RESUMEN
BACKGROUND: Since 2014, several clinical studies focusing on centronuclear myopathies have been conducted, including a prospective natural history study, a gene transfer clinical trial and a clinical trial using an antisense oligonucleotide. Dedicated patient organizations have played an important role in this process. The experience of members of these organizations, either as a study participant, parent or as a patient organization member communicating with the sponsors are potentially very informative for future trial design. METHODS: We investigated the burden of and the lessons learned from the first natural history studies and clinical trials from a patient perspective using a qualitative approach. We arranged 4 focus groups with a total of 37 participants from 3 large international patient organizations: ZNM-ZusammenStark!, the Myotubular Trust, and the MTM-CNM Family Connection. 4 themes, based on a systematic literature search were discussed: Expectations and preparation, Clinical study participation, Communication and Recommendations for future clinical trials. The focus group recordings were transcribed, anonymized, and uploaded to Atlas-ti version 8.1 software. The data were analyzed using a thematic content analysis. RESULTS: Overall, participants were realistic in their expectations, hoping for small improvements of function and quality of life. The realization that trial participation does not equate to a treatment was challenging. Participating in a clinical study had a huge impact on many aspects of daily life, both for patients and their immediate families. First-hand insights into the burden of the design and its possible effect on performance were provided, resulting in numerous compelling recommendations for future clinical studies. Furthermore, participants stressed the importance of clear communication, which was considered to be especially vital in cases of severe adverse events. Finally, while patients were understanding of the importance of adhering to the regulations of good clinical practice, they indicated that they would strongly appreciate a greater understanding and/or acknowledgment of the patient perspective and a reflection of this perspective in future clinical trial design. CONCLUSION: The acknowledgment and inclusion of patients' perspectives and efficient and effective communication is expected to improve patient recruitment and retention in future clinical studies, as well as more accurate assessment of the patient performance related to suitable planning of the study visits.
RESUMEN
The design of a clinical trial for a rare disease can be challenging. An optimal study design is required to effectively study the clinical outcomes for possible therapies for these types of disorders. Understanding the study participants' experiences as well as barriers and facilitators of participation are important to optimize future research and to inform clinical trial management. Centronuclear myopathies (CNMs) including X-linked myotubular myopathy (XLMTM) are a group of rare congenital myopathies for which there is no cure currently. Since 2014, a number of natural history studies and clinical trials have been conducted in CNMs. Two trials have been prematurely terminated because of severe adverse events. Since no research has been conducted regarding trial experience in CNM, we performed a scoping literature research on clinical trial experience of patients with neuromuscular disorders in general. The most common barriers to trial participation of patients comprise concerns about potential harmful effects, opportunity loss and the expected burden on daily life. The most common facilitators were an expected benefit on the disease course, altruism and collateral benefit. While several results are in line with trial experiences of other types of patients, for example oncological patients, distinctions can be made for patients with CNM and other neuromuscular disorders. However, the limited availability of relevant literature suggests that future (qualitative) research should focus on trial experiences in CNM patients.