Backbone Modification in a Protein Hydrophobic Core.

Targeted protein backbone modification can recreate tertiary structures reminiscent of folds found in nature on artificial scaffolds with improved biostability. Incorporation of altered monomers in such entities is typically limited to sites distant from the hydrophobic core to avoid potential disruptions to folding. This is limiting, as it is advantageous in some applications to incorporate artificial connectivity at buried sites. Here, we report an examination of protein backbone modification targeted specifically to hydrophobic core positions and its impacts on tertiary folded structure and fold stability. Different artificial monomer types are placed at core, core-flanking, or solvent-exposed positions in a compact three-helix protein. Effects on structure and folding energetics are assessed by NMR spectroscopy and biophysical methods. Results show that artificial residues can be well accommodated in the hydrophobic core of a defined tertiary fold, with effects on stability only modestly larger than identical changes at solvent-exposed sites. Collectively, these results provide new insights into folding behavior of protein-like artificial chains as well as strategies for the design of such molecules.

Protein Backbone Alteration in Non-Hairpin ß-Turns: Impacts on Tertiary Folded Structure and Folded Stability.

The importance of ß-turns to protein folding has motivated extensive efforts to stabilize the motif with non-canonical backbone connectivity. Prior work has focused almost exclusively on turns between strands in a ß-sheet (i. e., hairpins). Turns in other structural contexts are also common in nature and have distinct conformational preferences; however, design principles for their mimicry remain poorly understood. Here, we report strategies that stabilize non-hairpin ß-turns through systematic evaluation of the impacts of backbone alteration on the high-resolution folded structure and folded stability of a helix-loop-helix prototype protein. Several well-established hairpin turn mimetics are shown detrimental to folded stability and/or hydrophobic core packing, while less-explored modification schemes that reinforce alternate turn types lead to improved stability and more faithful structural mimicry. Collectively, these results have implications in control over protein folding through chemical modification as well as the design of protein mimetics.

Effects of chirality and side chain length in Cα,α-dialkylated residues on ß-hairpin peptide folded structure and stability.

Strategic incorporation of achiral Cα,α-dialkylated amino acids with bulky substituents into peptides can be used to promote extended strand conformations and inhibit protein-protein interactions associated with amyloid formation. In this work, we evaluate the thermodynamic impact of chiral Cα,α monomers on folding preferences in such systems through introduction of a series of Cα-methylated and Cα-ethylated residues into a ß-hairpin host sequence. Depending on stereochemical configuration of the artificial monomer and potential for additional hydrophobic packing, a Cα-ethyl-Cα-propyl glycine residue can provide similar or enhanced folded stability relative to an achiral Cα,α-diethyl analogue.

A twist in the road less traveled: The AMBER ff15ipq-m force field for protein mimetics.

We present a new force field, AMBER ff15ipq-m, for simulations of protein mimetics in applications from therapeutics to biomaterials. This force field is an expansion of the AMBER ff15ipq force field that was developed for canonical proteins and enables the modeling of four classes of artificial backbone units that are commonly used alongside natural α residues in blended or "heterogeneous" backbones: chirality-reversed D-α-residues, the Cα-methylated α-residue Aib, homologated ß-residues (ß3) bearing proteinogenic side chains, and two cyclic ß residues (ßcyc; APC and ACPC). The ff15ipq-m force field includes 472 unique atomic charges and 148 unique torsion terms. Consistent with the AMBER IPolQ lineage of force fields, the charges were derived using the Implicitly Polarized Charge (IPolQ) scheme in the presence of explicit solvent. To our knowledge, no general force field reported to date models the combination of artificial building blocks examined here. In addition, we have derived Karplus coefficients for the calculation of backbone amide J-coupling constants for ß3Ala and ACPC ß residues. The AMBER ff15ipq-m force field reproduces experimentally observed J-coupling constants in simple tetrapeptides and maintains the expected conformational propensities in reported structures of proteins/peptides containing the artificial building blocks of interest-all on the µs timescale. These encouraging results demonstrate the power and robustness of the IPolQ lineage of force fields in modeling the structure and dynamics of natural proteins as well as mimetics with protein-inspired artificial backbones in atomic detail.

Engineering Methyllysine Writers and Readers for Allele-Specific Regulation of Protein-Protein Interactions.

Protein-protein interactions mediated by methyllysine are ubiquitous in biological systems. Specific perturbation of such interactions has remained a challenging endeavor. Herein, we describe an allele-specific strategy toward an engineered protein-protein interface orthogonal to the human proteome. We develop a methyltransferase (writer) variant that installs aryllysine moiety on histones that can only be recognized by an engineered chromodomain (reader). We establish biochemical integrity of the engineered interface, provide structural evidence for orthogonality and validate its applicability to identify transcriptional regulators. Our approach provides an unprecedented strategy for specific manipulation of the methyllysine interactome.

