ABSTRACT
Amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS) is an incurable neurodegenerative disease in urgent need of disease biomarkers for the assessment of promising therapeutic candidates in clinical trials. Raman spectroscopy is an attractive technique for identifying disease related molecular changes due to its simplicity. Here, we describe a fibre optic fluid cell for undertaking spontaneous Raman spectroscopy studies of human biofluids that is suitable for use away from a standard laboratory setting. Using this system, we examined serum obtained from patients with ALS at their first presentation to our centre (n = 66) and 4 months later (n = 27). We analysed Raman spectra using bounded simplex-structured matrix factorization (BSSMF), a generalisation of non-negative matrix factorisation which uses the distribution of the original data to limit the factorisation modes (spectral patterns). Biomarkers associated with ALS disease such as measures of symptom severity, respiratory function and inflammatory/immune pathways (C3/C-reactive protein) correlated with baseline Raman modes. Between visit spectral changes were highly significant (p = 0.0002) and were related to protein structure. Comparison of Raman data with established ALS biomarkers as a trial outcome measure demonstrated a reduction in required sample size with BSSMF Raman. Our portable, simple to use fibre optic system allied to BSSMF shows promise in the quantification of disease-related changes in ALS over short timescales.
Subject(s)
Amyotrophic Lateral Sclerosis , Neurodegenerative Diseases , Humans , Amyotrophic Lateral Sclerosis/diagnosis , Amyotrophic Lateral Sclerosis/metabolism , Spectrum Analysis, Raman , Biomarkers , C-Reactive ProteinABSTRACT
Raman spectroscopy shows promise as a biomarker for complex nerve and muscle (neuromuscular) diseases. To maximise its potential, several challenges remain. These include the sensitivity to different instrument configurations, translation across preclinical/human tissues and the development of multivariate analytics that can derive interpretable spectral outputs for disease identification. Nonnegative matrix factorisation (NMF) can extract features from high-dimensional data sets and the nonnegative constraint results in physically realistic outputs. In this study, we have undertaken NMF on Raman spectra of muscle obtained from different clinical and preclinical settings. First, we obtained and combined Raman spectra from human patients with mitochondrial disease and healthy volunteers, using both a commercial microscope and in-house fibre optic probe. NMF was applied across all data, and spectral patterns common to both equipment configurations were identified. Linear discriminant models utilising these patterns were able to accurately classify disease states (accuracy 70.2-84.5%). Next, we applied NMF to spectra obtained from the mdx mouse model of a Duchenne muscular dystrophy and patients with dystrophic muscle conditions. Spectral fingerprints common to mouse/human were obtained and able to accurately identify disease (accuracy 79.5-98.8%). We conclude that NMF can be used to analyse Raman data across different equipment configurations and the preclinical/clinical divide. Thus, the application of NMF decomposition methods could enhance the potential of Raman spectroscopy for the study of fatal neuromuscular diseases.
ABSTRACT
OBJECTIVE: Electrical impedance myography (EIM) is a promising biomarker for amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS). A key issue is how best to utilise the complex high dimensional, multi-frequency data output by EIM to fully characterise the progression of disease. METHODS: Muscle volume conduction properties were obtained from EIM recordings of the tongue across three electrode configurations and 14 input frequencies (76 Hz-625 kHz). Analyses of individual frequencies, averaged EIM spectra and non-negative tensor factorisation were undertaken. Longitudinal data were collected from 28 patients and 17 healthy volunteers at 3-monthly intervals for a maximum of 9 months. EIM was evaluated against the Amyotrophic Lateral Sclerosis Functional Rating Scale-Revised (ALSFRS-R) bulbar sub-score, tongue strength and an overall bulbar disease burden score. RESULTS: Longitudinal changes to individual patient EIM spectra demonstrated complex shifts in the spectral shape. At a group level, a clear pattern emerged over time, characterised by an increase in centre frequency and general shift to the right of the spectral shape. Tensor factorisation reduced the spectral data from a total of 168 data points per participant per recording to a single value which captured the complexity of the longitudinal data and which we call tensor EIM (T-EIM). The absolute change in tensor EIM significantly increased within 3 months and continued to do so over the 9-month study duration. In a hypothetical clinical trial scenario tensor EIM required fewer participants (n = 64 at 50% treatment effect), than single frequency measures (n range 87-802) or ALSFRS-R bulbar subscore (n = 298). CONCLUSIONS: Changes to tongue EIM spectra over time in ALS are complex. Tensor EIM captured and quantified disease progression and was more sensitive to changes than single frequency EIM measures and other biomarkers of bulbar disease. SIGNIFICANCE: Objective biomarkers for the assessment of bulbar disease in ALS are lacking. Tensor EIM enhances the biomarker potential of EIM data and can improve bulbar symptom monitoring in clinical trials.
