Expanding Differential Ion Mobility Separations into the MegaDalton Range.

Along with mass spectrometry (MS), ion mobility separations (IMS) are advancing to ever larger biomolecules. The emergence of electrospray ionization (ESI) and native MS enabled the IMS/MS analyses of proteins up to ∼100 kDa in the 1990s and whole protein complexes and viruses up to ∼10 MDa since the 2000s. Differential IMS (FAIMS) is substantially orthogonal to linear IMS based on absolute mobility K and offers exceptional resolution, unique selectivity, and steady filtering readily compatible with slower analytical methods such as electron capture or transfer dissociation (ECD/ETD). However, the associated MS stages had limited FAIMS to ions with m/z < 8000 and masses under ∼300 kDa. Here, we integrate high-definition FAIMS with the Q-Exactive Orbitrap UHMR mass spectrometer that can handle m/z up to 80,000 and MDa-size ions in the native ESI regime. In the initial evaluation, the oligomers of monoclonal antibody adalimumab (148 kDa) are size-selected up to at least the nonamers (1.34 MDa) with m/z values up to ∼17,000. This demonstrates the survival and efficient separation of noncovalent MDa assemblies in the FAIMS process, opening the door to novel analyses of the heaviest macromolecules.

Multiplatform High-Definition Ion Mobility Separations of the Largest Epimeric Peptides.

Ion mobility spectrometry (IMS) coupled to mass spectrometry (MS) has become a versatile tool to fractionate complex mixtures, distinguish structural isomers, and elucidate molecular geometries. Along with the whole MS field, IMS/MS advances to ever larger species. A topical proteomic problem is the discovery and characterization of d-amino acid-containing peptides (DAACPs) that are critical to neurotransmission and toxicology. Both linear IMS and FAIMS previously disentangled d/l epimers with up to ∼30 residues. In the first study using all three most powerful IMS methodologies─trapped IMS, cyclic IMS, and FAIMS─we demonstrate baseline resolution of the largest known d/l peptides (CHH from Homarus americanus with 72 residues) with a dynamic range up to 100. This expands FAIMS analyses of isomeric modified peptides, especially using hydrogen-rich buffers, to the ∼50-100 residue range of small proteins. The spectra for d and l are unprecedentedly strikingly similar except for a uniform shift of the separation parameter, indicating the conserved epimer-specific structural elements across multiple charge states and conformers. As the interepimer resolution tracks the average for smaller DAACPs, the IMS approaches could help search for yet larger DAACPs. The a priori method to calibrate cyclic (including multipass) IMS developed here may be broadly useful.

Top-Down Ion Mobility Separations of Isomeric Proteoforms.

Continuing advances in proteomics highlight the ubiquity and biological importance of proteoforms─proteins with varied sequence, splicing, or distribution of post-translational modifications (PTMs). The preeminent example is histones, where the PTM pattern encodes the combinatorial language controlling the DNA transcription central to life. While the proteoforms with distinct PTM compositions are distinguishable by mass, the isomers with permuted PTMs commonly coexisting in cells generally require separation before mass-spectrometric (MS) analyses. That was accomplished on the bottom-up and middle-down levels using chromatography or ion mobility spectrometry (IMS), but proteolytic digestion obliterates the crucial PTM connectivity information. Here, we demonstrate baseline IMS resolution of intact isomeric proteoforms, specifically the acetylated H4 histones (11.3 kDa). The proteoforms with a single acetyl moiety on five alternative lysine residues (K5, K8, K12, K16, K20) known for distinct functionalities in vivo were constructed by two-step native chemical ligation and separated using trapped IMS at the resolving power up to 350 on the Bruker TIMS/ToF platform. Full resolution for several pairs was confirmed using binary mixtures and by unique fragments in tandem MS employing collision-induced dissociation. This novel capability for top-down proteoform characterization is poised to open major new avenues in proteomics and epigenetics.

High-Definition Ion Mobility/Mass Spectrometry with Structural Isotopic Shifts for Nominally Isobaric Isotopologues.

