Limits of structural plasticity in a picornavirus capsid revealed by a massively expanded equine rhinitis A virus particle.

UNLABELLED: The Picornaviridae family of small, nonenveloped viruses includes major pathogens of humans and animals. They have positive-sense, single-stranded RNA genomes, and the mechanism(s) by which these genomes are introduced into cells to initiate infection remains poorly understood. The structures of presumed uncoating intermediate particles of several picornaviruses show limited expansion and some increased porosity compared to the mature virions. Here, we present the cryo-electron microscopy structure of native equine rhinitis A virus (ERAV), together with the structure of a massively expanded ERAV particle, each at ∼17-Šresolution. The expanded structure has large pores on the particle 3-fold axes and has lost the RNA genome and the capsid protein VP4. The expanded structure thus illustrates both the limits of structural plasticity in such capsids and a plausible route by which genomic RNA might exit. IMPORTANCE: Picornaviruses are important animal and human pathogens that protect their genomic RNAs within a protective protein capsid. Upon infection, this genomic RNA must be able to leave the capsid to initiate a new round of infection. We describe here the structure of a unique, massively expanded state of equine rhinitis A virus that provides insight into how this exit might occur.

Virus isolate from carp: genetic characterization reveals a novel picornavirus with two aphthovirus 2A-like sequences.

Picornaviruses have been isolated from a variety of hosts, mainly mammals and birds. Here, we describe the sequence analysis of carp picornavirus 1 (CPV-1) F37/06 that was isolated from an organ pool (heart, brain, liver) of a common carp (Cyprinus carpio). This carp perished after an accidental discharge of liquid manure into a fish pond and presented without obvious clinical symptoms. Experimental intraperitoneal infection of young carp with CPV-1 revealed no clinical signs, but the virus was re-isolated from various organs. Sequence analysis of almost the complete genome (7632 nt excluding the poly-A tract) revealed a novel picornavirus clade. In phylogenetic trees, the polymerase sequence clusters with parechoviruses, duck hepatitis A virus, eel picornavirus and aquamavirus A. The ORF includes 6807 nt and encodes a polyprotein of 2269 amino acids. CPV-1 has a genome layout like that of picornaviruses except for the presence of two aphthovirus 2A-like NPGP sequence motifs: VPg+5'UTR[1AB-1C-1D-2A1(npgp)/2A2(npgp)-2B-2C(ATPase)/3A-3B(VPg)-3C(pro)-3D(pol)]3'UTR-poly-A. 2A1(npgp) and 2A2(npgp) are separated by 133 amino acids. The proteins 2A2(npgp), 2B, 3A and 3B(VPg) have no significant similarity to the corresponding proteins of other picornaviruses. Amino acid identities of the orthologous proteins P1, 2C, 3C(pro) and 3D(pol) range from 16.4 to 40.8 % in the eel picornavirus/CPV-1 comparison. 3D(pol) shows the closest similarity to eel picornavirus, with an amino acid identity of 40.8 %, followed by human parechovirus (36.5 %), duck hepatitis A virus (32.7 %) and swine pasivirus (29.3 %). Both the unique genome organization and low sequence similarity support the assignment of CPV-1 to a novel picornavirus species within a novel genus.

Crystal structure of equine rhinitis A virus in complex with its sialic acid receptor.

Equine rhinitis A virus (ERAV) shares many features with foot-and-mouth disease virus (FMDV) and both are classified within the genus Aphthovirus of the family Picornaviridae. ERAV is used as a surrogate for FMDV research as it does not require high-level biosecurity. In contrast to FMDV, which uses integrins as cellular receptors, the receptor for ERAV has been reported to involve the sugar moiety sialic acid. This study confirmed the importance of sialic acid for cell entry by ERAV and reports the crystal structure of ERAV particles complexed with the receptor analogue 3'-sialyllactose. The receptor is attached to the rim of a capsid pit adjacent to the major immunogenic site and distinct from the sialic acid binding site used by a related picornavirus, the cardiovirus Theiler's murine encephalitis virus. The structure of the major antigenic determinant of the virus, previously identified from antibody escape mutations, is also described as the EF loop of VP1, which forms a hairpin stretching across the capsid surface close to the icosahedral fivefold axis, neighbouring the receptor-binding site, and spanning two protomeric units.

Perturbations in the surface structure of A22 Iraq foot-and-mouth disease virus accompanying coupled changes in host cell specificity and antigenicity.

