Enhanced Thermal Stability and Reduced Aggregation in an Antibody Fab Fragment at Elevated Concentrations.

The aggregation of protein therapeutics such as antibodies remains a major challenge in the biopharmaceutical industry. The present study aimed to characterize the impact of the protein concentration on the mechanisms and potential pathways for aggregation, using the antibody Fab fragment A33 as the model protein. Aggregation kinetics were determined for 0.05 to 100 mg/mL Fab A33, at 65 °C. A surprising trend was observed whereby increasing the concentration decreased the relative aggregation rate, ln(v) (% day-1), from 8.5 at 0.05 mg/mL to 4.4 at 100 mg/mL. The absolute aggregation rate (mol L-1 h-1) increased with the concentration following a rate order of approximately 1 up to a concentration of 25 mg/mL. Above this concentration, there was a transition to an apparently negative rate order of -1.1 up to 100 mg/mL. Several potential mechanisms were examined as possible explanations. A greater apparent conformational stability at 100 mg/mL was observed from an increase in the thermal transition midpoint (Tm) by 7-9 °C, relative to those at 1-4 mg/mL. The associated change in unfolding entropy (△Svh) also increased by 14-18% at 25-100 mg/mL, relative to those at 1-4 mg/mL, indicating reduced conformational flexibility in the native ensemble. Addition of Tween or the crowding agents Ficoll and dextran, showed that neither surface adsorption, diffusion limitations nor simple volume crowding affected the aggregation rate. Fitting of kinetic data to a wide range of mechanistic models implied a reversible two-state conformational switch mechanism from aggregation-prone monomers (N*) into non-aggregating native forms (N) at higher concentrations. kD measurements from DLS data also suggested a weak self-attraction while remaining colloidally stable, consistent with macromolecular self-crowding within weakly associated reversible oligomers. Such a model is also consistent with compaction of the native ensemble observed through changes in Tm and △Svh.

Nonspecific Binding of Adenosine Tripolyphosphate and Tripolyphosphate Modulates the Phase Behavior of Lysozyme.

Adenosine tripolyphosphate (ATP) is a small polyvalent anion that has recently been shown to interact with proteins and have a major impact on assembly processes involved in biomolecular condensate formation and protein aggregation. However, the nature of non-specific protein-ATP interactions and their effects on protein solubility are largely unknown. Here, the binding of ATP to the globular model protein is characterized in detail using X-ray crystallography and nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR). Using NMR, we identified six ATP binding sites on the lysozyme surface, with one known high-affinity nucleic acid binding site and five non-specific previously unknown sites with millimolar affinities that also bind tripolyphosphate (TPP). ATP binding occurs primarily through the polyphosphate moiety, which was confirmed by the X-ray structure of the lysozyme-ATP complex. Importantly, ATP binds preferentially to arginine over lysine in non-specific binding sites. ATP and TPP have similar effects on solution-phase protein-protein interactions. At low salt concentrations, ion binding to lysozyme causes precipitation, while at higher salt concentrations, redissolution occurs. The addition of an equimolar concentration of magnesium to ATP does not alter ATP binding affinities but prevents lysozyme precipitation. These findings have important implications for both protein crystallization and cell biology. Crystallization occurs readily in ATP solutions outside the well-established crystallization window. In the context of cell biology, the findings suggest that ATP binds non-specifically to folded proteins in physiological conditions. Based on the nature of the binding sites identified by NMR, we propose several mechanisms for how ATP binding can prevent the aggregation of natively folded proteins.

ATP and Tri-Polyphosphate (TPP) Suppress Protein Aggregate Growth by a Supercharging Mechanism.

