Parameterization of nutrients and sediment build-up/wash-off processes for simulating stormwater quality from specific land uses.

Urbanization changes land cover through the expansion of impermeable surfaces, leading to a significant rise in runoff, sediment, and nutrient loading. The quality of stormwater is related to land use and is highly variable. Currently, stormwater is predominantly described through watershed models that rely minimally, if at all, on field monitoring data. The simple event mean concentration (EMC) wash-off approach by land use is a common method for estimating urban runoff loads. However, a major drawback of the EMC approach is it assumes concentration remains constant across events for a specific land use. Build-up/wash-off equations have been formulated to consider variations in concentration between events. However, several equation parameters are challenging to estimate, making them difficult to use. We conducted a monitoring and modeling study and investigated the impact of land use on stormwater quantity and quality and optimized and investigated the build-up/wash-off parameters for three homogenous urban land uses to estimate nutrients (nitrogen and phosphorus) and sediment loads. Stormwater from commercial, medium-density residential, and transportation land uses was sampled using automatic samplers during storm events, and water quality was characterized for a variety of them for 14 months. Analysis of stormwater samples included assessments for total nitrogen, total phosphorus, and total suspended solids. Results showed that medium-density residential land use had the highest median total nitrogen and total phosphorus event mean concentrations and commercial had the highest median total suspended solids EMCs. Water quality parameters (or build-up/wash-off parameters) exhibited significant variation between land uses, confirming that land use is a key determinant of stormwater quality. The median particle size for each land use was less than 150 µm, indicating that the most common particle size in stormwater was a very fine sand or smaller. This small size should be considered by stakeholders in the design of stormwater treatment systems.

Catchment based estimation of pollutant event mean concentration (EMC) and implications for first flush assessment.

The Event Mean Concentration (EMC) is considered as a key analytical parameter for assessing the quality of stormwater. The conventional estimation methods to determine EMC do not necessarily address the variability associated with the hydrologic characteristics. Accordingly, this study was conducted to identify the potential hydrologic variables that can influence EMC and thereby to create a mathematical model to determine EMC using the hydrologic variables while incorporating the catchment as an influential factor. This paper introduces an innovative approach to estimate EMC of a runoff event using a stepwise multiple linear regression model. The model incorporates hydrologic variables together with their two-way interaction terms. The catchment was included in the model as a dummy variable. This allows identifying the variability of EMC between catchments. Model can reasonably predict the EMC with an overall prediction error of 0.811. The regression coefficients of the model specify that, maximum rainfall intensity is the most influential variable having a coefficient of 1.008, followed by the average intensity with a coefficient -0.586. The interaction term of rainfall depth and the antecedent dry period indicates that for a relatively small rainfall event (<5 mm), an optimum value of antecedent dry period exists that maximises the EMC. Subsequently, EMC was employed to define the first flush runoff as an alternative approach to the conventional approaches for determining the first flush. The dynamic mean concentration (DMCt), was introduced as a parameter for estimating the first flush using EMC. The maximum accumulated runoff volume such that, DMCt≥EMC was defined as the first flush runoff. It was found that residential catchments generate more intense first flush compared to catchments with totally impervious surface areas and thereby a significant pollutant load is transported within a small initial fraction of the runoff.f.

A preliminary pan-European assessment of pollution loads from urban runoff.

Acknowledging the difficulty of modelling pollution conveyed by urban runoff, this contribution presents a first pan-European quantification of loads from this diffuse source. We estimate annual loads of 5-days biochemical oxygen demand (BOD5), nitrogen (N), phosphorus (P) and total suspended solids (TSS) using a simple event mean concentration (EMC) model initially proposed by Heaney et al., 1976. On a European scale, this yields discharges corresponding to untreated wastewater of about 31 million population equivalents (PE) for BOD5, about 18.5 million PE for N and P and about 280 million for TSS. These represent 51% of the pollution coming from treated wastewater for BOD5, 15% for N and P and 461% for TSS. Although the model applied for the assessment was developed more than 40 years ago, the results are consistent with those obtained using more recent parameterizations, except for a tendency to underestimate P loads. Although lack of data on pollution from urban runoff makes model verification impossible, and the uncertainty on EMC models is known to be very high, urban runoff emerges as a significant source of pollution, and should be properly addressed as such. Reducing runoff volume from urban areas through improved water retention is not only key to pollution control, but also a no-regret option thanks to its co-benefits, especially when incorporated at early stages of planning and design.