Heterogeneous-Backbone Foldamer Mimics of a Computationally Designed, Disulfide-Rich Miniprotein.

Disulfide-rich peptides have found widespread use in the development of bioactive agents; however, low proteolytic stability and the difficulty of exerting synthetic control over chain topology present barriers to their application in some systems. Herein, we report a method that enables the creation of artificial backbone ("foldamer") mimics of compact, disulfide-rich tertiary folds. Systematic replacement of a subset of natural α-residues with various artificial building blocks in the context of a computationally designed prototype sequence leads to "heterogeneous-backbone" variants that undergo clean oxidative folding, adopt tertiary structures indistinguishable from that of the prototype, and enjoy proteolytic protection beyond that inherent to the topologically constrained scaffold. Collectively, these results demonstrate systematic backbone substitution to be a viable method to engineer the properties of disulfide-rich sequences and expands the repertoire of protein mimicry by foldamers to an exciting new structural class.

Exploring the Functional Consequences of Protein Backbone Alteration in Ubiquitin through Native Chemical Ligation.

Ubiquitin (Ub) plays critical roles in myriad protein degradation and signaling networks in the cell. We report herein Ub mimetics based on backbones that blend natural and artificial amino acid units. The variants were prepared by a modular route based on native chemical ligation. Biological assays show that some are enzymatically polymerized onto protein substrates, and that the resulting Ub tags are recognized for downstream pathways. These results advance the size and complexity of folded proteins mimicked by artificial backbones and expand the functional scope of such agents.

Foldamer Tertiary Structure through Sequence-Guided Protein Backbone Alteration.

The prospect of recreating the complex structural hierarchy of protein folding in synthetic oligomers with backbones that are artificial in covalent structure ("foldamers") has long fascinated chemists. Foldamers offer complex functions from biostable scaffolds and have found widespread applications in fields from biomedical to materials science. Most precedent has focused on isolated secondary structures or their assemblies. In considering the goal of complex protein-like tertiary folding patterns, a key barrier became apparent. How does one design a backbone with covalent connectivity and a sequence of side-chain functional groups that will support defined intramolecular packing of multiple artificial secondary structures? Two developments were key to overcoming this challenge. First was the recognition of the power of blending α-amino acid residues with monomers differing in backbone connectivity to create "heterogeneous-backbone" foldamers. Second was the finding that replacing some of the natural α-residues in a biological sequence with artificial-backbone variants can result in a mimic that retains both the fold and function of the native sequence and, in some cases, gains advantageous characteristics. Taken together, these precedents lead to a view of a protein as chemical entity having two orthogonal sequences: a sequence of side-chain functional groups and a separate sequence of backbone units displaying those functional groups. In this Account, we describe our lab's work over the last ∼10 years to leverage the above concept of protein sequence duality in order to develop design principles for constructing heterogeneous-backbone foldamers that adopt complex protein-like tertiary folds. Fundamental to the approach is the utilization of a variety of artificial building blocks (e.g., d-α-residues, Cα-Me-α-residues, N-Me-α-residues, ß-residues, γ-residues, δ-residues, polymer segments) in concert, replacing a fraction of α-residues in a given prototype sequence. We provide an overview of the state-of-the-art in terms of design principles for choosing substitutions based on consideration of local secondary structure and retention of key side-chain functional groups. We survey high-resolution structures of backbone-modified proteins to illustrate how diverse artificial moieties are accommodated in tertiary fold contexts. We detail efforts to elucidate how backbone alteration impacts folding thermodynamics and describe how such data informs the development of improved design rules. Collectively, a growing body of results by our lab and others spanning multiple protein systems suggests there is a great deal of plasticity with respect to the backbone chemical structures upon which sequence-encoded tertiary folds can manifest. Moreover, these efforts suggest sequence-guided backbone alteration as a broadly applicable strategy for generating foldamers with complex tertiary folding patterns. We conclude by offering some perspective regarding the near future of this field, in terms of unanswered questions, technological needs, and opportunities for new areas of inquiry.

Heterogeneous-Backbone Foldamer Mimics of Zinc Finger Tertiary Structure.

