CA27.29: a valuable marker for breast cancer management. A confirmatory multicentric study on 603 cases.

Recently, a fully automated method has become commercially available to measure the MUC-1-associated antigen CA27.29. The present investigation was performed in order to compare CA27.29 and CA15.3 in a wide series of patients affected with breast cancer. Overall, 603 cases with breast cancer and 194 healthy controls were investigated. Patients were enrolled in 4 institutions, while assays were performed in one laboratory. CA27.29 was measured by the ACS:180 BR assay (Bayer Diagnostics) and CA15.3 by the AxSYM (Abbott Laboratories). An excellent correlation was found between the results obtained by the two methods. The two markers showed comparable results in healthy controls, with higher levels in post-menopausal than in pre-menopausal subjects. The markers were significantly higher in primary breast cancer than in controls. The areas under the receiver operating characteristics (ROC) curves of the two tests were comparable, but CA27.29 showed better sensitivity in cases with low antigen concentrations (below the cut-off point). Accordingly, when comparing each test in different stage categories, significance levels of the differences were higher for CA27.29 than for CA15.3 for all T categories versus healthy controls, for pT1 versus pT2, for all N categories versus healthy controls and for node-negative versus N1-3 patients. From the results of the present study, that has been performed on samples taken at diagnosis and prior to any treatment from the widest series of patients with primary breast cancer reported so far, we can draw the following conclusions: CA27.29 provides comparable results to CA15.3; CA27.29 seems more sensitive than CA15.3 to limited variations of tumour extension; however, it cannot help clinicians in distinguishing stage I patients from stage II patients. However, from the point of view of clinical decision making, CA27.29 provides comparable results to CA15.3. CA27.29 is therefore suitable for routine use in the management of patients with breast cancer.

Relationship between cathepsin D and other pathological and biological parameters in 1752 patients with primary breast cancer.

The relationship between cathepsin D and other pathological or biological prognostic parameters has not yet been defined through systematic studies in breast cancer. The aim of the present investigation was to define the relationship between cathepsin D and nodal status, tumour size, steroid receptors and tumour grade in a wide patient series. Cytosol cathepsin D was assayed with an immunoradiometric assay in tumour samples from 1752 patients. A statistically significant, but not biologically meaningful association was found between cathepsin D and both tumour size and grade. Cathepsin D was significantly higher in node-positive than in node-negative tumours. However, cathepsin D is not of great use in order to predict the risk of axillary metastases in individual patients, due to overlapping of cathepsin D values between node-positive and node-negative cases. A significant, direct association was found between cathepsin D and both oestrogen receptor and progesterone receptor cytosol levels. Nevertheless, preliminary data indicate that cathepsin D and steroid receptors provide independent prognostic information.

Tissue polypeptide antigen in breast cancer cytosol: a new effective prognostic indicator.

Since 1982 we have been evaluating oestrogen and progesterone receptors (PgR), cathepsin D and the cytosolic levels of the tumour marker, tissue polypeptide antigen (TPA), in 257 patients radically resected for breast cancer (follow-up 24-81 months). TPA was measured by an immunoradiometric assay previously validated for cytosol. No significant associations were found between cytosolic TPA and age, tumour size, lymph-node status, receptor status and cathepsin D. TPA+ cases showed a significantly longer disease-free survival (DFS) and overall survival (OS) than TPA-patients (log-rank P < 0.0001). The prognostic value of cytosolic TPA was also demonstrated after stratification by nodal status, PgR and cathepsin D. The prognostic value of TPA was independent of the other prognostic indicators, being the most powerful among the evaluated indices (Cox multivariate analysis: chi 2 15.5 for DFS, 11.4 for OS). We conclude that cytosolic TPA is a powerful additional prognostic factor in primary breast cancer. Its prognostic role should therefore be extensively evaluated.

Prognostic role of serum CA15.3 in 362 node-negative breast cancers. An old player for a new game.