BACKGROUND: Foot-and-mouth disease virus (FMDV) is an extremely infectious and antigenically diverse picornavirus of cloven-hoofed animals. Strains of the A22 subtype have been reported to change antigenically when adapted to different growth conditions. To investigate the structural basis of this phenomenon we have determined the structures of two variants of an A22 virus. RESULTS: The structures of monolayer- and suspension-cell-adapted A22 FMDV have been determined by X-ray crystallography. Picornaviruses comprise four capsid proteins, VP1-4. The major antigenic loop of the capsid protein VP1 is flexible in both variants of the A22 subtype but its overall disposition is distinct from that observed in other FMDV serotypes (O and C). A detailed structural comparison between A22 FMDV and a type O virus suggests that different conformations in a portion of the major antigenic loop of VP1 (the GH loop, which is also central to receptor attachment) result in distinct folds of the adjacent VP3 GH loop. Also, a single mutation (Glu82-->Gly) on the surface of VP2 in the suspension-cell-adapted virus appears to perturb the structure of the VP1 GH loop. CONCLUSION: The GH loop of VP1 is flexible in three serotypes of FMDV, suggesting that flexibility is important in both antigenic variability and structural communication with other regions of the virus capsid. Our results illustrate two instances of the propagation of structural perturbations across the virion surface: the change in the VP3 GH loop caused by the VP1 GH loop and the Glu82-->Gly change in VP2 which we believe perturbs the GH loop of VP1. In the latter case, the amplification of the sequence changes leads to differences, between the monolayer- and suspension-cell-adapted viruses, in host-cell interactions and antigenicity.

Structural comparison of two strains of foot-and-mouth disease virus subtype O1 and a laboratory antigenic variant, G67.

BACKGROUND: Foot-and-mouth disease viruses (FMDVs) are members of the picornavirus family and cause an economically important disease of cloven-hoofed animals. To understand the structural basis of antigenic variation in FMDV, we have determined the structures of two viruses closely related to strain O1BFS whose structure is known. RESULTS: The two new structure are, like O1BFS, both serotype O viruses. The first, O1 Kaüfbeuren (O1K), is a field isolate dating from an outbreak of FMD in Europe in the 1960s. The second, called G67, is a quadruple mutant of O1K, generated in the laboratory, that bears point mutations conferring resistance to neutralizing by monoclonal antibodies, specific for each of the four major antigenic sites defined previously. The availability of the three related virus structures permits a detailed analysis of the way amino acid substitutions influence antigenicity. Structural changes are seen to be limited, in general, to the substituted side chain. For example, the GH loop of VP1, a highly antigenic and mobile protuberance which becomes ordered only under reducing conditions, was essentially indistinguishable in the three viruses despite the accumulation of up to four changes within its 15-residue sequence. At one of the other antigenic sites, however, changes between the two field strains did perturb both side-chain and main-chain structures in the vicinity. CONCLUSIONS: The conservation of conformation of the GH loop of VP1 adds to the evidence implicating an integrin as the cellular receptor for FMDV, since this loop contains a conserved RGD (Arg-Gly-Asp) sequence structurally similar to the same tripeptide in some other integrin-binding proteins. Structural changes required for the virus to escape neutralization by monoclonal antibodies are generally small. The more extensive type of structural change exhibited by the field isolates probably reflects differing selective pressures operating in vivo and in vitro.

The structure and antigenicity of a type C foot-and-mouth disease virus.

BACKGROUND: Picornaviruses are responsible for a wide range of mammalian diseases and, in common with other RNA viruses, show considerable antigenic variation. Foot-and-mouth disease viruses (FMDVs) constitute one genus of the picornavirus family and are classified into seven serotypes, each of which shows considerable intratypic variation. This antigenic variation leads to continuing difficulties in controlling the disease. To date the structure of only one serotype, O, has been reported. RESULTS: The three-dimensional structure of a serotype C (isolate C-S8c1) FMDV, has been determined crystallographically at 3.5 A resolution. The main chain conformation of the virion is very similar to that of type O1 virus. The immunodominant G-H loop of VP1, the presumed site of cell attachment, is disordered in both types of virus indicating a functional role for flexibility of this region. There are significant changes in the structure of other antigenic loops and in some internal regions involved in protomer-protomer contacts, including the entire amino-terminal portion of VP2, described here for the first time for a picornavirus. Antigenic sites have been identified by genetic and peptide mapping methods, and located on the capsid. The data reveal a major new discontinuous antigenic site (site D) which is located near to the three-fold axis and involves residues of VP1, VP2 and VP3 which lie adjacent to each other on the capsid. CONCLUSION: In FMDV type C, amino acid substitutions seen in mutants that are resistant to neutralization by monoclonal antibodies (MAbs) map to predominantly surface-oriented residues with solvent-accessible side-chains not involved in interactions with other amino acids, whereas residues which are accessible but not substituted are found to be more frequently involved in protein-protein interactions. This provides a molecular interpretation for the repeated isolation of the same amino acid substitutions in MAb-resistant variants, an observation frequently made with RNA viruses. This first comparison of two FMDV serotypes shows how subtle changes at antigenic sites are sufficient to cause large changes in antigenic specificity between serotypes.

