[Can we talk about triage of patients and with whom?] / Peut-on parler de tri des malades et avec qui ?

During the first wave of the Covid-19 epidemic that hit France in the spring of 2020 sparked controversy over the triage of patients in the emergency room. From this controversy, this text will seek to clarify this notion of triage and, and to shed light on the ethical position of bedside physicians who find themselves summited to public health strategies, scientific data, regulatory injunctions and ethical duties.

Neuromuscular training based on whole body vibration in children with spina bifida: a retrospective analysis of a new physiotherapy treatment program.

INTRODUCTION: Spina bifida is the most common congenital cause of spinal cord lesions resulting in paralysis and secondary conditions like osteoporosis due to immobilization. Physiotherapy is performed for optimizing muscle function and prevention of secondary conditions. Therefore, training of the musculoskeletal system is one of the major aims in the rehabilitation of children with spinal cord lesions. INTERVENTION AND METHODS: The neuromuscular physiotherapy treatment program Auf die Beine combines 6 months of home-based whole body vibration (WBV) with interval blocks at the rehabilitation center: 13 days of intensive therapy at the beginning and 6 days after 3 months. Measurements are taken at the beginning (M0), after 6 months of training (M6), and after a 6-month follow-up period (M12). Gait parameters are assessed by ground reaction force and motor function by the Gross Motor Function Measurement (GMFM-66). Sixty children (mean age 8.71 ± 4.7 years) who participated in the program until February 2014 were retrospectively analyzed. RESULTS: Walking velocity improved significantly by 0.11 m/s (p = 0.0026) and mobility (GMFM-66) by 2.54 points (p = 0.001) after the training. All changes at follow-up were not significant, but significant changes were observed after the training period. Decreased contractures were observed with increased muscle function. CONCLUSION: Significant improvements in motor function were observed after the active training period of the new neuromuscular training concept. This first analysis of the new neuromuscular rehabilitation concept Auf die Beine showed encouraging results for a safe and efficient physiotherapy treatment program which increases motor function in children with spina bifida.

Noradrenaline use for septic shock in children: doses, routes of administration and complications.

AIM: To report our 10 year experience with noradrenaline use in children with septic shock focusing on doses, routes of administration and complications. METHODS: Retrospective single-centre review of children with septic shock who received noradrenaline between 2000 and 2010. RESULTS: We identified 144 children with septic shock treated with noradrenaline, in 22% as the first-line drug. The median volume resuscitation before vasoactive agent administration was 50 mL/kg interquartile range [IQR: 30-70]. Mean doses of noradrenaline ranged from 0.5 ± 0.4 µg/kg per min (starting dose) to 2.5 ± 2.2 µg/kg per min (maximum dose). Noradrenaline was administered via peripheral venous access or intra-osseous route in 19% of cases for a median duration of 3 h [IQR: 2-4] without any adverse effects. The use of noradrenaline increased over the study period. Mortality rate was 45% with a significant decrease over the study period. Adverse effects included arrhythmia in two children and hypertension in eight children. None of these arrhythmias required treatment and hypertension resolved with the noradrenaline dose reduction. CONCLUSION: Higher doses of noradrenaline than those suggested in the literature may be necessary to reverse hypotension and hypoperfusion. The use of noradrenaline through peripheral venous access or intra-osseous route was safe, without any adverse effects.

Organ donation by Maastricht-III pediatric patients: Recommendations of the Groupe Francophone de Réanimation et Urgences Pédiatriques (GFRUP) and Association des Anesthésistes Réanimateurs Pédiatriques d'Expression Française (ADARPEF) Part I: Ethical considerations and family care.