We had reported the isotopic envelopes in differential IMS (FAIMS) separations depending on the ion structure. However, this new approach to distinguish isomers was constrained by the unit-mass resolution commingling all nominally isobaric isotopologues. Here, we directly couple high-definition FAIMS to ultrahigh-resolution (Orbitrap) MS and employ the resulting platform to explore the FAIMS spectra for isotopic fine structure. The peak shifts therein for isotopologues of halogenated anilines with 15N and 13C (split by 6 mDa) in N2/CO2 buffers dramatically differ, more than for the 13C, 37Cl, or 81Br species apart by 1 or 2 Da. The shifts in FAIMS space upon different elemental isotopic substitutions are orthogonal mutually and to the underlying separations, forming fingerprint multidimensional matrices and 3-D trajectories across gas compositions that redundantly delineate all isomers considered. The interlocking instrumental and methodological upgrades in this work take the structural isotopic shift approach to the next level.

Assessing the Dipole Moments and Directional Cross Sections of Proteins and Complexes by Differential Ion Mobility Spectrometry.

Ion mobility spectrometry (IMS) has become a mainstream approach to fractionate complex mixtures, separate isomers, and assign the molecular geometries. All modalities were grouped into linear IMS (based on the absolute ion mobility, K) and field asymmetric waveform IMS (FAIMS) relying on the evolution of K at a high normalized electric field (E/N) that induces strong ion heating. In the recently demonstrated low-field differential (LOD) IMS, the field is too weak for significant heating but locks the macromolecular dipoles to produce novel separations controlled by the relevant directional collision cross sections (CCSs). Here, we show LODIMS for mass-selected species, exploring the dipole alignment across charge states for the monomers and dimers of an exemplary protein, the alcohol dehydrogenase. Distinct conformational families for aligned species are revealed with directional CCS estimated from the field-dependent trend lines. We set up a model to extract the fractions of pendular conformers as a function of field intensity and translate them into dipole moment distributions. These developments make a critical step toward establishing LODIMS as a new tool for top-down proteomics and integrative structural biology.

Differential Ion Mobility Separations of d/l Peptide Epimers.

Life was originally assumed to utilize the l-amino acids only. Since 1980s, the d-amino acid-containing peptides (DAACPs) were detected in animals, often at extremely low levels with tremendous functional specificity. As the unguided proteomic algorithms based on peptide masses are oblivious to DAACPs, many more are believed to be hidden in organisms and novel methods to tackle DAACPs are sought. Linear ion mobility spectrometry (IMS) can distinguish and characterize the d/l-epimers but is restricted by poor orthogonality to MS as in other contexts. We now bring to this area the newer technique of differential IMS (FAIMS). The orthogonality of MS to high-resolution FAIMS exceeded that to linear IMS by 6×, the greatest factor found for biomolecules so far. Hence, FAIMS has achieved the 2.5× resolution of trapped IMS on average despite a lower resolving power, fully separating all 18 pairs of representative epimer species with masses of ∼400-5,000 Da and charge states of 1-6. A constant isomer resolution over these ranges allows projecting success for yet larger DAACPs.

Ion Mobility Spectrometry of Superheated Macromolecules at Electric Fields up to 500 Td.

Since its inception in 1980s, differential or field asymmetric waveform ion mobility spectrometry (FAIMS) has been implemented at or near ambient gas pressure. We recently developed FAIMS at 15-30 Torr with mass spectrometry and utilized it to analyze amino acids, isomeric peptides, and protein conformers. The separations broadly mirrored those at atmospheric pressure, save for larger proteins that (as predicted) exhibited dipole alignment at ambient but not low pressure. Here we reduce the pressure down to 4.7 Torr, allowing normalized electric fields up to 543 Td-double the maximum in prior FAIMS or IMS studies of polyatomic ions. Despite the collisional heating to ∼1000 °C at the waveform peaks, the proteins of size from ubiquitin to albumin survived intact. The dissociation of macromolecules in FAIMS appears governed by the average ion temperature over the waveform cycle, unlike the isomerization controlled by the peak temperature. The global separation trends in this "superhot" regime extend those at moderately low pressures, with distinct conformers and no alignment as theorized. Although the scaling of the compensation voltage with the field fell below cubic at lower fields, the resolving power increased and the resolution of different proteins or charge states substantially improved.

Low-Field Differential Ion Mobility Spectrometry of Dipole-Aligned Macromolecules.

