ABSTRACT
OBJECTIVE: To assess the differences in scar outcomes between modified rotation-advancement techniques proposed by Drs. Mohler and Noordhoff, designed to address issues such as inadequate vertical lip length and scarring on the upper third of the lip in the original rotation-advancement technique. DESIGN: Retrospective single-surgeon (RD) study. PATIENTS: Consecutive non-syndromic children (n = 68) with unilateral complete cleft lip and palate. INTERVENTIONS: Modified Mohler (columellar backcut reconstructed with C flap; n = 34) and modified Noordhoff (lower, medially-created backcut reconstructed with laterally-based triangular skin flap; n = 34) repairs. MEAN OUTCOME MEASURES: Using 12-month postoperative frontal photographs, scar evaluations (overall and superior, middle, and inferior portions of the lip) were appraised by an assessment panel composed by independent professional and nonprofessional raters employing four validated qualitative scar assessment scales: Manchester Scar Scale, modified Scar-Rating Scale, Stony Brook Scar Evaluation Scale, and Visual Analog Scale. Quantitative computerized photogrammetric scar widths of the superior, middle, and inferior portions of the upper lip were also measured. RESULTS: The modified Noordhoff method showed significantly (all P < .001) better scar quality for the overall scar and superior portion of the scar in all four scales compared to the modified Mohler method, with no significant (all P > .05) difference for the middle and lower portions. No significant difference (all P > .05) was observed for photogrammetric scar width measurements. CONCLUSION: The modified Noordhoff technique provided better qualitative results for unilateral complete cleft lip-related scars compared to the modified Mohler technique.
ABSTRACT
OBJECTIVE: To appraise the degree of intraoperative palatal lengthening with the modified Furlow small double-opposing Z-plasty (sDOZ). DESIGN: Retrospective single-surgeon (R.D.) study. PATIENTS: Nonsyndromic children (n = 167) with Veau types I to IV cleft palates who underwent primary sDOZ palatoplasty. INTERVENTIONS: Intraoperative measurements of palatal lengths and widths were collected using calipers, paper rulers, and metal rulers before the administration of local anesthetic solution and before the removal of the mouth gag (initial and final palatal dimensions, respectively). MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Assessment of the intraoperative percentage change (difference between final and initial values) in surface palatal length, straight palatal length, and soft palatal length. Bivariate and multivariate analyses were performed to identify independent predictors (sex, age at surgery, Veau, Kernahan/ Stark, and Randall classifications, widest cleft width, presence of lateral relaxing incision, type of coverage with buccal fat flap, and postoperative complications) of soft palatal lengthening. RESULTS: Surface palatal, straight palatal, and soft palatal lengths had an intraoperative increase of 8%, 14.7%, and 27.7%, respectively. The degree of intraoperative soft palatal lengthening significantly varied among Veau cleft types (I = II < III = IV). Veau type III and cleft lip/palate were independent positive predictors (P < .001) of soft palatal lengthening, while other tested variables were not correlated (P > .05) with this outcome. CONCLUSIONS: Overall intraoperative palatal lengthening occurs with the modified sDOZ palatoplasty, with differences within the spectrum of cleft palate deformity.
ABSTRACT
OBJECTIVE: An inspiring early result with no oronasal fistula formation was recently described for a modified medial incision small double-opposing Z-plasty (MIsDOZ) for treating Veau type I cleft palate. This study describes an early single-surgeon experience in applying this newly proposed surgical approach. DESIGN: Retrospective single-surgeon study. PATIENTS: Consecutive nonsyndromic patients (n = 27) with Veau I cleft palate. INTERVENTIONS: Topographic anatomical-guided MIsDOZ palatoplasty with pyramidal space dissection (releasing of the ligamentous fibers in the greater palatine neurovascular bundle and pyramidal process region, in-fracture of the pterygoid hamulus, and widening of space of Ernst) performed by a novice surgeon (RD). MEAN OUTCOME MEASURES: Age at surgery, the presence of cleft lip, palatal cleft width, use of lateral relaxing incision, and 6-month complication rate (bleeding, dehiscence, fistula, and flap necrosis). A published senior surgeon-based outcome dataset (n = 24) was retrieved for comparison purposes. RESULTS: Twenty-two (81.5%) and 5 (18.5%) patients received the medial incision only technique and lateral incision technique, respectively (P = .002). Age, presence of cleft lip, and cleft width were not associated (all P > .05) with the use of lateral incision. Comparative analysis between the novice surgeon- and senior surgeon-based datasets revealed no significant differences for sex (females: 74.1% vs 62.5%; P = .546), age (10.2 ± 1.7 vs 9.6 ± 1.2 months; P = .143), rate of lateral incision (18.5% vs 4.2%; P = .195), and postoperative complication rate (0% vs 0%). CONCLUSION: This modified DOZ palatoplasty proved to be a reproducible procedure for Veau I cleft palate closure, with reduced need for lateral incision and with no early complication.