Approaching the RNA ligand for RIG-I?

Innate and antigen-specific antiviral immunity are triggered by immunorecognition of viral nucleic acids. The helicase retinoic acid-inducible gene I (RIG-I) (also known as DDX58) is the key sensor of negative strand RNA viruses in the cytosol of cells. RNA containing a triphosphate at the 5'-end was shown to activate RIG-I, but the exact structure of RNA supporting 5'-triphosphate recognition, the requirement of a 5'-triphosphate group, as well as the existence of RNA structures detected by RIG-I in the absence of 5'-triphosphate remain controversial. Here, we revisit the literature on RIG-I and RIG-I ligands. The literature proposes at least six different RIG-I ligands: (i) single strand with a 5'-triphosphate, (ii) double-stranded RNA with a 5'-triphosphate, (iii) 5'-triphosphate single-stranded RNA with A- and U-rich 3'-sequences, (iv) double-stranded RNA of intermediate length (>300 and <2000 bp) without 5'-triphosphate, (v) blunt-end short double-stranded RNA (23-30 bp) without 5'-triphosphate, and (vi) short double-stranded RNA (23-30 bp) with 5'-monophosphate. RIG-I thus seems promiscuous for a variety of different RNA molecules, very similar to the Toll-like receptors, of which 10 family members are sufficient for the safe detection of the microbial cosmos. In the light of these outstanding publications, it seems an unlikely possibility that there is a fundamental shortcoming in the design of all studies. Looking closely, the only issue that comes to mind is the in vitro transcription technique used by all investigators without confirming the identity of RNA products. This technique, together with the different biological systems used, the lack of dose responses and of proper comparison of different published ligands and controls leave us with more questions than answers as to what the exact RIG-I ligand is, if in fact it exists.

Was the ancestral MHC involved in innate immunity?

Understanding the nature of MHC class I presentation preferences is a challenging prospect. Large sets of peptide-MHC-class I complexes have been screened for their binding affinities and recent studies have shown that HLA-A share a preference for binding peptides derived from pathogens; however, no mechanism explaining the observed preferences has been demonstrated so far. In this issue of the European Journal of Immunology, a study demonstrates that HLA-A, but not HLA-B, preferentially recognises peptides enriched in amino acids encoded by sequences with low G+C content, and therefore recognises peptides associated with pathogens - low G+C content being a general feature of lower organisms. The authors of the study provide exciting results contributing to the understanding of the nature of MHC-I presentation preferences and MHC-I evolution. Although significant results are presented by the authors, here, we challenge the interpretation whereby HLA-A has been evolutionarily selected for such a function and appeal for the use of comparative phylogenetic methods to substantiate it. We propose a method to ascertain whether ancestral MHC recognised peptides from pathogens and hence was involved in the non-specific recognition of such organisms. Moreover, we suggest that ancestral MHC may have been involved in innate immune responses before being recruited for adaptive immunity.

MHC class I molecules exploit the low G+C content of pathogen genomes for enhanced presentation.

Distinguishing self from nonself and pathogenic from nonpathogenic is a fundamental challenge to the immune system but whether adaptive immune systems use pathogen-specific signatures to achieve this is largely unknown. By investigating the presentation of large sets of viruses and bacteria on MHC class I molecules, we analyze whether MHC-I molecules have a preference for pathogen-derived peptides. The fraction of potential MHC-I binders in different organisms can vary up to eight-fold. We find that this variation can be largely explained by G+C content differences of the organisms, which are reflected in amino acid frequencies. A significant majority of HLA-A, but not HLA-B, molecules has a preference for peptides derived from organisms with a low G+C content. Interestingly, a low G+C content seems to be a universal signature for pathogenicity. Finally, we find the same preferences in chimpanzee and rhesus macaque MHC-I molecules. These results demonstrate that despite the fast evolution of MHC-I alleles and their extreme polymorphism and diversity in peptide-binding preferences, MHC-I molecules can acquire a preference to exploit pathogen-specific signatures.

Does base composition help predispose the complementarity-determining regions of antibodies to hypermutation?

A survey of the base usage in genes coding for human antibodies reveals that more (A+T) and less (C+G) are found in the segments coding for the complementarity-determining regions, while the opposite is true for the segments coding for framework and constant regions. The possibility that this bias in base usage may contribute to hypermutation is explored.

Base-specific sequences that bias somatic hypermutation deduced by analysis of out-of-frame human IgVH genes.