The French Transplant Health Authority (Agence de la Biomédecine) has broadened its organ- and tissue-donation criteria to include pediatric patients whose death is defined by circulatory criteria and after the planned withdrawal of life-sustaining therapies (WLST) (Maastricht category III). A panel of pediatric experts convened to translate data in the international literature into recommendations for organ and tissue donation in this patient subgroup. The panel estimated that, among children aged 5 years or over with severe irreversible neurological injury (due to primary neurological injury or post-anoxic brain injury) and no progression to brain death, the number of potential donors, although small, deserves attention. The experts emphasized the importance of adhering strictly to the collegial procedure for deciding to withdraw life support. Once this decision is made, the available data should be used to evaluate whether the patient might be a potential donor, before suggesting organ donation to the parents. This suggestion should be reserved for parents who have unequivocally manifested their acceptance of WLST. The discussion with the parents should include both the pediatric intensive care unit (PICU) team under the responsibility of a senior physician and the hospital organ- and tissue-procurement team. All recommendations about family care during the end of life of a child in the PICU must be followed. The course and potential challenges of organ donation in Maastricht-III pediatric patients must be anticipated. The panel of experts recommended strict compliance with French recommendations (by the Groupe Francophone de Réanimation et Urgences Pédiatriques) about WLST and providing deep and continuous sedation until circulatory arrest. The experts identified the PICU as the best place to implement life-support discontinuation and emphasized the importance of returning the body to the PICU after organ donation. French law prohibits the transfer of these patients from one hospital to another. A description of the expert-panel recommendations regarding the organization and techniques appropriate for children who die after controlled circulatory arrest (Maastricht III) is published simultaneously in the current issue of this journal..

Organ donation by Maastricht-III pediatric patients: Recommendations of the Groupe Francophone de Réanimation et Urgences Pédiatriques (GFRUP) and Association des Anesthésistes Réanimateurs Pédiatriques d'Expression Française (ADARPEF). Part II: Specific organizational and technical considerations.

A panel of pediatric experts met to develop recommendations on the technical requirements specific to pediatric controlled donation after planned withdrawal of life-sustaining therapies (Maastricht category III). The panel recommends following the withdrawal of life-sustaining therapies protocol usually applied in each unit, which may or may not include immediate extubation. The organ retrieval process should be halted if death does not occur within 3 h of life-support discontinuation. Circulatory arrest is defined as loss of pulsatile arterial pressure and should be followed by a 5-min no-touch observation period. Death is declared based on a list of clinical criteria assessed by two senior physicians. The no-flow time should be no longer than 30, 45, and 90 min for the liver, kidneys, and lungs, respectively. At present, the panel does not recommend pediatric heart donation after death by circulatory arrest. The mean arterial pressure cutoff that defines the start of the functional warm ischemia (FWI) phase is 45 mmHg in patients older than 5 years and/or weighing more than 20 kg. The panel recommends normothermic regional perfusion in these patients. The FWI phase should not exceed 30 and 45 min for retrieving the pancreas and liver, respectively. There is no time limit to the FWI phase for the lungs and kidneys. The panel recommends routine sharing of experience with Maastricht-III donation among all healthcare institutions involved in order to ensure optimal outcome assessment and continuous discussion on the potential difficulties, notably those related to the management of normothermic regional perfusion in small children.

Longitudinal study on specific IgE against natural rubber latex, banana and kiwi in patients with spina bifida.

OBJECTIVE: Up to 2 out of 3 spina bifida (sb) patients with natural rubber latex (NRL) antibodies (ab) have crossreacting IgE-ab against tropical fruit, due to structural homologies between several NRL antigens and allergenic fruit proteins. It is essential to investigate whether the patients were first sensitized against NRL or fruit, to give recommendations for an evidence-based prophylaxis. PATIENTS AND METHODS: We investigated sera of 96 sb patients for specific IgE ab against NRL, banana and kiwi as examples for crossreacting fruit by FEIA (ImmunoCAP System, Phadia). These tests were repeated up to 3 times (mean after 2 years, maximum after 7 years). RESULTS: In the first testing only 2 of 50 NRL-IgE negative patients (4%) had ab against banana or kiwi. 4 of the 46 NRL-IgE positive patients (8%) showed ab against banana (2) or kiwi (2), 3 (7%) against both fruit. Symptoms of fruit allergy were presented by 3 patients, all symptomatic patients had high levels of specific fruit-ab. In the follow-up study 2 patients with low sensitization against NRL lost their NRL ab and their fruit ab, another 2 only the fruit ab, whereas 4 NRL-sensitized patients newly developed ab against banana and 1 against kiwi. Only 2 patients developed ab against fruit without being sensitized against NRL. 7 out of 10 patients with banana and kiwi ab were atopics. CONCLUSIONS: In most cases the sensitization against fruit follows the NRL sensitization. There is no need to recommend sb patients without NRL sensitization to primarily avoid tropical fruit.