The aims of the present investigation were to evaluate the association between serum CA15.3 levels and other biological and clinical variables and its prognostic role in patients with node-negative breast cancer. We evaluated 362 patients operated upon primary breast cancer from 1982 to 1992 (median follow-up 69 months). Serum CA15.3 was measured by an immunoradiometric assay. The association between variables was investigated by a Principal Component Analysis (PCA) and the prognostic role of CA15.3 on relapse-free survival (RFS) was investigated by Cox regression models adjusting for age, oestrogen receptor (ER), tumour stage, and ER x age interaction, with both the likelihood ratio test and Harrell's c statistic. The prognostic contribution of CA 15.3 was highly significant. Log relative hazard of relapse was constant until approximately 10 (U/ml) of CA15.3 and increased thereafter with increasing marker levels. CA15.3 showed a significant contribution using as a cut-off point a value of 31 U/ml. However, the contribution to the model of the marker as a continuous variable is much greater. From these findings, we can conclude that: (i) CA15.3 is a prognostic marker in node-negative breast cancer; (ii) its relationship with prognosis is continuous, with the risk of relapse increasing progressively from approximately 10 U/ml.

Ca549 immunoassay in breast-tissue - comparison with ca15.3 and mca.

The relationship between mucin markers and several clinical and pathological characteristics was investigated in breast cancer tissue. CA549, CA15.3 and MCA were measured using commercially available assay methods in 82 primary breast carcinomas and 47 normal glandular breast tissue samples. Similarly to CA15.3 and MCA, CA549 was significantly higher in cancer than in normal breast tissue. However, CA549 was directly associated with both receptor status and the presence of axillary metastasis being different from CA15.3 and MCA. The cytosol levels of the three markers were closely correlated. However, the ratio between CA549 and both CA15.3 and MCA showed widely scattered values in individual patients. From these findings we conclude that the three mucin markers evaluated are not interchangeable and may possibly have different biological roles at tissue level.

Dynamic use of tumor markers, rationale-clinical applications and pitfalls.

The dynamic evaluation of tumor markers is a promising area of investigation which is expected to provide clinical information when serial samples are available from the same patient. This is feasible in the post-operatory evaluation, during the follow-up after the treatment for to the primary tumor and in the monitoring of the treatment for metastatic disease. Variations among serial samples may be assessed using both empirical and mathematical approaches. Empirical approaches rely on overcoming a given percentage usually chosen on the base of arbitrary decisions. Mathematical approaches include the actual half-life, the doubling time, a dose/time regression analysis and the calculation of the critical difference. The two former are currently used in clinical practice whereas the two latter are still matter of investigation. As concerns the assessment of the radicality of the surgery for the primary tumor, the serum markers are used in germ cell tumors and in prostate cancer. The half-life of the markers is the decision criteria used in germ cell cancers, while in prostate cancer PSA is expected to be undetectable more than 30 days after the radical prostatectomy. Tumor markers are currently used during the follow-up of several malignancies after the treatment for primary tumor. Although several samples are available, decision criteria are still based on positive/negative cut-off values in several instances. Promising dynamic approaches are under investigation and are expected to lead to earlier and probably more accurate information concerning the disease progression. A critical point still under debate is the actual impact of tumor markers on patients' survival in malignancies incurable when metastatic, such as colorectal cancer and breast cancer. This matter urgently demands perspective clinical studies. Finally, the dynamic use of tumor markers is now commonly applied in the monitoring of the therapy for metastatic malignancies. In this clinical setting mathematical criteria are used for ovarian and and germ cell tumors with promising results. Nevertheless, the use of empirical criteria, namely the percentage of variation between two consecutive samples, is successfully used for the monitoring of the therapy of metastatic breast cancer. In conclusion, when several samples are available from an individual patient they may be evaluated according to dynamic criteria instead of referring to a conventional positive/negative cut-off point. Although mathematical decision criteria are expected to provide more reliable data, empirical approaches are used as well and provide useful information in decision making.

Biochemical parameters for prognostic evaluation in patients with breast cancer.