Assessment of stormwater pollutant loads and source area contributions with storm water management model (SWMM).

Decentralized urban runoff management requires detailed information about pollutant sources and pathways. However, scarce data of local water quality compel simplified approaches in water quality modelling. This study investigated the use of constant source concentrations in modelling pollutant loads. The source area contributions of total suspended solids, total phosphorus, total nitrogen, lead, copper and zinc were modelled with SWMM based on literature event mean concentrations (EMCs) for different land cover types and on-site rainfall and discharge data for a residential area in southern Finland. The simulated pollutant loads were compared with loads measured at the catchment outlet. Large differences were evident in the modelled catchment-scale and land cover specific loads, depending on the EMC data source. The simulated loads exceeded the measured loads especially during wet conditions, which was explained by the dilution effect of large stormwater volumes on measured EMCs. In addition, the mismatch was explained by the lack of local data for the source area EMCs and by the unaccountability of the mechanisms affecting loads along the pollutant pathways from source areas to sewer outlet. The spatial simulation of stormwater pollutant loads enabled the assessment of source area contributions at the catchment scale, as well as the pollutant pathways and the total diffuse pollution load. For a single pollutant, one or two important pollutant sources contributed the majority of the catchment load, which provides useful information for stormwater management. However, for a group of pollutants, no single land cover type dominated the pollutant loads, reflecting the challenges in decentralized water quality management in the scale of a residential area. Overall, the results emphasize that the widely used stormwater quality modelling with constant EMCs is uncertain even when on-site water quality and rainfall-runoff data from a catchment outlet are available.

Export of non-point source suspended sediment, nitrogen, and phosphorus from sloping highland agricultural fields in the East Asian monsoon region.

Excess sediment and nutrient export from agricultural fields with steep slopes is a major concern linked to surface water quality in Korea. In this study, the export of suspended sediment (SS), total nitrogen (TN), and total phosphorus (TP) and their event mean concentrations (EMCs) in surface runoff from a highland mixed land use (61% forested, 30% cropped, 9% other) watershed were quantified. In 2007, the Korean Ministry of Environment (MoE) declared the study area as a priority region for non-point source (NPS) pollution management and initiated various best management practices (BMPs) in the study watershed. SS, TN, and TP concentrations in Mandae Stream were monitored for 5 years (2009-2013) to evaluate the effectiveness of BMPs. Average EMCs for SS, TN, and TP were as high as 986, 3.4 and 0.8 mg/L, respectively. The agricultural export coefficients of agricultural land in the study watershed for SS, TN, and TP were 5611, 171, and 6.83 kg/ha/year, respectively. A comparison with results from other studies shows that both EMCs and agricultural export coefficients in the study watershed were much higher than most of the results reported for watersheds in other regions. The results show that sediment and nutrient export from intensive agriculture areas with steep slopes continue to be a major concern for the downstream reservoir, Lake Soyang. Remedial strategies should be directed towards controlling sources of SS, TN, and TP to improve downstream water quality in sloping highland agricultural areas in Korea.

Understanding phosphorus fractions and influential factors on urban road deposited sediments.

Phosphorus (P) is a primary pollutant that builds-up on urban road surfaces. Understanding the fraction and load characteristics of P, as well as their relationship with urban factors, is helpful for assessing the ecological risk of urban receiving water bodies. This study presents the characteristics of build-up loads of P fractions in road-deposited sediments (RDS) in Guangzhou, China, analyzes their correlation with three urban factors (road, traffic, and land-use area), and then estimates the exceedance probability of P in stormwater runoff over the past 10 years. The results showed that detrital apatite phosphorus (De-P) performed the highest build-up load on urban road surfaces, followed by apatite phosphorus (Ca-P), iron-bound phosphorus (Fe-P), exchangeable phosphorus (Ex-P), aluminum-bound phosphorus (Al-P), organophosphorus (POP), dissolved inorganic phosphorus (DIP), occluded phosphorus (Oc-P), and dissolved organic phosphorus (DOP). Depression depth, road materials, and land-use fractions affected the P fractions. The P in the RDS may have originated from three distinct sources: road background, domestic waste, and untreated wastewater discharge. In the most recent 10 years, the event mean concentrations of total P in the RDS have had a 30 % probability of exceeding 0.4 mg L-1, which indicates a serious threat of P to receiving water bodies. The outcomes of this study are expected to provide valuable guidance for elucidating the principal categories of urban non-point source P pollution and enhancing the ecological health of urban water environments.