A variety of oligomeric backbones with compositions deviating from biomacromolecules can fold in defined ways. Termed "foldamers," these agents have diverse potential applications. A number of protein-inspired secondary structures (e.g., helices, sheets) have been produced from unnatural backbones, yet examples of tertiary folds combining several secondary structural elements in a single entity are rare. One promising strategy to address this challenge is the systematic backbone alteration of natural protein sequences, through which a subset of the native side chains is displayed on an unnatural building block to generate a heterogeneous backbone. A drawback to this approach is that substitution at more than one or two sites often comes at a significant energetic cost to fold stability. Here we report heterogeneous-backbone foldamers that mimic the zinc finger domain, a ubiquitous and biologically important metal-binding tertiary motif, and do so with a folded stability that is superior to the natural protein on which their design is based. A combination of UV-vis spectroscopy, isothermal titration calorimetry, and multidimensional NMR reveals that suitably designed oligomers with >20% modified backbones can form native-like tertiary folds with metal-binding environments identical to the prototype sequence (the third finger of specificity factor 1) and enhanced thermodynamic stability. These results expand the scope of heterogeneous-backbone foldamer design to a new tertiary structure class and show that judiciously applied backbone modification can be accompanied by improvement to fold stability.

Supramolecular Metal-Coordination Polymers, Nets, and Frameworks from Synthetic Coiled-Coil Peptides.

Metal coordination and peptide-directed self-assembly are two proven methods for creating defined supramolecular architectures. Here, we report a new class of crystalline materials based on coiled-coil peptides bearing unnatural metal-chelating terpyridine moieties. High-resolution structural characterization of lattices formed in the presence of Cu2+ reveals a general assembly mechanism. Subtle sequence variation in the modular synthetic ligand dictates assembly morphology.

Peptide-functionalized semiconductor surfaces: strong surface electronic effects from minor alterations to backbone composition.

The use of non-canonical amino acids is a powerful way to control protein structure. Here, we show that subtle changes to backbone composition affect the ability of a dipeptide to modify solid surface electronic properties. The extreme sensitivity of the interactions to the peptide structure suggests potential applications in improving the performance of electronic devices.

Peptide Backbone Composition and Protease Susceptibility: Impact of Modification Type, Position, and Tandem Substitution.

The clinical utility of peptides is limited by their rapid degradation by endogenous proteases. Modification of the peptide backbone can generate functional analogues with enhanced proteolytic stability. Existing principles for the design of such oligomers have focused primarily on effective structural mimicry. A more robust strategy would incorporate a rational approach for engineering maximal proteolytic stability with minimal unnatural residue content. We report here the systematic comparison of the proteolytic resistance imparted by four backbone modifications commonly employed in the design of protease-stable analogues of peptides with complex folding patterns. The degree of protection was quantified as a function of modification type, position, and tandem substitution in the context of a long, unstructured host sequence and a canonical serine protease. These results promise to inform ongoing work to develop biostable mimics of increasingly complex peptides and proteins.

Thermodynamic origin of α-helix stabilization by side-chain cross-links in a small protein.

Peptide cross-linking has been widely explored as a means of constraining short sequences into stable folded conformations, most commonly α-helices. The prevailing hypothesis for the origin of helix stabilization is an entropic effect resulting from backbone pre-organization; however, obtaining direct evidence bearing on this hypothesis is challenging. Here, we compare the folding thermodynamics of a small helix-rich protein domain and analogues containing one of three common cross-linking motifs. Analysis of the folding free energy landscapes of linear vs. cyclized species reveal consistent trends in the effect of cyclization on folding energetics, as well as subtle differences based on the chemistry of the cross link. Stabilization in all three systems arises entirely from a reduction in the entropic penalty of folding that more than compensates for an enthalpic destabilization of the folded state.

Receptor-templated stapling of intrinsically disordered peptide ligands.

We report here a chemoselective peptide "stapling" method that can be performed on ligand-receptor complexes in situ. An appropriately structured macrocyclic bis-oxime linkage is shown to improve the affinity of a peptide ligand for its native protein receptor. The presence of the receptor as a template to preorganize the ligand into its bioactive conformation is found to bias reaction outcomes, suggesting the potential application of the method for receptor-assisted selection of stapled peptides.

The double-histidine Cu²âº-binding motif: a highly rigid, site-specific spin probe for electron spin resonance distance measurements.

The development of ESR methods that measure long-range distance distributions has advanced biophysical research. However, the spin labels commonly employed are highly flexible, which leads to ambiguity in relating ESR measurements to protein-backbone structure. Herein we present the double-histidine (dHis) Cu(2+)-binding motif as a rigid spin probe for double electron-electron resonance (DEER) distance measurements. The spin label is assembled in situ from natural amino acid residues and a metal salt, requires no postexpression synthetic modification, and provides distance distributions that are dramatically narrower than those found with the commonly used protein spin label. Simple molecular modeling based on an X-ray crystal structure of an unlabeled protein led to a predicted most probable distance within 0.5 Šof the experimental value. Cu(2+) DEER with the dHis motif shows great promise for the resolution of precise, unambiguous distance constraints that relate directly to protein-backbone structure and flexibility.