We evaluated the prognostic value of tissue polypeptide antigen (TPA), cathepsin D and pS2 in 267 patients operated for primary breast cancer. Cathepsin D, pS2 and cytosol TPA were independent of each other and of N, T, estrogen (ER) and progesterone (PgR) receptors. Cathepsin D was the best prognostic indicator for disease-free survival and pS2 for overall survival. The simultaneous evaluation of the three parameters was an effective discriminator between high and low risk patients in both N- and N+. Considering that cathepsin D, pS2 and cytosol TPA can be easily measured with reliable methods in small amounts of tissue, we conclude that they are a promising panel of biochemical parameters suitable for the assessment of the risk of relapse in patients with breast cancer.

Quantitative chemiluminescent immunoassay of p53: prognostic significance in 220 node-negative breast cancer tissue.

The prognostic and predictive role of p53 overexpression in breast cancer samples is usually investigated by using molecular biology or immunohistochemical methods. However, the results are to date controversial, and this is in part due to the methodological pitfalls of both the methods. To study the possibility of overcoming, at least in part, these problems we evaluated a commercially available chemiluminescent immunoassay with which the p53 concentrations of 220 specimens from node negative breast cancer were determined. The assay showed good analytical performance and found detectable levels in 84.7% of cases (median 0.22 ng/mg of proteins, range 0-50 ng/mg of proteins). p53 has been found inversely correlated with estrogen receptors and directly correlated with cathepsin D. The prognostic role of p53 was evaluated in two different ways: a) two previous studies (Borg et al 1995, DeWitte et al. 1996) using the same method found almost 30% of samples had significantly shorter DFS and OS. We subdivided our cases in order to identify the same positivity rate and to verify if the previous cathegorizations were effective also in our patient series. We confirmed the independent association with DFS (p = 0.006) and OS (p = 0.0005); b) considering that any categorization of quantitative parameters could cause a loss of clinical information, we also evaluated p53 as a continuous variable. Multivariate analysis showed a significant quantitative relationship between p53 and both disease free (p = 0.026) and overall survival (p = 0.02).

Cost/effectiveness ratio of carcinoembryonic antigen--importance of adequacy of routine requests of tumor markers.

Since 1987 we have been evaluating the cost/effectiveness ratio of tumor markers using carcinoembryonic antigen (CEA) as a leading indicator. Preliminary to the evaluation of cost/effectiveness ratio we verified the fitness of CEA requests to the proper clinical problems in order to identify any bias of cost due to inadequate CEA use. 2677 CEA orders were evaluated in 1987. The percentage of inadequate requests was very high (43%). Therefore, it seemed not advisable to carry out the evaluation of cost/effectiveness ratio, while educational actions (divulgation of informative material, service of telephone consultation) were addressed to the physicians of the geographic area of laboratory users. In 1991 the adequacy of CEA requests was reevaluated. The percentage of inadequate requests on 2647 orders was 29.4%. This result, although not yet satisfactory, suggests that proper educational programs may probably improve the fitness of tumor marker requests to correct clinical problems. Additional educational actions are mandatory to further reduce the rate of inadequate tumor marker orders.

Third-generation PSA: ultrasensitive or ultraprecise assay?

The ultrasensitive PSA assay has been recently acknowledged as a useful tool for the monitoring of patients prostatectomized for prostatic cancer. We have evaluated a commercially available ultrasensitive PSA assay (Immulite Third Generation PSA-DPC-Los Angeles CA) in comparison with the routinely used PSA (Immulite PSA-DPC-Los Angeles CA). When evaluated with different approaches, the analytical sensitivity of ultrasensitive PSA ranged between 0.0029 and 0.0038 ng/ml. The biological detection limit was 0.0098 ng/ml. Dilution of samples with low PSA levels showed a good recovery (from 88 to 113%) up to 1:128 dilution factor (final PSA levels ranging from 0.004 to 0.016 ng/ml in different samples). The assay precision was excellent in the low dose range, the highest interassay interadjustment CV among replicates being 5.84% when assaying serum samples with PSA lower than 1.0 ng/ml. Besides its role in the follow-up of prostatectomized patients, the evaluated ultrasensitive PSA could be reliably used for the detection of clinically meaningful PSA variations in the low dose range, and it could therefore be a candidate for the assessment of PSA velocity.