Withholding and withdrawing treatment in pediatric intensive care. Update of the GFRUP recommendations.

In 2005, the French-speaking task force on pediatric critical and emergency care [Groupe Francophone de Réanimation et d'Urgences Pédiatriques (GFRUP)] issued recommendations on withholding and withdrawing treatments in pediatric critical care. Since then, the French Public Health Code, modified by the laws passed in 2005 and 2016 and by their enactment decrees, has established a legal framework for practice. Now, 15 years later, an update of these recommendations was needed to factor in the experience acquired by healthcare teams, new questions raised by practice surveys, the recommendations issued in the interval, the changes in legislation, and a few legal precedents. The objective of this article is to help pediatric critical care teams find the closest possible compromise between the ethical principles guiding the care offered to the child and the family and compliance with current regulations and laws.

Effects of latex avoidance on latex sensitization, atopy and allergic diseases in patients with spina bifida.

BACKGROUND: Ten years ago, avoidance measures such as the performance of latex-free operations were implemented in children with spina bifida. Since then, latex sensitization and latex allergy have decreased in this high-risk group. OBJECTIVE: To study the effect of primary latex-free prophylaxis on the prevalence of allergic diseases and atopy as a marker for sensitization spreading in children with spina bifida. METHODS: One hundred and twenty children with spina bifida born after the introduction of latex-free prophylaxis and operated on under latex-free conditions ('current group') were examined for latex sensitization, latex allergy, sensitization to aero- and food allergens and allergic diseases. Results were compared to a 'historic' (not latex-free operated) group of children with spina bifida and comparable age (n = 87) and to a recent sample of children from the general population (n = 12,403). RESULTS: In comparison with the 'historic group', latex sensitization (55% vs 5%, P < 0.001) and latex allergy (37% vs 0.8%, P < 0.001) were significantly reduced in the 'current group'. Furthermore, a significant reduction could be demonstrated for sensitization to aeroallergens (41.4% vs 20.8%, P = 0.001) and for allergic diseases (35% vs 15%, P = 0.001). The prevalence for atopy, sensitization to aero-/foodallergens and for allergic diseases in children of the 'current group' was similar to those in children of the weighted population sample. CONCLUSIONS: Latex avoidance in children with spina bifida prevents latex sensitization and latex allergy. Additionally, it also seems to prevent sensitization to other allergens and allergic diseases which might be explained by the prevention of sensitization spreading.

[What become the decisions of limitation of treatments after discharge from the paediatric intensive care unit?]. / Que deviennent les décisions de limitation ou d'arrêt des traitements actifs à la sortie de réanimation pédiatrique ?

UNLABELLED: The fact that some children may survive despite a decision of limitation of treatments (DLT) is taken in Paediatric Intensive Care Unit (PICU) is a recent data. Although the French-speaking Group of Paediatric Intensive and Emergency Care (GFRUP) has published guidelines for limitation of treatments in PICU, outcome of these surviving children has not yet been studied. PURPOSES: To evaluate transmission of data concerning DLT in PICU toward teams in charge of children after the PICU stay and to evaluate perennility of these decisions. METHOD: Cohort study in children for whom DLT was discussed and who were discharged from PICU between 2002 and 2006. The study included an analysis of the medical files and discussions with the physicians in charge of children at the time of the study, including their responses to standardised scenarios concerning the outcome of their patients. RESULTS: Among the 96 children for whom DLT was discussed in PICU, 37 were discharged toward another unit. Only 1 discharge letter mentioned the DLT. At the time of the study, the Pediatric Overall Performance Category (POPC) score had increased in 16 children and was stable in 12. All the 6 children with a worsening POPC score died, without PICU readmission. The physicians in charge of children after the PICU stay did not remember any DLT. For 18 children (including 8 with previous DLT) PICU readmission would be proposed in case of life-threatening event. Their median POPC score at the time of study was lower than that of other children (3 versus 4; p=0.001). CONCLUSION: This study shows a lack of DLT data transmission, which is in contradiction with the GFRUP's guidelines. Correction of this lack is essential to improve cooperation between units in charge of these children.

Natural rubber latex sensitisation and allergy in patients with spina bifida, urogenital disorders and oesophageal atresia compared with a normal paediatric population.

