[Demons and Meigs syndromes and pseudosyndromes today]. / Syndromes et pseudosyndromes de Demons et Meigs aujourd'hui.

There is a total confusion between Demons or Meigs syndromes and pseudosyndromes.The need for greater precision in publications titles has become an emergency. We have analysed 297 observations gathered in litterature from 1904 to 2004. The increase in the number of Meigs pseudosyndromes based on diverse associated condition means that we must include under the name Demons syndrome, as he did himself, all tumours of the female genital tract, providing they are benign, wherever the effusion takes place, reserve the name Demons Meigs because it has been used historically and because it was Meigs wish, solely for fibrothecomas of the ovary and for tumours of the granulosa bring together under the name Demons pseudosyndrome all other non tumoral benign entities. Malignant tumours, with or without malignant cells in the effusions are not pseudosyndromes but authentic neoplastic lesions. An over-lax definition of pseudosyndromes runs the risk of the name simply becoming a catch-all term. On the other hand we can say that 100years later diagnosis is not earlier, a bilateral tumor is not a rarity, mechanisms of effusions genesis remain mysterious and the treatment has been enriched with coeliosurgery.

Ovarian malignancies with cytologically negative pleural and peritoneal effusions: demons' or meigs' pseudo-syndromes?

The authors reviewed the original reports of the association of malignant ovarian tumors with cytologically negative pleural and peritoneal effusions, commonly known as Meigs' pseudo-syndrome and challenged the recent attribution of this disease to Demons. They underlined the historical and clinical interest of the reports of Demons and Meigs and concluded that the term pseudo-Meigs' syndrome, and not pseudo-Demons' syndrome, must be used for malignant ovarian lesions with effusions with negative cytology because Demons did not describe a similar syndrome caused by malignant tumors.

Demons syndrome revisited: a review of the literature.

OBJECTIVES: To report various descriptions of the combination of a benign genital tumour with pleural and/or abdominal effusion throughout the years and to determine the paternity of this syndrome, commonly known as Meigs' syndrome. METHODS: A systematic review of the literature from 1728 to 2004. RESULTS: Before 1880, publications were rare and limited to clinical and anatomical descriptions drawing no conclusions between the cause and effect of this condition and even less about its management. Demons described the syndrome between 1887 and 1902. He was the first to specify that removal of the tumour (benign ovarian cyst, solid ovarian tumour, fibroma of the broad ligament) was essential for the patient to be cured of the effusions and that it was wrong to postpone surgery. In 1937, Meigs arrived at the same findings concerning ovarian fibromas and granulosa cell tumours, hence the name of Demons-Meigs which was given to this syndrome with the agreement of Meigs. Current literature reports on pseudosyndromes of Demons-Meigs including genital malignancies with negative cytology. These entities should not be called Demons or Meigs pseudosyndromes. Inversely, all benign tumours of the genital tract should be included in Demons syndrome, even if Demons did not actually encounter any during his years of practice, but it was in the spirit of his observations. CONCLUSION: Demons' syndrome includes all benign genital tumours, the Demons-Meigs eponym is reserved for the description of ovarian fibromas and granulosa cell tumours, and the Demons' pseudosyndrome includes all other entities.

Meigs' syndrome: the history of the eponym.

Meigs' syndrome is defined as presence of ascites with hydrothorax in association with benign ovarian tumor. The syndrome is named after Joe Vincent Meigs (1892-1963), a Harvard Medical School Professor of Gynecology. However, it was described by several authors in the 19th and the beginning of 20th centuries. Meigs and Cass deserve the credit for awakening the medical profession to the importance of the syndrome in 1937. At the end, the syndrome was coined Meigs' syndrome by Rhodes and Terrell in 1937.