How tumor markers are used in the routine follow-up of breast and colorectal cancer. A survey of 29 Italian hospitals.

The impact of tumor markers on the outcome of several malignancies is still under debate. This relative uncertainty leads to a subjective approach to their use. Monitoring the use of tumor markers is a valuable tool to identify the need for educational policies. We conducted a survey to evaluate how tumor markers are routinely used in the follow-up of patients with breast, colorectal and ovarian carcinoma. The former two malignancies are considered in the present paper. We surveyed 35 Italian hospitals; 29 (83%, accounting for 26,622 hospital beds) filled in and returned the questionnaire. Overall, 467,361 tumor marker requests were scrutinized by the surveyed hospitals. We found a wide variability in the type and number of routinely used markers, the cutoff points chosen, and the clinical decisions taken on the basis of marker results. In addition, we observed a relative lack of communication between clinicians and clinical pathologists in around 50% of the surveyed hospitals. In these cases clinical information was not provided to the laboratory and methodological aspects were not communicated to clinicians. From the findings of the present study we conclude that the cooperation between clinicians and clinical pathologists must improve before guidelines for the use of tumor marker assays can be framed and the compliance with these guidelines can be checked. Request forms for tumor marker assays should therefore be designed to contain clinical information and the quality of filling in request forms with clinical data should be carefully monitored.

Cathepsin D versus other prognostic factors in breast cancer. Results and controversies of a multicenter study on 2575 cases.

The aim of this study was the survey of cathepsin D determination in a large group of patients enrolled at several centers, under the coordination of the Italian Committee for Quality Control in the Oncological Laboratory. Cathepsin D was measured with the same methodology, under control of an intra and interlaboratory quality control program, in order to verify the comparability of cathepsin D results from different institutions and to analyze the frequency of cathepsin D positive cases in subgroups of patients stratified according to other prognostic parameters. This retrospective study included 2575 patients with primary breast cancer evaluated in 10 institutions. Cytosol from tumor tissue was the substrate for biochemical cathepsin D, estrogen receptor and progesterone receptor determination, with an interlaboratory quality control survey provided by the E.O.R.T.C. Receptor Group and the Italian Committee for Quality Control in the Oncological Laboratory. The results of the present study can be summarized as follows: 1) Cathepsin D is independent of menopausal status; 2) In spite of standardization of tissue handling and assay methods, different results may be obtained by different institutions. It is therefore essential that each laboratory calculates its own positive/negative cutoff values prior to any routine clinical use of the parameter. This should be a serious consideration when a multicenter study is planned.

Impact of steroid receptors, pS2 and cathepsin D on the outcome of N+ postmenopausal breast cancer patients treated with tamoxifen.

In spite of the complexity of the biological basis of the hormonal regulation of breast cancer, clinical studies tend to simplify the information by mainly categorizing continuous variables related to hormonal status and not considering the interactions between variables. The present study was planned to examine the presence of an interaction between cathepsin D (Cath-D) and pS2 in patients treated with adjuvant tamoxifen in a homogeneous subset of node-positive postmenopausal patients and to evaluate the contribution of the interaction to the predictive ability of the model. Steroid receptors (ER and PgR) were measured in cytosol using the dextran-coated charcoal method, while Cath-D and pS2 were determined using commercially available immunoradiometric assays. The prognostic role of each variable and their joint effect were investigated using a Cox regression model. Biological variables were analyzed as continuous and when their prognostic relationship did not seem linear, a restricted cubic spline regression smoothing approach was adopted. The logarithm of hazard showed a linear relationship with the log(ER), while it i) remained almost constant up to about 20 fmol/mg and subsequently decreased for PgR; ii) was almost constant up to about 50 pmol/mg and subsequently decreased for Cath-D; iii) decreased for increasing log(value) up to about 33 ng/mg and subsequently increased for pS2. In the multivariate analysis both PgR and the interaction between pS2 and Cath-D retained a significant prognostic role. For low values of pS2, the prognosis worsened with the increase in Cath-D levels and this relationship reversed for high values of pS2. From the results of the present study we can conclude that i) a significant interaction between Cath-D and pS2 was found in this case series; ii) the prognostic relationship should not be underestimated in clinical decision making; iii) a predictive score obtained considering the contribution of PgR, pS2 and Cath-D could be useful for clinical use.

