RESUMEN
BACKGROUND: Arthrofibrosis can limit function and return to sport after anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction. Previously reported risk factors for developing arthrofibrosis after ACL reconstruction include female sex, age <18 years, time from injury to surgery <28 days, concomitant meniscal repair, prolonged immobilization, and genetic factors. There is a lack of evidence regarding whether race plays a significant role. HYPOTHESIS: The risk of undergoing manipulation under anesthesia (MUA) and/or lysis of adhesions (LOA) after primary ACL reconstruction with bone-patellar tendon-bone (BTB) autograft in female basketball players is higher in African American players than in White players. STUDY DESIGN: Case-control study; Level of evidence, 3. METHODS: Using a computerized relational database, the authors identified competitive female basketball players who underwent primary ACL reconstruction with BTB autograft by the senior author over a 13-year period. Data previously entered from examinations and surgical findings were reviewed retrospectively. Univariate statistics and multivariable logistic regression were used to assess the relationship between undergoing subsequent MUA and/or LOA and study predictors. RESULTS: A total of 186 knees (114 African American knees and 72 White knees) met inclusion criteria. The overall rate of MUA and/or LOA was 8.6%. Thirteen African American knees (11.4%) and 3 White knees (4.2%) underwent MUA and/or LOA for treatment of arthrofibrosis. No study predictor was found to have a statistically significant relationship with the rate of MUA and/or LOA on univariate analysis. However, when controlling for body mass index and previously described risk factors (age <18 years, time from injury to surgery ≤28 days, and concomitant meniscal repair) in the logistic regression model, the authors found that MUA and/or LOA was more likely in African American (odds ratio, 4.01 [95% CI, 1.01-15.92]; P = .049) than in White female players and in patients who underwent ACL reconstruction within 28 days of injury (odds ratio, 4.01 [95% CI, 1.18-13.57]; P = .026) compared with those with surgery delayed beyond 28 days. CONCLUSION: In female basketball players, the present study found a statistically significantly increased risk for undergoing MUA and/or LOA after primary ACL reconstruction with BTB autograft in African American females compared with White females and in patients who underwent ACL reconstruction within 28 days of injury.
Asunto(s)
Anestesia , Lesiones del Ligamento Cruzado Anterior , Reconstrucción del Ligamento Cruzado Anterior , Baloncesto , Humanos , Femenino , Adolescente , Estudios de Casos y Controles , Estudios Retrospectivos , Lesiones del Ligamento Cruzado Anterior/cirugía , Lesiones del Ligamento Cruzado Anterior/etiología , Reconstrucción del Ligamento Cruzado Anterior/efectos adversos , Adherencias TisularesRESUMEN
A symptomatic meniscal tear is one of the most common problems treated by an orthopaedic surgeon. Treatment ranges from observation to complete meniscectomy. Prior research has shown that contact stresses increase within the joint compartment after partial meniscectomy, thus leading to arthritis of the compartment. The purpose of the current study was to determine the incidence of meniscal re-tears in two populations of patients and identify potential factors predisposing to re-tear. A retrospective review of our relational database identified 1,930 arthroscopic partial meniscectomies from 1993 to 2003. Meniscectomies were divided into two groups, 430 patients < 45 years of age (YOUNG) and 712 patients ≥ 45 (OLD). Age, onset date, Lysholm, Tegner, tear type, radial and circumferential location, as well as degree and location of chondromalacia, were analyzed. Of the YOUNG group, 1.16% experienced re-tears, versus 0.42% of the OLD group. From the younger re-tear group, 80% were chronic and 20% had grade 2 chondromalacia in one compartment. The YOUNG re-tear group was slightly more active with higher Tegner (5.6 vs. 4.3) and Lysholm (66.2 vs. 60) scores than the rest of the YOUNG group. The OLD re-tear group was less active with a lower Tegner (2.5 vs. 4.1) and Lysholm (62 vs. 66) score compared with the rest of the older group. In this study, patients under 45 years and with chronic tears had slightly higher incidence of re-tears. Results indicated that the lateral meniscus is more likely to re-tear.