Ion mobility spectrometry (IMS) with mass spectrometry has grown into a powerful approach to simplify complex mixtures, disentangle isomers, and elucidate their geometries. Two established branches are linear IMS based on the absolute mobility K at moderate normalized electric field E/N and field asymmetric waveform IMS (FAIMS) relying on the evolution of K at high E/N causing strong ion heating. Here, we introduce low-field differential IMS (LODIMS), where the field is too weak for significant heating but suffices to lock the permanent macromolecular ion dipoles, producing novel separations based solely on their alignment. The method is demonstrated for a prototypical large protein-albumin. Its oligomers start separating at fields of just 1 kV/cm (4 Td), or ∼5% of those typical for FAIMS. Negligible ion heating at such fields allows preserving fragile species, in particular the noncovalent complexes up to pentamers (332 kDa) destroyed in FAIMS and not detected without it. The separation parameter (compensation field, EC) in this regime scales with the field linearly versus cubically in FAIMS. The dipole moments obtained from threshold fields for alignment and directional cross sections estimated from the slope of said linear EC dependence appear reasonable.

Middle-Down Proteomic Analyses with Ion Mobility Separations of Endogenous Isomeric Proteoforms.

Biological functions of many proteins are governed by post-translational modifications (PTMs). In particular, the rich PTM complement in histones controls the gene expression and chromatin structure with major health implications via a combinatoric language. Deciphering that "histone code" is the great challenge for proteomics given an astounding number of possible proteoforms, including isomers with different PTM positions. These must be disentangled on the top- or middle-down level to preserve the key PTM connectivity, which condensed-phase separations failed to achieve. We reported the capability of ion mobility spectrometry (IMS) methods to resolve such isomers for model histone tails. Here, we advance to biological samples, showing middle-down analyses of histones from mouse embryonic stem cells via online chromatography to fractionate proteoforms with distinct PTM sets, differential or field asymmetric waveform IMS (FAIMS) to resolve the isomers, and Orbitrap mass spectrometry with electron transfer dissociation to identify the resolved species.

Recommendations for reporting ion mobility Mass Spectrometry measurements.

Here we present a guide to ion mobility mass spectrometry experiments, which covers both linear and nonlinear methods: what is measured, how the measurements are done, and how to report the results, including the uncertainties of mobility and collision cross section values. The guide aims to clarify some possibly confusing concepts, and the reporting recommendations should help researchers, authors and reviewers to contribute comprehensive reports, so that the ion mobility data can be reused more confidently. Starting from the concept of the definition of the measurand, we emphasize that (i) mobility values (K0 ) depend intrinsically on ion structure, the nature of the bath gas, temperature, and E/N; (ii) ion mobility does not measure molecular surfaces directly, but collision cross section (CCS) values are derived from mobility values using a physical model; (iii) methods relying on calibration are empirical (and thus may provide method-dependent results) only if the gas nature, temperature or E/N cannot match those of the primary method. Our analysis highlights the urgency of a community effort toward establishing primary standards and reference materials for ion mobility, and provides recommendations to do so. © 2019 The Authors. Mass Spectrometry Reviews Published by Wiley Periodicals, Inc.

Elemental Dependence of Structurally Specific Isotopic Shifts in High-Field Ion Mobility Spectra.

Nearly all molecules incorporate at least one element with stable isotopes, yielding ubiquitous isotopologic envelopes in mass spectra. Those envelopes split in differential or field asymmetric waveform ion mobility (FAIMS) spectra depending on the ion geometry, enabling a new general approach to isomer delineation as we demonstrated for chloroanilines. Here, we report that analogous bromoanilines exhibit qualitatively distinct isotopic shifts under identical conditions, some changing signs depending on the gas. This dramatic elemental specificity conveys the breadth and diversity of structural isotopic effect in FAIMS, suggesting unique information-rich patterns for compounds involving various elements and feasibility of enhancing the structural elucidation by atom substitution. We also introduce the capability to make or ensure structural assignments employing major isomer-specific peak broadening due to unresolved isotopomer mixtures.

Ion Mobility Spectrometry of Macromolecules with Dipole Alignment Switchable by Varying the Gas Pressure.

