The rise of intelligent matter.

Artificial intelligence (AI) is accelerating the development of unconventional computing paradigms inspired by the abilities and energy efficiency of the brain. The human brain excels especially in computationally intensive cognitive tasks, such as pattern recognition and classification. A long-term goal is de-centralized neuromorphic computing, relying on a network of distributed cores to mimic the massive parallelism of the brain, thus rigorously following a nature-inspired approach for information processing. Through the gradual transformation of interconnected computing blocks into continuous computing tissue, the development of advanced forms of matter exhibiting basic features of intelligence can be envisioned, able to learn and process information in a delocalized manner. Such intelligent matter would interact with the environment by receiving and responding to external stimuli, while internally adapting its structure to enable the distribution and storage (as memory) of information. We review progress towards implementations of intelligent matter using molecular systems, soft materials or solid-state materials, with respect to applications in soft robotics, the development of adaptive artificial skins and distributed neuromorphic computing.

A Spatiotemporal Controllable Biomimetic Skin for Accelerating Wound Repair.

Skin injury repair is a dynamic process involving a series of interactions over time and space. Linking human physiological processes with materials' changes poses a significant challenge. To match the wound healing process, a spatiotemporal controllable biomimetic skin is developed, which comprises a three-dimensional (3D) printed membrane as the epidermis, a cell-containing hydrogel as the dermis, and a cytokine-laden hydrogel as the hypodermis. In the initial stage of the biomimetic skin repair wound, the membrane frame aids wound closure through pre-tension, while cells proliferate within the hydrogel. Next, as the frame disintegrates over time, cells released from the hydrogel migrate along the residual membrane. Throughout the process, continuous cytokines release from the hypodermis hydrogel ensures comprehensive nourishment. The findings reveal that in the rat full-thickness skin defect model, the biomimetic skin demonstrated a wound closure rate eight times higher than the blank group, and double the collagen content, particularly in the early repair process. Consequently, it is reasonable to infer that this biomimetic skin holds promising potential to accelerate wound closure and repair. This biomimetic skin with mechanobiological effects and spatiotemporal regulation emerges as a promising option for tissue regeneration engineering.

Improving stability of human three dimensional skin equivalents using plasma surface treatment.

In developing three-dimensional (3D) human skin equivalents (HSEs), preventing dermis and epidermis layer distortion due to the contraction of hydrogels by fibroblasts is a challenging issue. Previously, a fabrication method of HSEs was tested using a modified solid scaffold or a hydrogel matrix in combination with the natural polymer coated onto the tissue culture surface, but the obtained HSEs exhibited skin layer contraction and loss of the skin integrity and barrier functions. In this study, we investigated the method of HSE fabrication that enhances the stability of the skin model by using surface plasma treatment. The results showed that plasma treatment of the tissue culture surface prevented dermal layer shrinkage of HSEs, in contrast to the HSE fabrication using fibronectin coating. The HSEs from plasma-treated surface showed significantly higher transepithelial electrical resistance compared to the fibronectin-coated model. They also expressed markers of epidermal differentiation (keratin 10, keratin 14 and loricrin), epidermal tight junctions (claudin 1 and zonula occludens-1), and extracellular matrix proteins (collagen IV), and exhibited morphological characteristics of the primary human skins. Taken together, the use of plasma surface treatment significantly improves the stability of 3D HSEs with well-defined dermis and epidermis layers and enhanced skin integrity and the barrier functions.

Patterns of use of advanced wound matrices in the Veterans Administration clinics.

Chronic wounds are a common and costly health issue affecting millions of individuals in the United States, particularly those with underlying conditions such as diabetes, venous insufficiency, and peripheral artery disease. When standard treatments fail, advanced wound care therapies, such as skin substitutes, are often applied. However, the clinical effectiveness, indications, and comparative benefits of these therapies have not been well established. In this study, we report on the usage of both acellular and cellular, single and bilayer, natural and synthetic, dermal, and epidermal skin substitutes in a VA hospital system. We performed a retrospective chart review to understand the ordering and usage patterns of advanced wound therapies for patients with chronic wounds at the VA Northern California Health Care System. We examined types of products being recommended, categories of users recommending the products, indications for orders, and rate of repeated orders. Neuropathic, venous, or pressure ulcers were the main indications for using advanced wound matrices. Only 15.6% of patients for whom the matrices were ordered had supporting laboratory tests. Exactly 34.3% of the ordered matrices were not applied. And the use of wound matrices resulted in increased costs per patient visit of $1018-$3450. Our study sheds light on the usage patterns of these therapies in a VA healthcare facility and highlights the need for more robust evidence-based studies to determine the true benefits, efficacy, and cost-effectiveness of these innovative treatment options.