A common strategy to increase aggregation resistance is through rational mutagenesis to supercharge proteins, which leads to high colloidal stability, but often has the undesirable effect of lowering conformational stability. We show this trade-off can be overcome by using small multivalent polyphosphate ions, adenosine triphosphate (ATP) and tripolyphosphate (TPP) as excipients. These ions are equally effective at suppressing aggregation of ovalbumin and bovine serum albumin (BSA) upon thermal stress as monitored by dynamic and static light scattering. Monomer loss kinetic studies, combined with measurements of native state protein-protein interactions and ζ-potentials, indicate the ions reduce aggregate growth by increasing the protein colloidal stability through binding and overcharging the protein. Out of three additional proteins studied, ribonuclease A (RNaseA), α-chymotrypsinogen (α-Cgn), and lysozyme, we only observed a reduction in aggregate growth for RNaseA, although overcharging by the poly-phosphate ions still occurs for lysozyme and α-Cgn. Because the salts do not alter protein conformational stability, using them as excipients could be a promising strategy for stabilizing biopharmaceuticals once the protein structural factors that determine whether multivalent ion binding will increase colloidal stability are better elucidated. Our findings also have biological implications. Recently, it has been proposed that ATP also plays an important role in maintaining intracellular biological condensates and preventing protein aggregation in densely packed cellular environments. We expect electrostatic interactions are a significant factor in determining the stabilizing ability of ATP towards maintaining proteins in non-dispersed states in vivo.

Measuring Nonspecific Protein-Protein Interactions by Dynamic Light Scattering.

Dynamic light scattering has become a method of choice for measuring and quantifying weak, nonspecific protein-protein interactions due to its ease of use, minimal sample consumption, and amenability to high-throughput screening via plate readers. A procedure is given on how to prepare protein samples, carry out measurements by commonly used experimental setups including flow through systems, plate readers, and cuvettes, and analyze the correlation functions to obtain diffusion coefficient data. The chapter concludes by a theoretical section that derives and rationalizes the correlation between diffusion coefficient measurements and protein-protein interactions.

Controlling Phase Separation of Lysozyme with Polyvalent Anions.

The ability of polyvalent anions to influence protein-protein interactions and protein net charge was investigated through solubility and turbidity experiments, determination of osmotic second virial coefficients ( B22), and ζ-potential values for lysozyme solutions.  B22 values showed that all anions reduce protein-protein repulsion between positively charged lysozyme molecules, and those anions with higher net valencies are more effective. The polyvalent anions pyrophosphate and tripolyphosphate were observed to induce protein reentrant condensation, which has been previously observed with negatively charged proteins in the presence of trivalent cations. Reentrant condensation is a phenomenon in which low concentrations of polyvalent ions induce protein precipitation, but further increasing polyvalent ion concentration causes the protein precipitate to resolubilize. Interestingly, citrate does not induce lysozyme reentrant condensation despite having a similar charge, size, and shape to pyrophosphate. We observe qualitative differences in protein behavior when compared against negatively charged proteins in solutions of trivalent cations. The polyphosphate ions induce a much stronger protein-protein attraction, which correlates with the occurrence of a liquid-gel transition that replaces the liquid-liquid transition observed with trivalent cations. The results indicate that solutions of polyphosphate ions provide a model system for exploring the link between the protein-phase diagram and model interaction potentials and also highlight the importance that ion-specific effects can have on protein solubility.

Analysis of Mesoscopic Structured 2-Propanol/Water Mixtures Using Pressure Perturbation Calorimetry and Molecular Dynamic Simulation.

In this paper we demonstrate the application of pressure perturbation calorimetry (PPC) to the characterization of 2-propanol/water mixtures. PPC of different 2-propanol/water mixtures provides two useful measurements: (i) the change in heat (ΔQ); and (ii) the [Formula: see text] value. The results demonstrate that the ΔQ values of the mixtures deviate from that expected for a random mixture, with a maximum at ~20-25 mol% 2-propanol. This coincides with the concentration at which molecular dynamics (MD) simulations show a maximum deviation from random distribution, and also the point at which alcohol-alcohol hydrogen bonds become dominant over alcohol-water hydrogen bonds. Furthermore, the [Formula: see text] value showed transitions at 2.5 mol% 2-propanol and at approximately 14 mol% 2-propanol. Below 2.5 mol% 2-propanol the values of [Formula: see text] are negative; this is indicative of the presence of isolated 2-propanol molecules surrounded by water molecules. Above 2.5 mol% 2-propanol [Formula: see text] rises, reaching a maximum at ~14 mol% corresponding to a point where mixed alcohol-water networks are thought to dominate. The values and trends identified by PPC show excellent agreement not only with those obtained from MD simulations but also with results in the literature derived using viscometry, THz spectroscopy, NMR and neutron diffraction.

