Protein domains of low sequence complexity-dark matter of the proteome.

This perspective begins with a speculative consideration of the properties of the earliest proteins to appear during evolution. What did these primitive proteins look like, and how were they of benefit to early forms of life? I proceed to hypothesize that primitive proteins have been preserved through evolution and now serve diverse functions important to the dynamics of cell morphology and biological regulation. The primitive nature of these modern proteins is easy to spot. They are composed of a limited subset of the 20 amino acids used by traditionally evolved proteins and thus are of low sequence complexity. This chemical simplicity limits protein domains of low sequence complexity to forming only a crude and labile type of protein structure currently hidden from the computational powers of machine learning. I conclude by hypothesizing that this structural weakness represents the underlying virtue of proteins that, at least for the moment, constitute the dark matter of the proteome.

Oxidative regulation of TDP-43 self-association by a ß-to-α conformational switch.

An evolutionarily conserved region of the TDP-43 low-complexity domain (LCD) twenty residues in length can adopt either an α-helical or ß-strand conformation. When in the latter conformation, TDP-43 self-associates via the formation of a labile, cross-ß structure. Self-association can be monitored via the formation of phase-separated protein droplets. Exposure of droplets to hydrogen peroxide leads to oxidation of conserved methionine residues distributed throughout the LCD. Oxidation disassembles the cross-ß structure, thus eliminating both self-association and phase separation. Here, we demonstrate that this process reciprocally enables formation of α-helical structure in precisely the same region formerly functioning to facilitate ß-strand-mediated self-association. We further observe that the α-helical conformation allows interaction with a lipid-like detergent and that exposure to lipids enhances the ß-to-α conformational switch. We hypothesize that regulation of this oxidative switch will prove to be important to the control of localized translation within vertebrate cells. The experimental observations reported herein were heavily reliant on studies of 1,6-hexanediol, a chemical agent that selectively dissolves labile structures formed via the self-association of protein domains of low sequence complexity. This aliphatic alcohol is shown to exert its dissociative activity primarily via hydrogen-bonding interactions with carbonyl oxygen atoms of the polypeptide backbone. Such observations underscore the central importance of backbone-mediated protein:protein interactions that facilitate the self-association and phase separation of LCDs.

How do disordered head domains assist in the assembly of intermediate filaments?

The dominant structural feature of intermediate filament (IF) proteins is a centrally located α-helix. These long α-helical segments become paired in a parallel orientation to form coiled-coil dimers. Pairs of dimers further coalesce in an anti-parallel orientation to form tetramers. These early stages of intermediate filament assembly can be accomplished solely by the central α-helices. By contrast, the assembly of tetramers into mature intermediate filaments is reliant upon an N-terminal head domain. IF head domains measure roughly 100 amino acids in length and have long been understood to exist in a state of structural disorder. Here, we describe experiments favoring the unexpected idea that head domains self-associate to form transient structural order in the form of labile cross-ß interactions. We propose that this weak form of protein structure allows for dynamic regulation of IF assembly and disassembly. We further offer that what we have learned from studies of IF head domains may represent a simple, unifying template for understanding how thousands of other intrinsically disordered proteins help to establish dynamic morphological order within eukaryotic cells.

Oxidative regulation of TDP-43 self-association by a ß-to-α conformational switch.

