Sphingolipids and their metabolism in physiology and disease.

Studies of bioactive lipids in general and sphingolipids in particular have intensified over the past several years, revealing an unprecedented and unanticipated complexity of the lipidome and its many functions, which rivals, if not exceeds, that of the genome or proteome. These results highlight critical roles for bioactive sphingolipids in most, if not all, major cell biological responses, including all major cell signalling pathways, and they link sphingolipid metabolism to key human diseases. Nevertheless, the fairly nascent field of bioactive sphingolipids still faces challenges in its biochemical and molecular underpinnings, including defining the molecular mechanisms of pathway and enzyme regulation, the study of lipid-protein interactions and the development of cellular probes, suitable biomarkers and therapeutic approaches.

Author Correction: Sphingolipids and their metabolism in physiology and disease.

In the original Figure 2, sphingolipids on the endosomal and lysosomal membranes are facing the outside of these organelles. The correct orientation of these species should be towards the lumen, as shown in the corrected figure.

Ceramide as an endothelial cell surface receptor and a lung-specific lipid vascular target for circulating ligands.

The vascular endothelium from individual organs is functionally specialized, and it displays a unique set of accessible molecular targets. These serve as endothelial cell receptors to affinity ligands. To date, all identified vascular receptors have been proteins. Here, we show that an endothelial lung-homing peptide (CGSPGWVRC) interacts with C16-ceramide, a bioactive sphingolipid that mediates several biological functions. Upon binding to cell surfaces, CGSPGWVRC triggers ceramide-rich platform formation, activates acid sphingomyelinase and ceramide production, without the associated downstream apoptotic signaling. We also show that the lung selectivity of CGSPGWVRC homing peptide is dependent on ceramide production in vivo. Finally, we demonstrate two potential applications for this lipid vascular targeting system: i) as a bioinorganic hydrogel for pulmonary imaging and ii) as a ligand-directed lung immunization tool against COVID-19. Thus, C16-ceramide is a unique example of a lipid-based receptor system in the lung vascular endothelium targeted in vivo by circulating ligands such as CGSPGWVRC.

GRASP55 regulates intra-Golgi localization of glycosylation enzymes to control glycosphingolipid biosynthesis.

The Golgi apparatus, the main glycosylation station of the cell, consists of a stack of discontinuous cisternae. Glycosylation enzymes are usually concentrated in one or two specific cisternae along the cis-trans axis of the organelle. How such compartmentalized localization of enzymes is achieved and how it contributes to glycosylation are not clear. Here, we show that the Golgi matrix protein GRASP55 directs the compartmentalized localization of key enzymes involved in glycosphingolipid (GSL) biosynthesis. GRASP55 binds to these enzymes and prevents their entry into COPI-based retrograde transport vesicles, thus concentrating them in the trans-Golgi. In genome-edited cells lacking GRASP55, or in cells expressing mutant enzymes without GRASP55 binding sites, these enzymes relocate to the cis-Golgi, which affects glycosphingolipid biosynthesis by changing flux across metabolic branch points. These findings reveal a mechanism by which a matrix protein regulates polarized localization of glycosylation enzymes in the Golgi and controls competition in glycan biosynthesis.

Golgi maturation-dependent glycoenzyme recycling controls glycosphingolipid biosynthesis and cell growth via GOLPH3.

Glycosphingolipids are important components of the plasma membrane where they modulate the activities of membrane proteins including signalling receptors. Glycosphingolipid synthesis relies on competing reactions catalysed by Golgi-resident enzymes during the passage of substrates through the Golgi cisternae. The glycosphingolipid metabolic output is determined by the position and levels of the enzymes within the Golgi stack, but the mechanisms that coordinate the intra-Golgi localisation of the enzymes are poorly understood. Here, we show that a group of sequentially-acting enzymes operating at the branchpoint among glycosphingolipid synthetic pathways binds the Golgi-localised oncoprotein GOLPH3. GOLPH3 sorts these enzymes into vesicles for intra-Golgi retro-transport, acting as a component of the cisternal maturation mechanism. Through these effects, GOLPH3 controls the sub-Golgi localisation and the lysosomal degradation rate of specific enzymes. Increased GOLPH3 levels, as those observed in tumours, alter glycosphingolipid synthesis and plasma membrane composition thereby promoting mitogenic signalling and cell proliferation. These data have medical implications as they outline a novel oncogenic mechanism of action for GOLPH3 based on glycosphingolipid metabolism.

