Blood transfusion safety: a new philosophy.

Blood transfusion safety has had a chequered history, and there are current and future challenges. Internationally, there is no clear consensus for many aspects of the provision of safe blood, although pan-national legislation does provide a baseline framework in the European Union. Costs are rising, and new safety measures can appear expensive, especially when tested against some other medical interventions, such as cancer treatment and vaccination programmes. In this article, it is proposed that a comprehensive approach is taken to the issue of blood transfusion safety that considers all aspects of the process rather than considering only new measures. The need for an agreed level of safety for specified and unknown risks is also suggested. The importance of providing care and support for those inadvertently injured as a result of transfusion problems is also made. Given that the current blood safety decision process often uses a utilitarian principle for decision making--through the calculation of Quality Adjusted Life Years--an alternative philosophy is proposed. A social contract for blood safety, based on the principles of 'justice as fairness' developed by John Rawls, is recommended as a means of providing an agreed level of safety, containing costs and providing support for any adverse outcomes.

Long-term follow-up of HCV-infected hematopoietic SCT patients and effects of antiviral therapy.

This prospective study was initiated in 1993 with the aim to study late effects and responses to antiviral therapy in a cohort of hepatitis C virus (HCV)-infected patients. A total of 195 patients were included from 12 centers. In all, 134 patients had undergone allogeneic and 61 autologous hematopoietic SCT (HSCT). The median follow-up from HSCT is currently 16.8 years and the maximum 27.2 years. Overall 33 of 195 patients have died of which 6 died from liver complications. The survival probability was 81.6% and the cumulative incidence for death in liver complications was 6.1% at 20 years after HSCT. The cumulative incidence of severe liver complications (death from liver failure, cirrhosis and liver transplantation) was 11.7% at 20 years after HSCT. In all, 85 patients have been treated with IFN; 42 in combination with ribavirin. The sustained response rate was 40%. The rates of severe side effects were comparable to other patient populations and no patient developed significant exacerbations of GVHD. Patients receiving antiviral therapy had a trend toward a decreased risk of severe liver complications (odds ratio=0.33; P=0.058). HCV infection is associated with morbidity and mortality in long-term survivors after HSCT. Antiviral therapy can be given safely and might reduce the risk for severe complications.

Benefits of a blood donation archive repository: international survey of donor repository procedures and Scottish experiences.

BACKGROUND: The use of a donation sample archive has been in place within the Scottish National Blood Transfusion Service for almost 35 years but the advent of human immunodeficiency virus donor testing led to this archive being kept for an indefinite period. This article describes the uses made of our archive repository. STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS: Records of various potential transfusion transmission episodes were accessed and examined to assess the age of the archives investigated and the outcome of the investigations. Other uses of the archive repository were also investigated by reviewing the records of retrievals. The use of the archive to aid the interpretation of hepatitis C virus-indeterminate results was also conducted. Finally a global survey was performed to ascertain the temperature and length of storage used by various transfusion services. RESULTS: A 3-year archive would have allowed for the investigation of 45 percent of cases (including all hepatitis B virus cases), while a 10-year archive would have allowed for 90 percent of cases. Only 34 percent of cases were shown to be transfusion-transmitted. Of 16 donors with c22-indeterminate bands on recombinant immunoblot assay, 2 (12%) could have been classified as confirmed-positive on the basis of their archive samples. A considerable proportion (41%) of the most recent requests for retrieval from the archive have been associated with the need to perform new mandatory tests for tissue donations at issue. Samples older than 3 years accounted for 25 percent of all samples retrieved. The global survey showed a variety of conditions in terms of both length and temperature of storage. CONCLUSION: The use of a donation archive has been shown to be extremely useful in the investigation of potential transfusion-transmitted infections with most (66%) having no evidence of transfusion transmission. Although 90 percent of our cases could have been fully investigated with only a 10-year archive, perhaps the future retention period of hospital records should be considered when determining the length of storage of current donation archive samples.

The EU optimal blood use project.