Asunto(s)
Meniscectomía/efectos adversos , Lesiones de Menisco Tibial/epidemiología , Lesiones de Menisco Tibial/cirugía , Adolescente , Adulto , Factores de Edad , Artroscopía , Causalidad , Enfermedad Crónica , Bases de Datos Factuales , Femenino , Humanos , Incidencia , Masculino , Meniscectomía/métodos , Persona de Mediana Edad , Osteoartritis de la Rodilla/etiología , Recurrencia , Estudios Retrospectivos , Adulto JovenRESUMEN
Meniscal repair has been introduced to preserve knee function and limit the accelerated degenerative changes associated with meniscal tissue resection. Arthroscopic techniques have evolved to improve morbidity. However, there are few clinical outcome studies in the peer-reviewed literature that compare the use of these approaches. Therefore, our purpose was to perform a meta-analysis of the existing literature on arthroscopic meniscal repair techniques. Specifically, we evaluated differences in: (1) operating time; (2) incidence of postoperative meniscal healing; (3) functional outcomes, using various scoring systems; and (4) incidence of complications. We searched the peer-reviewed literature using SCOPUS, Medline, EMBASE, and Web of Science. Eight studies were eligible for the meta-analysis. These included one prospective, randomized trial (level I), three prospective, comparative studies (level II), and four retrospective, comparative studies (level III). There were a total of 476 patients who had a mean follow-up between 3 and 156 months. When evaluating objective outcomes, the inside-out technique had a significantly higher mean operating time than the all-inside technique. The inside-out and all-inside techniques had comparable meniscal healing rates, but the outside-in repair had a significantly higher rate of meniscal healing than the all-inside repair. Upon assessment of functional outcomes, the inside-out and all-inside methods had comparable International Knee Documentation Committee and Tegner activity scores, but the all-inside method had greater improvements in Lysholm scores. The inside-out and all-inside repairs had similar overall complication rates. All-inside repair may demonstrate lower operating times, but the outside-in repair may have superior meniscal healing rates. Functional outcomes are overall comparable between the techniques. However, there are limited clinical data on the outcome differences between these procedures, and further comparative studies with longer follow-up are needed.
Asunto(s)
Artroscopía/métodos , Meniscos Tibiales/cirugía , Lesiones de Menisco Tibial/cirugía , Artroscopía/estadística & datos numéricos , Humanos , Articulación de la Rodilla/cirugía , Escala de Puntuación de Rodilla de Lysholm , Meniscos Tibiales/fisiología , Tempo Operativo , Evaluación de Resultado en la Atención de Salud , Complicaciones Posoperatorias , Periodo Posoperatorio , Estudios Prospectivos , Estudios Retrospectivos , Cicatrización de HeridasRESUMEN
The purpose of this study is to compare failure rate and functional outcome in young, active patients (< 25 years) with two-incision (rear-entry) versus transtibial (all-endoscopic) anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstructions.Utilizing a computerized relational database (Access 2007, Microsoft Inc., Redmond, WA), 480 patients were identified that underwent ACL reconstruction, using a bone-patellar-tendon-bone autograft, by a single surgeon between January 2000 and December 2010 via a transtibial or two-incision technique. Totally, 377 (78.6%) of these patients were less than 25 years of age. Data for each patient were collected at their initial clinic visit, at the time of surgery, and at each follow-up clinic visit and entered into the computerized relational database. Overall, 274 patients (72.7%) underwent ACL reconstruction with a transtibial technique, and 103 patients (27.3%) underwent reconstruction with a two-incision technique. Failures were identified as a 2+ Lachman, 1+ or greater pivot shift, or a KT-1000 arthrometer difference of five or more.In patients < 25 years of age, there were 10 failures (9.7%) out of 103 patients undergoing a two-incision reconstruction and 28 failures (10.2%) out of 274 patients undergoing a transtibial reconstruction (p = 1.000). There was no statistical significance between the failure rate in the two different groups in regards to gender, meniscal tear, activity level, or any other factor that was analyzed.Our study showed no statistical difference between the two-incision technique and the transtibial technique for ACL reconstruction using bone-patellar-tendon-bone autograft with an overall 10.1% failure rate in young, active patients (< 25 years of age). The level of evidence is level IV.