A comprehensive measure of Golgi sphingolipid flux using NBD C6-Ceramide: evaluation of sphingolipid inhibitors.

Measurements of sphingolipid metabolism are most accurately performed by liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry. However, this technique is expensive, not widely accessible, and without the use of specific probes, it does not provide insight into metabolic flux through the pathway. Employing the fluorescent ceramide analogue NBD-C6-ceramide as a tracer in intact cells, we developed a comprehensive HPLC-based method that simultaneously measures the main nodes of ceramide metabolism in the Golgi. Hence, by quantifying the conversion of NBD-C6-Ceramide to NBD-C6-sphingomyelin, NBD-C6-Hexosylceramides, and NBD-C6-ceramide-1-phosphate (NBD-C1P), the activities of Golgi resident enzymes sphingomyelin synthase 1, glucosylceramide synthase, and ceramide kinase (CERK) could be measured simultaneously. Importantly, the detection of NBD-C1P allowed us to quantify CERK activity in cells, a usually difficult task. By applying this method, we evaluated the specificity of commonly used sphingolipid inhibitors and discovered that PDMP, which targets glucosylceramide synthase, and fenretinide (4HPR), an inhibitor for dihydroceramide desaturase, also suppress CERK activity. This study demonstrates the benefit of an expanded analysis of ceramide metabolism in the Golgi, and it provides a qualitative and easy-to-implement method.

Expression of Ceramide Synthases in Mice and Their Roles in Regulating Acyl-Chain Sphingolipids: A Framework for Baseline Levels and Future Implications in Aging and Disease.

Sphingolipids are an important class of lipids present in all eukaryotic cells that regulate critical cellular processes. Disturbances in sphingolipid homeostasis have been linked to several diseases in humans. Ceramides are central in sphingolipid metabolism and are largely synthesized by six ceramide synthase (CerS) isoforms (CerS1-6), each with a preference for different fatty acyl chain lengths. Although the tissue distribution of CerS mRNA expression in humans and the roles of CerS isoforms in synthesizing ceramides with different acyl chain lengths are known, it is unknown how CerS expression dictates ceramides and downstream metabolites within tissues. In this study, we analyzed sphingolipid levels and CerS mRNA expression in 3-month-old C57BL/6J mouse brain, heart, kidney, liver, lung, and skeletal muscle. The results showed that CerS expression and sphingolipid species abundance varied by tissue and that CerS expression was a predictor of ceramide species within tissues. Interestingly, although CerS expression was not predictive of complex sphingolipid species within all tissues, composite scores for CerSs contributions to total sphingolipids measured in each tissue correlated to CerS expression. Lastly, we determined that the most abundant ceramide species in mouse tissues aligned with CerS mRNA expression in corresponding human tissues (based on chain length preference), suggesting that mice are relevant preclinical models for ceramide and sphingolipid research. SIGNIFICANCE STATEMENT: The current study demonstrates that ceramide synthase (CerS) expression in specific tissues correlates not only with ceramide species but contributes to the generation of complex sphingolipids as well. As many of the CerSs and/or specific ceramide species have been implicated in disease, these studies suggest the potential for CerSs as therapeutic targets and the use of sphingolipid species as diagnostics in specific tissues.

Upregulation of sphingosine kinase 1 in response to doxorubicin generates an angiogenic response via stabilization of Snail.

Sphingosine kinase 1 (SK1) converts the pro-death lipid sphingosine to the pro-survival sphingosine-1-phosphate (S1P) and is upregulated in several cancers. DNA damaging agents, such as the chemotherapeutic doxorubicin (Dox), have been shown to degrade SK1 protein in cancer cells, a process dependent on wild-type p53. As mutations in p53 are very common across several types of cancer, we evaluated the effects of Dox on SK1 in p53 mutant cancer cells. In the p53 mutant breast cancer cell line MDA-MB-231, we show that Dox treatment significantly increases SK1 protein and S1P. Using MDA-MB-231 cells with CRISPR-mediated knockout of SK1 or the selective SK1 inhibitor PF-543, we implicated SK1 in both Dox-induced migration and in a newly uncovered proangiogenic program induced by Dox. Mechanistically, inhibition of SK1 suppressed the induction of the cytokine BMP4 and of the EMT transcription factor Snail in response to Dox. Interestingly, induction of BMP4 by SK1 increased Snail levels following Dox treatment by stabilizing Snail protein. Furthermore, we found that SK1 was required for Dox-induced p38 MAP kinase phosphorylation and that active p38 MAPK in turn upregulated BMP4 and Snail, positioning p38 downstream of SK1 and upstream of BMP4/Snail. Modulating production of S1P by inhibition of de novo sphingolipid synthesis or knockdown of the S1P-degrading enzyme S1P lyase identified S1P as the sphingolipid activator of p38 in this model. This work establishes a novel angiogenic pathway in response to a commonly utilized chemotherapeutic and highlights the potential of SK1 as a secondary drug target for patients with p53 mutant cancer.

