Metastability of Protein Solution Structures in the Absence of a Solvent: Rugged Energy Landscape and Glass-like Behavior.

Native ion mobility/mass spectrometry is well-poised to structurally screen proteomes but characterizes protein structures in the absence of a solvent. This raises long-standing unanswered questions about the biological significance of protein structures identified through ion mobility/mass spectrometry. Using newly developed computational and experimental ion mobility/ion mobility/mass spectrometry methods, we investigate the unfolding of the protein ubiquitin in a solvent-free environment. Our data suggest that the folded, solvent-free ubiquitin observed by ion mobility/mass spectrometry exists in a largely native fold with an intact ß-grasp motif and α-helix. The ensemble of folded, solvent-free ubiquitin ions can be partitioned into kinetically stable subpopulations that appear to correspond to the structural heterogeneity of ubiquitin in solution. Time-resolved ion mobility/ion mobility/mass spectrometry measurements show that folded, solvent-free ubiquitin exhibits a strongly stretched-exponential time dependence, which simulations trace to a rugged energy landscape with kinetic traps. Unfolding rate constants are estimated to be approximately 800 to 20,000 times smaller than in the presence of water, effectively quenching the unfolding process on the time scale of typical ion mobility/mass spectrometry measurements. Our proposed unfolding pathway of solvent-free ubiquitin shares substantial characteristics with that established for the presence of solvent, including a polarized transition state with significant native content in the N-terminal ß-hairpin and α-helix. Our experimental and computational data suggest that (1) the energy landscape governing the motions of folded, solvent-free proteins is rugged in analogy to that of glassy systems; (2) large-scale protein motions may at least partially be determined by the amino acid sequence of a polypeptide chain; and (3) solvent facilitates, rather than controls, protein motions.

Differentiation of Isomeric, Nonseparable Carbohydrates Using Tandem-Trapped Ion Mobility Spectrometry-Mass Spectrometry.

Carbohydrates play important roles in biological processes, but their identification remains a significant analytical problem. While mass spectrometry has increasingly enabled the elucidation of carbohydrates, current approaches are limited in their abilities to differentiate isomeric carbohydrates when these are not separated prior to tandem-mass spectrometry analysis. This analytical challenge takes on increased relevance because of the pervasive presence of isomeric carbohydrates in biological systems. Here, we demonstrate that TIMS2-MS2 workflows enabled by tandem-trapped ion mobility spectrometry-mass spectrometry (tTIMS/MS) provide a general approach to differentiate isomeric, nonseparated carbohydrates. Our analysis shows that (1) cross sections measured by TIMS are sufficiently precise and robust for ion identification; (2) fragment ion cross sections from TIMS2 analysis can be analytically exploited to identify carbohydrate precursors even if the precursor ions are not separated by TIMS; (3) low-abundant fragment ions can be exploited to identify carbohydrate precursors even if the precursor ions are not separated by IMS. (4) MS2 analysis of fragment ions produced by TIMS2 can be used to validate and/or further characterize carbohydrate structures. Taken together, our analysis underlines the opportunities that tandem-ion mobility spectrometry/MS methods offer for the characterization of mixtures of isomeric carbohydrates.

The role of solvation on the conformational landscape of α-synuclein.

Native ion mobility mass spectrometry has been used extensively to characterize ensembles of intrinsically disordered protein (IDP) conformers, but the extent to which the gaseous measurements provide realistic pictures of the solution conformations for such flexible proteins remains unclear. Therefore, we systematically studied the relationship between the solution and gaseous structural ensembles by measuring electrospray charge state and collision cross section (CCS) distributions for cationic and anionic forms of α-synuclein (αSN), an anionic protein in solution, as well as directly probed gas phase residue to residue distances via ion/ion reactions between gaseous α-synuclein cations and disulfonic acid linkers that form strong electrostatic bonds. We also combined results from in-solution protein crosslinking identified from native tandem mass spectrometry (MS/MS) with an initial αSN ensemble generated computationally by IDPConformerGenerator to generate an experimentally restrained solution ensemble of αSN. CCS distributions were directly calculated for the solution ensembles determined by NMR and compared to predicted gaseous conformers. While charge state and collision cross section distributions are useful for qualitatively describing the relative structural dynamics of proteins and major conformational changes induced by changes to solution states, the predicted and measured gas phase conformers include subpopulations that are significantly different than those expected from completely "freezing" solution conformations and preserving them in the gas phase. However, insights were gained on the various roles of solvent in stabilizing various conformers for extremely dynamic proteins like α-synuclein.