Since inception in the 1980s, differential or field asymmetric waveform ion mobility spectrometry (FAIMS) was implemented at or near the ambient gas pressure (AP). Recently, we developed FAIMS at 15-30 Torr within a mass spectrometer and demonstrated it for small and medium sized ions, including peptides. The overall separation properties mirrored those at AP, reflecting the shared underlying physics. Here we extend these analyses to macromolecules, namely, multiply charged proteins generated by electrospray ionization. The spectra for smaller proteins (ubiquitin, cytochrome c, myoglobin) again resemble those at AP, producing features for one or a few adjacent well-defined conformers with type C behavior. Large proteins (single aldolase domain and albumin) now follow, with no broad bands for type A or B species that dominated at 1 atm. Those unique behaviors were ascribed to pendular ions with electric dipoles reversibly locked by the strong field in FAIMS. Disappearance of those bands shows loss of alignment predicted by first-principles theory, further supporting dipole locking at AP. The capability to modulate dipole alignment by varying gas pressure at constant normalized field provides the basis for determining the ion dipole moment and direction within the molecular frame from the pressure of onset and characteristics of spectral drift. This new approach to alter FAIMS separations of proteins could make a powerful tool for structural biology and be useful for proteomics and imaging.

Differential Ion Mobility Separations/Mass Spectrometry with High Resolution in Both Dimensions.

Strong orthogonality to mass spectrometry makes differential ion mobility spectrometry (FAIMS) a powerful tool for isomer separations. However, high FAIMS resolution has been achieved overall only with buffers rich in He or H2. That obstructed coupling to Fourier transform mass spectrometers operating under ultrahigh vacuum, but exceptional m/ z resolution and accuracy of FTMS are indispensable for frontline biological and environmental applications. By raising the waveform amplitude to 6 kV, we enabled high FAIMS resolution using solely N2 and thus straightforward integration with any MS platform: here Orbitrap XL with the electron transfer dissociation (ETD) option. The initial evaluation for complete histone tails (50 residues) with diverse post-translational modifications on alternative sites demonstrates a broad capability to separate and confidently identify the PTM localization variants in the middle-down range.

High-Resolution Differential Ion Mobility Separations/Orbitrap Mass Spectrometry without Buffer Gas Limitations.

Strong orthogonality between differential ion mobility spectrometry (FAIMS) and mass spectrometry (MS) makes their hybrid a powerful approach to separate isomers and isobars. Harnessing that power depends on high resolution in both dimensions. The ultimate mass resolution and accuracy are delivered by Fourier Transform MS increasingly realized in Orbitrap MS, whereas FAIMS resolution is generally maximized by buffers rich in He or H2 that elevate ion mobility and lead to prominent non-Blanc effects. However, turbomolecular pumps have lower efficiency for light gas molecules and their flow from the FAIMS stage complicates maintaining the ultrahigh vacuum (UHV) needed for Orbitrap operation. Here we address this challenge via two hardware modifications: (i) a differential pumping step between FAIMS and MS stages and (ii) reconfiguration of vacuum lines to isolate pumping of the high vacuum (HV) region. Either greatly ameliorates the pressure increases upon He or H2 aspiration. This development enables free optimization of FAIMS carrier gas without concerns about MS performance, maximizing the utility and flexibility of FAIMS/MS platforms.

Identification of Isomers by Multidimensional Isotopic Shifts in High-Field Ion Mobility Spectra.

Nearly all molecules incorporate elements with stable isotopes. The resulting isotopologue envelopes in mass spectra tell the exact stoichiometry but nothing about the geometry. Chromatography and electrophoresis at high resolution also can distinguish isotopologues, again without revealing structural information. In high-definition differential ion mobility (FAIMS) spectra, these envelopes universally split in a structure-specific manner, providing a new general approach to isomer delineation. Here, we show that the peak shifts from instances of the same isotope are equal and can be averaged into characteristic elemental shifts, namely 13C and 37Cl for dichloroanilines (DCA). Matrices of these shifts, including the gas composition dimension, are unique to the structure. Hence, all six DCA isomers (with four making two unresolved pairs) are readily delineated in the 13C/37Cl maps with He/CO2 buffer gases. Mixtures of coeluting isomers are also distinguished from pure components.

Molecular Structure Characterization by Isotopic Splitting in Nonlinear Ion Mobility Spectra.

Nearly all compounds comprise numerous isotopologues ensuing from stable natural isotopes for constituent elements. The consequent isotopic envelopes in mass spectra can reveal the ion stoichiometry but not geometry. We found those envelopes to split in differential ion mobility (FAIMS) spectra in a manner dependent on the ion geometry and buffer gas composition. The resulting multidimensional matrix of isotopic shifts is specific to isomers, providing a fundamentally new approach to the characterization of chemical structure. The physical origins of the effect remain to be clarified but likely ensue from the transposition of center of mass of the ion within its geometry frame affecting the partition of energy in above-thermal collisions between the translational and rotational degrees of freedom. The additivity of shifts, holding with no exception so far, may be the key to unraveling the foundations of observed behavior.