Targeting sphingosine kinase 1 in p53KO thymic lymphoma.

Sphingosine kinase 1 (SK1) is a key sphingolipid enzyme that is upregulated in several types of cancer, including lymphoma which is a heterogenous group of malignancies. Treatment for lymphoma has improved significantly by the introduction of new therapies; however, subtypes with tumor protein P53 (p53) mutations or deletion have poor prognosis, making it critical to explore new therapeutic strategies in this context. SK1 has been proposed as a therapeutic target in different types of cancer; however, the effect of targeting SK1 in cancers with p53 deletion has not been evaluated yet. Previous work from our group suggests that loss of SK1 is a key event in mediating the tumor suppressive effect of p53. Employing both genetic and pharmacological approaches to inhibit SK1 function in Trp53KO mice, we show that targeting SK1 decreases tumor growth of established p53KO thymic lymphoma. Inducible deletion of Sphk1 or its pharmacological inhibition drive increased cell death in tumors which is accompanied by selective accumulation of sphingosine levels. These results demonstrate the relevance of SK1 in the growth and maintenance of lymphoma in the absence of p53 function, positioning this enzyme as a potential therapeutic target for the treatment of tumors that lack functional p53.

A simple, highly sensitive, and facile method to quantify ceramide at the plasma membrane.

The role of ceramide in biological functions is typically based on the elevation of cellular ceramide, measured by LC-MS in the total cell lysate. However, it has become increasingly appreciated that ceramide in different subcellular organelles regulates specific functions. In the plasma membrane, changes in ceramide levels might represent a small percentage of the total cellular ceramide, evading MS detection but playing a critical role in cell signaling. Importantly, there are currently no efficient techniques to quantify ceramide in the plasma membrane. Here, we developed a method to measure the mass of ceramide in the plasma membrane using a short protocol that is based on the hydrolysis of plasma membrane ceramide into sphingosine by the action of exogenously applied bacterial recombinant neutral ceramidase. Plasma membrane ceramide content can then be determined by measuring the newly generated sphingosine at a stoichiometry of 1:1. A key step of this protocol is the chemical fixation of cells to block cellular sphingolipid metabolism, especially of sphingosine to sphingosine 1-phosphate. We confirmed that chemical fixation does not disrupt the lipid composition at the plasma membrane, which remains intact during the time of the assay. We illustrate the power of the approach by applying this protocol to interrogate the effects of the chemotherapeutic compound doxorubicin. Here we distinguished two pools of ceramide, depending on the doxorubicin concentration, consolidating different reports. In summary, we have developed the first approach to quantify ceramide in the plasma membrane, allowing the study of new avenues in sphingolipid compartmentalization and function.

A novel HSPB1S139F mouse model of Charcot-Marie-Tooth Disease.