Tuning assembly size in Peptide-based supramolecular polymers by modulation of subunit association affinity.

Nature uses proteins and nucleic acids to form a wide array of functional architectures, and scientists have found inspiration from these structures in the rational design of synthetic biomaterials. We have recently shown that a modular subunit consisting of two α-helical coiled coil peptides attached at their midpoints by an organic linking group can spontaneously self-assemble in aqueous solution to form a soluble supramolecular polymer. Here we explore the use of coiled-coil association affinity, readily tuned by amino acid sequence, as a means to predictably alter properties of these supramolecular assemblies. A series of dimeric coiled-coil peptide sequences with identical quaternary folded structures but systematically altered folded stability were designed and biophysically characterized. The sequences were cross-linked to generate a series of branched, self-assembling biomacromolecular subunits. A clear relationship is observed between coiled-coil association affinity and apparent hydrodynamic diameter of the supramolecular polymers formed by these subunits. Our results provide a family of soluble supramolecular polymers of tunable size and well-characterized coiled-coil sequences that add to the library of building blocks available for use in the rational design of protein-based supramolecular biomaterials.

Protein backbone engineering as a strategy to advance foldamers toward the frontier of protein-like tertiary structure.

A variety of non-biological structural motifs have been incorporated into the backbone of natural protein sequences. In parallel work, diverse unnatural oligomers of de novo design (termed "foldamers") have been developed that fold in defined ways. In this Perspective article, we survey foundational studies on protein backbone engineering, with a focus on alterations made in the context of complex tertiary folds. We go on to summarize recent work illustrating the potential promise of these methods to provide a general framework for the construction of foldamer mimics of protein tertiary structures.

Comparison of backbone modification in protein ß-sheets by α→γ residue replacement and α-residue methylation.

The mimicry of protein tertiary structure by oligomers with unnatural backbones is a significant contemporary research challenge. Among common elements of secondary structure found in natural proteins, sheets have proven the most difficult to address. Here, we report the systematic comparison of different strategies for peptide backbone modification in ß-sheets with the goal of identifying the best method for replacing a multi-stranded sheet in a protein tertiary fold. The most effective sheet modifications examined led to native-like tertiary folding behavior with a thermodynamic folded stability comparable to the prototype protein on which the modified backbones are based.

Dynamic covalent side-chain cross-links via intermolecular oxime or hydrazone formation from bifunctional peptides and simple organic linkers.

Peptide cyclization via chemoselective reactions between side chains has proven a useful strategy to control folded structure. We report here a method for the synthesis of side-chain to side-chain cyclic peptides based on the intermolecular reaction between a linear peptide functionalized with two aminooxy or hydrazide side chains and an organic dialdehyde linker. A family of oxime-based and hydrazone-based cyclic products is prepared in a modular and convergent fashion by combination of unprotected linear peptide precursors and various small molecule linkers in neutral aqueous buffer. The side-chain to side-chain linkages that result can alter peptide folding behavior. The dynamic covalent nature of the Schiff bases in the cyclic products can be utilized to create mixtures where product composition changes in response to experimental conditions. Thus, a linear peptide precursor can select one organic linker from a mixture, and a cyclic product can dynamically exchange the small molecule component of the macrocycle.

Probing effects of site-specific aspartic acid isomerization on structure and stability of GB1 through chemical protein synthesis.

Chemical modifications of long-lived proteins, such as isomerization and epimerization, have been evoked as prime triggers for protein-damage related diseases. Deamidation of Asn residues, which results in formation of a mixture of l- and d-Asp and isoAsp via an intermediate aspartyl succinimide, can result in the disruption of cellular proteostasis and toxic protein depositions. In contrast to extensive data on the biological prevalence and functional implications of aspartyl succinimide formation, much less is known about the impact of the resulting altered backbone composition on properties of individual proteins at a molecular level. Here, we report the total chemical synthesis, biophysical characterization, and NMR structural analysis of a series of variants of the B1 domain of protein G from Streptococcal bacteria (GB1) in which all possible Asp isomers as well as an aspartyl succinimide were individually incorporated at a defined position in a solvent-exposed loop. Subtle local structural effects were observed; however, these were accompanied by notable differences in thermodynamic folded stability. Surprisingly, the noncanonical backbone connectivity of d-isoAsp led to a variant that exhibited enhanced stability relative to the natural protein.