BACKGROUND: Natural rubber latex (NRL) contains proteins which, after repeated contact with latex products and an allergic predisposition (atopy), can lead to sensitisation (specific IgE against NRL proteins) or allergy (type 1 allergy with symptoms from urticaria to allergic shock). Spina bifida patients are known to be a high risk group for latex allergy and sensitisation due to numerous operations beginning soon after birth. In the study presented here we compared spina bifida patients with patients who also underwent repeated operations beginning soon after birth (urological malformations) or underwent surgery once in the neonatal period but had numerous anaesthesias because of repeated treatment with a bougie (oesophageal atresia). In this setting the influence of surgery and anaesthesia on NRL-sensitisation was investigated. MATERIALS AND METHODS: We investigated the prevalence of NRL-specific IgE (> 0.35 kU/l, ImmunoCAP system, Pharmacia) in a normal paediatric population (neither atopic nor having undergone surgery) (group I), spina bifida patients (group II), children with urogenital malformations (group III) and children with oesophago-tracheal malformations (group IV). RESULTS: The highest rate of NRL-sensitised patients was found in the spina bifida group (II) (48 %), followed by groups III and IV with 17 % each, compared to 4 % for the control group. NRL-allergic reactions were noted only in the patients with spina bifida and the urological malformation group (18 % in group II, 8 % in Group III). Apart from atopy the number of operations could be identified as a risk factor for the development of NRL-sensitisation and allergy (group II, III). The prevalence of latex allergy was lower after repeated anaesthesia (group IV) than after repeated surgery. CONCLUSIONS: In addition to the known high risk group of spina bifida patients, other patients with congenital malformations and early surgery also have a significant risk for latex sensitisation. When treating patients with malformations requiring repeated surgery, prophylactic measures similar to those for spina bifida patients should be considered.

[Non-invasive ventilation in infants with severe infection presumably due to respiratory syncytial virus: feasibility and failure criteria]. / Ventilation non invasive des nourrissons ayant une infection respiratoire sévère présumée à virus respiratoire syncitial: faisabilité et critères d'échec.

UNLABELLED: Beneficial effect of continuous positive airway pressure (CPAP) during non invasive ventilation (NIV) has been reported in infants with respiratory syncytial virus (RSV) infection, but no study has analyzed the predictors of its failure. OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the feasibility of NIV and to determine NIV failure criteria. POPULATION AND METHODS: All infants hospitalized in one PICU with presumed RSV infection between 2002 and 2006 were prospectively included. When respiratory support was needed, NIV was first started according to a pre-established protocol. RESULTS: One hundred and one infants, 43 females, 58 males, median age 49 days (range: 10-334), median weight 3.9 kg (range: 2,4-12) were included. RSV infection was confirmed in 84/101. Sixty-seven infants were transported by the paediatric medical transport system, 27 with NIV and 15 with invasive ventilation (IV). Fifteen infants were in IV at admission, 69 received NIV during their PICU stay (12 secondarily requiring IV) and 17 were never ventilated. A significant decrease in PCO2 with increase in pH was observed within 2 hours of NIV. Parameters associated with NIV failure were apneas, high values of admission PCO2 and H24 PRISM score. The 17 non-ventilated infants were older and had a lower severity score than those who were ventilated. CONCLUSION: In infants with RSV and needing respiratory support, NIV represented the sole method of respiratory support in 68% of cases. NIV failure criteria were apneas, high values of admission PCO2 and H24 PRISM score.

[Withholding or withdrawing life saving treatment in pediatric intensive care unit: GFRUP guidelines]. / Limitations et arrêts de traitements actifs en réanimation pédiatrique: recommandations du GFRUP.

Several recent French studies have revealed that 40% of death in pediatric intensive care units are associated with withdrawal or limitation of life saving treatments. Because such decisions are common, the Groupe francophone de réanimation et urgences pédiatriques (GFRUP) has decided to publish recommendations in order to help paediatricians dealing with those difficult issues and to improve their decisions. In a first part of the document the ethical principles that imply those guidelines are recalled, followed by definitions of the terms currently employed. The second part contains guidelines regarding decision making process, the way it is applied and organisation of relatives as well as paramedical and medical staff support when the death of a child occurs.

[Organization of collaborative deliberation for limiting or withholding treatments in children]. / Comment organiser la délibération collégiale pour limiter ou arrêter les traitements en pédiatrie?