An evolutionarily conserved region of the TDP-43 low complexity domain twenty residues in length can adopt either an α-helical or ß-strand conformation. When in the latter conformation, TDP-43 self-associates via the formation of a labile, cross-ß structure. Self-association can be monitored via the formation of phase separated protein droplets. Exposure of droplets to hydrogen peroxide leads to oxidation of conserved methionine residues distributed throughout the low complexity domain. Oxidation disassembles the cross-ß structure, thus eliminating both self-association and phase separation. Here we demonstrate that this process reciprocally enables formation of α-helical structure in precisely the same region formerly functioning to facilitate ß-strand mediated self-association. We further observe that the α-helical conformation allows interaction with a lipid-like detergent, and that exposure to lipids enhances the ß-to-α conformational switch. We hypothesize that regulation of this oxidative switch will prove to be important to the control of localized translation within vertebrate cells. The experimental observations reported herein were heavily reliant on studies of 1,6-hexanediol, a chemical agent that selectively dissolves labile structures formed via the self-association of protein domains of low sequence complexity. This aliphatic alcohol is shown to exert its dissociative activity primarily via hydrogen bonding interactions with carbonyl oxygen atoms of the polypeptide backbone. Such observations underscore the central importance of backbone-mediated protein:protein interactions that facilitate the self-association and phase separation of low complexity domains. Significance Statement: The TDP-43 protein is a constituent of RNA granules involved in regulated translation. TDP-43 contains a C-terminal domain of 150 amino acids of low sequence complexity conspicuously decorated with ten methionine residues. An evolutionarily conserved region (ECR) of 20 residues within this domain can adopt either of two forms of labile secondary structure. Under normal conditions wherein methionine residues are reduced, the ECR forms a labile cross-ß structure that enables RNA granule condensation. Upon methionine oxidation, the ECR undergoes a conformational switch to become an α-helix incompatible with self-association and granule integrity. Oxidation of the TDP-43 low complexity domain is hypothesized to occur proximal to mitochondria, thus facilitating dissolution of RNA granules and activation of localized translation.

Mutations linked to neurological disease enhance self-association of low-complexity protein sequences.

Protein domains of low sequence complexity do not fold into stable, three-dimensional structures. Nevertheless, proteins with these sequences assist in many aspects of cell organization, including assembly of nuclear and cytoplasmic structures not surrounded by membranes. The dynamic nature of these cellular assemblies is caused by the ability of low-complexity domains (LCDs) to transiently self-associate through labile, cross-ß structures. Mechanistic studies useful for the study of LCD self-association have evolved over the past decade in the form of simple assays of phase separation. Here, we have used such assays to demonstrate that the interactions responsible for LCD self-association can be dictated by labile protein structures poised close to equilibrium between the folded and unfolded states. Furthermore, missense mutations causing Charcot-Marie-Tooth disease, frontotemporal dementia, and Alzheimer's disease manifest their pathophysiology in vitro and in cultured cell systems by enhancing the stability of otherwise labile molecular structures formed upon LCD self-association.

How do protein domains of low sequence complexity work?

This review covers research findings reported over the past decade concerning the ability of low complexity (LC) domains to self-associate in a manner leading to their phase separation from aqueous solution. We focus our message upon the reductionist use of two forms of phase separation as biochemical assays to study how LC domains might function in living cells. Cells and their varied compartments represent extreme examples of material condensates. Over the past half century, biochemists, structural biologists, and molecular biologists have resolved the mechanisms driving innumerable forms of macromolecular condensation. In contrast, we remain largely ignorant as to how 10%-20% of our proteins actually work to assist in cell organization. This enigmatic 10%-20% of the proteome corresponds to gibberish-like LC sequences. We contend that many of these LC sequences move in and out of a structurally ordered, self-associated state as a means of offering a combination of organizational specificity and dynamic pliability to living cells. Finally, we speculate that ancient proteins may have behaved similarly, helping to condense, organize, and protect RNA early during evolution.

The low-complexity domain of the FUS RNA binding protein self-assembles via the mutually exclusive use of two distinct cross-ß cores.

The low-complexity (LC) domain of the fused in sarcoma (FUS) RNA binding protein self-associates in a manner causing phase separation from an aqueous environment. Incubation of the FUS LC domain under physiologically normal conditions of salt and pH leads to rapid formation of liquid-like droplets that mature into a gel-like state. Both examples of phase separation have enabled reductionist biochemical assays allowing discovery of an N-terminal region of 57 residues that assembles into a labile, cross-ß structure. Here we provide evidence of a nonoverlapping, C-terminal region of the FUS LC domain that also forms specific cross-ß interactions. We propose that biologic function of the FUS LC domain may operate via the mutually exclusive use of these N- and C-terminal cross-ß cores. Neurodegenerative disease-causing mutations in the FUS LC domain are shown to imbalance the two cross-ß cores, offering an unanticipated concept of LC domain function and dysfunction.

Transiently structured head domains control intermediate filament assembly.

