Increased parental anxiety and a benign clinical course: Infants identified with short-chain acyl-CoA dehydrogenase deficiency and isobutyryl-CoA dehydrogenase deficiency through newborn screening in Georgia.

ABSTRACT

The long-term consequences and need for therapy in children with short-chain acyl-CoA dehydrogenase deficiency (SCADD) or isobutyryl-CoA dehydrogenase deficiency (IBDD) identified via newborn screening (NBS) remains controversial. Initial clinical descriptions were severe; however, while most cases identified through NBS have remained asymptomatic, clinical concerns have been raised in these populations. It is not clear whether these children are asymptomatic because of the success of NBS, or because the normal clinical course of these disorders is relatively benign. To evaluate these possibilities in our program, we evaluated the clinical outcomes of children with SCADD or IBDD identified by the Georgia NBS compared to the health status of a healthy age-matched control group. We also assessed parental anxiety during a phone interview both subjectively and objectively using the Pediatric Inventory for Parents (PIP), a validated measure of illness-related parental stress. The general health of 52 SCADD and nine IBDD cases from 2007 to 2016 were compared to the general health of unaffected control children obtained through the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) parent listserv. We also collected statements from parents who participated in a phone survey regarding events they experienced during and after their diagnostic process. Overall, the children with SCADD and IBDD had no major health problems. There was no significant difference in cognitive development (p = .207). We identified a slightly higher incidence of reported neonatal hypoglycemia in the SCADD group; two of these occurred in the context of maternal diabetes. All interviewed parents reported extreme anxiety during the diagnostic period and current feelings of uncertainty about their child's future. PIP scores for all six caregivers who responded to that portion of the survey were consistent with some degree of parental stress. The greatest reported stressor was the unknown long-term impact of the illness. All children with SCADD and IBDD had no significant long-term sequelae. The phone interviews revealed substantial parental anxiety about the identification and follow-up of SCADD and IBDD. Based on our findings, the anxiety parents experience may be unwarranted given that we see no disease-associated morbidity or mortality in these children. Consideration should be given to the removal of these conditions from NBS panels, or if that is not possible, clinicians could educate parents on the benign nature of these diagnoses and release them from follow-up without treatment.