Subject(s)
Amyotrophic Lateral Sclerosis , Amyotrophic Lateral Sclerosis/diagnosis , Biomarkers , Disease Progression , Electric Impedance , Humans , Muscle, Skeletal , Myography/methodsABSTRACT
Objective.Electrical impedance myography (EIM) shows promise as an effective biomarker in amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS). EIM applies multiple input frequencies to characterise muscle properties, often via multiple electrode configurations. Herein, we assess if non-negative tensor factorisation (NTF) can provide a framework for identifying clinically relevant features within a high dimensional EIM dataset.Approach.EIM data were recorded from the tongue of healthy and ALS diseased individuals. Resistivity and reactivity measurements were made for 14 frequencies, in three electrode configurations. This gives 84 (2 × 14 × 3) distinct data points per participant. NTF was applied to the dataset for dimensionality reduction, termed tensor EIM. Significance tests, symptom correlation and classification approaches were explored to compare NTF to using all raw data and feature selection.Main Results.Tensor EIM provides highly significant differentiation between healthy and ALS patients (p< 0.001, AUROC = 0.78). Similarly tensor EIM differentiates between mild and severe disease states (p< 0.001, AUROC = 0.75) and significantly correlates with symptoms (ρ= 0.7,p< 0.001). A trend of centre frequency shifting to the right was identified in diseased spectra, which is in line with the electrical changes expected following muscle atrophy.Significance.Tensor EIM provides clinically relevant metrics for identifying ALS-related muscle disease. This procedure has the advantage of using the whole spectral dataset, with reduced risk of overfitting. The process identifies spectral shapes specific to disease allowing for a deeper clinical interpretation.
Subject(s)
Amyotrophic Lateral Sclerosis , Amyotrophic Lateral Sclerosis/diagnosis , Electric Impedance , Humans , Muscle, Skeletal , Myography , TongueABSTRACT
OBJECTIVE: Electrical impedance myography (EIM) performed on the centre of the tongue shows promise in detecting amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS). Lateral recordings may improve diagnostic performance and provide pathophysiological insights through the assessment of asymmetry. However, it is not known if electrode proximity to the muscle edge, or electrode rotation, distort spectra. We evaluated this using finite element-based modelling. APPROACH: Nine thousand EIM from patients and healthy volunteers were used to develop a finite element model for phase and magnitude. Simulations varied electrode proximity to the muscle edge and electrode rotation. LT-Spice simulations assessed disease effects. Patient data were assessed for reliability, agreement and classification performance. MAIN RESULTS: No effect on phase spectra was seen if all electrodes remained in contact with the tissue. Small effects on magnitude were observed. Cole-Cole circuit simulations indicated capacitance reduced with disease severity. Lateral tongue muscle recordings in both patients and healthy volunteers were reproducible and symmetrical. Combined lateral/central tongue EIM improved disease classification compared to either placement alone. SIGNIFICANCE: Lateral EIM tongue measurements using phase angle are feasible. Such measurements are reliable, find no evidence of tongue muscle asymmetry in ALS and improve disease classification. Lateral measurements enhance tongue EIM in ALS.