Peptide collision cross sections of 22 post-translational modifications.

Recent advances have rekindled the interest in ion mobility as an additional dimension of separation in mass spectrometry (MS)-based proteomics. Ion mobility separates ions according to their size and shape in the gas phase. Here, we set out to investigate the effect of 22 different post-translational modifications (PTMs) on the collision cross section (CCS) of peptides. In total, we analyzed ~4300 pairs of matching modified and unmodified peptide ion species by trapped ion mobility spectrometry (TIMS). Linear alignment based on spike-in reference peptides resulted in highly reproducible CCS values with a median coefficient of variation of 0.26%. On a global level, we observed a redistribution in the m/z vs. ion mobility space for modified peptides upon changes in their charge state. Pairwise comparison between modified and unmodified peptides of the same charge state revealed median shifts in CCS between -1.4% (arginine citrullination) and +4.5% (O-GlcNAcylation). In general, increasing modified peptide masses were correlated with higher CCS values, in particular within homologous PTM series. However, investigating the ion populations in more detail, we found that the change in CCS can vary substantially for a given PTM and is partially correlated with the gas phase structure of its unmodified counterpart. In conclusion, our study shows PTM- and sequence-specific effects on the cross section of peptides, which could be further leveraged for proteome-wide PTM analysis.

Tandem Trapped Ion Mobility Spectrometry/Mass Spectrometry (tTIMS/MS) Reveals Sequence-Specific Determinants of Top-Down Protein Fragment Ion Cross Sections.

Top-down proteomics provides a straightforward approach to the level of proteoforms but remains technologically challenging. Using ion mobility spectrometry/mass spectrometry (IMS/MS) to separate top-down fragment ions improves signal/noise and dynamic range. Such applications, however, do not yet leverage the primary information obtained from IMS/MS, which is the characterization of the fragment ion structure by the measured momentum transfer cross sections. Here, we perform top-down analysis of intact proteins and assemblies using our tandem trapped ion mobility spectrometer/mass spectrometer (tTIMS/MS) and compile over 1400 cross section values of fragment ions. Our analysis reveals that most fragment ions exhibit multiple, stable conformations similar to those of intact polypeptides and proteins. The data further indicate that the conformational heterogeneity is strongly influenced by the amino acid sequences of the fragment ions. Moreover, time-resolved tTIMS/MS experiments reveal that conformations of top-down fragment ions can be metastable on the timescale of ion mobility measurements. Taken together, our analysis indicates that top-down fragment ions undergo a folding process in the gas phase and that this folding process can lead to kinetic trapping of intermediate states in ion mobility measurements. Hence, because the folding free energy surface of a polypeptide ion is encoded by its amino acid sequence and charge state, our analysis suggests that cross sections can be exploited as sequence-specific determinants of top-down fragment ions.

Tandem-trapped ion mobility spectrometry/mass spectrometry (tTIMS/MS): a promising analytical method for investigating heterogenous samples.

Ion mobility spectrometry/mass spectrometry (IMS/MS) is widely used to study various levels of protein structure. Here, we review the current state of affairs in tandem-trapped ion mobility spectrometry/mass spectrometry (tTIMS/MS). Two different tTIMS/MS instruments are discussed in detail: the first tTIMS/MS instrument, constructed from coaxially aligning two TIMS devices; and an orthogonal tTIMS/MS configuration that comprises an ion trap for irradiation of ions with UV photons. We discuss the various workflows the two tTIMS/MS setups offer and how these can be used to study primary, tertiary, and quaternary structures of protein systems. We also discuss, from a more fundamental perspective, the processes that lead to denaturation of protein systems in tTIMS/MS and how to soften the measurement so that biologically meaningful structures can be characterised with tTIMS/MS. We emphasize the concepts underlying tTIMS/MS to underscore the opportunities tandem-ion mobility spectrometry methods offer for investigating heterogeneous samples.

