Compassionate use: a story of ethics and science in the development of a new drug.

This history chronicles the unusual development of the antiviral drug ganciclovir. The first compound with activity against human cytomegalovirus (CMV), ganciclovir was so clearly efficacious that a placebo-controlled clinical trial could not ethically be done, and the FDA rejected the first application to market the drug. Used to treat a blinding eye infection in patients with AIDS, the story of ganciclovir paralleled the spread of the AIDS epidemic. Both ganciclovir and AIDS caught the federal government off guard. Caught in a Catch-22 situation, the pharmaceutical company developing ganciclovir gave the drug away free for five years under compassionate use guidelines. The problems encountered in the development of ganciclovir provide guidance on how future drugs to treat life-threatening diseases can be developed.

High dose oral ganciclovir treatment for cytomegalovirus retinitis.

BACKGROUND: The oral formulation of ganciclovir is approved at a dose of 3.0 g/day for maintenance treatment of cytomegalovirus (CMV) retinitis following an initial induction course of intravenous (IV) anti-CMV therapy. Median time to progression of CMV retinitis is 12-20 days shorter with oral compared to IV ganciclovir maintenance, likely due to the limited oral bioavailability of ganciclovir. OBJECTIVES: We hypothesized that higher systemic drug exposures associated with increased doses of oral ganciclovir would be associated with increased efficacy. STUDY DESIGN: Maintenance treatment of CMV retinitis with higher than standard doses of oral ganciclovir (>3.0 g/day) was studied in 281 AIDS patients with previously treated, stable retinitis randomized to 3.0, 4.5 or 6.0 g/day oral, or 5 m/kg/day IV ganciclovir. Graders unaware of treatment assignments determined retinitis progression using fundus photographs. Vision, other ophthalmic measures and safety were assessed open-label. RESULTS: Median days to photographic progression were 41, 50, 57 and 70, respectively (P=0.052; 3.0 g vs. IV). Hazard ratios for progression relative to IV were 1.66, 1.28 and 1.19 (P=0.016 for 3.0 g). NONMEM-modeled estimates of average serum ganciclovir concentration area under the curve (AUC(0-24)) correlated best with time to progression (P=0.0019). Six grams per day oral ganciclovir was most similar in efficacy to IV, although broad confidence intervals prevented a conclusive comparison. Patients receiving oral ganciclovir had a lower frequency of sepsis and IV catheter events. CONCLUSIONS: This study suggests that the efficacy of ganciclovir for the maintenance treatment of CMV retinitis improves with increasing total drug exposure (measured as average serum concentration AUC(0-24)). All four regimens of ganciclovir were reasonably well tolerated, with safety profiles similar to what has been reported in prior work.