Low complexity (LC) head domains 92 and 108 residues in length are, respectively, required for assembly of neurofilament light (NFL) and desmin intermediate filaments (IFs). As studied in isolation, these IF head domains interconvert between states of conformational disorder and labile, ß-strand-enriched polymers. Solid-state NMR (ss-NMR) spectroscopic studies of NFL and desmin head domain polymers reveal spectral patterns consistent with structural order. A combination of intein chemistry and segmental isotope labeling allowed preparation of fully assembled NFL and desmin IFs that could also be studied by ss-NMR. Assembled IFs revealed spectra overlapping with those observed for ß-strand-enriched polymers formed from the isolated NFL and desmin head domains. Phosphorylation and disease-causing mutations reciprocally alter NFL and desmin head domain self-association yet commonly impede IF assembly. These observations show how facultative structural assembly of LC domains via labile, ß-strand-enriched self-interactions may broadly influence cell morphology.

Redox-mediated regulation of low complexity domain self-association.

Eukaryotic cells express thousands of protein domains long believed to function in the absence of molecular order. These intrinsically disordered protein (IDP) domains are typified by gibberish-like repeats of only a limited number of amino acids that we refer to as domains of low sequence complexity. A decade ago, it was observed that these low complexity (LC) domains can undergo phase transition out of aqueous solution to form either liquid-like droplets or hydrogels. The self-associative interactions responsible for phase transition involve the formation of specific cross-ß structures that are unusual in being labile to dissociation. Here we give evidence that the LC domains of two RNA binding proteins, ataxin-2 and TDP43, form cross-ß interactions that specify biologically relevant redox sensors.

Redox-mediated regulation of an evolutionarily conserved cross-ß structure formed by the TDP43 low complexity domain.

A methionine-rich low complexity (LC) domain is found within a C-terminal region of the TDP43 RNA-binding protein. Self-association of this domain leads to the formation of labile cross-ß polymers and liquid-like droplets. Treatment with H2O2 caused phenomena of methionine oxidation and droplet melting that were reversed upon exposure of the oxidized protein to methionine sulfoxide reductase enzymes. Morphological features of the cross-ß polymers were revealed by H2O2-mediated footprinting. Equivalent TDP43 LC domain footprints were observed in polymerized hydrogels, liquid-like droplets, and living cells. The ability of H2O2 to impede cross-ß polymerization was abrogated by the prominent M337V amyotrophic lateral sclerosis-causing mutation. These observations may offer insight into the biological role of TDP43 in facilitating synapse-localized translation as well as aberrant aggregation of the protein in neurodegenerative diseases.

Dynamic structural order of a low-complexity domain facilitates assembly of intermediate filaments.

The coiled-coil domains of intermediate filament (IF) proteins are flanked by regions of low sequence complexity. Whereas IF coiled-coil domains assume dimeric and tetrameric conformations on their own, maturation of eight tetramers into cylindrical IFs is dependent on either "head" or "tail" domains of low sequence complexity. Here we confirm that the tail domain required for assembly of Drosophila Tm1-I/C IFs functions by forming labile cross-ß interactions. These interactions are seen in polymers made from the tail domain alone, as well as in assembled IFs formed by the intact Tm1-I/C protein. The ability to visualize such interactions in situ within the context of a discrete cellular assembly lends support to the concept that equivalent interactions may be used in organizing other dynamic aspects of cell morphology.

Passing Through.

mRNAs move to the right place in cells to facilitate localized translation. The pathway of mRNA movement involves nuclear and cytoplasmic puncta not surrounded by investing membranes. Discoveries reported by Hondele et al. explain how mRNA molecules can be passed from one puncta to another, forming a relay that directs mRNAs to their proper location.

Redox State Controls Phase Separation of the Yeast Ataxin-2 Protein via Reversible Oxidation of Its Methionine-Rich Low-Complexity Domain.