Development of pro-angiogenic skin substitutes for wound healing.

Wounds pose significant challenges to public health, primarily due to the loss of the mechanical integrity and barrier function of the skin and impaired angiogenesis, causing physical morbidities and psychological trauma to affect patients. Reconstructing the vasculature of the wound bed is crucial for promoting wound healing, reducing scar formation and enhancing the quality of life for patients. The development of pro-angiogenic skin substitutes has emerged as a promising strategy to facilitate vascularization and expedite the healing process of burn wounds. This review provides an overview of the various types of skin substitutes employed in wound healing, explicitly emphasising those designed to enhance angiogenesis. Synthetic scaffolds, biological matrices and tissue-engineered constructs incorporating stem cells and primary cells, cell-derived extracellular vesicles (EVs), pro-angiogenic growth factors and peptides, as well as gene therapy-based skin substitutes are thoroughly examined. The review summarises the existing challenges, future directions and potential innovations in pro-angiogenic dressing for skin substitutes. It highlights the need for continued research to develop new technologies and combine multiple strategies and factors, and to overcome obstacles and advance the field, ultimately leading to improved outcomes for wound patients.

Development of a novel human stratum corneum mimetic phospholipid -vesicle-based permeation assay models for in vitro permeation studies.

OBJECTIVES: To develop and evaluate a novel human stratum corneum (SC) mimetic phospholipid vesicle-based permeation assay (PVPASC) model for in vitro permeation studies. SIGNIFICANCE: Due to the increasing restrictions on the use of human and animal skins, artificial skin models have attracted substantial interest in pharmaceuticals and cosmetic industries. In this study, a modified PVPASC model containing both SC lipids and proteins was developed. METHODS: The PVPASC model was optimized by altering the lipid composition and adding keratin in the formulation of large liposomes. The barrier properties were monitored by measuring the electrical resistance (ER) and permeability of Rhodamine B (RB). The modified PVPASC model was characterized in terms of the surface topography, solvent influence and storage stability. The permeation studies of the active components in Compound Nanxing Zhitong Plaster (CNZP) were performed to examine the capability of PVPASC in the application of skin penetration. RESULTS: The ER and Papp values of RB obtained from the optimized PVPASC model indicated a similar barrier property to porcine ear skin. Scanning electron microscope analysis demonstrated a mimic 'brick-and-mortar' structure. The PVPASC model can be stored for three weeks at -20 °C, and withstand the presence of different receptor medium for 24 h. The permeation studies of the active components demonstrated a good correlation (r2 = 0.9136) of Papp values between the drugs' permeation through the PVPASC model and porcine ear skin. CONCLUSION: Keratin contained composite phospholipid vesicle-based permeation assay models have been proven to be potential skin tools in topical/transdermal permeation studies.

Bioengineering Skin Substitutes for Wound Management-Perspectives and Challenges.

Non-healing wounds and skin losses constitute significant challenges for modern medicine and pharmacology. Conventional methods of wound treatment are effective in basic healthcare; however, they are insufficient in managing chronic wound and large skin defects, so novel, alternative methods of therapy are sought. Among the potentially innovative procedures, the use of skin substitutes may be a promising therapeutic method. Skin substitutes are a heterogeneous group of materials that are used to heal and close wounds and temporarily or permanently fulfill the functions of the skin. Classification can be based on the structure or type (biological and synthetic). Simple constructs (class I) have been widely researched over the years, and can be used in burns and ulcers. More complex substitutes (class II and III) are still studied, but these may be utilized in patients with deep skin defects. In addition, 3D bioprinting is a rapidly developing method used to create advanced skin constructs and their appendages. The aforementioned therapies represent an opportunity for treating patients with diabetic foot ulcers or deep skin burns. Despite these significant developments, further clinical trials are needed to allow the use skin substitutes in the personalized treatment of chronic wounds.

Cancer Spheroids Embedded in Tissue-Engineered Skin Substitutes: A New Method to Study Tumorigenicity In Vivo.