Function of minor polypeptides in foot-and-mouth disease virus and poliovirus.

Foot-and-mouth disease virus and poliovirus each contain several minor polypeptides, in addition to the four structural proteins. One of these, the viral RNA polymerase, can also act as a nuclease, hydrolysing the RNA and thus destroying viral infectivity. It is tightly bound to the RNA and may be the packaging signal for assembly of the particle.

Titration calculations of foot-and-mouth disease virus capsids and their stabilities as a function of pH.

Foot-and-mouth disease virus (FMDV), a non-enveloped picornavirus, is sensitive to acidic conditions. At pH values below 7 the icosahedral virus capsid, formed from 60 copies of a protomer containing four polypeptides (VP1 to 4), dissociates into 12 pentamers, releasing the viral RNA. Evidence suggests that this acid lability may assist FMDV cell entry via an endosomal pathway. Calculations of titration curves and pH-stability profiles are presented for three different strains of FMDV, O1BFS, A10(61) and A22 Iraq, and compared with experimental data for complete virions and empty capsids (which lack RNA). The finite difference Poisson-Boltzmann method was used for the calculation of electrostatic free energies with the solvent treated as a dielectric continuum. The inter-pentamer interface in the virus is formed by two protomers related by 2-fold icosahedral symmetry. As a simple model for inter-pentamer interactions, a dimer and two separate protomers were compared. The association free energy was computed by integrating the difference between the titration curves of the two species. The calculations reproduced the observed decrease in capsid stability at acidic pH but not the difference in pH sensitivities of the two type A viruses. It is shown that only residues within 15 A of the interface play a significant role in determining acid lability. For the experimentally studied pH range (5 to 7.6), histidine residues were found to dominate the pH-dependence of the stability. Two histidine residues in VP3, H142 and H145, are shown to have the greatest effect by virtue of their interactions with many polar residues across the inter-pentamer interface; the interaction of H142 with an alpha-helix in the opposite pentamer contributes only a small proportion of the destabilization energy.

Conformational flexibility in a highly mobile protein loop of foot-and-mouth disease virus: distinct structural requirements for integrin and antibody binding.

The G-H loop of foot-and-mouth disease virus VP1 protein is a highly mobile peptide, that extends from the capsid surface and that in native virions is invisible by X-ray crystallography. In serotype C, this segment contains a hypervariable region with several continuous, overlapping, B-cell epitopes that embrace the conserved Arg-Gly-Asp (RGD) cell attachment motif. The solvent-exposed positioning of this peptide by selective insertion into different structural frameworks of E. coli beta-galactosidase, generates a spectrum of antigenic variants which react distinctively with a panel of anti-VP1 monoclonal antibodies and exhibit different efficiencies as cell ligands. The cell attachment efficiency is much less restricted by the different positioning of the viral segment at the insertion sites. A molecular model of an inserted stretch reveals a highest flexibility of the RGD tripeptide segment compared with the flanking sequences, that could allow a proper accommodation to integrin receptors even in poorly antigenic conformations. The non-converging structural requirements for RGD-mediated integrin binding and antibody recognition, explains the dynamism of the generation of neutralisation-resistant antigenic variants in the viral quasi-species, arising from a conformational space of integrin-binding competent peptides. This might be of special relevance for foot-and-moth disease virus evolution, since unlike in other picornaviruses, the cell binding motif and the major neutralising B-cell epitopes overlap in a solvent-exposed peptide accessible to the host immune system, in a virion lacking canyons and similar hiding structures.

Crystallization and preliminary X-ray analysis of three serotypes of foot-and-mouth disease virus.

Foot-and-mouth disease viruses from serotypes O, A and C have been crystallized. The particular strains studied include O1K, A10(61), A22 Iraq 24/64, A24 Cruzeiro and C-S8c1. In addition, crystals have been grown of G67, a monoclonal antibody neutralization escape mutant derived from O1K, and of virus R100, recovered after the establishment of a persistent infection in baby hamster kidney cells with C-S8c1. Empty particles, capsids which lack the RNA genome, have also been crystallized for subtypes A22 Iraq 24/64 and A10(61). In almost all cases, crystals suitable for high resolution structure determination were obtained from (NH4)2SO4 or mixtures of polyethylene glycol and NH4Cl.