Environmental regulations in the United States lead to improvements in untreated stormwater quality over four decades.

Identifying sources of pollutants in watersheds is critical to accurately predicting stormwater quality. Many existing software used to model stormwater quality rely on decades-old data sets which may not represent current runoff quality in the United States. Because of environmental regulations promulgated at the federal level over previous decades, there is a need to understand long-term trends (and potential shifts) in runoff quality to better parameterize models. Pollutant event mean concentrations (EMCs) from the National Stormwater Quality Database (NSQD) were combined with those from recent sources to understand if untreated stormwater quality has changed over the past 40 years. A significant decreasing monotonic trend (i.e., continually decreasing in a nonuniform fashion) was observed for total suspended solids (TSS), total phosphorus (TP), total Kjeldahl nitrogen (TKN), total copper (Cu), total lead (Pb), and total zinc (Zn) in the resultant database, suggesting that runoff quality has become less polluted with time. Median EMCs decreased from 99.2 to 42 mg/L, 0.34 to 0.26 mg/L, 1.27 to 1.03 mg/L, 40 to 6.8 µg/L, 110 to 3.7 µg/L, and 375 to 53.3 µg/L for TSS, TP, TN, Cu, Pb, and Zn, respectively, from the 1980s to the 2010s. These significant reductions often aligned temporally with advancements in clean manufacturing, amendments of the Clean Air Act, and other source control efforts which impact pollutant bioavailability and atmospheric deposition. Results suggest environmental regulations not specifically targeting stormwater management have had a positive impact on stormwater quality and that temporal fluctuations should be considered in modeling.

Effects of land use, climate, and imperviousness on urban stormwater quality: A meta-analysis.

Many natural and anthropogenic factors cause degradation of urban stormwater quality, resulting in negative consequences to receiving waters. In order to improve water quality models at a variety of scales, accurate estimates of pollutant (nutrients, total suspended solids, and heavy metal) concentrations are needed using potential explanatory variables. To this end, a meta-analysis was performed on aggregated stormwater quality data from the published literature from 360 urban catchments worldwide to understand how urban land use and land cover (LULC), climate (i.e., KÓ§ppen-Geiger zone), and imperviousness (1) affect runoff quality, and (2) whether they are able to predict stormwater pollutant concentrations. Runoff pollutant concentrations were more influenced by LULC and climate than imperviousness. Differences in LULC significantly affected the generation of metals and some nitrogen species. Road, city center, and commercial LULCs generally produced the most elevated pollutant concentrations. Changes in climate zones resulted in significant differences in concentrations of nutrients and metals. Continental and arid climate zones produced runoff with the highest pollutant concentrations. Rainfall patterns seemed to have a more important role in affecting runoff quality than seasonal temperature. Differences in imperviousness only significantly affected chromium and nickel concentrations, although increased imperviousness led to slightly (not significantly) elevated concentrations of nutrients, suspended solids, and other heavy metals. Multiple linear regression models were created to predict the quality of urban runoff. Predictive equations were significant (p < 0.05) for 67% of the pollutants analyzed (ammonia, total Kjeldahl nitrogen, total nitrogen, total phosphorus, cadmium, nickel, lead, and zinc) suggesting that LULC, climate, and imperviousness are useful predictors of stormwater quality when local field monitoring or modeling is not practical. This study provides useful relationships to better inform urban stormwater quality models and regulations such as total maximum daily loads.

Event mean concentration and first flush from residential catchments in different climate zones.

