From microbial membrane proteins to the mysteries of emotion.

On the occasion of the 2021 Lasker Basic Medical Research Award to Karl Deisseroth, Peter Hegemann, and Dieter Oesterhelt (for "the discovery of light-sensitive microbial proteins that can activate or deactivate individual brain cells-leading to the development of optogenetics and revolutionizing neuroscience"), Deisseroth reflects on this international collaboration, his basic mechanistic and structural discoveries regarding microbial channels that transduce photons into ion current, the causal exploration of brain cell function, and the pressing mysteries of psychiatry.

Roles of functional lipids in bacteriorhodopsin photocycle in various delipidated purple membranes.

Purple membrane (PM) is composed of several native lipids and the transmembrane protein bacteriorhodopsin (bR) in trimeric configuration. The delipidated PM (dPM) samples can be prepared by treating PM with CHAPS (3-[(3-cholamidopropyl)dimethylammonio]-1-propanesulfonate) to partially remove native lipids while maintaining bR in the trimeric configuration. By correlating the photocycle kinetics of bR and the exact lipid compositions of the various dPM samples, one can reveal the roles of native PM lipids. However, it is challenging to compare the lipid compositions of the various dPM samples quantitatively. Here, we utilize the absorbances of extracted retinal at 382 nm to normalize the concentrations of the remaining lipids in each dPM sample, which were then quantified by mass spectrometry, allowing us to compare the lipid compositions of different samples in a quantitative manner. The corresponding photocycle kinetics of bR were probed by transient difference absorption spectroscopy. We found that the removal rate of the polar lipids follows the order of BPG ≈ GlyC < S-TGD-1 ≈ PG < PGP-Me ≈ PGS. Since BPG and GlyC have more nonpolar phytanyl groups than other lipids at the hydrophobic tail, causing a higher affinity with the hydrophobic surface of bR, the corresponding removal rates are slowest. In addition, as the reaction period of PM and CHAPS increases, the residual amounts of PGS and PGP-Me significantly decrease, in concomitance with the decelerated rates of the recovery of ground state and the decay of intermediate M, and the reduced transient population of intermediate O. PGS and PGP-Me are the lipids with the highest correlation to the photocycle activity among the six polar lipids of PM. From a practical viewpoint, combining optical spectroscopy and mass spectrometry appears a promising approach to simultaneously track the functions and the concomitant active components in a given biological system.

Nanohybrid Structures Based on Plasmonic or Fluorescent Nanoparticles and Retinal-Containing Proteins.

Rhodopsins are light-sensitive membrane proteins enabling transmembrane charge separation (proton pump) on absorption of a light quantum. Bacteriorhodopsin (BR) is a transmembrane protein from halophilic bacteria that belongs to the rhodopsin family. Potential applications of BR are considered so promising that the number of studies devoted to the use of BR itself, its mutant variants, as well as hybrid materials containing BR in various areas grows steadily. Formation of hybrid structures combining BR with nanoparticles is an essential step in promotion of BR-based devices. However, rapid progress, continuous emergence of new data, as well as challenges of analyzing the entire data require regular reviews of the achievements in this area. This review is devoted to the issues of formation of materials based on hybrids of BR with fluorescent semiconductor nanocrystals (quantum dots) and with noble metal (silver, gold) plasmonic nanoparticles. Recent data on formation of thin (mono-) and thick (multi-) layers from materials containing BR and BR/nanoparticle hybrids are presented.

Uniaxial Symmetry Breaking in Bacteriorhodopsin at the Thermal Phase Transition of Lipids of Purple Membranes.

The article correlates between symmetry breaking and phase transition. An analogy, extending from physics to biology, is known to exist between these two topics. Bacteriorhodopsin (bR) as a paradigm of membrane proteins has been used as a case study in the present work. The bR, as the sole protein embedded in what is called a purple membrane (PM), has attracted widespread interest in bionanotechnological applications. The lipids of PM have a crucial role in maintaining the crystal lattice of bR inside PM. For this reason, the present work has been concerned with elucidating the thermal phase transition properties of the PM lipids in orthogonal directions. The results indicated that the axial symmetry of bR exhibits considerable changes occurring at the thermal phase transition of lipids. These changes are brought by an anomaly observed in the time course of orthogonal electric responses during the application of thermal fields on PM. The observed anomaly may bear on symmetry breaking in bR occurring at the phase transition of lipids based on such analogy found between symmetry breaking and phase transition. Lipid-protein interactions may underlie the broken axial symmetry of bR at such lipid thermal transition of PM. Accordingly, thermally perturbed axial symmetry of bR may be of biological relevance relying on the essence of the crystal lattice of bR. Most importantly, a question has to be raised in the present study: Can bR, as a helical protein with broken axial symmetry, affect the symmetry breaking of helical light? This may be of potential technical applications based on a recent discovery that bR breaks the symmetry of helical light.