Cyclic disulfide model of the major antigenic site of serotype-C foot-and-mouth disease virus. Synthetic, conformational and immunochemical studies.

A cyclic disulfide peptide representing antigenic site A of foot-and-mouth disease virus (FMDV) strain C-S8c1 (residues 134 to 155 of viral protein 1 (VP1) with Tyr136 and Arg153 replaced by cystine; TTCTASARGDLAHLTTTHACHL) was synthesized by solid phase methods. Formation of the cyclic disulfide was carried out by air oxidation of the fully deprotected and reduced bis-cysteine precursor, under high dilution conditions. The identity of the cyclic peptide was confirmed by both physical and enzymatic methods. A conformational study of the cyclic peptide and of its linear parent structure (YTASARGDLAHLTTTHARHLP, residues 136-156 of VP1 of FMDV C-S8c1) by circular dichroism in the presence of a structure-inducing solvent showed the cyclic disulfide analog to adopt lower levels of alpha-helix than its linear counterpart. In competitive ELISA assays both peptides reacted with similar affinity against a representative panel of neutralizing monoclonal antibodies directed towards antigenic site A. Thus, a high inherent flexibility of this loop may preclude a conformational restriction strong enough to alter recognition by anti-virus antibodies.

Biochemical and structural studies with neutralizing antibodies raised against foot-and-mouth disease virus.

The function of a loop exposed on the aphthovirus capsid (the G-H loop of protein VP1) has been explored by combining genetic and structural studies with viral mutants. The loop displays a dual function of receptor recognition and interaction with neutralizing antibodies. Remarkably, some amino acid residues play a critical role in both such disparate functions. Therefore residues subjected to antibody pressure for variation may nevertheless maintain a role in receptor recognition for which invariance is a requirement. Evolution of FMDV in cell culture may relax the requirements at this site and allow further increase of antigenic diversification. Essential residues at one stage of virus evolution may become dispensable at another not very distant point in the evolutionary landscape. Implications for FMDV evolution and vaccine design are discussed.

Mutational analysis of discontinuous epitopes of foot-and-mouth disease virus using an unprocessed capsid protomer precursor.

An unprocessed capsid precursor (P1) of foot-and-mouth disease virus (FMDV) has been expressed in mammalian cells to study discontinuous epitopes involved in viral neutralization. Amino acid replacements found in virus-escape mutants were engineered in the P1 precursor by site-directed mutagenesis of the plasmid. In all cases the replacements abolished recognition of unprocessed P1 by the relevant monoclonal antibodies (MAbs), paralleling the effects of the corresponding substitutions in neutralization of infectious FMDV. Five capsid surface residues within the same discontinuous antigenic area that were never found replaced in escape mutants were also engineered in P1. None of the substitutions affected antibody recognition, suggesting that these residues were not directly involved in the interaction with the antibodies tested. The results validate site-directed mutagenesis of constructs encoding capsid precursors as an approach to probe the structure of viral discontinuous epitopes not amenable to analysis with synthetic peptides.

Foot-and-mouth disease and beyond: vaccine design, past, present and future.

The first experimental vaccines against foot-and-mouth disease were made in 1925 by Vallee, Carre and Rinjard using formaldehyde inactivation of tongue tissue from cattle infected with the virus. This method was essentially unaltered until the late 1940s when the important experiments by Frenkel in Holland showed that the quantities of virus required for vaccine production could be obtained from fragments of tongue epithelium incubated in vitro following infection with the virus. This major step made possible the comprehensive vaccination programmes which followed in Western Europe and which, in turn, resulted in the elimination of the disease from that part of the world by 1989. This spectacular success has led many to question whether other kinds of vaccine are required to control the disease worldwide. Such reservations ignore the danger to the environment associated with the growth of large amounts of virus. This can never be a zero-risk situation. Consequently, a vaccine which is not based on infectious virus as starting material has many attractions from safety considerations alone. In addition, a vaccine based on more fundamental considerations would not only be more aesthetically satisfying but could possibly provide an understanding at the molecular level of antigenic variation, still a problem in the control of the disease. The advances in our knowledge of the structure of the virus and the fragments which elicit a protective immune response now allow us to envisage a vaccine which does not require infectious virus and which protects against the multiple serotypes of the agent. Since antigenic variation is still a major problem in the control of the disease by vaccination, such a product would have important advantages over the current vaccines.

The structure of an immunodominant loop on foot and mouth disease virus, serotype O1, determined under reducing conditions.