Relationship between cytosol TPS, TPA and cell proliferation.

The serological tumor marker tissue polypeptide antigen (TPA) and the more recently identified tissue-specific polypeptide antigen (TPS) have been reported to be indicators of the proliferation rate of the tumor. In the present investigation we compared the cytosol level of the two markers with the proliferative activity of the tumor measured using the 3H-thymidine labelling index. The preliminary results presented here show that higher TLI is associated with lower cytosol levels of both TPA and TPS. TPA and TPS in the cytosol were significantly associated. These findings are in agreement with the previously demonstrated association between high TPA cytosol levels and better prognosis in breast cancer. Further studies are ongoing in order to: 1. confirm these findings in a larger patient series; 2. investigate any possible prognostic indication provided by TPS; 3. evaluate any possible biological meaning of the negative association between TPA/TPS and TLI in the cytosol of breast cancer.

Evaluation of critical differences of CEA and CA 15.3 levels in serial samples from patients operated for breast cancer.

In the present investigation we evaluated the variability of tumor marker levels in the follow-up of patients without evidence of disease after resection of primary breast cancer. CEA and CA15.3 were measured using commercially available methods in serial blood samples collected from 170 patients. The coefficient of variation among all samples from each patient, which accounts for the total variability (analytical variability+biological variability), was widely scattered (from 4 to 99% for CEA; from 4 to 52% for CA15.3). The critical difference was calculated using the formula designed by Fraser [CD = 2.77. (CVa2 + CVb2)1/2]. It ranged from 11 to 276 for CEA and from 11 to 144 for CA15.3. From the present findings we conclude that: 1) it is possible to identify individually tailored decision criteria to evaluate tumor marker variations in the follow-up of breast cancer patients; 2) in a considerable number of cases the non-tumor-related variability is too high to allow the early identification of minor tumor marker variations that are of clinical relevance.

Carcinoembryonic antigen, ferritin, tissue polypeptide antigen, and CA15/3 in breast cancer: relationship between carcinoma and normal breast tissue.

The study of tumor markers in breast cancer tissue may supply information on the tumor's biological features and its clinical behaviour. Forty-nine primary breast cancer patients are evaluable to date. CEA, ferritin, TPA and CA15/3 were measured with radioimmunometric methods in the cytosol of carcinoma and normal tissue from the same breast. The concentrations of the four markers were higher in the tumor than in normal tissue in 42/49 cases for CEA, 47/49 for ferritin, 42/49 for TPA and in 24/29 for CA15/3. However, an overlap was found between carcinoma and normal tissue levels, particularly for CEA and TPA. We can conclude that the four substances studied may be markers of malignancy in breast carcinoma when non-malignant breast tissue from the same patient is determined at the same time, whereas assays within a single, unknown breast tissue sample may be useful only in the case of ferritin and, partly, CA15/3.

A new approach to tumour marker assessment by perioperative determination in breast and colorectal cancer.

Preoperative serum tumour markers are currently classified as positive or negative according to a predetermined cut-off point. In the present study we examined the dynamic variation of marker levels after radical surgery of breast and colorectal cancer. CEA and CA15.3 were measured in 93 patients with breast cancer, CEA and CA19.9 in 97 patients with colorectal carcinoma before and 30 days after radical surgery. Any variation higher than 3-fold the analytical coefficient of variation of the assay was considered significant. In patients with negative preoperative marker levels a significant decrease was noted after surgery in 15.6% of cases for CEA and 27.8% for CA15.3 in breast cancer and in 46.8% for CEA and 25.7% for CA19.9 in colorectal cancer. Using both cut-off-based and dynamic criteria, we found an overall positivity rate of 19.6% for CEA and 33.3% for CA15.3 in breast cancer; 60.0% for CEA and 37.1% for CA19.9 in colorectal cancer. From the present findings we conclude that the dynamic study of perioperative variations of tumour markers is a sensitive method additional to cut-off-based criteria for the assessment of the phenotypic expression of the marker by the tumour.