Role of trimer-trimer interaction of bacteriorhodopsin studied by optical spectroscopy and high-speed atomic force microscopy.

Bacteriorhodopsin (bR) trimers form a two-dimensional hexagonal lattice in the purple membrane of Halobacterium salinarum. However, the physiological significance of forming the lattice has long been elusive. Here, we study this issue by comparing properties of assembled and non-assembled bR trimers using directed mutagenesis, high-speed atomic force microscopy (HS-AFM), optical spectroscopy, and a proton pumping assay. First, we show that the bonds formed between W12 and F135 amino acid residues are responsible for trimer-trimer association that leads to lattice assembly; the lattice is completely disrupted in both W12I and F135I mutants. HS-AFM imaging reveals that both crystallized D96N and non-crystallized D96N/W12I mutants undergo a large conformational change (i.e., outward E-F loop displacement) upon light-activation. However, lattice disruption significantly reduces the rate of conformational change under continuous light illumination. Nevertheless, the quantum yield of M-state formation, measured by low-temperature UV-visible spectroscopy, and proton pumping efficiency are unaffected by lattice disruption. From these results, we conclude that trimer-trimer association plays essential roles in providing bound retinal with an appropriate environment to maintain its full photo-reactivity and in maintaining the natural photo-reaction pathway.

Facile isolation of purple membrane from Halobacterium salinarum via aqueous-two-phase system.

Purple membrane (PM) is a part of cytoplasmic membrane in certain extreme halophilic microorganisms belonging to Domain Archaea. It transduces light energy to generate proton gradient for ATP synthesis in the microorganisms. Bacteriorhodopsin (BR) is the only protein in PM responsible for the generation of proton gradient. Generally, PM was purified from Halobacterium salinarum via a tedious and lengthy sucrose density gradient ultracentrifugation (SGU). In this work, a facile method based on polyethyleneglycol (PEG)-phosphate aqueous-two- phase extraction system (ATPS) was employed to purify PM from cell lysate of H. salinarum. The results showed that PM could be completely recovered from the interface of PEG-phosphate ATPS with BR purity ca 94.1% as measured by UV-visible absorption spectra. In comparison with PM obtained by SGU, the PM isolated by ATPS could achieve the same level of purity and photocurrent activity (ca 177.2nA/µgBR/cm(2)) as analyzed by SDS-PAGE and photocurrent measurement, respectively. The easily scalable and straightforward ATPS procedure demonstrated that PM can be purified and recovered more cost-effectively with a significantly reduced operation time that should lead to broader range applications of PM possible.

Detection of Lipid-Bound Bacteriorhodopsin Trimer Complex Directly from Purple Membrane by Native Mass Spectrometry.

Native mass spectrometry (MS) was used to detect the membrane protein, bacteriorhodopsin (bR), in its 27 kDa monomeric form and trimeric assemblies directly from lipid-containing purple membranes (PMs) from the halophilic archaeon, Halobacterium salinarum. Trimer bR ion populations bound to lipid molecules were detected with n-octyl ß-d-glucopyranoside as the solubilizing detergent; the use of octyl tetraethylene glycol monooctyl ether or n-dodecyl-ß-d-maltopyranoside resulted in only detection of monomeric bR. The archaeal lipids phosphotidylglycerolphosphate methyl ester and 3-HSO3-Galp-ß1,6-Manp-α1,2-Glcp-α1,1-sn-2,3-diphytanylglycerol were the only lipids in the PMs found to bind to bR, consistent with previous high-resolution structural studies. Removal of the lipids from the sample resulted in the detection of only the bR monomer, highlighting the importance of specific lipids for stabilizing the bR trimer. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first report of the detection of the bR trimer with resolved lipid-bound species by MS.

Detection of bacteriorhodopsin trimeric rotation at thermal phase transitions of purple membrane in suspension.

