ABSTRACT
Despite advances in gender equality, only 6% of German neurosurgical departments are currently led by women. With regard to their pioneering work and the importance of their role model effect, we aimed at reporting on the career pathways of the present and former female chairs of neurosurgical departments in Germany. We approached current and former female chairs in German neurosurgery and gathered descriptive information on their ways into leadership positions through structured interviews. Data were obtained from 16/22 (72.7%) female neurosurgical chairs, aged between 44 and 82 years. They completed their training within 6.5 ± 0.6 years, and it took them further 14.5 ± 5.9 years between training completion and chair acquisition. Having obtained their chair positions between 1993 and 2020, six (37.5%) of them have retired or changed career tracks. Of ten (62.5%) chairs still practicing, two are directors of university departments. Twelve (75.0%) hold professorships. Nine chairs (56.3%) are married, eight (50.0%) having children. Five chairs reported having experienced gender-based discrimination. Twelve had a male mentor or role model, two had a female role model, while only one had a female mentor. This study characterizes the to date small number of female neurosurgical chairs in Germany and their paths to neurosurgical leadership positions. In future, these should become historical in order to perceive the presence of women in leadership positions as self-evident normality, reflecting our society. However, further analyses comparing paths of both female and male neurosurgical chairs are necessary to explore gender-based differences in achieving neurosurgical leadership positions.
Subject(s)
Neurosurgery , Child , Humans , Male , Female , United States , Adult , Middle Aged , Aged , Aged, 80 and over , Faculty, Medical , Sex Factors , Germany , LeadershipABSTRACT
Introduction: In the first part of this White Paper, the European Association of Neurosurgical Societies (EANS) Diversity in Neurosurgery Committee (DC) addressed the obstacles faced by neurosurgeons when planning to have a family and practice during pregnancy, attempting to enumerate potential, easily implementable solutions for departments to be more family-friendly and retain as well as foster talent of parent-neurosurgeons, regardless of their gender identity and/or sexual orientation. Attrition avoidance amongst parent-neurosurgeons is at the heart of these papers. Research question: In this second part, we address the obstacles posed by practice with children and measures to mitigate attrition rates among parent-neurosurgeons. For the methodology employed to compose this White Paper, please refer to Supplementary Electronic Materials (SEM) 1. Materials and methods: For composing these white papers, the European Association of Neurosurgical Societies (EANS)'s Diversity Committee (DC) recruited neurosurgeon volunteers from all member countries, including parents, aspiring parents, and individuals without any desire to have a family to create a diverse and representative working group (WG). Results: In spite of the prevailing heterogeneity in policies across the continent, common difficulties can be identified for both mothers and fathers considering the utilization of parental leave. Discussion and conclusion: Reconciliation of family and a neurosurgical career is challenging, especially for single parents. However, institutional support in form of childcare facilities and/or providers, guaranteed lactation breaks and rooms, flexible schedule models including telemedicine, and clear communication of policies can improve working conditions for parent-neurosurgeons, avoid their attrition, and foster family-friendly work environments.
ABSTRACT
Introduction: Family and work have immensely changed and become intertwined over the past half century for both men and women. Additionally, alongside to traditional family structures prevalent, other forms of families such as single parents, LGBTQ + parents, and bonus families are becoming more common. Previous studies have shown that surgical trainees regularly leave residency when considering becoming a parent due to the negative stigma associated with pregnancy during training, dissatisfaction with parental leave options, inadequate lactation and childcare support, and desire for greater mentorship on work-life integration. Indeed, parenthood is one of the factors contributing to attrition in surgical specialities, neurosurgery not being an exception. Research question: The Diversity in Neurosurgery Committee (DC) of the European Association of Neurosurgical Societies (EANS) recognizes the challenges individuals face in parenthood with neurosurgery and wishes to address them in this white paper. Materials and methods: In the following sections, the authors will focus on the issues pertaining to family planning and neurosurgical practice during pregnancy in itemized fashion based on an exhaustive literature search and will make recommendations to address the matters raised. Results: Potential solutions would be to further improve the work-family time ration as well as improving working conditions in the hospital. Discussion and conclusion: While many obstacles have been quoted in the literature pertaining to parenthood in medicine, and in neurosurgery specifically, initiatives can and should be undertaken to ensure not only retention of colleagues, but also to increase productivity and job satisfaction of those seeking to combine neurosurgery and a family life, regardless of their sexual identity and orientation.
ABSTRACT
Astroblastoma is a rare, mostly supratentorial glial tumor, occurring predominantly in children and young adults with female preponderance. Due to the rarity, with only about 230 reported cases, treatment strategies are still to be discussed. We describe two more cases to add to the clinical experiences with this tumor entity. In both of these cases, the clinical behavior did not follow the expectations based on histopathological classification. Case 1: A sixteen-year old female presented with a six month history of intermittent headaches, nausea and dizziness. MRI scans revealed a left parietooccipital mass lesion with bubbly contrast enhancement and marked peritumoral edema. After gross total tumor resection the histology gave the diagnosis of low grade astroblastoma. Fifteen months later, the patient was operated on a local recurrence and received postoperative radiotherapy, with the histology still being that of low grade astroblastoma. Two years later, a meningeally based tumor nodule frontal of the former tumor bed was removed, now diagnosed as high grade astroblastoma. Eighteen months later, a fourth operation with excision of two more meningeally based tumor nodules of high-grade astroblastoma followed. Chemotherapy was suggested, but the patient decided against it. The last MRI follow-up 14 months after last operation showed no further recurrence so far. Case 2: A 24-year old female presented with a four week history of vomiting and headaches with focal seizures affecting her left arm. CT and MRI scans revealed a superficial partly cystic right temporal mass lesion with few edema and macrocalcifications and adjacent bone atrophy. Despite dural invasion, total tumor resection could be performed. MRI scans six months later showed no recurrence. The patient refused further MRI controls but did not show any clinical signs or symptoms suggesting tumor recurrence four years after the operation. In order to find more predictive tools that might help to determine the individual clinical course and treatment, we performed a review of the literature, analyzing 29 cases with detailed data on clinical history, MRI/CT characteristics, histopathological subtyping, treatment details and a follow-up of at least 12 months. We found, that low-grade astroblastoma with marked peritumoral edema has a tendency to early recurrence and suggest that it should be treated by combined surgery and radiotherapy. In high-grade astroblastoma with well defined tumor borders and few peritumoral edema, the prognosis may be better than expected for a high-grade glioma, if GTR is possible.