Most studies on EMC (Event mean concentration) and first flush are reported as local studies; however variations of EMC and first flush across catchments in different climate zones has not been studied. This research collected continuous flow and discrete water quality data and rainfall measurements from 17 catchments, EMC and rainfall data from 14 catchments, and an additional dataset where only average EMC values are reported (19 catchments). The data are from residential sites across temperate, tropical, dry, and continental climate zones and include water quality parameters in particulate (total suspended solids), mixed (total nitrogen and total phosphorus) and dissolved (orthophosphate and ammonium nitrogen) forms. Our study shows that EMC differs significantly between climate zones. The average EMC is highest in dry followed by continental and temperate, with lowest in the tropical zone. Pearson's correlation analysis revealed that the rainfall depth is negatively correlated with EMC for particulate and mixed form parameters for the tropical, temperate and dry zones, but positively correlated for the continental zone. The discrete time-series data from the 17 catchments were used to evaluate first flush and it was found that catchments in the tropics exhibit stronger first flush than temperate zone catchments, for all the water quality parameters with particulate showing a stronger first flush compared to dissolved forms. Based on the distribution of the data, new limits for very strong, strong, moderate, and very weak to no first flush are suggested for TSS for different climate zones. The new limits were quantified by fitting the function L^=V^bwhere L^and V^are the normalized cumulative runoff load and volume, respectively. For catchments in the tropics, this corresponds to b < 0.47, 0.6 > b > 0.47, 0.76 > b > 0.6 and b > 0.76, respectively. For the temperate zone, b < 0.5, 0.67 > b > 0.5, 0.85 > b > 0.67 and b > 0.85, are appropriate. From a design perspective, the FF20 concept defined as the load corresponding to 20% runoff volume, is often used. The ranges FF20 < 0.27, 0.36 > FF20 > 0.27, 0.45 > FF20 > 0.36 and FF20 > 0.45 and FF20 < 0.24, 0.31 > FF20 > 0.24, 0.31 > FF20 > 0.39 and FF20 > 0.39 are proposed for tropical and temperate catchments, respectively. Other limits for TP, TN, OP and NH4-N are also suggested. This is the first study of its kind and an expended dataset especially for continental and dry regions is needed to further validate the findings.

What are the relevant sources and factors affecting event mean concentrations (EMCs) of nutrients and sediment in stormwater?

Urbanization increases runoff, sediment, and nutrient loadings downstream, causing flooding, eutrophication, and harmful algal blooms. Stormwater control measures (SCMs) are used to address these concerns and are designed based on inflow loads. Thus, estimating nutrient and sediment loads is important for meeting restoration objectives. Pollutants accumulate on surfaces during dry periods, making Event Mean Concentration (EMC) a function of antecedent dry period (ADP). An EMC results from wash-off of accumulated pollutants from catchment surface during runoff events. However, several studies found little to no correlation between constituent concentrations in stormwater and ADP. The objective of this study is to verify this finding and discover which climatological or catchment characteristics most significantly affect stormwater quality. Stormwater quality data were obtained from the National Stormwater Quality Database (NSQD), which is the largest data repository of stormwater quality data in the U.S. Bayesian Network Structure Learner (BNSL) was used to assess the relationships between catchment characteristics, climatological information, and stormwater quality for selected land uses. Given the optimal BN structure, it was determined which parameters most affect stormwater quality EMCs. The results demonstrate that both catchment and rain characteristics affected stormwater quality EMCs. Among catchment characteristics, land use (LU) was the most important factor and catchment size was the least. Precipitation depth (P) and duration (D) affected Total Phosphorus (TP), Total Nitrogen (TN), and Total Suspended Solids (TSS). This indicated that it is likely that P and D had a greater influence on stormwater quality more than ADP. P, D, and ADP affected the dissolved constituents of TN (i.e. NO2-N/NO3-N) and TP (i.e. Ortho-P). Compared to other factors (i.e. P and D), the effect of ADP on TSS was negligible. Stormwater quality EMCs related to nitrogen were not affected by catchment slope (S). However, TSS and Ortho-P were influenced by S.

The effects of land use characteristics on urban stormwater quality and watershed pollutant loads.