Tandem-trapped ion mobility spectrometry/mass spectrometry coupled with ultraviolet photodissociation.

RATIONALE: Tandem-ion mobility spectrometry/mass spectrometry methods have recently gained traction for the structural characterization of proteins and protein complexes. However, ion activation techniques currently coupled with tandem-ion mobility spectrometry/mass spectrometry methods are limited in their ability to characterize structures of proteins and protein complexes. METHODS: Here, we describe the coupling of the separation capabilities of tandem-trapped ion mobility spectrometry/mass spectrometry (tTIMS/MS) with the dissociation capabilities of ultraviolet photodissociation (UVPD) for protein structure analysis. RESULTS: We establish the feasibility of dissociating intact proteins by UV irradiation at 213 nm between the two TIMS devices in tTIMS/MS and at pressure conditions compatible with ion mobility spectrometry (2-3 mbar). We validate that the fragments produced by UVPD under these conditions result from a radical-based mechanism in accordance with prior literature on UVPD. The data suggest stabilization of fragment ions produced from UVPD by collisional cooling due to the elevated pressures used here ("UVnoD2"), which otherwise do not survive to detection. The data account for a sequence coverage for the protein ubiquitin comparable to recent reports, demonstrating the analytical utility of our instrument in mobility-separating fragment ions produced from UVPD. CONCLUSIONS: The data demonstrate that UVPD carried out at elevated pressures of 2-3 mbar yields extensive fragment ions rich in information about the protein and that their exhaustive analysis requires IMS separation post-UVPD. Therefore, because UVPD and tTIMS/MS each have been shown to be valuable techniques on their own merit in proteomics, our contribution here underscores the potential of combining tTIMS/MS with UVPD for structural proteomics.

Structural Analysis of the Glycoprotein Complex Avidin by Tandem-Trapped Ion Mobility Spectrometry-Mass Spectrometry (Tandem-TIMS/MS).

Glycoproteins play a central role in many biological processes including disease mechanisms. Nevertheless, because glycoproteins are heterogeneous entities, it remains unclear how glycosylation modulates the protein structure and function. Here, we assess the ability of tandem-trapped ion mobility spectrometry-mass spectrometry (tandem-TIMS/MS) to characterize the structure and sequence of the homotetrameric glycoprotein avidin. We show that (1) tandem-TIMS/MS retains native-like avidin tetramers with deeply buried solvent particles; (2) applying high activation voltages in the interface of tandem-TIMS results in collision-induced dissociation (CID) of avidin tetramers into compact monomers, dimers, and trimers with cross sections consistent with X-ray structures and reports from surface-induced dissociation (SID); (3) avidin oligomers are best described as heterogeneous ensembles with (essentially) random combinations of monomer glycoforms; (4) native top-down sequence analysis of the avidin tetramer is possible by CID in tandem-TIMS. Overall, our results demonstrate that tandem-TIMS/MS has the potential to correlate individual proteoforms to variations in protein structure.

Recommendations for reporting ion mobility Mass Spectrometry measurements.

Here we present a guide to ion mobility mass spectrometry experiments, which covers both linear and nonlinear methods: what is measured, how the measurements are done, and how to report the results, including the uncertainties of mobility and collision cross section values. The guide aims to clarify some possibly confusing concepts, and the reporting recommendations should help researchers, authors and reviewers to contribute comprehensive reports, so that the ion mobility data can be reused more confidently. Starting from the concept of the definition of the measurand, we emphasize that (i) mobility values (K0 ) depend intrinsically on ion structure, the nature of the bath gas, temperature, and E/N; (ii) ion mobility does not measure molecular surfaces directly, but collision cross section (CCS) values are derived from mobility values using a physical model; (iii) methods relying on calibration are empirical (and thus may provide method-dependent results) only if the gas nature, temperature or E/N cannot match those of the primary method. Our analysis highlights the urgency of a community effort toward establishing primary standards and reference materials for ion mobility, and provides recommendations to do so. © 2019 The Authors. Mass Spectrometry Reviews Published by Wiley Periodicals, Inc.

From Noncovalent Chalcogen-Chalcogen Interactions to Supramolecular Aggregates: Experiments and Calculations.