Charcot-Marie-Tooth Disease (CMT) is a commonly inherited peripheral polyneuropathy. Clinical manifestations for this disease include symmetrical distal polyneuropathy, altered deep tendon reflexes, distal sensory loss, foot deformities, and gait abnormalities. Genetic mutations in heat shock proteins have been linked to CMT2. Specifically, mutations in the heat shock protein B1 (HSPB1) gene encoding for heat shock protein 27 (Hsp27) have been linked to CMT2F and distal hereditary motor and sensory neuropathy type 2B (dHMSN2B) subtype. The goal of the study was to examine the role of an endogenous mutation in HSPB1 in vivo and to define the effects of this mutation on motor function and pathology in a novel animal model. As sphingolipids have been implicated in hereditary and sensory neuropathies, we examined sphingolipid metabolism in central and peripheral nervous tissues in 3-month-old HspS139F mice. Though sphingolipid levels were not altered in sciatic nerves from HspS139F mice, ceramides and deoxyceramides, as well as sphingomyelins (SMs) were elevated in brain tissues from HspS139F mice. Histology was utilized to further characterize HspS139F mice. HspS139F mice exhibited no alterations to the expression and phosphorylation of neurofilaments, or in the expression of acetylated α-tubulin in the brain or sciatic nerve. Interestingly, HspS139F mice demonstrated cerebellar demyelination. Locomotor function, grip strength and gait were examined to define the role of HspS139F in the clinical phenotypes associated with CMT2F. Gait analysis revealed no differences between HspWT and HspS139F mice. However, both coordination and grip strength were decreased in 3-month-old HspS139F mice. Together these data suggest that the endogenous S139F mutation in HSPB1 may serve as a mouse model for hereditary and sensory neuropathies such as CMT2F.

Asah2 Represses the p53-Hmox1 Axis to Protect Myeloid-Derived Suppressor Cells from Ferroptosis.

Myeloid-derived suppressor cells (MDSCs) are immune suppressive cells that massively accumulate under pathological conditions to suppress T cell immune response. Dysregulated cell death contributes to MDSC accumulation, but the molecular mechanism underlying this cell death dysregulation is not fully understood. In this study, we report that neutral ceramidase (N-acylsphingosine amidohydrolase [ASAH2]) is highly expressed in tumor-infiltrating MDSCs in colon carcinoma and acts as an MDSC survival factor. To target ASAH2, we performed molecular docking based on human ASAH2 protein structure. Enzymatic inhibition analysis of identified hits determined NC06 as an ASAH2 inhibitor. Chemical and nuclear magnetic resonance analysis determined NC06 as 7-chloro-2-(3-chloroanilino)pyrano[3,4-e][1,3]oxazine-4,5-dione. NC06 inhibits ceramidase activity with an IC50 of 10.16-25.91 µM for human ASAH2 and 18.6-30.2 µM for mouse Asah2 proteins. NC06 induces MDSC death in a dose-dependent manner, and inhibition of ferroptosis decreased NC06-induced MDSC death. NC06 increases glutathione synthesis and decreases lipid reactive oxygen species to suppress ferroptosis in MDSCs. Gene expression profiling identified the p53 pathway as the Asah2 target in MDSCs. Inhibition of Asah2 increased p53 protein stability to upregulate Hmox1 expression to suppress lipid reactive oxygen species production to suppress ferroptosis in MDSCs. NC06 therapy increases MDSC death and reduces MDSC accumulation in tumor-bearing mice, resulting in increased activation of tumor-infiltrating CTLs and suppression of tumor growth in vivo. Our data indicate that ASAH2 protects MDSCs from ferroptosis through destabilizing p53 protein to suppress the p53 pathway in MDSCs in the tumor microenvironment. Targeting ASAH2 with NC06 to induce MDSC ferroptosis is potentially an effective therapy to suppress MDSC accumulation in cancer immunotherapy.

Neutral ceramidase-active site inhibitor chemotypes and binding modes.

Ceramides impact a diverse array of biological functions and have been implicated in disease pathogenesis. The enzyme neutral ceramidase (nCDase) is a zinc-containing hydrolase and mediates the metabolism of ceramide to sphingosine (Sph), both in cells and in the intestinal lumen. nCDase inhibitors based on substrate mimetics, for example C6-urea ceramide, have limited potency, aqueous solubility, and micelle-free fraction. To identify non-ceramide mimetic nCDase inhibitors, hit compounds from an HTS campaign were evaluated in biochemical, cell based and in silico modeling approaches. A majority of small molecule nCDase inhibitors contained pharmacophores capable of zinc interaction but retained specificity for nCDase over zinc-containing acid and alkaline ceramidases, as well as matrix metalloprotease-3 and histone deacetylase-1. nCDase inhibitors were refined by SAR, were shown to be substrate competitive and were active in cellular assays. nCDase inhibitor compounds were modeled by in silico DOCK screening and by molecular simulation. Modeling data supports zinc interaction and a similar compound binding pose with ceramide. nCDase inhibitors were identified with notably improved activity and solubility in comparison with the reference lipid-mimetic C6-urea ceramide.

1-Deoxysphinganine initiates adaptive responses to serine and glycine starvation in cancer cells via proteolysis of sphingosine kinase.