Yeast ataxin-2, also known as Pbp1, senses the activity state of mitochondria in order to regulate TORC1. A domain of Pbp1 required to adapt cells to mitochondrial activity is of low sequence complexity. The low-complexity (LC) domain of Pbp1 forms labile, cross-ß polymers that facilitate phase transition of the protein into liquid-like or gel-like states. Phase transition for other LC domains is reliant upon widely distributed aromatic amino acids. In place of tyrosine or phenylalanine residues prototypically used for phase separation, Pbp1 contains 24 similarly disposed methionine residues. Here, we show that the Pbp1 methionine residues are sensitive to hydrogen peroxide (H2O2)-mediated oxidation in vitro and in living cells. Methionine oxidation melts Pbp1 liquid-like droplets in a manner reversed by methionine sulfoxide reductase enzymes. These observations explain how reversible formation of labile polymers by the Pbp1 LC domain enables the protein to function as a sensor of cellular redox state.

Structural characterization of the D290V mutation site in hnRNPA2 low-complexity-domain polymers.

Human genetic studies have given evidence of familial, disease-causing mutations in the analogous amino acid residue shared by three related RNA binding proteins causative of three neurological diseases. Alteration of aspartic acid residue 290 of hnRNPA2 to valine is believed to predispose patients to multisystem proteinopathy. Mutation of aspartic acid 262 of hnRNPA1 to either valine or asparagine has been linked to either amyotrophic lateral sclerosis or multisystem proteinopathy. Mutation of aspartic acid 378 of hnRNPDL to either asparagine or histidine has been associated with limb girdle muscular dystrophy. All three of these aspartic acid residues map to evolutionarily conserved regions of low-complexity (LC) sequence that may function in states of either intrinsic disorder or labile self-association. Here, we present a combination of solid-state NMR spectroscopy with segmental isotope labeling and electron microscopy on the LC domain of the hnRNPA2 protein. We show that, for both the wild-type protein and the aspartic acid 290-to-valine mutant, labile polymers are formed in which the LC domain associates into an in-register cross-ß conformation. Aspartic acid 290 is shown to be charged at physiological pH and immobilized within the polymer core. Polymers of the aspartic acid 290-to-valine mutant are thermodynamically more stable than wild-type polymers. These observations give evidence that removal of destabilizing electrostatic interactions may be responsible for the increased propensity of the mutated LC domains to self-associate in disease-causing conformations.

ACSS2 promotes systemic fat storage and utilization through selective regulation of genes involved in lipid metabolism.

Acetyl-CoA synthetase 2 (ACSS2) is a conserved nucleocytosolic enzyme that converts acetate to acetyl-CoA. Adult mice lacking ACSS2 appear phenotypically normal but exhibit reduced tumor burdens in mouse models of liver cancer. The normal physiological functions of this alternate pathway of acetyl-CoA synthesis remain unclear, however. Here, we reveal that mice lacking ACSS2 exhibit a significant reduction in body weight and hepatic steatosis in a diet-induced obesity model. ACSS2 deficiency reduces dietary lipid absorption by the intestine and also perturbs repartitioning and utilization of triglycerides from adipose tissue to the liver due to lowered expression of lipid transporters and fatty acid oxidation genes. In this manner, ACSS2 promotes the systemic storage or metabolism of fat according to the fed or fasted state through the selective regulation of genes involved in lipid metabolism. Thus, targeting ACSS2 may offer a therapeutic benefit for the treatment of fatty liver disease.

A Solid-State Conceptualization of Information Transfer from Gene to Message to Protein.

In this review, we describe speculative ideas and early stage research concerning the flow of genetic information from the nuclear residence of genes to the disparate, cytoplasmic sites of protein synthesis. We propose that this process of information transfer is meticulously guided by transient structures formed from protein segments of low sequence complexity/intrinsic disorder. These low complexity domains are ubiquitously associated with regulatory proteins that control gene expression and RNA biogenesis, but they are also found in the central channel of nuclear pores, the nexus points of intermediate filament assembly, and the locations of action of other well-studied cellular proteins and pathways. Upon being organized into localized cellular positions via mechanisms utilizing properly folded protein domains, thereby facilitating elevated local concentration, certain low complexity domains adopt cross-ß interactions that are both structurally specific and labile to disassembly. These weakly tethered assemblies, we propose, are built to relay the passage of genetic information from one site to another within a cell, ensuring that the process is of extreme fidelity.

Benefits of Enhancing Nicotinamide Adenine Dinucleotide Levels in Damaged or Diseased Nerve Cells.