Molecular Mechanism for the Hofmeister Effect Derived from NMR and DSC Measurements on Barnase.

The effects of sodium thiocyanate, sodium chloride, and sodium sulfate on the ribonuclease barnase were studied using differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) and NMR. Both measurements reveal specific and saturable binding at low anion concentrations (up to 250 mM), which produces localized conformational and energetic effects that are unrelated to the Hofmeister series. The binding of sulfate slows intramolecular motions, as revealed by peak broadening in 13C heteronuclear single quantum coherence spectroscopy. None of the anions shows significant binding to hydrophobic groups. Above 250 mM, the DSC results are consistent with the expected Hofmeister effects in that the chaotropic anion thiocyanate destabilizes barnase. In this higher concentration range, the anions have approximately linear effects on protein NMR chemical shifts, with no evidence for direct interaction of the anions with the protein surface. We conclude that the effects of the anions on barnase are mediated by solvent interactions. The results are not consistent with the predictions of the preferential interaction, preferential hydration, and excluded volume models commonly used to describe Hofmeister effects. Instead, they suggest that the Hofmeister anion effects on both stability and solubility of barnase are due to the way in which the protein interacts with water molecules, and in particular with water dipoles, which are more ordered around sulfate anions and less ordered around thiocyanate anions.

A study of the relationship between water and anions of the Hofmeister series using pressure perturbation calorimetry.

Pressure perturbation calorimetry (PPC) was used to study the relationship between water and sodium salts with a range of different anions. At temperatures around 25 °C the heat on pressurisation (ΔQ) from 1 to 5 bar was negative for all solutions relative to pure water. The raw data showed that as the temperature rose, the gradient was positive relative to pure water and the transition temperature where ΔQ was zero was related to anion surface charge density and was more pronounced for the low-charge density anions. A three component model was developed comprising bulk water, the hydration layer and the solute to calculate the molar expansivity of the hydration layer around the ions in solution. The calculated molar expansivities of water in the hydration layer around the ions were consistently less than pure water. ΔQ at different disodium hydrogen phosphate concentrations showed that the change in molar enthalpy relative to pure water was not linear even as it approached infinite dilution suggesting that while hydration layers can be allocated to the water around ions this does not rule out interactions between water and ions extending beyond the immediate hydration layer.

Three stages of lysozyme thermal stabilization by high and medium charge density anions.

Addition of high and medium charge density anions (phosphate, sulfate, and chloride) to lysozyme in pure water demonstrates three stages for stabilization of the protein structure. The first two stages have a minor impact on lysozyme stability and are probably associated with direct interaction of the ions with charged and partial charges on the protein's surface. There is a clear transition between the second and third stages; in the case of sodium chloride, disodium sulfate and disodium hydrogen phosphate this is at 550, 210, and 120 mM, respectively. Stabilization of lysozyme can be explained by the free energy required to hydrate the protein as it unfolds. At low ion concentrations, the protein's hydration layer is at equilibrium with the bulk water. After the transition, bulk water is depleted and the protein is competing for water with the ions. With competition for water between the protein and the ions at higher salt concentrations, the free energy required to hydrate the interior of the protein rises and it is this that stabilizes the protein structure.

Biopharmaceutical liquid formulation: a review of the science of protein stability and solubility in aqueous environments.

Formulation scientists employed in the biopharmaceutical industry face the challenge of creating liquid aqueous formulations for proteins that never had evolutionary pressure to be exceptionally stable or soluble. Yet commercial products usually need a shelf life of 2 years to be economically viable. The research done in this field is dominated by physical chemists who have developed theories like preferential interaction, preferential hydration and excluded volume to explain the mechanisms for the interaction between salt, small organic molecules and proteins. This review aims to translate the research findings on protein stability and solubility produced by the physical chemists and make it accessible to formulation scientists working within the biopharmaceutical industry.

Analysis of the hydration water around bovine serum albumin using terahertz coherent synchrotron radiation.