Asunto(s)
Lesiones del Ligamento Cruzado Anterior/cirugía , Plastía con Hueso-Tendón Rotuliano-Hueso/métodos , Adolescente , Ligamento Cruzado Anterior/cirugía , Reconstrucción del Ligamento Cruzado Anterior , Trasplante Óseo , Femenino , Humanos , Inestabilidad de la Articulación/cirugía , Traumatismos de la Rodilla/cirugía , Masculino , Rótula/cirugía , Insuficiencia del Tratamiento , Resultado del Tratamiento , Adulto JovenRESUMEN
Is there a correlation between increased posterior-inferior tibial slope angle and noncontact anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) injury? Does increasing the posterior-inferior tibial slope angle increase the risk of bilateral ACL injury? A computerized relational database (Access 2007; Microsoft Inc, Redmond, Washington) was used to conduct a retrospective review of patients undergoing bilateral or unilateral ACL reconstruction surgery or treatment by a single surgeon between 1995 and 2013. Included in the study were patients with bilateral and unilateral ACL injuries and patellofemoral pain syndrome with no associated ACL deficiency. Exclusion criteria included concomitant ligament injury, previous ACL reconstruction, and previous knee surgery. Also excluded were patients who did not have plain lateral radiographs. Fifty patients were randomly selected from each group. After controlling for age and Tegner activity level, the authors found that the posterior-inferior tibial slope angle was a significant predictor (P=.002) of noncontact ACL injury. Mean posterior-inferior tibial slope angle for the bilateral, unilateral, and control groups was 11.8°±2.3°, 9.3°±2.4°, and 7.5°±2.3°, respectively. In the group with unilateral ACL injury vs the group without ACL deficiency, a 1° increase in posterior-inferior tibial slope angle (P=.03) was associated with a 20% increase in unilateral ACL injury. In those with bilateral ACL injury vs those without ACL deficiency, a 1° increase in posterior-inferior tibial slope angle (P=.001) increased bilateral knee injury by 34%. The difference between the mean angles of the control group without ACL deficiency and both the bilateral injury and unilateral injury cohorts was statistically significant (P=.003). Increased posterior-inferior tibial slope angle is associated with an increased risk of noncontact bilateral and unilateral ACL injury. [Orthopedics. 2017; 40(1):e136-e140.].
Asunto(s)
Lesiones del Ligamento Cruzado Anterior/epidemiología , Tibia/anatomía & histología , Tibia/diagnóstico por imagen , Adolescente , Adulto , Lesiones del Ligamento Cruzado Anterior/etiología , Lesiones del Ligamento Cruzado Anterior/cirugía , Reconstrucción del Ligamento Cruzado Anterior , Estudios de Casos y Controles , Niño , Femenino , Humanos , Masculino , Síndrome de Dolor Patelofemoral/diagnóstico por imagen , Radiografía , Estudios Retrospectivos , Factores de Riesgo , Adulto JovenRESUMEN
This study assessed the relationship between body mass index (BMI), anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) injury, and associated meniscal and cartilage injury. Age, ACL classification, and Tegner activity score were considered. A total of 1968 ACL reconstruction patients (2/1/1996 to 5/1/2012) were analyzed. All graft types, age groups, and activity levels were included. A BMI ≥30 correlated with a significant likelihood of medial meniscus tears (p = .022). Patients with a BMI ≥30 were 21.6% more likely to have a medial meniscus tear with an ACL injury. Grade III and IV chondral lesions correlated with a BMI ≥30 (p = .029). Patient's age predicted medial meniscus outcome (p = .013). Patients whose age was >25 had a 25.7% higher risk of medial meniscus tear. Chronic ACL patients were 52.6% more likely to have a meniscus injury. BMI, age, Tegner activity score, and ACL classification are good predictors of medial meniscus injury. Patients with a BMI ≥30 exhibit a greater risk of medial meniscus tear with ACL instability; however, BMI does not significantly contribute to increased chondral damage in ACL-deficient patients.