This review considers noncovalent bonds between divalent chalcogen centers. In the first part we present X-ray data taken from the solid state structures of dimethyl- and diphenyl-dichalcogenides as well as oligoalkynes kept by alkyl-sulfur, -selenium, and -tellurium groups. Furthermore, we analyzed the solid state structures of medium sized (12-24 ring size) selenium coronands and medium to large rings with alkyne and alkene units between two chalcogen centers. The crystal structures of the cyclic structures revealed columnar stacks with close contacts between neighboring rings via noncovalent interactions between the chalcogen centers. To get larger space within the cavities, rings with diyne units between the chalcogen centers were used. These molecules showed channel-like structures in the solid state. The flexibility of the rings permits inclusion of guest molecules such as five-membered heterocycles and aromatic six-membered rings. In the second part we discuss the results of quantum chemical calculations. To treat properly the noncovalent bonding between chalcogens, we use diffuse augmented split valence basis sets in combination with electron correlation methods. Our model substances were 16 dimers consisting of two Me-X-Me (X = O, S, Se, Te) pairs and dimers of Me-X-Me/Me-X-CN (X = O, S, Se, Te) pairs. The calculations show the anticipated increase of the interaction energy from (Me-O-Me)2 (-2.15 kcal/mol) to (Me-O-Me/Me-Te-CN) (-6.59 kcal/mol). An analysis by the NBO method reveals that in the case of the chalcogen centers O and S the hydrogen bridges between the molecules dominate. However, in the case of Se and Te the major bonding between the pairs originates from dispersion forces between the chalcogen centers. It varies between -1.7 and -4.0 kcal/mol.

A Transferable, Sample-Independent Calibration Procedure for Trapped Ion Mobility Spectrometry (TIMS).

Ion mobility spectrometry-mass spectrometry (IMS-MS) determines momentum transfer cross sections of ions to elucidate their structures. Recent IMS methods employ electrodynamic fields or nonstationary buffer gases to separate ions. These methods require a calibration procedure to determine ion mobilities from the experimental data. This applies in particular to trapped IMS (TIMS), a novel IMS method with reported high resolving powers. Here, we report the first systematic assessment of the accuracy and the limitations of mobility calibration in TIMS. Our data show that the currently used TIMS calibration approach reproduces drift tube mobilities to approximately 1% (95th percentile). Furthermore, we develop a transferable and sample-independent calibration procedure for TIMS. The central aspects of our approach are (1) a calibration function derived from a solution to the Boltzmann transport equation and (2) calibration constants based on a Taylor expansion of instrument properties (TEIP). The key advantage of our calibration approach over current ones is its transferability: one equation and one set of parameters are sufficient to calibrate ion mobilities for various instrument settings, compound classes, or charge states. Our approach is transferable over time and sufficiently accurate (∼1-2%) for structure-elucidation purposes. While we develop our calibration procedure specifically for TIMS, the approach we take is generic in nature and can be applied to other IMS systems.

Tandem trapped ion mobility spectrometry.

There is currently a strong interest in the use of ion mobility spectrometry-mass spectrometry (IMS-MS) instrumentation for structural biology. In these applications, momentum transfer cross sections derived from IMS-MS measurements are used to reconstruct the three-dimensional analyte structure. Recent reports indicate that additional structural information can be extracted from measuring changes in cross sections in response to changes of the analyte structure. To further this approach, we constructed a tandem trapped IMS analyser (TIMS-TIMS) and incorporated it in a QqTOF mass spectrometer. TIMS-TIMS is constructed by coupling two TIMS analysers via an "interface region" composed of two apertures. We show that peptide oligomers (bradykinin) and native-like protein (ubiquitin) ions can be preserved through the course of an experiment in a TIMS-TIMS analyser. We demonstrate the ability to collisionally-activate as well as to trap mobility-selected ions, followed by subsequent mobility-analysis. In addition to inducing conformational changes, we show that we can fragment low charge states of ubiquitin at >1 mbar between the TIMS analysers with significant sequence coverage. Many fragment ions exhibit multiple features in their TIMS spectra, which means that they may not generally exist as the most stable isomer. The ability of TIMS-TIMS to dissociate mobility-selected protein ions and to measure the cross sections of their fragment ions opens new possibilities for IMS-based structure elucidation.