Tumorigenic assays are used during a clinical translation to detect the transformation potential of cell-based therapies. One of these in vivo assays is based on the separate injection of each cell type to be used in the clinical trial. However, the injection method requires many animals and several months to obtain useful results. In previous studies, we showed the potential of tissue-engineered skin substitutes (TESs) as a model for normal skin in which cancer cells can be included in vitro. Herein, we showed a new method to study tumorigenicity, using cancer spheroids that were embedded in TESs (cTES) and grafted onto athymic mice, and compared it with the commonly used cell injection assay. Tumors developed in both models, cancer cell injection and cTES grafting, but metastases were not detected at the time of sacrifice. Interestingly, the rate of tumor development was faster in cTESs than with the injection method. In conclusion, grafting TESs is a sensitive method to detect tumor cell growth with and could be developed as an alternative test for tumorigenicity.

[Skin substitutes : a step forward in skin regeneration using tissue engineering]. / Les substituts cutanés :un progrès dans la régénération de la peau à l'aide de l'ingénierie tissulaire.

The use of skin substitutes in burn surgery and in the treatment of acute or chronic wounds is constantly evolving. For years, scientists have been researching skin substitutes that can be used in place of autologous skin. New products are regularly developed and approved for clinical use. In this article, we take a look at the skin substitutes most commonly used in Europe and briefly summarize the current clinical experience of our centre.

L'utilisation des substituts cutanés dans la chirurgie des grands brûlés et dans le traitement des plaies aiguës ou chroniques est en constante évolution. Depuis des années, les scientifiques recherchent des substituts cutanés qui peuvent être utilisés à la place de la peau autologue. De nouveaux produits sont régulièrement développés et approuvés pour l'utilisation clinique. Dans cet article, nous examinons les substituts cutanés les plus utilisés en Europe et résumons brièvement l'expérience pratique de notre centre.

A Dual-Responsive Artificial Skin for Tactile and Touchless Interfaces.

The progress from intelligent interactions and supplemented/augmented reality requires artificial skins to shift from the single-functional tactile paradigm. Dual-responsive sensors that can both detect pre-contact proximal events and tactile pressure levels enrich the perception dimensions and deliver additional cognitive information. Previous dual-responsive sensors show very limited utilizations only in proximity perception or approaching switches. Whereas, the approaching inputs from the environment should be able to convey more valuable messages. Herein, a flexible iontronic dual-responsive artificial skin is present. The artificial skin is sensitive to external object's applied pressure as well as its approaching, and can elicit information of target material categories encoded in the proximal inputs. Versatile applications are then demonstrated. Dual-mode human-machine interfaces are developed based on the devices, including a manipulation of virtual game characters, navigation and zooming in of electronic maps, and scrolling through electronic documents. More importantly, the proof-of-concept application of an entirely touchless material classification system is demonstrated. Three types of materials (metals, polymers, and human skins) are classified and predicted accurately. These features of the artificial skin make it highly promising for next-generation smart engineered electronics.

Bioconversion of retinol and its cell barrier function in human immortalized keratinocytes cells and artificial epidermis-dermis skin.

The current study aimed to characterize cellular uptake and bioconversion of retinol in fully differentiated human immortalized keratinocytes cells (HaCaT) and artificial skin by measuring the cell integrity of skin barriers, time-dependent transport of retinol, and bioconversion to its metabolites. The expression of epidermal differentiation related genes including Keratin 1 (KRT1), Keratin 10 (KRT10), and Involucrin (IVL) significantly increased in differentiated HaCaT. TEER of HaCaT did not decrease after incubating retinol compared to control (p > 0.05), indicating that retinol tends to maintain strength and integrity of epidermal barrier. TEER of artificial skin decreased treatment of retinol for 2 h, but it was recovered after 4 h. During retinol transport, metabolite was eluted at 13.37 and 13.82 min of basal medium of both keratinocytes and artificial skin, which was identified as retinoic acid by product ion of m/z 283.47. Retinol appeared to be accumulated in keratinocytes, but its uptake tends to be reduced in a time-dependent manner. Retinoic acid converted from retinol in keratinocytes was time dependently transported. In case of artificial skin, retinol was mostly found in apical at initial incubation time, but it was reduced during incubation for 24 h. Retinoic acid was time-dependently found in a basal, which was converted via epidermis-dermis. Results from the current study suggest that topical application of retinol to human skin optimal concentration and time exposure could maintain epidermal barrier function and promote skin function due to its remarkable bioconversion to retinoic acid in the epidermis-dermis.