The EU optimal blood use project (EUOBUP) is co-funded by the European Commission and led by the Scottish National Blood Transfusion Service (SNBTS). Its purpose is to develop, evaluate and disseminate a manual that provides practical guidance and support for those seeking to improve the safety of the clinical transfusion process and the effectiveness of the prescribing of blood components. We define the optimal use of blood components as the safe, clinically effective and efficient use of the scarce resource of donated human blood. The project will build on the experience of a pilot project in optimal use of blood in the national health service in Scotland. This pilot developed training resources in the safe and effective use of blood and delivered training to a large number of practitioners. It has also developed systems to provide hospitals with comparative information on their use of blood components for specific clinical groups of patients to assist them in reviewing practice against that of their peers.

Immature monocytes from G-CSF-mobilized peripheral blood stem cell collections carry surface-bound IL-10 and have the potential to modulate alloreactivity.

Production of the anti-inflammatory cytokine IL-10 by monocytes has been implicated as a probable negative regulator of graft-versus-host disease (GvHD) in patients undergoing allogeneic stem cell transplants (SCT). Monocytes from G-CSF-mobilized peripheral blood stem cell (gmPBSC) collections have been reported to produce more IL-10 than unmobilized monocytes in response to proinflammatory factors such as LPS. Why this should occur is unclear. In this study, monocyte phenotype and IL-10 localization and release were investigated in PB mononuclear cells (MNC) from 27 healthy donors mobilized for allogeneic SCT and from 13 patients with hematological malignancies mobilized for autologous SCT. All isolates contained elevated total percentages of monocytes in comparison with unmobilized PB, a high proportion of which displayed an immature phenotype. Stimulation of gmPB MNC with an inflammatory stimulus [fixed Staphylococcus aureus cells (SAC)] induced rapid up-regulation of CD14, indicating conversion to mature status. Localization studies indicated that IL-10 was predominantly present, bound on the surface of CD64(+)/CD14(low/neg) immature monocytes. Inflammatory stimuli (LPS, polyinosinic:polycytidylic acid, or SAC) induced release of variable quantities of IL-10 from the cell surface. MNC, separated into surface IL-10-positive or -negative fractions, differed in their ability to stimulate alloreactivity in MLR, and IL-10(+) MNC induced significantly lower levels of proliferation than IL-10(-) MNC. Thus, the subset of immature monocytes carrying surface-bound IL-10 in gmPB has the potential to modulate alloreactivity and GvHD after allogeneic SCT through cell-to-cell contact and released IL-10.

A randomized study (WOS MM1) comparing the oral regime Z-Dex (idarubicin and dexamethasone) with vincristine, adriamycin and dexamethasone as induction therapy for newly diagnosed patients with multiple myeloma.

Whilst infusional vincristine, adriamycin and dexamethasone (VAD) is an effective treatment for patients with multiple myeloma (MM), administration may be complicated by line-associated infections and thromboses. The oral regime, Z-Dex (idarubicin and dexamethasone) has been shown to be efficacious in MM. We conducted a randomized study comparing Z-Dex with VAD as induction therapy in newly diagnosed MM patients. A total of 106 patients (median age, 56 years; range: 37-73; Durie-Salmon stage II/III) were randomized to receive four to six cycles of Z-Dex or VAD. Central line complications were reported in 38 patients on 57 cycles, primarily because of infection. Neutropenia (all grades) was more common in the Z-Dex arm (P = 0.009) although grade III/IV neutropenia was not significantly different between the treatment groups (P = 0.06). Infections (all grades) were more commonly seen in the VAD arm (P = 0.001) although grade III/IV infections were not significantly different between the two groups (P = 0.081). The responses to therapy (complete/partial response) in evaluable patients were: VAD 74% vs. Z-Dex 58%, with an estimated difference in response of 16% (95% CI -2-33, P = 0.075). VAD recipients (15%) suffered early treatment-related mortality compared with 12% of Z-Dex recipients. Overall, 45 patients have died: disease progression (Z-Dex n = 13, VAD n = 10), regimen-related toxicity (Z-Dex n = 2, VAD n = 2), infection (Z-Dex n = 0, VAD n = 3), other causes (Z-Dex n = 7, VAD n = 2), unknown (Z-Dex n = 3, VAD n = 2). This study demonstrated that Z-Dex might be a suitable oral alternative to VAD for treating newly diagnosed MM patients, although definitive evidence for equivalence is not provided.

Immediate haemostasis with recombinant factor VIIa for haemorrhage following Hickman line insertion in acute myeloid leukaemia.