On the structural denaturation of biological analytes in trapped ion mobility spectrometry - mass spectrometry.

Key to native ion mobility/mass spectrometry is to prevent the structural denaturation of biological molecules in the gas phase. Here, we systematically assess structural changes induced in the protein ubiquitin during a trapped ion mobility spectrometry (TIMS) experiment. Our analysis shows that the extent of structural denaturation induced in ubiquitin ions is largely proportional to the amount of translational kinetic energy an ion gains from the applied electric field between two collisions with buffer gas particles. We then minimize the efficiency of the structural denaturation of ubiquitin ions in the gas phase during a TIMS experiment. The resulting "soft" TIMS spectra of ubiquitin are found largely identical to those observed on "soft" elevated-pressure ion mobility drift tubes and the corresponding calibrated cross sections are consistent with structures reported from NMR experiments for the native and A-state of ubiquitin. Thus, our analysis reveals that TIMS is useful for native ion mobility/mass spectrometry analysis.

Protomers of benzocaine: solvent and permittivity dependence.

The immediate environment of a molecule can have a profound influence on its properties. Benzocaine, the ethyl ester of para-aminobenzoic acid that finds an application as a local anesthetic, is found to adopt in its protonated form at least two populations of distinct structures in the gas phase, and their relative intensities strongly depend on the properties of the solvent used in the electrospray ionization process. Here, we combine IR-vibrational spectroscopy with ion mobility-mass spectrometry to yield gas-phase IR spectra of simultaneously m/z and drift-time-resolved species of benzocaine. The results allow for an unambiguous identification of two protomeric species: the N- and O-protonated forms. Density functional theory calculations link these structures to the most stable solution and gas-phase structures, respectively, with the electric properties of the surrounding medium being the main determinant for the preferred protonation site. The fact that the N-protonated form of benzocaine can be found in the gas phase is owed to kinetic trapping of the solution-phase structure during transfer into the experimental setup. These observations confirm earlier studies on similar molecules where N- and O-protonation have been suggested.

Molecular Structures and Ion Mobility Cross Sections: Analysis of the Effects of He and N2 Buffer Gas.

An empirically observed correlation between ion mobility cross sections in helium and nitrogen buffer gases was examined as a function of temperature, molecular size, and shape. Experimental cross sections were determined for tetraglycine, bradykinin, angiotensin 2, melittin, and ubiquitin at 300 K and in the range from 80 to 550 K on home-built instruments and calculated by the projection superposition approximation (PSA) method. The PSA was also used to predict cross sections for larger systems such as human pancreatic alpha-amylase, concanavalin, Pichia pastoris lysyl oxidase, and Klebsiella pneumoniae acetolactate synthase. The data show that the ratio of cross sections in helium and nitrogen depends significantly on the temperature of the buffer gas as well as the size and shape of the analyte ion. Therefore, the analysis of the data indicates that a simple formula that seeks to quantitatively relate the momentum transfer cross sections observed in two distinct buffer gases lacks a sound physical basis.

A local collision probability approximation for predicting momentum transfer cross sections.

The local collision probability approximation (LCPA) method is introduced to compute molecular momentum transfer cross sections for comparison to ion mobility experiments. The LCPA replaces the (non-local) scattering trajectory used in the trajectory method to describe the collision process by a (local) collision probability function. This momentum transfer probability is computed using the exact same analyte-buffer interaction potential as used in the trajectory method. Subsequently, the momentum transfer cross section ΩLCPA(T) is calculated in a projection-type manner (corrected for shape effects through a shape factor). Benchmark calculations on a set of 208 carbon clusters with a range of molecular size and degree of concavity demonstrate that LCPA and trajectory calculations agree closely with one another. The results discussed here indicate that the LCPA is suitable to efficiently calculate momentum transfer cross sections for use in ion mobility spectrometry in conjunction with different buffer gases.

Evaluation of a Commercial TIMS-Q-TOF Platform for Native Mass Spectrometry.