Requisite instruments for the establishment of three-dimensional epidermal human skin equivalents-A methods review.

Human skin equivalents (HSEs) are three-dimensional skin organ culture models raised in vitro. This review gives an overview of common techniques for setting up HSEs. The HSE consists of an artificial dermis and epidermis. 3T3-J2 murine fibroblasts, purchased human fibroblasts or freshly isolated and cultured fibroblasts, together with other components, for example, collagen type I, are used to build the scaffold. Freshly isolated and cultured keratinocytes are seeded on top. It is possible to add other cell types, for example, melanocytes, to the HSE-depending on the research question. After several days and further steps, the 3D skin can be harvested. Additionally, we show possible markers and techniques for evaluation of artificial skin. Furthermore, we provide a comparison of HSEs to human skin organ culture, a model which employs human donor skin. We outline advantages and limitations of both models and discuss future perspectives in using HSEs.

Antimicrobial peptide-loaded decellularized placental sponge as an excellent antibacterial skin substitute against XDR clinical isolates.

Post-wound infections have remained a serious threat to society and healthcare worldwide. Attempts are still being made to develop an ideal antibacterial wound dressing with high wound-healing potential and strong antibacterial activity against extensively drug-resistant bacteria (XDR). In this study, a biological-based sponge was made from decellularized human placenta (DPS) and then loaded with different concentrations (0, 16 µg/mL, 32 µg/mL, 64 µg/mL) of an antimicrobial peptide (AMP, CM11) to optimize an ideal antibacterial wound dressing. The decellularization of DPS was confirmed by histological evaluations and DNA content assay. The DPS loaded with different contents of antimicrobial peptides (AMPs) showed uniform morphology under a scanning electron microscope (SEM) and cytobiocompatibility for human adipose tissue-derived mesenchymal stem cells. Antibacterial assays indicated that the DPS/AMPs had antibacterial behavior against both standard strain and XDR Acinetobacter baumannii in a dose-dependent manner, as DPS loaded with 64 µg/mL showed the highest bacterial growth inhibition zone and elimination of bacteria under SEM than DPS alone and DPS loaded with 16 µg/mL and 32 µg/mL AMP concentrations. The subcutaneous implantation of all constructs in the animal model demonstrated no sign of acute immune system reaction and graft rejection, indicating in vivo biocompatibility of the scaffolds. Our findings suggest the DPS loaded with 64 µg/mL as an excellent antibacterial skin substitute, and now promises to proceed with pre-clinical and clinical investigations.

Converting Acellular Dermal Matrix into On-Demand Versatile Skin Scaffolds by a Balanceable Crosslinking Approach for Integrated Infected Wounds Therapy.

Ideal tissue-engineered skin scaffolds should possess integrated therapeutic effects and multifunctionality, such as broad-spectrum antibacterial properties, adjustable mechanical properties, and bionic structure. Acellular dermal matrix (ADM) has been broadly used in many surgical applications as an alternative treatment to the "gold standard" tissue transplantation. However, insufficient broad-spectrum antibacterial and mechanical properties for therapeutic efficacy limit the practical clinical applications of ADM. Herein, a balanceable crosslinking approach based on oxidized 2-hydroxypropyltrimethyl ammonium chloride chitosan (OHTCC) was developed for converting ADM into on-demand versatile skin scaffolds for integrated infected wounds therapy. Comprehensive experiments show that different oxidation degrees of OHTCC have significative influences on the specific origins of OHTCC-crosslinked ADM scaffolds (OHTCC-ADM). OHTCC with an oxidation degree of about 13% could prosperously balance the physiochemical properties, antibacterial functionality, and cytocompatibility of the OHTCC-ADM scaffolds. Owing to the natural features and comprehensive crosslinking effects, the proposed OHTCC-ADM scaffolds possessed the desirable multifunctional properties, including adjustable mechanical, degradable characteristics, and thermal stability. In vitro/in vivo biostudies indicated that OHTCC-ADM scaffolds own well-pleasing broad-spectrum antibacterial performances and play effectively therapeutic roles in treating infection, inhibiting inflammation, promoting angiogenesis, and promoting collagen deposition to enhance the infected wound healing. This study proposes a facile balanceable crosslinking approach for the design of ADM-based versatile skin scaffolds for integrated infected wounds therapy.