Asunto(s)
Lesiones del Ligamento Cruzado Anterior , Traumatismos en Atletas/epidemiología , Traumatismos de la Rodilla/epidemiología , Obesidad/epidemiología , Lesiones de Menisco Tibial , Enfermedad Aguda , Adulto , Factores de Edad , Reconstrucción del Ligamento Cruzado Anterior , Traumatismos en Atletas/cirugía , Índice de Masa Corporal , Cartílago Articular , Enfermedad Crónica , Estudios de Cohortes , Femenino , Humanos , Traumatismos de la Rodilla/cirugía , Masculino , Estudios Retrospectivos , Factores de Riesgo , Adulto JovenRESUMEN
BACKGROUND: Patient age, Tegner activity level, and graft size could be factors that influence the outcome of anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction (ACLR) with hamstring autografts. HYPOTHESIS: Decreased graft size, higher Tegner activity score, and younger age are associated with an increased failure rate of ACLR, represented by continued knee laxity and revision surgery. STUDY DESIGN: Cohort study; Level of evidence, 3. METHODS: A total of 98 patients who had undergone ACLR with hamstring tendon autografts between 2000 and 2007 were identified from a computerized relational database. Inclusion criteria consisted of a minimum of 2 years of follow-up, all age groups, and all activity levels. Exclusion criteria consisted of treatment with other grafts or previous ligament surgery, previous ACL repairs, bilateral ACL injuries, and associated ligament tears. Failure was defined as a 2+ Lachman result, positive pivot shift, and 5-mm difference or more on KT-1000 arthrometer measurement. RESULTS: Fifteen of the 98 ACLRs (15.3%) were defined as failures. Of the failures, 12 of 48 (25%) occurred in patients aged 25 years and younger, whereas 3 of 50 (6%) occurred in patients older than 25 years. There was a statistically significant association when comparing failure rate and age groups (P = .009); however, a significant association was not found between graft size and failure rate in the entire study population (P = .135) or within the different age groups (age ≤25 years vs. >25 years) based on failure rate (P = .390 and P = .165, respectively). No statistical significance was found when Tegner activity level and failure rate were compared in the overall study population (P = .463) or within age groups (≤25 years, P = .707; >25 years, P = .174). CONCLUSION: In this study population, younger patients (≤25 years) demonstrated a higher failure rate compared with the over-25 age group. A statistically significant difference was not found in terms of graft size and activity level correlating with failure rate in ACL reconstruction with hamstring autograft.
Asunto(s)
Lesiones del Ligamento Cruzado Anterior , Reconstrucción del Ligamento Cruzado Anterior/métodos , Traumatismos de la Rodilla/cirugía , Tendones/trasplante , Adolescente , Adulto , Factores de Edad , Ligamento Cruzado Anterior/cirugía , Niño , Femenino , Estudios de Seguimiento , Humanos , Traumatismos de la Rodilla/fisiopatología , Masculino , Persona de Mediana Edad , Reoperación , Estudios Retrospectivos , Trasplante Autólogo , Insuficiencia del Tratamiento , Adulto JovenRESUMEN
BACKGROUND: When reviewing anterior cruciate ligament instability, age, gender, activity level, associated injury, and type of graft should all be considered. HYPOTHESIS: The authors hypothesized that patients under 25 years of age will have higher failure rates with anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction than those older than 25 years, and that in the patients younger than 25 years, bone-patellar tendon-bone autograft will have the lowest failure rate. STUDY DESIGN: Cohort study; Level of evidence, 3. METHODS: With use of a computerized relational database, all patients having primary anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction at 1 institution between January 2000 and July 2007 with allograft, bone-patellar tendon-bone, and hamstring grafts were evaluated. RESULTS: A significant association was found between age group and graft failure (P = .012). Patients 25 years and younger had a significantly higher failure rate (16.5%) than patients older than 25 years (8.3%). Pairwise comparisons indicated that both allograft (29.2%) and semitendinosus/gracilis (25.0%) grafts resulted in significantly higher failure rates than bone-patellar tendon-bone grafts (11.8%) in the age group of patients 25 years and younger. CONCLUSION: Autograft hamstrings and allografts had a significantly higher failure rate in the age group of patients 25 years and younger compared with the bone-patellar tendon-bone autograft. These data suggest that bone-patellar tendon-bone autografts may be a better graft source for young, active individuals.
Asunto(s)
Reconstrucción del Ligamento Cruzado Anterior/métodos , Ligamento Cruzado Anterior/trasplante , Plastía con Hueso-Tendón Rotuliano-Hueso/métodos , Actividad Motora , Adolescente , Adulto , Factores de Edad , Niño , Estudios de Cohortes , Femenino , Humanos , Inestabilidad de la Articulación/cirugía , Masculino , Persona de Mediana Edad , Estudios Retrospectivos , Trasplante Autólogo , Trasplante Homólogo , Insuficiencia del Tratamiento , Adulto JovenRESUMEN
PURPOSE: The purpose was to analyze outcomes of nonirradiated, fresh-frozen bone-patellar tendon-bone (BPTB) allograft anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction in patients aged under 40 years with regard to activity level (Tegner score). METHODS: Between 1993 and 2005, 111 patients, aged under 40 years, underwent primary, nonirradiated, fresh-frozen BPTB allograft ACL reconstruction and were retrospectively reviewed. Follow-up was limited to a minimum of 24 months. Patients with concomitant ligament injuries and previous surgeries were excluded. Seventy-eight patients met the inclusion criterion and were available for follow-up. Four hundred eleven patients had BPTB autograft ACL reconstructions and comprised the control group. Failure of the graft was defined as repeat ACL reconstruction because of reinjury or graft failure, 2+ Lachman (no endpoint), any pivot shift, and/or 5-mm side-to-side KT-1000 difference (MEDmetric, San Diego, CA) or greater. Initial examinations, surgical findings, and follow-up examinations were prospectively entered into a computerized relational database. The results were assessed by both objective and subjective measures. RESULTS: High-activity allograft patients had a 2.6- to 4.2-fold increase in the probability of graft failure compared with low-activity BPTB allograft patients and low- and high-activity BPTB autograft patients. Patients undergoing BPTB autograft reconstruction reported significantly fewer problems on a visual analog scale and scored significantly higher on the postoperative Tegner activity scale than patients undergoing allograft reconstruction. CONCLUSIONS: The active allograft group is 2.6 to 4.2 times more likely to fail compared with low-activity allografts and low- and high-activity autografts. We conclude that fresh-frozen BPTB allografts should not be used in young patients who have a high Tegner activity score because of their higher risk of failure. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level III, retrospective comparative study.
