Using whole disease modeling to inform resource allocation decisions: economic evaluation of a clinical guideline for colorectal cancer using a single model.

OBJECTIVE: To assess the feasibility and value of simulating whole disease and treatment pathways within a single model to provide a common economic basis for informing resource allocation decisions. METHODS: A patient-level simulation model was developed with the intention of being capable of evaluating multiple topics within National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence's colorectal cancer clinical guideline. The model simulates disease and treatment pathways from preclinical disease through to detection, diagnosis, adjuvant/neoadjuvant treatments, follow-up, curative/palliative treatments for metastases, supportive care, and eventual death. The model parameters were informed by meta-analyses, randomized trials, observational studies, health utility studies, audit data, costing sources, and expert opinion. Unobservable natural history parameters were calibrated against external data using Bayesian Markov chain Monte Carlo methods. Economic analysis was undertaken using conventional cost-utility decision rules within each guideline topic and constrained maximization rules across multiple topics. RESULTS: Under usual processes for guideline development, piecewise economic modeling would have been used to evaluate between one and three topics. The Whole Disease Model was capable of evaluating 11 of 15 guideline topics, ranging from alternative diagnostic technologies through to treatments for metastatic disease. The constrained maximization analysis identified a configuration of colorectal services that is expected to maximize quality-adjusted life-year gains without exceeding current expenditure levels. CONCLUSIONS: This study indicates that Whole Disease Model development is feasible and can allow for the economic analysis of most interventions across a disease service within a consistent conceptual and mathematical infrastructure. This disease-level modeling approach may be of particular value in providing an economic basis to support other clinical guidelines.

Estimating the direct costs of bowel cancer services provided by the National Health Service in England.

OBJECTIVES: Bowel cancer is the second most common cancer in England and Wales, accounting for approximately 13,000 deaths per year. Economic evaluations and national guidance have been produced for individual treatments for bowel cancer. However, it has been suggested that Primary Care Trusts develop program budgeting or equivalent methodology demonstrating a whole system approach to investment and disinvestment. The objective of this study was to provide a baseline framework for considering a whole system approach to estimate the direct costs of bowel cancer services provided by the National Health Service (NHS) in England. METHODS: A treatment pathway, developed in 2005, was used to construct a service pathway model to estimate the direct cost of bowel cancer services in England. RESULTS: The service pathway model estimated the direct cost of bowel cancer services to the NHS to be in excess of £1 billion in 2005. Thirty-five percent of the cost is attributable to the screening and testing of patients with suspected bowel cancer, subsequently diagnosed as cancer-free. CONCLUSIONS: This study is believed to be the most comprehensive attempt to identify the direct cost of managing bowel cancer services in England. The approach adopted could be useful to assist local decision makers in identifying those aspects of the pathway that are most uncertain in terms of their cost-effectiveness and as a basis to explore the implications of re-allocated resources. Research recommendations include the need for detailed costs on surgical procedures, high-risk patients and the utilization of the methods used in this study across other cancers.

Cholesterol crystal embolism leading to perforation of the gallbladder.

BACKGROUND: Cholesterol crystal embolism (CCE) from atherosclerotic arterial disease leading to perforation of the gallbladder is rare. We describe our experience of managing a patient with perforation of gallbladder caused by CCE. METHODS: A 64-year-old man was admitted to this hospital because of acute abdominal pain with clinical features suggestive of peritonitis. He was known to suffer from atherosclerotic peripheral arterial disease and had undergone aortobifemoral bypass 17 years ago. A CT scan showed a collection of peri-hepatic fluid. The gallbladder was normal in appearance but contained multiple calculi. At laparotomy, free bile was observed in the peritoneal cavity, leaking from a pin-hole size peroration of the fundus of the gallbladder. Hence cholecystectomy was performed. RESULTS: The patient made an uneventful recovery. Histological study of the gallbladder showed chronic cholecystitis and obliteration of the lumen of the mural arteries with cholesterol crystals within, indicating CCE. CONCLUSIONS: Although perforation of the gallbladder following CCE of its mural arteries is rare, the diagnosis should be considered in patients with abdominal pain and known atherosclerotic arterial disease. Management should include an early recognition of this condition, prompt institution of treatment, prevention of further insults by discontinuing or avoiding predisposing factors, and modification of cardiovascular risk factors.

Improving Weekend Out Of hours Surgical Handover (WOOSH).

An effective surgical handover is imperative to optimise patient care and safety, whilst ensuring progression of clinical management and the delivery of an efficient service. The introduction of full-shift working, as a response to progressive implementation of the European Working Time Directive (EWTD), has placed the spotlight on patient and doctor safety. Effective handover between shifts is vital to protect patient safety and assist doctors with clinical governance. The weekend is a critical point where the transfer of patient care to the ongoing weekend team is efficient, thorough and informative, as this is a point in the patient journey where the patient is the most vulnerable. The weekend team is often not responsible for the management of the patient throughout the week and poor or incomplete information can have disastrous consequences on patient safety. (1,2,3) There is a general consensus and anecdotal evidence that this process is variable, occasionally unsafe or of poor quality, and can be improved. (4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11) However, no standardised format is deemed optimal or available. The aim therefore, was to design and implement a weekend handover proforma, in order to deliver a more efficient and safer system for patient care over the weekend without increasing junior doctor workload. The Weekend Out Of Hours Surgical Handover (WOOSH) form was designed following consultation with medical, nursing and allied health professionals. All staff were instructed how to complete the form, with pre- and post-intervention questionnaires undertaken. The results of the study enforce and advocate the permanent practice of the WOOSH form with 93.33% endorsing the permanent introduction of the form and 100% finding the form useful.

Support expectations of cancer patients.

Patients' satisfaction is a paramount in the delivery of health care provisions, particularly in patients with poor prognosis. Effective communication with such patients helps in achieving a better satisfaction score. A survey was conducted on upper gastrointestinal cancer patients to assess their perceived satisfaction regarding the healthcare received. A frank but supportive communication helps in meeting the expectations of these patients in their cancer journey.

Obstructive uropathy secondary to incisional herniation of a transplant ureter - case report and review of literature.

BACKGROUND: Herniation of transplant ureter into an incisional hernia is an uncommon and unreported cause of ureteric obstruction, which can lead to transplant dysfunction and diagnostic dilemmas. A report of our case and review of pertinent literature is presented. CASE REPORT: We report a 61-year-old lady, who presented with transplant dysfunction and hydronephrosis due to obstruction of the transplant ureter in an incisional hernia 8 years post-transplantation. An antegrade pyelogram and a computerised tomographic scan demonstrated an incisional hernia containing the obstructed transplant ureter. Antegrade stent insertion followed by an open mesh repair of the incision hernia restored normal alignment of the ureter and transplant renal function. CONCLUSIONS: Due to its rarity, awareness of this condition is important in its prevention and successful management.