Three-Dimensional Artificial Skin Construct Bioprinted with a Marine-Based Biocomposite.

A variety of artificial skin scaffolds, including 3D-bioprinted constructs, have been widely studied for regenerating injured skin tissue. Here, we devised a new composite biomaterial ink using fish-skin-based decellularized extracellular matrices (dECM) from tilapia and cod fish. The composition of the biocomposite mixture was carefully selected to obtain a mechanically stable and highly bioactive artificial cell construct. In addition, the decellularized extracellular matrices were methacrylated, followed by exposure to UV light to initiate photo-cross-linking. Porcine-skin-based dECMMa (pdECMMa) and tilapia-skin-based dECMMa (tdECMMa) biomaterials were used as controls. Assessment of various biophysical parameters and in vitro cellular activities, including cytotoxicity, wound healing ability, and angiogenesis, showed that the biocomposite exhibited much higher cellular activities compared to the controls owing to the synergistic effect of the favorable biophysical properties of tdECMMa and bioactive components (collagen, glycosaminoglycans (GAGs), elastin, and free fatty acids) from the decellularized cod skin. Furthermore, the skin constructs bioprinted using the bioinks exhibited more than 90% cell viability, performed with 3 days of submerged culture and then 28 days of air-liquid culture. For all cell constructs, the expression of cytokeratin 10 (CK10) was observed on the top surface of the epidermal layer, and cytokeratin 14 (CK14) was detected in the lower section of the keratinocyte layer. However, more developed CK10 and CK14 antibodies were observed in the cell-laden biocomposite construct [tilapia-skin-based dECMMa with cod-skin-based dECM] than in the controls [porcine-skin-based dECMMa (pdECMMa) and tilapia-skin-based dECMMa (tdECMMa)]. Based on these results, we believe that the fish-skin-based biocomposite construct is a potential biomaterial ink for skin regeneration.

A Comparative Analysis of Biological and Synthetic Skin Models for Drug Transport Studies.

Ethical restrictions as well as practical or economic issues related to use of animal and human skin has been the main reason the growth in the number of investigations with alternative models. Reconstructed skin models, for example, have been useful to evaluate the in vitro toxicity of compounds; however, these models usually overestimate the amount of drug permeated due to impaired barrier properties. In this review, the performance of synthetic and biological skin models in transport studies was compared by considering two compounds with different physicochemical properties. The advantages and limitations of each skin model are discussed in detail. Although synthetic and reconstructed skin models have shown to be useful in the formulation optimization step, they present many limitations: (1) impaired barrier properties; (2) lack of follicular transport; (3) no metabolism in synthetic membranes; (4) differences in terms of lipid organization; (5) more affected by formulation constituents. Therefore, animal and human tissues should still be prioritized in drug transport studies until new advances in alternative models are achieved. Investigations of the impact of cell-culture conditions on skin formation, in turn, bring perspectives related to the development of unhealthy/injured skin models (an aspect that still deserves attention).

Successful reconstruction of full-thickness skin defects in a swine model using simultaneous split-thickness skin grafting and composite collagen microstructured dermal scaffolds.

Reconstitution of normal skin anatomy after full-thickness skin loss may be accomplished using a combination of a dermal regeneration template (DRT) and a split thickness skin graft (STSG). However, because of the relatively low rate of cell infiltration and vascularisation of currently available DRTs, reconstruction is almost always performed in a two-step procedure over the course of several weeks, resulting in multiple dressing changes, prolonged immobilisation and increased chance of infection. To mitigate the potential complications of this prolonged process, the collagen-based dermal template DermiSphere™ was developed and tested in a single-step procedure wherein DermiSphere and STSG were implanted simultaneously. When evaluated in a porcine, full thickness, excisional wound model, DermiSphere successfully supported simultaneous split thickness skin graft take and induced functional neodermal tissue deposition. When compared to a market leading product Integra Bilayer Wound Matrix, which was used in a multistep procedure (STSG placed 14 days after product implantation according to the product IFU), DermiSphere induced a similar moderate and transient inflammatory response that produced similar neodermal tissue maturity, thickness and vascularity, despite being implanted in a single surgical procedure leading to wound closure 2 weeks earlier. These data suggest that DermiSphere may be implanted in a single-step procedure with an STSG, which would significantly shorten the time course required for the reconstruction of both dermal and epidermal components of skin after full thickness loss.