In 2005, the French law on patients' rights at the end of life required that decisions to withdraw or withhold life-sustaining treatments be made and carried out by the physician in charge of the patient, after obtaining advice from an independent consulting colleague and the caregiving team. The purpose of this study was to identify theoretical and practical obstacles to this collaborative deliberation and to propose practical guidelines to organize it.

[Neurogenic bladder function disorders in patients with meningomyelocele: S2k guidelines on diagnostics and therapy]. / Neurogene Blasenfunktionsstörungen bei Patienten mit Meningomyelozele : S2k-Leitlinie zu Diagnostik und Therapie.

The treatment of children and adolescents with meningomyelocele has experienced a clear change in the last 30 years. The establishment of pharmacotherapy, clean intermittent catheterization (CIC) and infection prophylaxis have improved the prognosis for patients and have led to new therapeutic strategies. The interdisciplinary cooperation between neonatologists, neurosurgeons, pediatric neurologists, pediatric urologists, pediatric nephrologists, pediatric orthopedists and pediatric surgeons leads to optimization of individualized therapy. These guidelines present definitions and classifications, investigations and timing which are described in detail. The conservative and operative therapy options for neurogenic bladder function disorders are described and discussed with reference to the current literature. The brief overview provides in each case assistance for the treating physician in the care of this patient group and facilitates the interdisciplinary cooperation.

Plastic bronchitis mimicking foreign body aspiration that needs a specific diagnostic procedure.

OBJECTIVE: To report two children admitted to our emergency department with respiratory failure, one for status asthmaticus with pneumomediastinum and requiring mechanical ventilation and the other for high suspicion of foreign body aspiration. INTERVENTIONS: Bronchoscopy revealed obstructive plugs and permitted their extraction and their identification as bronchial casts after the immersion in normal saline. Allergy was suspected in the first one, and Hemophilus influenzae infection was present in the second. The outcome was favorable. CONCLUSIONS: Plastic bronchitis is an infrequent cause of acute life-threatening respiratory failure that can mimic foreign body aspiration or status asthmaticus. Bronchoscopic extraction must be performed urgently in the case of severe obstruction. This entity is probably underestimated as the casts with their specific ramifications are difficult to recognize. We recommend the immersion in normal saline of all plugs discovered in children with predisposing diseases mainly represented by infections, allergy, acute chest syndrome, and congenital cardiopathies.

Admission plasma vasopressin levels in children with meningococcal septic shock.

OBJECTIVE: Vasopressin (AVP) response has been reported to be inappropriately low in adult established septic shock. We studied admission AVP levels in children with meningococcal septic shock (MSS). PATIENTS AND METHODS: All children with meningococcal infection admitted to our PICU between May 2001 and August 2002 were classified as MSS (persistent hypotension despite fluid therapy, with perfusion abnormalities and the need for vasoactive drug infusion for at least 24 h or until death), or meningococal infection without shock (fever and purpura, with or without meningitis). Blood samples were collected at admission and AVP levels were subsequently determined using Nichols Institute Diagnostics vasopressin assay. Eighteen of 19 children with MSS (7 deaths) and 15 without shock (no death) were included. RESULTS: In children with MSS median admission AVP level was 41.6 pg/ml (1.4-498.9) and in those without 3.3 pg/ml (1.6-63.8). In children with MSS the AVP level was not correlated with duration of shock and fluid expansion prior to AVP sampling, or with age-adjusted blood pressure and natremia at the time of blood sampling. AVP levels were higher in nonsurvivors, but not significantly so. Only one nonsurvivor had an admission AVP level below 30 pg/ml. CONCLUSIONS: In our children with established MSS who died the admission AVP level Delta were not inappropriately low. Further studies including serial AVP level assessments are needed before concluding that AVP administration is of little interest in children with MSS.

Measurement of respiratory mechanics in paediatric intensive care: in vitro assessment of a pulmonary function device.