Three unbiased lines of research have commonly pointed to the benefits of enhanced levels of nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide (NAD+) to diseased or damaged neurons. Mice carrying a triplication of the gene encoding the culminating enzyme in NAD+ salvage from nicotinamide, NMNAT, are protected from a variety of insults to axons. Protection from Wallerian degeneration of axons is also observed in flies and mice bearing inactivating mutations in the SARM1 gene. Functional studies of the SARM1 gene product have revealed the presence of an enzymatic activity directed toward the hydrolysis of NAD+ Finally, an unbiased drug screen performed in living mice led to the discovery of a neuroprotective chemical designated P7C3. Biochemical studies of the P7C3 chemical show that it can enhance recovery of NAD+ from nicotinamide by activating NAMPT, the first enzyme in the salvage pathway. In combination, these three unrelated research endeavors offer evidence of the benefits of enhanced NAD+ levels to damaged neurons.

Structure of FUS Protein Fibrils and Its Relevance to Self-Assembly and Phase Separation of Low-Complexity Domains.

Polymerization and phase separation of proteins containing low-complexity (LC) domains are important factors in gene expression, mRNA processing and trafficking, and localization of translation. We have used solid-state nuclear magnetic resonance methods to characterize the molecular structure of self-assembling fibrils formed by the LC domain of the fused in sarcoma (FUS) RNA-binding protein. From the 214-residue LC domain of FUS (FUS-LC), a segment of only 57 residues forms the fibril core, while other segments remain dynamically disordered. Unlike pathogenic amyloid fibrils, FUS-LC fibrils lack hydrophobic interactions within the core and are not polymorphic at the molecular structural level. Phosphorylation of core-forming residues by DNA-dependent protein kinase blocks binding of soluble FUS-LC to FUS-LC hydrogels and dissolves phase-separated, liquid-like FUS-LC droplets. These studies offer a structural basis for understanding LC domain self-assembly, phase separation, and regulation by post-translational modification.

Cross-ß polymerization and hydrogel formation by low-complexity sequence proteins.

Low-complexity (LC) sequences, typically believed to be incapable of assuming structural order, are abundant constituents of the proteomes of all eukaryotic organisms. These sequences have emerged as critical components for formation of meso-scaled, sub-cellular organelles not invested by surrounding membranes, exemplified by RNA granules. We have observed that LC domains of many RNA binding proteins known to be constituents of RNA granules readily form labile cross-ß polymers under physiological conditions. Several lines of experimentation have shown that formation of labile, cross-ß polymers assembled from LC domain monomers is important for formation of RNA granules. Among the various experiments we have carried out, hydrogel binding assays have evolved as a versatile technique allowing a reliable means of assessing polymer formation and the binding of heterotypic cellular components integral to the formation of RNA granules. This article presents methods allowing for the production of hydrogel droplets composed of LC domain polymers. We further describe methods allowing straightforward assessment for binding of test LC domains to hydrogel droplets by fluorescence microscopy.

Toxic PRn poly-dipeptides encoded by the C9orf72 repeat expansion block nuclear import and export.

The toxic proline:arginine (PRn) poly-dipeptide encoded by the (GGGGCC)n repeat expansion in the C9orf72 form of heritable amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS) binds to the central channel of the nuclear pore and inhibits the movement of macromolecules into and out of the nucleus. The PRn poly-dipeptide binds to polymeric forms of the phenylalanine:glycine (FG) repeat domain, which is shared by several proteins of the nuclear pore complex, including those in the central channel. A method of chemical footprinting was used to characterize labile, cross-ß polymers formed from the FG domain of the Nup54 protein. Mutations within the footprinted region of Nup54 polymers blocked both polymerization and binding by the PRn poly-dipeptide. The aliphatic alcohol 1,6-hexanediol melted FG domain polymers in vitro and reversed PRn-mediated enhancement of the nuclear pore permeability barrier. These data suggest that toxicity of the PRn poly-dipeptide results in part from its ability to lock the FG repeats of nuclear pore proteins in the polymerized state. Our study offers a mechanistic interpretation of PRn poly-dipeptide toxicity in the context of a prominent form of ALS.