptible to underestimation due to lateral and elevational shearing that occurs within the tracking resolution cell. In this study, optical tracking was utilized to experimentally measure the displacement underestimation achieved by acoustic tracking using a clinical ultrasound system. Three optically translucent phantoms of varying stiffness were created, embedded with subwavelength diameter microspheres, and ARFI excitation pulses with F/1.5 or F/3 lateral focal configurations were transmitted from a standard linear array to induce phantom motion. Displacements were tracked using confocal optical and acoustic methods. As predicted by earlier finite element method studies, significant acoustic displacement underestimation was observed for both excitation focal configurations; the maximum underestimation error was 35% of the optically measured displacement for the F/1.5 excitation pulse in the softest phantom. Using higher F/#, less tightly focused beams in the lateral dimension improved accuracy of displacements by approximately 10 percentage points. This work experimentally demonstrates limitations of ARFI implemented on a clinical scanner using a standard linear array and sets up a framework for future displacement tracking validation studies.

Acoustic radiation force beam sequence performance for detection and material characterization of atherosclerotic plaques: preclinical, ex vivo results.

This work presents preclinical data demonstrating performance of acoustic radiation force (ARF)-based elasticity imaging with five different beam sequences for atherosclerotic plaque detection and material characterization. Twelve trained, blinded readers evaluated parametric images taken ex vivo under simulated in vivo conditions of 22 porcine femoral arterial segments. Receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curve analysis was carried out to quantify reader performance using spatially-matched immunohistochemistry for validation. The beam sequences employed had high sensitivity (sens) and specificity (spec) for detecting Type III+ plaques (sens: 85%, spec: 79%), lipid pools (sens: 80%, spec: 86%), fibrous caps (sens: 86%, spec: 82%), calcium (sens: 96%, spec: 85%), collagen (sens: 78%, spec: 77%), and disrupted internal elastic lamina (sens: 92%, spec: 75%). 1:1 single-receive tracking yielded the highest median areas under the ROC curve (AUC), but was not statistically significantly higher than 4:1 parallel-receive tracking. Excitation focal configuration did not result in statistically different AUCs. Overall, these results suggest ARF-based imaging is relevant to detecting and characterizing plaques and support its use for diagnosing and monitoring atherosclerosis.

Contrast-enhanced imaging of SPIO-labeled platelets using magnetomotive ultrasound.

The ability to image platelets in vivo can provide insight into blood clotting processes and coagulopathies, and aid in identifying sites of vascular endothelial damage related to trauma or cardiovascular disease. Toward this end, we have developed a magnetomotive ultrasound (MMUS) system that provides contrast-enhanced imaging of superparamagnetic iron oxide (SPIO) labeled platelets via magnetically-induced vibration. Platelets are a promising platform for functional imaging contrast because they readily take up SPIOs and are easily harvested from blood. Here we report a novel MMUS system that accommodates an arbitrarily thick sample while maintaining portability. We employed a frequency- and phase-locked motion detection algorithm based on bandpass filtering of the differential RF phase, which allows for the detection of sub-resolution vibration amplitudes on the order of several nanometers. We then demonstrated MMUS in homogenous tissue phantoms at SPIO concentrations as low as 0.09 mg ml(-1) Fe (p < 0.0001, n = 6, t-test). Finally, we showed that our system is capable of three-dimensional imaging of a 185 µL simulated clot containing SPIO-platelets. This highlights the potential utility for non-invasive imaging of platelet-rich clots, which would constitute a fundamental advance in technology for the study of hemostasis and detection of clinically relevant thrombi.