Asunto(s)
Ligamento Cruzado Anterior/cirugía , Adolescente , Adulto , Lesiones del Ligamento Cruzado Anterior , Trasplante Óseo , Femenino , Estudios de Seguimiento , Humanos , Masculino , Ligamento Rotuliano/trasplante , Recuperación de la Función , Índice de Severidad de la Enfermedad , Trasplante Homólogo , Insuficiencia del Tratamiento , Resultado del Tratamiento , Adulto JovenRESUMEN
Allograft usage for cruciate ligament reconstruction has gained in popularity. Many techniques are described for posterior cruciate reconstruction with both autograft and allograft tendons. Achilles tendon allograft is a versatile and effective graft that can be used for a transtibial, double femoral bundle posterior cruciate reconstruction.
Asunto(s)
Tendón Calcáneo/trasplante , Procedimientos Ortopédicos/métodos , Ligamento Cruzado Posterior/cirugía , Humanos , Trasplante Homólogo/métodosRESUMEN
Bone defects are a common obstacle to successful revision anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) reconstruction. We describe the use of a synthetic bone graft plug to fill a cylindric defect after femoral interference screw removal. During revision ACL reconstruction performed through a 2-incision technique, we placed an outside-in guidewire for a new femoral tunnel that converged with the femoral screw from the primary ACL reconstruction. The screw was removed, and the resultant defect appeared very similar to the cylindric bone defect left after an osteochondral graft harvest. The confluence of the defect and the planned femoral tunnel would have allowed a "windshield wiper" effect of the graft at the lateral wall of the notch. We filled the screw defect with a synthetic bone graft plug to limit the aperture size of the femoral tunnel and to buttress the tendinous portion of the revision ACL graft, while maintaining proper anatomic graft position. In this article, we present a readily available all-arthroscopic option for repairing cylindric bone defects without the risk of an allograft or the morbidity of an autograft for a single-stage revision ACL reconstruction.
Asunto(s)
Ligamento Cruzado Anterior/cirugía , Artroscopía/métodos , Trasplante Óseo/métodos , Fémur/patología , Fémur/cirugía , Traumatismos de la Rodilla/cirugía , Adulto , Tornillos Óseos/efectos adversos , Trasplante Óseo/instrumentación , Remoción de Dispositivos , Humanos , Masculino , Reoperación/instrumentación , Reoperación/métodos , Resultado del TratamientoRESUMEN
PURPOSE: The purpose of this study was to determine whether an increased posterior-inferior tibial slope (PITS) is associated with anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) rupture and whether an increased PITS results in worse pivot-shift grades in ACL-insufficient patients. This study also examined the difference in PITS between men and women. METHODS: We radiographically measured the PITS angle of 100 ACL-insufficient patients and 100 patients with patellofemoral pain (control patients). The mean PITS of male and female cases and control patients was compared to determine whether sex had an influence on the mean PITS angle. The measured PITS was compared with the pivot-shift grade with patients under anesthesia in a subgroup of 87 isolated ACL-insufficient patients with no other knee injury. RESULTS: Female ACL-insufficient patients had a significantly greater PITS (12.0 degrees +/- 3.5 degrees ) than their negative controls (8.6 degrees +/- 2.7 degrees ) (P < .001). Male ACL-insufficient patients had a significantly greater PITS (10.8 degrees +/- 3.9 degrees ) than their negative controls (8.4 degrees +/- 3.4 degrees ) (P < .001). In the isolated ACL-insufficient patients, the high-grade pivot-shift patient group had a statistically significantly greater PITS (11.10 degrees +/- 3.85 degrees ) than the low-grade pivot-shift patient group (9.19 degrees +/- 3.58 degrees ) (P = .03). CONCLUSIONS: An increased PITS is associated with ACL rupture. A higher pivot-shift grade is associated with an increased degree of PITS. Female patients did not have a significantly greater mean PITS angle than male patients. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level III, prognostic case-control study.