Terahertz spectroscopy was used to study the absorption of bovine serum albumin (BSA) in water. The Diamond Light Source operating in a low alpha mode generated coherent synchrotron radiation that covered a useable spectral bandwidth of 0.3-3.3 THz (10-110 cm(-1)). As the BSA concentration was raised, there was a nonlinear change in absorption inconsistent with Beer's law. At low BSA concentrations (0-1 mM), the absorption remained constant or rose slightly. Above a concentration of 1 mM BSA, a steady decrease in absorption was observed, which was followed by a plateau that started at 2.5 mM. Using a overlapping hydration layer model, the hydration layer was estimated to extend 15 Å from the protein. Calculation of the corrected absorption coefficient (αcorr) for the water around BSA by subtracting the excluded volume of the protein provides an alternative approach to studying the hydration layer that provides evidence for complexity in the population of water around BSA.

Thermal stability of lysozyme as a function of ion concentration: a reappraisal of the relationship between the Hofmeister series and protein stability.

Anion and cation effects on the structural stability of lysozyme were investigated using differential scanning calorimetry. At low concentrations (<5 mM) anions and cations alter the stability of lysozyme but they do not follow the Hofmeister (or inverse Hofmeister) series. At higher concentrations protein stabilization follows the well-established Hofmeister series. Our hypothesis is that there are three mechanisms at work. At low concentrations the anions interact with charged side chains where the presence of the ion can alter the structural stability of the protein. At higher concentrations the low charge density anions perchlorate and iodide interact weakly with the protein. Their presence however reduces the Gibbs free energy required to hydrate the core of the protein that is exposed during unfolding therefore destabilizing the structure. At higher concentrations the high charge density anions phosphate and sulfate compete for water with the protein as it unfolds increasing the Gibbs free energy required to hydrate the newly exposed core of the protein therefore stabilizing the structure.

Dual effects of sodium phytate on the structural stability and solubility of proteins.

The interaction between sodium phytate and three proteins was studied using solubility experiments and differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) to assess structural stability. Lysozyme, which is positively charged at neutral pH, bound phytate by an electrostatic interaction. There was evidence that phytate cross-linked lysozyme molecules forcing them out of solution. Myoglobin and human serum albumin, which were neutral or negatively charged, respectively, displayed association rather than binding, and there was no complex formation. All of the proteins were structurally destabilized by the presence of phytate but were not denatured. From these findings, we predict that phytate would bind electrostatically to a wide variety of positively charged proteins in the stomach as well as to trypsin and chymotrypsin in the duodenum. Both binding reactions may compromise the digestion of the protein component in feed stuffs. Because the interaction between phytate and protein is electrostatic, the presence of anions, such as chloride, would nullify the antinutritional effect of phytate.

A functional description of CymA, an electron-transfer hub supporting anaerobic respiratory flexibility in Shewanella.

CymA (tetrahaem cytochrome c) is a member of the NapC/NirT family of quinol dehydrogenases. Essential for the anaerobic respiratory flexibility of shewanellae, CymA transfers electrons from menaquinol to various dedicated systems for the reduction of terminal electron acceptors including fumarate and insoluble minerals of Fe(III). Spectroscopic characterization of CymA from Shewanella oneidensis strain MR-1 identifies three low-spin His/His co-ordinated c-haems and a single high-spin c-haem with His/H(2)O co-ordination lying adjacent to the quinol-binding site. At pH 7, binding of the menaquinol analogue, 2-heptyl-4-hydroxyquinoline-N-oxide, does not alter the mid-point potentials of the high-spin (approximately -240 mV) and low-spin (approximately -110, -190 and -265 mV) haems that appear biased to transfer electrons from the high- to low-spin centres following quinol oxidation. CymA is reduced with menadiol (E(m) = -80 mV) in the presence of NADH (E(m) = -320 mV) and an NADH-menadione (2-methyl-1,4-naphthoquinone) oxidoreductase, but not by menadiol alone. In cytoplasmic membranes reduction of CymA may then require the thermodynamic driving force from NADH, formate or H2 oxidation as the redox poise of the menaquinol pool in isolation is insufficient. Spectroscopic studies suggest that CymA requires a non-haem co-factor for quinol oxidation and that the reduced enzyme forms a 1:1 complex with its redox partner Fcc3 (flavocytochrome c3 fumarate reductase). The implications for CymA supporting the respiratory flexibility of shewanellae are discussed.