Cancer cells may depend on exogenous serine, depletion of which results in slower growth and activation of adaptive metabolic changes. We previously demonstrated that serine and glycine (SG) deprivation causes loss of sphingosine kinase 1 (SK1) in cancer cells, thereby increasing the levels of its lipid substrate, sphingosine (Sph), which mediates several adaptive biological responses. However, the signaling molecules regulating SK1 and Sph levels in response to SG deprivation have yet to be defined. Here, we identify 1-deoxysphinganine (dSA), a noncanonical sphingoid base generated in the absence of serine from the alternative condensation of alanine and palmitoyl CoA by serine palmitoyl transferase, as a proximal mediator of SG deprivation in SK1 loss and Sph level elevation upon SG deprivation in cancer cells. SG starvation increased dSA levels in vitro and in vivo and in turn induced SK1 degradation through a serine palmitoyl transferase-dependent mechanism, thereby increasing Sph levels. Addition of exogenous dSA caused a moderate increase in intracellular reactive oxygen species, which in turn decreased pyruvate kinase PKM2 activity while increasing phosphoglycerate dehydrogenase levels, and thereby promoted serine synthesis. We further showed that increased dSA induces the adaptive cellular and metabolic functions in the response of cells to decreased availability of serine likely by increasing Sph levels. Thus, we conclude that dSA functions as an initial sensor of serine loss, SK1 functions as its direct target, and Sph functions as a downstream effector of cellular and metabolic adaptations. These studies define a previously unrecognized "physiological" nontoxic function for dSA.

Neutral ceramidase deficiency protects against cisplatin-induced acute kidney injury.

Cisplatin is a commonly used chemotherapeutic for the treatment of many solid organ cancers; however, its effectiveness is limited by the development of acute kidney injury (AKI) in 30% of patients. AKI is driven by proximal tubule cell death, leading to rapid decline in renal function. It has previously been shown that sphingolipid metabolism plays a role in regulating many of the biological processes involved in cisplatin-induced AKI. For example, neutral ceramidase (nCDase) is an enzyme responsible for converting ceramide into sphingosine, which is then phosphorylated to become sphingosine-1-phosphate, and our lab previously demonstrated that nCDase knockout (nCDase-/-) in mouse embryonic fibroblasts led to resistance to nutrient and energy deprivation-induced cell death via upregulation of autophagic flux. In this study, we further characterized the role of nCDase in AKI by demonstrating that nCDase-/- mice are resistant to cisplatin-induced AKI. nCDase-/- mice display improved kidney function, reduced injury and structural damage, lower rates of apoptosis, and less ER stress compared to wild-type mice following cisplatin treatment. Although the mechanism of protection is still unknown, we propose that it could be mediated by increased autophagy, as chloroquine treatment resensitized nCDase-/- mice to AKI development. Taken together, we conclude that nCDase may represent a novel target to prevent cisplatin-induced nephrotoxicity.

Sphingosine kinase 1 downregulation is required for adaptation to serine deprivation.

It has been well-established that cancer cells often display altered metabolic profiles, and recent work has concentrated on how cancer cells adapt to serine removal. Serine can be either taken exogenously or synthesized from glucose, and its regulation forms an important mechanism for nutrient integration. One of the several important metabolic roles for serine is in the generation of bioactive sphingolipids since it is the main substrate for serine palmitoyltransferase, the initial and rate-limiting enzyme in the synthesis of sphingolipids. Previously, serine deprivation has been connected to the action of the tumor suppressor p53, and we have previously published on a role for p53 regulating sphingosine kinase 1 (SK1), an enzyme that phosphorylates sphingosine to form sphingosine-1-phosphate (S1P). SK1 is a key enzyme in sphingolipid synthesis that functions in pro-survival and tumor-promoting pathways and whose expression is also often elevated in cancers. Here we show that SK1 was degraded during serine starvation in a time and dose-dependent manner, which led to sphingosine accumulation. This was independent of effects on p53 but required the action of the proteasome. Furthermore, we show that overexpression of SK1, to compensate for SK1 loss, was detrimental to cell growth under conditions of serine starvation, demonstrating that the suppression of SK1 under these conditions is adaptive. Mitochondrial oxygen consumption decreased in response to SK1 degradation, and this was accompanied by an increase in intracellular reactive oxygen species (ROS). Suppression of ROS with N-acteylcysteine resulted in suppression of the metabolic adaptations and in decreased cell growth under serine deprivation. The effects of SK1 suppression on ROS were mimicked by D-erythro-sphingosine, whereas S1P was ineffective, suggesting that the effects of loss of SK1 were due to the accumulation of its substrate sphingosine. This study reveals a new mechanism for regulating SK1 levels and a link of SK1 to serine starvation as well as mitochondrial function.