Somatic hypermutation introduces mutations into IgV genes during affinity maturation of the B cell response. Mutations are introduced nonrandomly, and are generally targeted to the complementarity determining regions (CDRs). Subsequent selection against mutations that result in lower affinity or nonfunctional Ig increases the relative number of mutations in the CDRs. Investigation of somatic hypermutation is hampered by the effects of selection. We have avoided this by studying out-of-frame human IgVH4.21 and 251 genes, which, being unused alleles, are unselected. By comparison of the frequency of A, C, G, and T nucleotides at positions -3 to +3 around mutated or unmutated A, C, and G nucleotides, we have identified flanking sequences that most commonly surround mutated bases. Distinct trends in flanking sequences that were unique for each base were observed. Statistically significant trends that were common to both IgVH4.21 and 251 were used to deduce motifs that bias somatic hypermutation. The motifs deduced from this data, with targeted bases in regular type, are AANB, WDCH, and DGHD (where W = A/T, B = C/G/T, D = A/G/T, H = A/C/T, and N = any base). Mutations from C and G in two further groups of out-of-frame human IgVH genes, not used in the deduction of the motifs, occurred significantly within the motifs for C and G. The proposed target sequence for G is within the reverse complement of the target sequence for C, suggesting that the hypermutation mechanism may target only G or C. The mutation in the complementary base would appear on the other strand following replication.

Hypermutation in Ig V genes from mice deficient in the MLH1 mismatch repair protein.

During somatic hypermutation of Ig V genes, mismatched nucleotide substitutions become candidates for removal by the DNA mismatch repair pathway. Previous studies have shown that V genes from mice deficient for the MSH2 and PMS2 mismatch repair proteins have frequencies of mutation that are comparable with those from wild-type (wt) mice; however, the pattern of mutation is altered. Because the absence of MSH2 and PMS2 produced different mutational spectra, we examined the role of another protein involved in mismatch repair, MLH1, on the frequency and pattern of hypermutation. MLH1-deficient mice were immunized with oxazolone Ag, and splenic B cells were analyzed for mutations in their V kappa Ox1 light chain genes. Although the frequency of mutation in MLH1-deficient mice was twofold lower than in wt mice, the pattern of mutation in Mlh1-/- clones was similar to wt clones. These findings suggest that the MLH1 protein has no direct effect on the mutational spectrum.

Is a mutator analogous to the Ig hypermutator of the sheep ileal Peyer's patch active on MHC class I genes in the germ line?

Polymorphic sequence variation in the peptide-binding domains of MHC class I molecules appears to have been driven largely by the constructive action of natural selection on the specificity of the peptide-binding groove. Similar features are displayed by the variable domains of immunoglobulins generated in the sheep ileal Peyer's patch, but in this case there is evidence that the action of a targeted hypermutator acting on a selected substrate rather than antigen-driven selection is responsible for the pattern of variation in the system. Such a hypermutator acting in the germ line would not only mimic the action of natural selection but also, by convergent mutation, generate similar patterns of variation in unrelated alleles that could be interpreted as evidence for short-tract gene conversion. We analyzed human class I MHC alleles in the light of these data, but failed to find evidence of the action of a similar hypermutator. A search for other mutationally driven patterns of variation also failed, even in hypervariable residues from parsimonious phylogenies. Single-nucleotide variation at these residues is also frequent in recent allelic variants, but the data are as consistent with short-tract gene conversion as with base mutation. We conclude that the patterns of allelic variation in MHC molecules are not driven by mutational pressure, but rather by conventional mutational processes, accompanied by short-tract gene conversion and intense natural selection.

Crucial role of TCR gamma chain junctional region in prenyl pyrophosphate antigen recognition by gamma delta T cells.

Human gamma delta T cells recognize prenyl pyrophosphate Ags and their analogues in a V gamma 2V delta 2 TCR-dependent manner. Few data are available regarding the TCR structural requirements for recognition of such prenyl pyrophosphate Ags by gamma delta T cells. Presently, we made chain pair switch, chimeric, and site mutant gamma delta TCRs and transfected them into TCR- mutant Jurkat T cells to examine the effects of changing the TCR gamma junctional region sequences on reactivity to prenyl pyrophosphate Ags. Substitution of the TCR gamma junctional region (N and J) sequences from an Ag-reactive TCR with TCR gamma junctional region sequences from an Ag-nonreactive TCR abrogated reactivity to the prenyl pyrophosphate Ag isopentenyl pyrophosphate and to its synthetic analogue ethyl pyrophosphate but not to a mycobacterial supernatant containing a mixture of prenyl pyrophosphate Ags. Substitution of only the TCR gamma N nucleotide region with that from this Ag-nonreactive TCR destroyed reactivity to isopentenyl pyrophosphate and to the mycobacterial supernatant. Substitution of the entire V delta 2 chain from the Ag-reactive TCR with a V delta 1 chain from an Ag-nonreactive TCR yielded a prenyl pyrophosphate Ag-nonreactive TCR. Thus, using TCR mutagenesis and TCR transfectants, we show that gamma delta TCR reactivity to prenyl pyrophosphate Ags is dependent upon the junctional region of the TCR gamma chain and upon pairing of V gamma 2 and V delta 2 TCR chains. These structural requirements of TCR gamma delta recognition of prenyl pyrophosphates distinguish this reactivity from that of protein superantigens and emphasize the importance of the TCR gamma CDR3 loop and adjacent residues.