Bacteriorhodopsin (bR) of purple membrane (PM) is a retinal protein that forms aggregates in the form of trimers constituting, together with archaeal lipids, the crystalline structure of PM. The rotary motion of bR inside PM may be pertinent in understanding the essence of the crystalline lattice. An attempt has been made to determine the rotation of bR trimers which has been found to be detected solely at thermal phase transitions of PM, namely lipid, crystalline lattice and protein melting phase transitions. The temperature dependences of dielectric versus electronic absorption spectra of bR have been determined. The results suggest that the rotation of bR trimers, together with concomitant bending of PM, are most likely brought by structural changes in bR which might be driven by retinal isomerization and mediated by lipid. The rupturing of the lipid-protein contact might consequently lead to rotation of trimers associated with bending, curling or vesicle formation of PM. So the retinal reorientation may underlie the concomitant rotation of trimers. Most importantly, rotation of trimers might play a role, in terms of the essence of the crystalline lattice, in the functional activity of bR and may serve physiological relevance.

Origins of phase contrast in the atomic force microscope in liquids.

We study the physical origins of phase contrast in dynamic atomic force microscopy (dAFM) in liquids where low-stiffness microcantilever probes are often used for nanoscale imaging of soft biological samples with gentle forces. Under these conditions, we show that the phase contrast derives primarily from a unique energy flow channel that opens up in liquids due to the momentary excitation of higher eigenmodes. Contrary to the common assumption, phase-contrast images in liquids using soft microcantilevers are often maps of short-range conservative interactions, such as local elastic response, rather than tip-sample dissipation. The theory is used to demonstrate variations in local elasticity of purple membrane and bacteriophage 29 virions in buffer solutions using the phase-contrast images.

Deposition of bacteriorhodopsin protein in a purple membrane form on nitrocellulose membranes for enhanced photoelectric response.

Bacteriorhodopsin protein (bR)-based systems are one of the simplest known biological energy converters. The robust chemical, thermal and electrochemical properties of bR have made it an attractive material for photoelectric devices. This study demonstrates the photoelectric response of a dry bR layer deposited on a nitrocellulose membrane with indium tin oxide (ITO) electrodes. Light-induced electrical current as well as potential and impedance changes of dried bR film were recorded as the function of illumination. We have also tested bR in solution and found that the electrical properties are strongly dependent on light intensity changing locally proton concentration and thus pH of the solution. Experimental data support the assumption that bR protein on a positively charged nitrocellulose membrane (PNM) can be used as highly sensitive photo- and pH detector. Here the bR layer facilitates proton translocation and acts as an ultrafast optoelectric signal transducer. It is therefore useful in applications related to bioelectronics, biosensors, bio-optics devices and current carrying junction devices.

Detection of membrane protein two-dimensional crystals in living cells.

It is notoriously difficult to grow membrane protein crystals and solve membrane protein structures. Improved detection and screening of membrane protein crystals are needed. We have shown here that second-order nonlinear optical imaging of chiral crystals based on second harmonic generation can provide sensitive and selective detection of two-dimensional protein crystalline arrays with sufficiently low background to enable crystal detection within the membranes of live cells. The method was validated using bacteriorhodopsin crystals generated in live Halobacterium halobium bacteria and confirmed by electron microscopy from the isolated crystals. Additional studies of alphavirus glycoproteins indicated the presence of localized crystalline domains associated with virus budding from mammalian cells. These results suggest that in vivo crystallization may provide a means for expediting membrane protein structure determination for proteins exhibiting propensities for two-dimensional crystal formation.

Sensitive detection of protein-lipid interaction change on bacteriorhodopsin using dodecyl ß-D-maltoside.

A light-driven proton pump bacteriorhodopsin (bR) forms a two-dimensional hexagonal lattice with about 10 archaeal lipids per monomer bR on purple membrane (PM) of Halobacterium salinarum. In this study, we found that the weakening of the bR-lipid interaction on PM by addition of alcohol can be detected as the significant increase of protein solubility in a nonionic detergent, dodecyl ß-D-maltoside (DDM). The protein solubility in DDM was also increased by bR-lipid interaction change accompanied by structural change of the apoprotein after retinal removal and was about 7 times higher in the case of completely bleached membrane than that of intact PM. Interestingly, the cyclic and milliseconds order of structural change of bR under light irradiation also led to increasing the protein solubility and had a characteristic light intensity dependence with a phase transition. These results indicate that there is a photointermediate in which bR-lipid interaction has been changed by its dynamic structural change. Because partial delipidation of PM by CHAPS gave minor influence for the change of the protein solubility compared to intact PM in both dark and light conditions, it is suggested that specific interactions of bR with some lipids which remain on PM even after delipidation treatment have a key role for the change of solubility in DDM induced by alcohol binding, ligand release, and photon absorption on bR.