Mass-spectrometry based assays in structural biology studies measure either intact or digested proteins. Typically, different mass spectrometers are dedicated for such measurements: those optimized for rapid analysis of peptides or those designed for high molecular weight analysis. A commercial trapped ion mobility-quadrupole-time-of-flight (TIMS-Q-TOF) platform is widely utilized for proteomics and metabolomics, with ion mobility providing a separation dimension in addition to liquid chromatography. The ability to perform high-quality native mass spectrometry of protein complexes, however, remains largely uninvestigated. Here, we evaluate a commercial TIMS-Q-TOF platform for analyzing noncovalent protein complexes by utilizing the instrument's full range of ion mobility, MS, and MS/MS (both in-source activation and collision cell CID) capabilities. The TIMS analyzer is able to be tuned gently to yield collision cross sections of native-like complexes comparable to those previously reported on various instrument platforms. In-source activation and collision cell CID were robust for both small and large complexes. TIMS-CID was performed on protein complexes streptavidin (53 kDa), avidin (68 kDa), and cholera toxin B (CTB, 58 kDa). Complexes pyruvate kinase (237 kDa) and GroEL (801 kDa) were beyond the trapping capabilities of the commercial TIMS analyzer, but TOF mass spectra could be acquired. The presented results indicate that the commercial TIMS-Q-TOF platform can be used for both omics and native mass spectrometry applications; however, modifications to the commercial RF drivers for both the TIMS analyzer and quadrupole (currently limited to m/z 3000) are necessary to mobility analyze protein complexes greater than about 60 kDa.

Differentiation of CC vs CXC chemokine dimers with GAG octasaccharide binding partners: an ion mobility mass spectrometry approach.

Chemokines, 8 kDa proteins implicated in leukocyte migration via oligomerization, bind to glycosaminoglycans (GAGs) during the inflammation response as a means to regulate chemokine migration. Structural characterization of chemokines non-covalently bound to GAGs provides physiologically meaningful data in regard to routine inmmunosurveillance and disease response. In order to analyze the structures resulting from the GAG:chemokine interaction, we employed ion mobility mass spectrometry (IMMS) to analyze monocyte chemoattractant protein-1 (MCP-1), a CC chemokine, and interleukin-8 (IL-8), a CXC chemokine, along with their individual interactions with GAG heparin octasaccharides. We show that MCP-1 and IL-8 are physiologically present as a dimer, with MCP-1 having two variants of its dimeric form and IL-8 having only one. We also show that the MCP-1 dimer adopts two conformations, one extended and one compact, when bound to a dodecasulfated heparin octasaccharide. Binding of MCP-1 to heparin octasaccharide isomers of varying sulfation patterns results in similar arrival time distribution values, which suggests minimal distinguishing features among the resultant complexes. Additionally, tandem mass spectrometry (MS/MS) showed that the binding of MCP-1 to a heparin octasaccharide has different dissociation patterns when compared with the corresponding IL-8 bound dimer. Overall, IMMS and MS/MS were used to better define the structural tendencies and differences associated with CC and CXC dimers when associated with GAG octasaccharides.

Ion mobility spectrometry reveals the mechanism of amyloid formation of Aß(25-35) and its modulation by inhibitors at the molecular level: epigallocatechin gallate and scyllo-inositol.

Amyloid cascades leading to peptide ß-sheet fibrils and plaques are central to many important diseases. Recently, intermediate assemblies of these cascades were identified as the toxic agents that interact with the cellular machinery. The relationship between the transformation from natively unstructured assembly to the ß-sheet oligomers to disease is important in understanding disease onset and the development of therapeutic agents. Research on this early oligomeric region has largely been unsuccessful since traditional techniques measure only ensemble average oligomer properties. Here, ion mobility methods are utilized to deduce the modulation of peptide self-assembly pathways in the amyloid-ß protein fragment Aß(25-35) by two amyloid inhibitors (epigallocatechin gallate and scyllo-inositol) that are currently in clinical trials for Alzheimer's Disease. We provide evidence that suppression of ß-extended oligomers from the onset of the conversion into ß-oligomer conformations is essential for effective attenuation of ß-structured amyloid oligomeric species often associated with oligomer toxicity. Furthermore, we demonstrate the ease with which ion mobility spectrometry-mass spectrometry can guide the development of therapeutic agents and drug evaluation by providing molecular level insight into the amyloid formation process and its modulation by small molecule assembly modulators.