Urban developments can result in higher runoff and nutrient loadings transported to downstream receiving waterbodies. While much effort has been made recently in watershed restoration in the U.S., a lack of recent runoff quality data limits the prediction capability of urban watershed models. The objectives of this study was to fill an existing information gap on how rainfall and land uses interact and affect such loadings. This study instrumented six coastal urban catchments, each dominated by a single land use. We measured total nitrogen (TN), total phosphorus (TP), total suspended solids (TSS), total Kjeldahl Nitrogen (TKN), ortho-P, and nitrate concentrations in runoff from 30 storm events over one year from six urban land uses, namely commercial, industrial, transportation, open space, low density residential, and high density residential. Results indicated that the median event mean concentrations (EMCs) for TSS, TP, and TN were 30 (19-34), 0.31 (0.26-0.31), and 0.94 (0.73-1.25) mg L-1, respectively. TSS EMCs from the open space and industrial land uses were significantly greater than other land uses; there were positive correlations between TN concentrations and imperviousness and between TP concentrations and turf coverage. Both the amount and intensity of rainfall positively influenced TSS concentrations in runoff regardless of land use. Using the collected data, this study developed a generic equation for predicting the loading of a pollutant as a function of rainfall depth. This equation was verified by comparing its predictions with the simulations of a sufficiently-calibrated water quality model in terms of TSS, TP, and TN loadings from various land uses in another coastal catchment for a period of ten years. Average TSS, TN, and TP loadings from the catchment were estimated to be 0.86, 0.03, and 0.01 kg ha-1 cm-1, respectively.

[Analysis of Rainwater Runoff Pollution Characteristics of Various Typical Underlying Surfaces in Ningbo].

The pollution of rainwater runoff in urban areas can cause nutrient enrichment and eutrophication in receiving waters. To explore the pollution characteristics of rainwater runoff in Ningbo, eight sampling campaigns were carried out during rainfall events from 2009 to 2019. Samples of rainwater runoff were collected from underlying surfaces of roofs, squares, grassland, main roads, and the roads in commercial streets and residential districts. The concentrations of runoff pollutants, their sources and correlations, and first flush effects were studied using frequency statistical analysis and correlation analysis. The average event mean concentrations of the chemical oxygen demand (COD), ammonia nitrogen, total nitrogen, total phosphorus, and total suspended solids (TSS) in the rainwater runoff in Ningbo were in the ranges of 23.88-102.31, 0.40-1.69, 3.41-8.71, 0.09-0.50, and 37.6-323.4 mg·L-1, respectively. Apart from the square surfaces, the COD and total nitrogen pollution of the underlying surfaces was severe. The ammonia nitrogen concentrations from the roof, commercial street, and residential district surfaces were significantly higher (P<0.05) than those from the square, grassland, and main road surfaces. The concentrations of total phosphorus from the commercial street, main road, and grassland surfaces were significantly higher (P<0.05) than those of the other underlying surfaces. The correlations of TSS with COD, ammonia nitrogen, and total phosphorus showed that the pollutants and TSS have the same original sources in roof, square, main road, and commercial street runoff, while ammonia nitrogen and total nitrogen have the same original sources in runoff from grassland and residential areas. Under the meteorological conditions of light and moderate rain, the first flush effects of ammonia nitrogen in the runoff of roofs and grassland were observed clearly, whereas this was not the same for the pollutants of total nitrogen and total phosphorus in the residential area, main road, and square runoff.

Performance assessment of extensive green roof runoff flow and quality control capacity based on pilot experiments.

Green roof is an important measure in "Sponge Cities" to reduce the runoff and improve the runoff quality. The runoff quantity and quality control capacity of five types of extensive green roofs (EGRs) were analyzed in Beijing for 51 nature rainfall events and 6 simulated events from July 2017 to October 2018. Different module scales (sizes) and substrate depths were examined to study their correlation to runoff retention, peak flow reduction, pollutant event mean concentration (EMC) and load reduction performance of EGRs. In general, both the single-field rainfall events and the long-term monitoring showed that as the module scale and substrate thickness increased, the retention capacity of the EGRs increased. As the module scale increased, the peak flow reduction rate (Pfrr) of the EGR modules increased, while the thickness of the substrate appeared to have less of an effect on Pfrr. When water quality effect was considered, compared with module scale, the substrate thickness had a more obvious effect on the average EMC of different pollutants. As the substrate thickness increased, the EMC of pollutants decreased. Under six simulated design rainfalls, EMC reduction rate of suspended solid (SS) of all types of EGRs ranged from 64.3%-73.1% while no reduction was found in the EMC of chemical oxygen demand (COD). The EMC trends of ammonia nitrogen (NH4+-N), nitrate nitrogen (NO3--N), total nitrogen (TN) and total phosphorus (TP) were almost the same, and their EMCs decreased with increasing total rainfall depth. When the pollutant load was considered, the EGRs in this study were a sink of NH4+-N, NO3--N, TN, and TP but a source of COD.