Residues 136-159 of VPI of foot and mouth disease virus (FMDV) comprise the G-H loop of the protein and form a prominent feature on the surface of virus particles. This sequence contains an immunodominant neutralizing epitope, which can be mimicked with synthetic peptides, and includes an Arg, Gly, Asp motif which has been implicated in the binding of the virus to cellular receptors. Crystallographic analysis of native virus particles failed to resolve the structure of this region due to its disordered state. However, reduction of a disulphide bond between cysteine residues 134 of VP1 and 130 of VP2 caused the G-H loop to collapse onto the surface of the virus particle and allowed its conformation to be determined.

Methods used in the structure determination of foot-and-mouth disease virus.

The structure of foot-and-mouth disease virus (FMDV) strain O1 BFS 1860 has been determined to 2.9 A resolution using the molecular-replacement method [Acharya, Fry, Stuart, Fox, Rowlands & Brown (1989). Nature (London), 337, 709-716]. Crystals of the virus with average dimensions 0.12 x 0.06 x 0.12 mm belong to space group I23, a = 345 A with 1/12 of the icosahedral particle per asymmetric unit giving fivefold noncrystallographic redundancy. Oscillation diffraction photographs were collected at the SERC Synchrotron Radiation Source at Daresbury in accordance with strict disease security regulations. The ambiguity in particle orientation was resolved using a self-rotation function and starting estimates of the phases to 8 A were derived from the known structures of two picornaviruses similarly oriented in the I23 unit cell. The phases were refined and extended using iterative averaging and solvent flattening with the implementation of a simple automatic envelope-determination procedure to increase the phasing power available.

Biochemical characterization of FMDV A10 and A22 subtypes by PAGE and IEF.

Both polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (PAGE) and iso-electric focusing (IEF) have been standardized using the sucrose density gradient purified 146S particles of FMD virus subtypes A10 and A22. Differences in the molecular weights of structural proteins (VP1, VP2 and VP3 of two subtypes (A10 and A22) of FMDV have been revealed in PAGE but no appreciable differences in the pI of VP1, VP2 and VP3 is found in IEF.

RGD-containing peptides of VP1 of foot-and-mouth disease virus (FMDV) prevent virus infection in vitro.

RGD-containing peptides from the immunodominant region of VP1 between amino acids 135-160 from foot-and-mouth disease virus (FMDV) type O1 Kaufbeuren (O1K) prevented virus adsorption to piglet kidney (PK) cells. The highly conserved amino acid RGD sequence (Arg.-Gly.-Asp.) was a prerequisite of this effect. To prevent infection with 100-200 TCID50 in 10(6) PK cells, 20-250 micrograms of each peptide should have been added.

Comparison of amino acid sequences at the amino acid 130-160 region of VP1 polypeptide of Indian field isolates of foot-and-mouth disease virus serotype Asia 1.

The nucleotide and deduced amino acid sequences in the amino acid (aa) 130-160 region of VP1 polypeptide of 65 field isolates of foot- and mouth disease virus (FMDV) serotype Asia 1 were determined and the consensus sequences were deduced. Comparison of amino acid sequences revealed conservation of NGK (130-132), TYG (134-136), RGD (142-144), and LPTSF (156-160) motifs and aa 148 (L) while variation was observed at the rest of the region (variability index (VI) of 2.06 to 16.85). Synonymous and non-synonymous mutations at the nucleotide level were well correlated with those of the corresponding amino acids. Comparison of the aa 130-160 sequence of Asia 1 serotype with those of other serotypes of FMDV revealed conservation of aa 135, 148-149, 157 and 160. Amino acids 133-138 and 148-154 were unique for Asia 1 serotype and are presumably responsible for its distinct antigenic nature. The present study revealed that the FMDV isolates of serotype Asia 1 causing outbreaks in India are very much heterogeneous in the aa 130-160 region of VP1.

[Synthetic peptide designs based on immunoactive fragments of the VP1 protein of the foot-and-mouth disease virus strain A22]. / Sinteticheskie peptidnye konstruktsii na osnove immunoaktivnykh fragmentov belka VP1 virusa iashchura shtamma A22.

Peptide constructs consisting of 44-53 aa were synthesized on the basis of sequences 135-159, 170-190 and 197-213 of VP1 from the foot-and-mouth disease A22 strain. Immunogenic and protective properties of the peptide constructs were studied in guinea pigs and mice of three lines. The constructs were shown to induce higher levels of antibodies and exhibit higher protective effects than the separate peptides. The most active among the peptides studied was the construct involving the VP1 fragments 135-160 and 170-190: it protected pigs from the experimental infection by the foot-and-mouth disease virus.