Analysis of a 26-kb region linked to the Mhc in zebrafish: genomic organization of the proteasome component beta/transporter associated with antigen processing-2 gene cluster and identification of five new proteasome beta subunit genes.

Sequencing of zebrafish (Danio rerio) bacterial artificial chromosome and P1 artificial chromosome genomic clone fragments and of cDNA clones has led to the identification of five new loci coding for beta subunits of proteasomes (PSMB). Together with the four genes identified previously, nine PSMB genes have now been defined in the zebrafish. Six of the nine genes reside in the zebrafish MHC (Mhc) class I region, four of them reside in a single cluster closely associated with TAP2 on a 26-kb long genomic fragment, and two reside at some distance from the fragment. In addition to homologues of the human genes PSMB5 through PSMB9, two new genes, PSMB11 and PSMB12, have been found for which there are no known corresponding genes in humans. The new genes reside in the PSMB cluster in the Mhc. Homology and promoter region analysis suggest that the Mhc-associated genes might be inducible by IFN-gamma. The zebrafish class I region contains representatives of three phylogenetically distinguishable groups of PSMB genes, X, Y, and Z. It is proposed that these genes were present in the ancestral PSMB region before Mhc class I genes became associated with it.

The invariant chain gene intronic enhancer shows homology to class II promoter elements.

Coordinate expression of MHC class II proteins and the class II-associated invariant chain (Ii) is important for proper MHC class II functioning in Ag processing and presentation. The coordinate regulation of these genes results, in part, from the sharing of transcriptional regulatory regions between MHC class II and Ii genes; the Ii has previously been shown to have an upstream enhancer closely related to the essential class II promoter elements. We report here the characterization of a second enhancer in the Ii gene, located within the first intron. This intronic enhancer is contained within a 155-bp region, enhances transcription from the Ii minimal promoter, and also contains elements that are homologous to class II promoter elements X1, X2, and Y boxes.

Macrophages sense pathogens via DNA motifs: induction of tumor necrosis factor-alpha-mediated shock.

Cell surface components of pathogens, such as lipopolysaccharide (LPS), are an important signal for receptor-mediated activation of immune cells. Here we demonstrate that DNA of gram-positive and gram-negative bacteria or certain synthetic oligonucleotides displaying unmethylated CpG-motifs can trigger macrophages in vitro to induce nuclear translocation of nuclear factor-kappa B, accumulate tumor necrosis factor (TNF)-alpha mRNA and release large amounts of TNF-alpha. In vivo these events culminate in acute cytokine-release syndrome which includes systemic but transient accumulation of TNF-alpha. D-Galactosamine (DGalN)-sensitized mice succumb to lethal toxic shock due to macrophage-derived TNF-alpha resulting in fulminant apoptosis of liver cells. LPS and a specific oligonucleotide synergized in vivo as measured by TNF-alpha-release, suggesting that macrophages integrate the respective signals. The ability of macrophages to discriminate and to respond to bacterial DNA with acute release of pro-inflammatory cytokines may point out an important and as yet unappreciated sensing mechanism for foreign DNA.

Induction of Ig somatic hypermutation and class switching in a human monoclonal IgM+ IgD+ B cell line in vitro: definition of the requirements and modalities of hypermutation.

Partly because of the lack of a suitable in vitro model, the trigger(s) and the mechanism(s) of somatic hypermutation in Ig genes are largely unknown. We have analyzed the hypermutation potential of human CL-01 lymphocytes, our monoclonal model of germinal center B cell differentiation. These cells are surface IgM+ IgD+ and, in the absence of T cells, switch to IgG, IgA, and IgE in response to CD40:CD40 ligand engagement and exposure to appropriate cytokines. We show here that CL-01 cells can be induced to effectively mutate the expressed VHDJH-C mu, VHDJH-C delta, VHDJH-C gamma, VHDJH-C alpha, VHDJH-C epsilon, and V lambda J lambda-C lambda transcripts before and after Ig class switching in a stepwise fashion. In these cells, induction of somatic mutations required cross-linking of the surface receptor for Ag and T cell contact through CD40:CD40 ligand and CD80: CD28 coengagement. The induced mutations showed intrinsic features of Ig V(D)J hypermutation in that they comprised 110 base substitutions (97 in the heavy chain and 13 in the lambda-chain) and only 2 deletions and targeted V(D)J, virtually sparing CH and C lambda. These mutations were more abundant in secondary VHDJH-C gamma than primary VHDJH-C mu transcripts and in V(D)J-C than V lambda J lambda-C lambda transcripts. These mutations were also associated with coding DNA strand polarity and showed an overall rate of 2.42 x 10(-4) base changes/cell division in VHDJH-CH transcripts. Transitions were favored over transversions, and G nucleotides were preferentially targeted, mainly in the context of AG dinucleotides. Thus, in CL-01 cells, Ig somatic hypermutation is readily inducible by stimuli different from those required for class switching and displays discrete base substitution modalities.