Binding, reconstitution and 2D crystallization of membrane or soluble proteins onto functionalized lipid layer observed in situ by reflected light microscopy.

Monolayer of functionalized lipid spread at the air/water interface is used for the structural analysis of soluble and membrane proteins by electron crystallography and single particle analysis. This powerful approach lacks of a method for the screening of the binding of proteins to the surface of the lipid layer. Here, we described an optical method based on the use of reflected light microscopy to image, without the use of any labeling, the lipid layer at the surface of buffers in the Teflon wells used for 2D crystallization. Images revealed that the lipid layer was made of a monolayer coexisting with liposomes or aggregates of lipids floating at the surface. Protein binding led to an increase of the contrast and the decrease of the fluidity of the lipid surface, as demonstrated with the binding of soluble Shiga toxin B subunit, of purple membrane and of solubilized His-BmrA, a bacterial ABC transporter. Moreover the reconstitution of membrane proteins bound to the lipidic surface upon detergent removal can be followed through the appearance of large recognizable domains at the surface. Proteins binding and reconstitution were further confirmed by electron microcopy. Overall, this method provides a quick evaluation of the monolayer trials, a significant reduction in screening by transmission electron microscopy and new insights in the proteins binding and 2D crystallogenesis at the lipid surface.

Combination of extended X-ray absorption fine structure spectroscopy with lipidic cubic phases for the study of cation binding in bacteriorhodopsin.

We have performed a quantitative X-ray absorption fine structure analysis of bacteriorhodopsin in purple membrane patches and in lipidic cubic phases regenerated with Mn(2+). Lipidic cubic phases and purple membrane results have been compared, demonstrating that the lipidic cubic phase process does not introduce relevant distortions in the local geometry of the cation binding sites. For both samples, we have observed similarities for Mn(2+) coordination in terms of type, number, and average distances of surrounding atoms, indicating a first coordination shell composed by 6 O atoms, and 3/4 C atoms located in the second coordination shell.

pH-dependent bending in and out of purple membranes comprising BR-D85T.

The light-driven proton pump bacteriorhodopsin (BR) embedded in a purple membrane (PM) from Halobacterium salinarum undergoes a series of conformational changes while transporting a proton from the cytoplasmic to the extracellular side over the course of the so-called photocycle. Wild-type BR variant D85T, where aspartic acid 85 is replaced by threonine, allows for the study of structural intermediates of this photocycle that are formed in a light-dependent manner in the wild-type and in thermal equilibrium by tuning the pH of the D85T purple membrane suspension. Especially the last and least studied O-intermediate of the photocycle of bacteriorhodopsin has caught recent attention. First AFM images of D85T under acidic conditions resembling wild-type BR under physiological conditions in the O-photocycle-intermediate are presented. Bacteriorhodopsins embedded in the strongly bent purple membranes were analyzed by single molecule force spectroscopy (SMFS) providing the first single molecule force spectra of BR in the O-intermediate. SMFS was further employed to determine the absolute sign of membrane curvature. Complementary electrostatic force microscopy (EFM) was performed to support PM side discrimination and determination of the bending direction. Bending of PM-D85T was analyzed in more detail providing further insight into the structure-function relationship of the bacteriorhodopsin proton pump as well as PM behaviour at the solid-liquid junction. Findings reported here are of general interest to the field of chemomechanical transducers.

Elastase digests: new ammunition for shotgun membrane proteomics.

Despite many advances in membrane proteomics during the last decade the fundamental problem of accessing the transmembrane regions itself has only been addressed to some extent. The present study establishes a method for the nano-LC-based analysis of complex membrane proteomes on the basis of a methanolic porcine pancreatic elastase digest to increase transmembrane coverage. Halobacterium salinarium purple and Corynebacterium glutamicum membranes were successfully analyzed by using the new protocol. We demonstrated that elastase digests yield a large proportion of transmembrane peptides, facilitating membrane protein identification. The potential for characterization of a membrane protein through full sequence coverage using elastase is there but is restricted to the higher abundance protein components. Compatibility of the work flow with the two most common mass spectrometric ionization techniques, ESI and MALDI, was shown. Currently better results are obtained using ESI mainly because of the low response of MALDI for strictly neutral peptides. New findings concerning elastase specificity in complex protein mixtures reveal a new prospect beyond the application in shotgun experiments. Furthermore peptide mass fingerprinting with less specific enzymes might be done in the near future but requires an adaptation of current search algorithms to the new proteases.