Bleeding following Hickman line insertion is not uncommon but can be life threatening, especially in the presence of coagulopathy and thrombocytopenia following chemotherapy. Treatment to control the bleeding can be challenging and treatment options are limited. We present our experience of a patient who had persisting haemorrhage immediately following Hickman line insertion for administration of chemotherapy for relapsed acute myeloid leukaemia. Haemostasis could not be achieved after FFP and platelet administration. A single dose of recombinant factor VIIa (rhFVIIa) stopped the bleeding immediately, avoiding the need for surgical intervention or line removal. Our experience indicates rhFVIIa may be an effective option for bleeding related to Hickman line insertion.

No strong relationship between mannan binding lectin or plasma ficolins and chemotherapy-related infections.

Chemotherapy causes neutropenia and an increased susceptibility to infection. Recent reports indicate that mannan-binding lectin (MBL) insufficiency is associated with an increased duration of febrile neutropenia and incidence of serious infections following chemotherapy for haematological malignancies. We aimed to confirm or refute this finding and to extend the investigation to the plasma ficolins, P35 (L-ficolin) and the Hakata antigen (H-ficolin). MBL, L-ficolin and H-ficolin were measured in 128 patients with haematological malignancies treated by chemotherapy alone or combined with bone marrow transplantation. Protein concentrations were related to clinical data retrieved from medical records. MBL concentrations were elevated compared with healthy controls in patients who received chemotherapy, while L-ficolin concentrations were decreased and H-ficolin levels were unchanged. There was no correlation between MBL, L-ficolin or H-ficolin concentration and febrile neutropenia expressed as the proportion of neutropenic periods in which patients experienced fever, and there was no relation between abnormally low (deficiency) levels of MBL, L-ficolin or H-ficolin and febrile neutropenia so expressed. Patients with MBL < or =0.1 microg/ml had significantly more major infections than no infections within the follow-up period (P<0.05), but overall most patients had signs or symptoms of minor infections irrespective of MBL concentration. Neither L-ficolin nor H-ficolin deficiencies were associated with infections individually, in combination or in combination with MBL deficiency. MBL, L-ficolin and H-ficolin, independently or in combination, did not have a major influence on susceptibility to infection in these patients rendered neutropenic by chemotherapy. These results cast doubt on the potential value of MBL replacement therapy in this clinical context.

The storage and re-infusion of autologous blood and BM as back-up following failed primary hematopoietic stem-cell transplantation: a survey of European practice.

BACKGROUND: Traditionally, autologous BM or PBSC have been stored as a secondary source ('back-up') of hematopoietic stem cells (HSC) prior to allogeneic and autologous HSC transplantation. METHOD: We conducted an audit of a single transplant center practice for providing back-up HSC and compared this practice with other European centers. Laboratory records relating to the collection and re-infusion of consecutive HSC harvests were reviewed for 515 transplants (300 autologous and 215 allogeneic HSC transplants). RESULTS: In our experience, 2.3% (five of 215) of allogeneic HSC transplants required secondary HSC rescue for failure to engraft or graft failure (MUD, n = 2; un-manipulated sibling BMT, n = 1; T-cell depleted sibling BMT, n = 2). For autologous transplants, 4.7% (14 of 300) required rescue due to failure to engraft or late graft failure (ABMT for AML, n = 8; CD34+ cell selection/ex vivo expanded, n = 4; ABMT/PBSCT, n = 2). Among the European centers, 69.7% replied to a postal questionnaire, demonstrating that 81.4% and 45.6% of centers stored a secondary HSC source for manipulated and unmanipulated MUD BMT, respectively; 50% and 11.6% of centers stored a secondary source of HSC for manipulated and unmanipulated matched sibling BMT, respectively; 36.4% and 12.7% of centers stored HSC for manipulated and unmanipulated matched sibling PBSCT, respectively. In the autologous setting, 15.2% and 62.1% of centers stored back-up for unmanipulated and manipulated BMT, respectively and 19.5% and 68.5% stored back-up for unmanipulated and manipulated PBSCT, respectively, when myeloablative conditioning regimens were used. DISCUSSION: These data suggest that a small minority of patients require a secondary source of HSC rescue, most commonly in transplants with higher risk of graft failure. This is reflected in the practice across Europe of storing 'back-up' HSC. Guidelines should accommodate the need for storage of a secondary source of HSC only in those transplants associated with a higher risk of graft failure, especially in relation to graft engineering.