Differential Ion Mobility Separations in the Low-Pressure Regime.

Ion mobility spectrometry (IMS) in conjunction with mass spectrometry (MS) has emerged as a powerful platform for biological and environmental analyses. An inherent advantage of differential or field asymmetric waveform IMS (FAIMS) based on the derivative of mobility vs electric field over linear IMS based on absolute mobility is much greater orthogonality to MS. Effective coupling of linear IMS to MS and diverse IMS/MS arrangements and modalities impossible at ambient buffer gas pressure were enabled at much reduced pressures. In contrast, FAIMS devices operate at or near atmospheric pressure, which complicated integration with MS. Here, we show FAIMS at ∼15-30 Torr using a planar-gap stage within the MS instrument envelope. Fields up to ∼300 Td permitted by the Paschen law at these pressures greatly raise the separation speed, providing fair resolution in ∼10 ms and FAIMS scans in under 5 s. Rapid separation and efficient ion collection at low pressure minimize losses in the FAIMS step. Separations for key analyte classes and their dependences on electric field mirror those at ambient pressure. The potential for proteomics is demonstrated by separations of isomeric peptides with variant localization of post-translational modifications.

Linear and Differential Ion Mobility Separations of Middle-Down Proteoforms.

Comprehensive characterization of proteomes comprising the same proteins with distinct post-translational modifications (PTMs) is a staggering challenge. Many such proteoforms are isomers (localization variants) that require separation followed by top-down or middle-down mass spectrometric analyses, but condensed-phase separations are ineffective in those size ranges. The variants for "middle-down" peptides were resolved by differential ion mobility spectrometry (FAIMS), relying on the mobility increment at high electric fields, but not previously by linear IMS on the basis of absolute mobility. We now use complete histone tails with diverse PTMs on alternative sites to demonstrate that high-resolution linear IMS, here trapped IMS (TIMS), broadly resolves the variants of ∼50 residues in full or into binary mixtures quantifiable by tandem MS, largely thanks to orthogonal separations across charge states. Separations using traveling-wave (TWIMS) and/or involving various time scales and electrospray ionization source conditions are similar (with lower resolution for TWIMS), showing the transferability of results across linear IMS instruments. The linear IMS and FAIMS dimensions are substantially orthogonal, suggesting FAIMS/IMS/MS as a powerful platform for proteoform analyses.

Characterization of Complete Histone Tail Proteoforms Using Differential Ion Mobility Spectrometry.

Histone proteins are subject to dynamic post-translational modifications (PTMs) that cooperatively modulate the chromatin structure and function. Nearly all functional PTMs are found on the N-terminal histone domains (tails) of ∼50 residues protruding from the nucleosome core. Using high-definition differential ion mobility spectrometry (FAIMS) with electron transfer dissociation, we demonstrate rapid baseline gas-phase separation and identification of tails involving monomethylation, trimethylation, acetylation, or phosphorylation in biologically relevant positions. These are by far the largest variant peptides resolved by any method, some with PTM contributing just 0.25% to the mass. This opens the door to similar separations for intact proteins and in top-down proteomics.

Ultrahigh-resolution differential ion mobility separations of conformers for proteins above 10 kDa: onset of dipole alignment?

Biomacromolecules tend to assume numerous structures in solution or the gas phase. It has been possible to resolve disparate conformational families but not unique geometries within each, and drastic peak broadening has been the bane of protein analyses by chromatography, electrophoresis, and ion mobility spectrometry (IMS). The new differential or field asymmetric waveform IMS (FAIMS) approach using hydrogen-rich gases was recently found to separate conformers of a small protein ubiquitin with the same peak width and resolving power up to ∼400 as for peptides. The present work explores the reach of this approach for larger proteins, exemplified by cytochrome c and myoglobin. Resolution similar to that for ubiquitin was largely achieved with longer separations, while the onset of peak broadening and coalescence with shorter separations suggests the limitation of the present technique to proteins under ∼20 kDa. This capability may enable one to distinguish whole proteins with differing residue sequences or localizations of post-translational modifications. Small features at negative compensation voltages that markedly grow from cytochrome c to myoglobin indicate the dipole alignment of rare conformers in accord with theory, further supporting the concept of pendular macroions in FAIMS.