Experimental evidence for membrane-mediated protein-protein interaction.

Membrane proteins diffuse within the membrane, form oligomers and supramolecular assemblies. Using high-speed atomic force microscopy, we present direct experimental measure of an in-membrane-plane interaction potential between membrane proteins. In purple membranes, ATP-synthase c-rings formed dimers that temporarily dissociated. C-ring dimers revealed subdiffusive motion, while dissociated monomers diffused freely. C-rings center-to-center distance probability distribution allowed the calculation and modeling of an in-membrane-plane energy landscape that presented repulsion at 80 Å, most stable dimer association at 103 Å (-3.5 k(B)T strength), and dissociation at 125 Å (-1 k(B)T strength). This first experimental data of nonlabeled membrane protein diffusion and the corresponding in-membrane-plane interaction energy landscape characterized membrane protein interaction with an attractive range of several k(B)T that reaches to a radius of ∼50 Å within the membrane plane.

Overcoming merohedral twinning in crystals of bacteriorhodopsin grown in lipidic mesophase.

Twinning is one of the most common crystal-growth defects in protein crystallography. There are neither efficient rational approaches for the growth of nontwinned protein crystals nor are there examples of systematic studies of the dependence of the twinning-ratio distribution on crystallization conditions. The description of the twinning phenomenon has been covered even less for membrane-protein crystals and is non-existent for crystals grown using lipidic phases (in meso). In the present work, possibilities for overcoming merohedral twinning are investigated for crystals of the membrane protein bacteriorhodopsin (bR) grown in meso. It is shown that traditional crystallization additives are not effective in the case of the in meso crystallization of bR. The twinning ratio was determined for 310 crystals grown under different crystallization conditions. A correlation of the twinning ratio with the growth rate of the crystals was observed. Slow growth indicated that crystals had a noticeable chance of avoiding twinning. Model calculations were performed in order to rationalize this observation. The calculations confirmed the experimental observation that most crystals consist of two twin domains and showed that under this condition small changes in the probability of twin-domain formation lead to dramatic changes in the number of nontwinned crystals, which explains why slow crystal growth results in a considerable number of nontwinned crystals.

A neutron diffraction study of purple membranes under pressure.

Neutron diffraction from hydrated stacks of natural two-dimensional crystal patches of purple membrane from Halobacterium salinarum was studied as a function of pressure. Measurements in H(2)O and D(2)O permitted the determination of the distribution of water of hydration in the in-plane projection of the membrane. The main experimental difference observed between the samples at 300 MPa and atmospheric pressure was a major reorganization of the hydration around the lipid head groups and protein, associated with a protein conformational change and small reductions in lamellar (stacking) and in-plane lattice spacings, which was consistent with the compressibility of membrane-protein and lipid components.

Effect of the fluorination degree of partially fluorinated octyl-phosphocholine surfactants on their interfacial properties and interactions with purple membrane as a membrane protein model.

Interfacial properties and membrane protein solubilization activity of a series of partially fluorinated octyl-phosphocholine (PC) surfactants were investigated from the viewpoint of the fluorination degree of the hydrophobic chain. The critical micelle concentration (CMC), surface tension lowering activity, molecular occupied area at the CMC and free energy changes of micellization as well as adsorption to the air-water interface for each PC surfactant were estimated from surface tension measurements at 25 °C. The PCs with higher degree of fluorination exhibited low CMC and high surface activity, while the single trifluoromethyl group at the end of the chain appeared to enhance the hydrophilicity of the surfactant molecule. Under conditions where conventional short-chain surfactants, n-octyl-ß-D-glucoside, Triton X-100 and dioctanoylphosphatidylcholine significantly solubilize purple membranes (PM), none of the fluorinated-PCs solubilized PM. This suggests that fluorinated-PCs are low-invasive enough to maintain the structure of lipids/protein assemblies like PM.