Impacts of urbanization on regional nonpoint source pollution: case study for Beijing, China.

Due to limits on available data, the effects of urban sprawl on regional nonpoint source pollution (NPS) have not been investigated over long time periods. In this paper, the characteristics of urban sprawl from 1999 to 2014 in Beijing were explored by analyzing historical land-use data. The Event Mean Concentration data have been collected from all available references, which were used to estimate the variation in urban NPSs. Moreover, the impacts of variation in urban sprawl on regional NPSs were qualified. The results indicated that the urbanization process showed different influences on pollutants, while COD and TN were identified as key NPS pollutants. Residential areas contributed more NPS pollutants than did roads, which played a tremendous role in the control of urban NPS. The results also suggested in part that the impact of urban sprawl on the variation of COD decreased while TN increased in Beijing during the study period. These results would provide insight into the impacts of urban sprawl on NPS variation over a long period, as well as the reference for reasonable urban planning directives.

Event mean concentration and first flush effect from different drainage systems and functional areas during storms.

This study aimed to investigate the characteristics of the event mean concentration (EMC) and first flush effect (FFE) during typical rainfall events in outfalls from different drainage systems and functional areas. Stormwater outfall quality data were collected from five outfalls throughout Fuzhou City (China) during 2011-2012. Samples were analyzed for water quality parameters, such as COD, NH3-N, TP, and SS. Analysis of values indicated that the order of the event mean concentrations (EMCs) in outfalls was intercepting combined system > direct emission combined system > separated system. Most of the rainfall events showed the FFE in all outfalls. The order of strength of the FFE was residential area of direct emission combined system > commercial area of separated system > residential area of intercepting combined system > office area of separated system > residential area of separated system. Results will serve as guide in managing water quality to reduce pollution from drainage systems.

A comparative study of the grain-size distribution of surface dust and stormwater runoff quality on typical urban roads and roofs in Beijing, China.

The deposition of pollutants on impervious surfaces is a serious problem associated with rapid urbanization, which results in non-point-source pollution. Characterizing the build-up and wash-off processes of pollutants in urban catchments is essential for urban planners. In this paper, the spatial variation and particle-size distributions of five heavy metals and two nutrients in surface dust were analyzed, and the runoff water first-flush effect (FF30) and event-mean concentrations (EMCs) of 10 common constituents were characterized. The relationships between runoff variables and stormwater characteristics were examined from three typical urban impervious surfaces in Beijing, China. Dust on road surfaces with smaller grain sizes had higher pollutant concentrations, whereas concentrations of Mn, Zn, Fe, and TP in roof surface dust increased with grain size. Particles with grain sizes of 38-74 and 125-300 µm contributed most to the total pollutant load in roads, while particles with the smallest grain sizes (<38 µm) contributed most on roofs (23.46-41.71 %). Event-mean concentrations (EMCs) and FF30 values for most runoff pollutants tended to be higher on roofs than on roads. The maximum intensity (I max) and the antecedent dry days (ADD) were critical parameters for EMCs in roads, while ADD was the only dominant parameter for EMCs on our studied roof. The rainfall intensity (RI) and maximum intensity (I max) were found to be the parameters with the strongest correlation to the first-flush effect on both roads and roofs. Significant correlations of total suspended solids (TSS) concentration in runoff with grain-size fractions of surface dust indicated that coarser particles (74-300 µm) are most likely to contribute to the solid-phase pollutants, and finer particles (<38 µm) are likely the main source of dissolved pollutants.