Ceramide synthase 2-C24:1 -ceramide axis limits the metastatic potential of ovarian cancer cells.

Regulation of sphingolipid metabolism plays a role in cellular homeostasis, and dysregulation of these pathways is involved in cancer progression. Previously, our reports identified ceramide as an anti-metastatic lipid. In the present study, we investigated the biochemical alterations in ceramide-centered metabolism of sphingolipids that were associated with metastatic potential. We established metastasis-prone sublines of SKOV3 ovarian cancer cells using an in vivo selection method. These cells showed decreases in ceramide levels and ceramide synthase (CerS) 2 expression. Moreover, CerS2 downregulation in ovarian cancer cells promoted metastasis in vivo and potentiated cell motility and invasiveness. Moreover, CerS2 knock-in suppressed the formation of lamellipodia required for cell motility in this cell line. In order to define specific roles of ceramide species in cell motility controlled by CerS2, the effect of exogenous long- and very long-chain ceramide species on the formation of lamellipodia was evaluated. Treatment with distinct ceramides increased cellular ceramides and had inhibitory effects on the formation of lamellipodia. Interestingly, blocking the recycling pathway of ceramides by a CerS inhibitor was ineffective in the suppression of exogenous C24:1 -ceramide for the formation of lamellipodia. These results suggested that C24:1 -ceramide, a CerS2 metabolite, predominantly suppresses the formation of lamellipodia without the requirement for deacylation/reacylation. Moreover, knockdown of neutral ceramidase suppressed the formation of lamellipodia concomitant with upregulation of C24:1 -ceramide. Collectively, the CerS2-C24:1 -ceramide axis, which may be countered by neutral ceramidase, is suggested to limit cell motility and metastatic potential. These findings may provide insights that lead to further development of ceramide-based therapy and biomarkers for metastatic ovarian cancer.

The doxorubicin-induced cell motility network is under the control of the ceramide-activated protein phosphatase 1 alpha.

We have recently reported that a specific pool of ceramide, located in the plasma membrane, mediated the effects of sublethal doses of the chemotherapeutic compound doxorubicin on enhancing cancer cell migration. We identified neutral sphingomyelinase 2 (nSMase2) as the enzyme responsible to generate this bioactive pool of ceramide. In this work, we explored the role of members of the protein phosphatases 1 family (PP1), and we identified protein phosphatase 1 alpha isoform (PP1 alpha) as the specific PP1 isoform to mediate this phenotype. Using a bioinformatics approach, we build a functional interaction network based on phosphoproteomics data on plasma membrane ceramide. This led to the identification of several ceramide-PP1 alpha downstream substrates. Studies on phospho mutants of ezrin (T567) and Scrib (S1378/S1508) demonstrated that their dephosphorylation is sufficient to enhance cell migration. In summary, we identified a mechanism where reduced doses of doxorubicin result in the dysregulation of cytoskeletal proteins and enhanced cell migration. This mechanism could explain the reported effects of doxorubicin worsening cancer metastasis in animal models.

Substantial contribution of extrinsic risk factors to cancer development.

Recent research has highlighted a strong correlation between tissue-specific cancer risk and the lifetime number of tissue-specific stem-cell divisions. Whether such correlation implies a high unavoidable intrinsic cancer risk has become a key public health debate with the dissemination of the 'bad luck' hypothesis. Here we provide evidence that intrinsic risk factors contribute only modestly (less than ~10-30% of lifetime risk) to cancer development. First, we demonstrate that the correlation between stem-cell division and cancer risk does not distinguish between the effects of intrinsic and extrinsic factors. We then show that intrinsic risk is better estimated by the lower bound risk controlling for total stem-cell divisions. Finally, we show that the rates of endogenous mutation accumulation by intrinsic processes are not sufficient to account for the observed cancer risks. Collectively, we conclude that cancer risk is heavily influenced by extrinsic factors. These results are important for strategizing cancer prevention, research and public health.