A new regulatory region of the IL-2 locus that confers position-independent transgene expression.

Although the promoter/enhancer of the IL-2 gene mediates inducible reporter gene expression in vitro, it cannot drive consistent expression in transgenic mice. The location and existence of any regulatory elements that could open the IL-2 locus in vivo have remained unknown, preventing analysis of IL-2 regulation in developmental contexts. In this study, we report the identification of such a regulatory region, marked by novel DNase-hypersensitive sites upstream of the murine IL-2 promoter in unstimulated and stimulated T cells. Inclusion of most of these sites in an 8.4-kb IL-2 promoter green fluorescent protein transgene gives locus control region-like activity. Expression is efficient, tissue specific, and position independent. This transgene is expressed not only in peripheral T cells, but also in immature thymocytes and thymocytes undergoing positive selection, in agreement with endogenous IL-2 expression. In contrast, a 2-kb promoter green fluorescent protein transgene, lacking the new hypersensitive sites, is expressed in only a few founder lines, and expression is dysregulated in CD8(+) cells. Thus, the 6.4 kb of additional upstream IL-2 sequence contains regulatory elements that provide integration site independence and differential regulation of transgene expression in CD8 vs CD4 cells.

Hepatocyte NF-1 and STAT6 cooperate with additional DNA-binding factors to activate transcription of the human polymeric Ig receptor gene in response to IL-4.

Secretory IgA and IgM, which protect the mucosal surfaces, are generated by selective transport of locally produced polymeric (p)Igs through the epithelial barrier by the pIgR. The expression of this receptor, and hence the generation of secretory Igs, is modulated by numerous extracellular factors. We have previously identified a STAT6 site in intron 1 of the human pIgR gene that is required for the slow and de novo protein synthesis-dependent IL-4-mediated transcriptional activation of the gene. In this study, we show that this intronic IL-4-responsive enhancer is confined to a 250-bp region that is highly conserved in the murine pIgR gene. The enhancer was dependent on the cooperation between the STAT6 site and at least four additional DNA elements. EMSA experiments demonstrated binding by hepatocyte NF-1 to one of these DNA elements. Extensive overlap in the tissue distribution of hepatocyte NF-1 and pIgR suggests that this transcription factor contributes to tissue-specific pIgR expression. Changing the helical phase between the STAT6 site and downstream DNA elements greatly reduced the strength of the IL-4 response, suggesting that the precise organization of this enhancer is important for its proper function. Thus, several transcription factors cooperate in this enhanceosome to mediate IL-4 responsiveness in HT-29 epithelial cells.

Evidence for epigenetic mechanisms that silence both basal and immune-stimulated transcription of the IL-8 gene.

It is becoming increasingly clear that epigenetic silencing of gene transcription plays a critical role in the regulation of gene expression in many biological processes. Tight regulation of immunomodulatory substances that are important for the initiation of the inflammatory cascade, such as chemoattractive cytokines, is essential to prevent initiation of unrestrained immune activation. Using the Caco-2 intestinal cell line as a model, we reveal two distinctly different mechanisms by which the gene for the neutrophil chemoattractive cytokine IL-8 is silenced. Nuclear run-on studies, as well as stably transfected reporter and marked minigene constructs, demonstrate that cellular differentiation inhibits immune-activated transcription of the IL-8 gene, a mechanism that is dependent on histone deacetylase activity. Unexpectedly, this silencing mechanism does not involve previously described regulatory elements in the IL-8 promoter but rather cis-acting regions located at a distance from the IL-8 gene locus. Genomic elements distant to the immediate IL-8 locus are also required to silence aberrant basal transcriptional activity of the IL-8 promoter in the absence of immune activation. However, in this case, silencing occurs in a histone deacetylase-independent fashion. These findings were confirmed in transgenic mice in which, in the absence of these elements, aberrant IL-8 gene activity was present primarily in the intestinal tract. Epigenetic silencing of cytokine gene transcription through distant genomic elements is an important level of gene regulation that may be relevant to the pathogenesis of immunologic disease states.