Asunto(s)
Ligamento Cruzado Anterior/fisiopatología , Artropatías/fisiopatología , Tibia/anatomía & histología , Fenómenos Biomecánicos , Femenino , Humanos , Masculino , Estudios Retrospectivos , Rotura Espontánea , Factores SexualesRESUMEN
BACKGROUND: Despite emphasis on classifying meniscal tears based on healing potential of the tear, research has concentrated on unstable knees, and few reports have provided information regarding associated clinical variables in stable knees. PURPOSE: To report on a large series of meniscal tears in stable knees that have been carefully mapped by tear shape and tear zones to allow comparison with meniscal tears in unstable knees. STUDY DESIGN: Prospective case series, reviewed retrospectively. METHODS: A total of 1485 meniscal tears in stable knees were evaluated. Preoperatively, each patient underwent a standardized assessment. Each tear was carefully mapped at arthroscopy. Statistical analysis was performed to determine factors that may be associated with peripheral meniscal tears. RESULTS: The distribution and shape of tears varied significantly within the radial and circumferential zones in this stable knee population. Five prospective variables were associated with peripheral tears: gender, presence of an effusion, positive McMurray test, varus alignment, or a loss of extension more than 5 degrees. CONCLUSIONS: Patient demographic information and physical examination can be useful in identifying patients who may have a peripheral meniscus tear.
Asunto(s)
Traumatismos de la Rodilla/cirugía , Lesiones de Menisco Tibial , Adulto , Artroscopía , Femenino , Humanos , Inestabilidad de la Articulación/fisiopatología , Traumatismos de la Rodilla/patología , Modelos Lineales , Masculino , Meniscos Tibiales/cirugía , Persona de Mediana Edad , Examen Físico , Estudios Prospectivos , Estudios Retrospectivos , Factores de Riesgo , Encuestas y CuestionariosRESUMEN
PURPOSE: To compare the clinical results of anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction in female patients using quadruple-looped hamstring autograft versus patellar tendon autograft at minimum 2-year follow-up. TYPE OF STUDY: Case series. METHODS: A prospective clinical review was performed to compare the results of ACL reconstruction with hamstring versus patellar tendon autograft in a group of female patients. Exclusion criteria included chronic injuries (greater than 3 months), associated collateral ligament injuries, Workers' Compensation or litigation cases, and bilateral anterior cruciate ligament injuries. There were 39 female patients in the hamstring group (average follow-up, 40.9 months) and 37 female patients in the patellar tendon group (average follow-up, 52 months). Both types of grafts were fixed with an EndoButton proximally and with sutures tied over a post or button distally. The postoperative rehabilitation regimen was identical for both groups. Objective parameters evaluated included preinjury and postoperative Tegner and Lysholm scores, side-to-side KT-1000 maximum-manual arthrometer differences, and clinical examination including Lachman and pivot-shift tests. Graft failure was defined by any one of the following: a KT-1000 difference of greater than 5 mm, a 2+ Lachman, a 1+ or greater pivot shift, or revision surgery. RESULTS: The failure rate in the hamstring group was 23% versus 8% in the patellar tendon group, which was not statistically significant (P >.1). Comparison of preinjury Tegner activity scores to postoperative scores revealed that patients in the hamstring group did not return to their preinjury level of activity (preinjury 6.54 v postoperative 5.17) as well as patients in the patellar tendon group (preinjury 6.20 v postoperative 6.59). Patients in the hamstring group had a significant increase in pain compared with the patellar tendon group (P =.034). CONCLUSIONS: Although not statistically significant, the hamstring group had more failures, more laxity on clinical examination, and more patients with larger KT-1000 arthrometer differences. These results indicate a trend toward increased graft laxity in female patients undergoing reconstruction with hamstring autograft compared with patellar tendon when evaluated by a single surgeon using similar fixation techniques at short- to medium-range follow-up. More studies with larger patient numbers using current fixation techniques are necessary to confirm these findings.