TAF test in primary esophageal carcinoma: comparison with other tumor markers.

An ELISA method for the determination of circulating specific HSV-TAA antibodies has recently become available (TAF test). The presence of TAF was tested in serum of 154 patients with primary esophageal carcinoma, collected in three institutions. The overall TAF-test positivity rate was 57.1%, being significantly lower in stage IV than in stage III patients. The concordance rate between TAF and CEA, ferritin, TPA, SCC and TATI was low, suggesting that TAF is probably independent of the other tumor markers evaluated. The clinical role of TAF-test determination in patients with esophageal carcinoma is currently under evaluation.

Tumor markers in squamous cell carcinoma of esophagus: immunometric assay in cytosol and membrane fraction.

Carcinoembryonic antigen (CEA), tissue polypeptide antigen (TPA), ferritin, and the monoclonal antibody-detected tumor-associated antigens CA19.9 and CA50 were measured by radioimmunoassay in tissue fractions of carcinoma and normal esophageal mucosa from 59 patients with untreated primary squamous cell carcinoma of the esophagus. Tumor markers were measured in cytosol (118 samples) and in a membrane-enriched fraction (32 samples). CEA, TPA and ferritin were detected in almost all the cytosol samples evaluated, CA19.9 and CA50 in 66% and 50% of cases respectively. Ferritin was significantly higher in carcinoma than in normal mucosa. The cytosol concentrations of CEA, TPA, CA19.9 and CA50 were not significantly different in carcinoma and normal tissue. Concentrations of CEA, CA19.9 and CA50 in the membrane fraction tended to be higher in normal tissue than in carcinoma, whereas the cytosol-to-membrane ratio was significantly higher in carcinoma. For CEA, CA19.9 and CA50, the phenotypic pattern of the malignant transformation seems to involve a different intracellular distribution rather than a quantitative change. No correlations were found between tissue and serum concentrations of the tumor markers, the former being related to the phenotypic characteristics of the tumor, the latter to the tumor burden.

Prostate cancer probability after total PSA and percent free PSA determination.

UNLABELLED: The percent free PSA value is a promising diagnostic tool for prostate cancer. However, its actual role has not yet been established because of the widely diverging sensitivity and specificity values. This could depend at least in part on analytical difficulties, since the free PSA concentration is much lower than that of total PSA. The present investigation was designed to evaluate the diagnostic performance of the percent free PSA in the most favorable analytical conditions. MATERIALS AND METHODS: 81 patients affected by newly diagnosed, untreated primary prostate cancer (CaP) and 239 patients with untreated benign prostatic hyperplasia (BPH) were prospectively enrolled. Hybritech total and free PSA were measured by the same technician using the same reagent batch. RESULTS: The percent free PSA was not significantly associated with age, tumor stage, gland volume, Gleason score, and total PSA, nor was it significantly affected by concomitant prostatic complications either in CaP or BPH. Percent free PSA was more effective than total PSA in the differential diagnosis between CaP and BPH in every evaluated dose range of total PSA. Percent free PSA determination could have reduced the rate of unnecessary biopsies in cases with total PSA > or = 4 ng/mL and > or = 10 ng/mL (avoided biopsies 61% and 63%, respectively). The post-test probability of the disease, which represents the proportion of patients with a positive percent free PSA value who have the disease, was, however, relatively low in younger patients with total PSA within the normal range. CONCLUSIONS: The diagnostic performance of the percent free PSA value is enhanced when the methodological variability is reduced, particularly in men with low total PSA. Percent free PSA is superior to total PSA in distinguishing primary CaP from BPH in patients with total PSA between 2 and 30 ng/mL. The percent free PSA value is effective in reducing the rate of unnecessary biopsies in men with total PSA higher than 4 or 10 ng/mL. However, due to its relatively low post-test probability, the percent free PSA value should be interpreted with caution in the decision-making related to individual patients and should be used in association with clinical and instrumental evaluation of the patient.