Comparison of biopolymer scaffolds for the fabrication of skin substitutes in a porcine wound model.

This study compared three acellular scaffolds as templates for the fabrication of skin substitutes. A collagen-glycosaminoglycan (C-GAG), a biodegradable polyurethane foam (PUR) and a hybrid combination (PUR/C-GAG) were investigated. Scaffolds were prepared for cell inoculation. Fibroblasts and keratinocytes were serially inoculated onto the scaffolds and co-cultured for 14 days before transplantation. Three pigs each received four full-thickness 8 cm × 8 cm surgical wounds, into which a biodegradable temporising matrix (BTM) was implanted. Surface seals were removed after integration (28 days), and three laboratory-generated skin analogues and a control split-thickness skin graft (STSG) were applied for 16 weeks. Punch biopsies confirmed engraftment and re-epithelialisation. Biophysical wound parameters were also measured and analysed. All wounds showed greater than 80% epithelialisation by day 14 post-transplantation. The control STSG displayed 44% contraction over the 16 weeks, and the test scaffolds, C-GAG 64%, Hybrid 66.7% and PUR 67.8%. Immunohistochemistry confirmed positive epidermal keratins and basement membrane components (Integrin alpha-6, collagens IV and VII). Collagen deposition and fibre organisation indicated the degree of fibrosis and scar produced for each graft. All scaffold substitutes re-epithelialised by 4 weeks. The percentage of original wound area for the Hybrid and PUR was significantly different than the STSG and C-GAG, indicating the importance of scaffold retainment within the first 3 months post-transplant. The PUR/C-GAG scaffolds reduced the polymer pore size, assisting cell retention and reducing the contraction of in vitro collagen. Further investigation is required to ensure reproducibility and scale-up feasibility.

Collagen-coated agarose-chitosan scaffold used as a skin substitute.

A single biomaterial is disadvantageous for constructing skin in vitro, so a mixed biomaterial is more conducive to skin research. In this study, agarose-chitosan scaffolds with a final concentration of 4% were constructed by freeze-drying, in which the concentration ratios of agarose to chitosan were 1:3, 2:2, and 3:1. The scaffolds were coated with a 3 mg/ml collagen solution, and the mechanical properties were evaluated by studying density, porosity, swelling rate, and degradation rate. The results demonstrated that the agarose-chitosan scaffolds were porous, with porosity reaching 93%. Their densities ranged from 0.1 to 0.16 g/cm3 . Analysis of Young's modulus showed that the mechanical properties of the agarose-chitosan scaffolds were significantly enhanced when the agarose content in the agarose-chitosan scaffolds was increased. Moreover, the density and Young's modulus of the agarose-chitosan scaffolds of different concentration ratios were significantly different (p < 0.01). These scaffolds can withstand a certain amount of external pressure, such as that of human skin, making them more suitable for further skin replacement research. In addition, the results of thiazolyl blue tetrazolium bromide (MTT) cell assay and immunofluorescence staining showed that the collagen-coated agarose-chitosan scaffolds were conducive to keratinocyte proliferation and differentiation. The MTT results revealed significant differences between the agarose-chitosan scaffolds coated with collagen and the agarose-chitosan scaffolds without collagen (p < 0.05). This study provides the potential for in vitro skin research and applications.

Evaluation of the antiwear-ability/scratch-resistance efficacy of makeup products by in vitro test method application.

OBJECTIVE: The objective of this study is to propose a method for assessing the antiwear-ability (AW) or surface scratch-resistance (SR) efficacy of makeup products through in vitro experiments. MATERIALS AND METHOD: The method primarily involves measuring the change in weight as a means of evaluating the overall effectiveness. AW/SR effects are evaluated by applying a fixed amount of makeup product on artificial fake skin and comparing the weight difference after simulated friction/scratch. RESULTS: The in vitro results indicate that this method is easy to operate and yields repeatable data. It consistently reflects differences between samples when compared to clinical studies. CONCLUSIONS: This method effectively compares the AW/SR effects of makeup products and demonstrates utility in evaluating product efficacy and difference. It holds great scientific and practical value.