OBJECTIVE: To evaluate a recently developed and manufactured device for monitoring respiratory parameters in mechanically ventilated children. DESIGN: In vitro study using a lung model. SETTING: University paediatric intensive care unit. MATERIAL AND INTERVENTIONS: Evaluation of the accuracy of volume and pressure measurements, of the determination of respiratory system compliance (10 to 30 ml/cmH2O) and of resistance (20 and 50 cmH2O/l per s) by the inflation technique (volume- and pressure-controlled mode of ventilation); assessment of interobserver agreement for compliance (10, 15 ml/cmH2O) and resistance (20, 50 cmH2O/l per s) determinations (ANOVA, intraclass correlation coefficient). MEASUREMENTS AND RESULTS: The accuracy of volume measurements (No.1 Fleisch pneumotachograph) was < or = 5 % of true volumes up to 11 (Flow: 30 l/min) even after the introduction of an endotracheal tube. The accuracy of pressure measurements up to 70 cmH2O was < or = 2.5% of the true values. Coefficients of variation of volume and pressure measurements were < 2%. The accuracy of compliance and resistance determinations was, respectively, < or = 17 and 25% of the true values. No significant observer effect was found on compliance and resistance determinations. Indeed, mean differences in compliance and resistance determinations by pairs of observers were < 1%. Intraclass correlation coefficients were > 0.98. CONCLUSIONS: The measuring error of volume, pressure, compliance and resistance determined using this monitoring system seems acceptable for monitoring purpose. Moreover, use of this system by members of the medical team can be recommended since results obtained by observers, even untrained ones, were similar. In vivo evaluation is now needed.

Age-related differences in timing of position and velocity identification.

The aim of this investigation was to study age-related differences in timing of position and velocity identification in a laboratory task. The skills required for performing this task are thought to be similar to those needed in real traffic situations. From this perspective, the results of this study may be taken into account in studies on accident analysis and prevention. To control for differences in the conscious experience of time and for simple reaction time to visual stimuli, young (25-34) and old (58-70) adults had to produce timed periods of 20 seconds and to time the arrival of a visible moving object at its goal. In these simple tasks no differences were found between young and old subjects. In the proper, more complex experiment, timing of position and velocity identification of a moving object were assessed with or without feedback on timing and velocity in the same old and young group. The object, moving from left to right at a constant velocity, was shown on a video screen during the first 40% of its trajectory. The moving object could have any of four (fixed) velocities which were presented in blocks with a regular or a mixed order. By pushing a button subjects estimated at which time the object would have reached the marked end of a trajectory. In a condition without feedback on timing of position, the timing error of older adults was higher than that of young adults and particularly with higher object velocities.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Reduction of latex sensitisation in spina bifida patients by a primary prophylaxis programme (five years experience).

Spina bifida patients represent a group with the highest risk for latex sensitisation and allergy with life-threatening symptoms mostly during surgery. At the end of 1995 we initiated a primary latex prophylaxis around and during surgery and anaesthesia of all spina bifida patients. The aim of our study was to investigate the prevalence of latex sensitisation in the spina bifida patients born during the five years after establishing latex prophylaxis in the Cologne Children's Hospital in December 1995. We investigated 34 serum samples of 27 spina bifida patients (mean age 2.4 years) for specific IgE antibodies against latex allergens (CAP system) and compared these patients born after 1995 with 38 spina bifida patients up to 5 years of age (mean 3.1 years) born before. In the prophylaxis group two of 27 patients (7 %), one of them with two operations outside the Children's Hospital, had low specific IgE against latex ( 100 kU/l (mean 22.6 kU/l, min 0.4 kU/l). Sera of 22 patients remained negative for latex IgE (min. 1, max. 19, mean 4.3 operations). By primary latex prophylaxis during surgery, anaesthesia and in paediatric wards the prevalence of latex sensitisation can be significantly reduced even in the high risk group of spina bifida patients. Problems can arise by the need for surgery in hospitals not experienced in the treatment of spina bifida patients, where latex prophylaxis is neglected.

[Dynamics of cognitive abilities in the course of active lifespan]. / De dynamiek van cognitieve vermogens tijdens de actieve levensloop.

Behavioral effects of cognitive aging and the meaning of experience are compared. Relating the process of aging to biological and functional decay does not do justice to the accumulation of knowledge and abilities over the active lifespan. Human development is a continuous process of growth and decline. It accounts for both gain and loss of cognitive abilities. From this perspective human capacities are not static but composed of a changing set of abilities which grow and decline over the life span. Despite decreasing capacity with age, reserve capacity may be sufficient to cope with normal task demands. Finally, it is illustrated how experience of older workers may contribute to the design of training programs.