Data sharing as a national quality improvement program: reporting on BRCA1 and BRCA2 variant-interpretation comparisons through the Canadian Open Genetics Repository (COGR).

PurposeThe purpose of this study was to develop a national program for Canadian diagnostic laboratories to compare DNA-variant interpretations and resolve discordant-variant classifications using the BRCA1 and BRCA2 genes as a case study.MethodsBRCA1 and BRCA2 variant data were uploaded and shared through the Canadian Open Genetics Repository (COGR; http://www.opengenetics.ca). A total of 5,554 variant observations were submitted; classification differences were identified and comparison reports were sent to participating laboratories. Each site had the opportunity to reclassify variants. The data were analyzed before and after the comparison report process to track concordant- or discordant-variant classifications by three different models.ResultsVariant-discordance rates varied by classification model: 38.9% of variants were discordant when using a five-tier model, 26.7% with a three-tier model, and 5.0% with a two-tier model. After the comparison report process, the proportion of discordant variants dropped to 30.7% with the five-tier model, to 14.2% with the three-tier model, and to 0.9% using the two-tier model.ConclusionWe present a Canadian interinstitutional quality improvement program for DNA-variant interpretations. Sharing of variant knowledge by clinical diagnostic laboratories will allow clinicians and patients to make more informed decisions and lead to better patient outcomes.

Prenatal hydrops fetalis associated with infantile free sialic acid storage disease due to a novel homozygous deletion in the SLC17A5 gene.

Nonimmune hydrops fetalis, the excessive accumulation of serous fluid in the subcutaneous tissues and serous cavities of the fetus, has many possible etiologies, providing a diagnostic challenge for the physician. Lysosomal storage diseases have been reported in up to 5%-16% of nonimmune hydrops fetalis pregnancies. Infantile free sialic acid storage disease (ISSD) (OMIM #269920) is a severe form of autosomal recessive sialic acid storage disease. ISSD is caused by mutations in SLC17A5 (OMIM #604322), which encodes sialin, a lysosomal-membrane sialic acid transporter. We describe a case of fetal hydrops due to a novel homozygous deletion in the SLC17A5 gene. Prenatal single-nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) array analysis was performed on amniocytes after the discovery of fetal hydrops at 24 wk gestation revealing no copy-number variants. The SNP array, however, reported several regions of homozygosity (ROHs) including one on Chromosome 6 encompassing the SLC17A5 gene. High levels of urine sialic acid in the newborn were detected. SLC17A5 gene sequencing was initiated with no sequence variants identified; however, the assay failed to amplify exons 8 and 9, prompting an exon-level copy-number analysis that revealed a novel homozygous deletion of exons 8 and 9, inherited from heterozygous carrier parents. ISSD should be considered in the workup of patients with nonimmune hydrops fetalis, and analysis for SLC17A5 deletions should be carried out when variants are not detected by gene sequencing.

Isolated sulfite oxidase deficiency: a founder mutation.

Isolated sulfite oxidase deficiency is a rare autosomal recessive inborn error of sulfur metabolism. Clinical features generally include devastating neurologic dysfunction, ectopia lentis, and increased urinary excretion of sulfite, thiosulfate, and S-sulfocysteine. Missed diagnosis is not unusual because of variability in the sensitivity of the urinary sulfite and thiosulfate screening test. We present clinical, biochemical, and molecular data on two unrelated patients with isolated sulfite oxidase deficiency. The two patients belong to an Indigenous genetic isolate in Manitoba, Canada. Both patients (one male and one female, both now deceased) developed neonatal seizures and demonstrated progressive neurodevelopmental delay. Based on increased urinary excretion of sulfite, thiosulfate, and S-sulfocysteine and normal serum uric acid levels, sulfite oxidase deficiency was suspected. Both patients have a homozygous 4-bp deletion, 1347-1350delTTGT in the sulfite oxidase gene (SUOX), predicting a premature termination of the sulfite oxidase protein leading to absence of the carboxy-terminal third portion of the protein. This domain contains most of the contact sites essential for enzyme dimerization. This deletion mutation resulted in sulfite oxidase deficiency with early-onset severe clinical phenotype.