Venous valvular stasis-associated hypoxia and thrombosis: what is the link?

This review focuses on the role of the venous valves in the genesis of thrombus formation in venous thromboembolic disease (VTE). Clinical VTE and the evidence for the valvular origin of venous thrombosis are reviewed. Virchow's triad is then used as a framework for discussion to approach the question posed regarding the link between venous valvular stasis-associated hypoxia and thrombosis. Thus, the effects of blood flow stasis, hypercoagulability of blood, and the characteristics of the vessel wall within the venous valvular sinus are assessed in turn.

A genome-wide association study for venous thromboembolism: the extended cohorts for heart and aging research in genomic epidemiology (CHARGE) consortium.

Venous thromboembolism (VTE) is a common, heritable disease resulting in high rates of hospitalization and mortality. Yet few associations between VTE and genetic variants, all in the coagulation pathway, have been established. To identify additional genetic determinants of VTE, we conducted a two-stage genome-wide association study (GWAS) among individuals of European ancestry in the extended cohorts for heart and aging research in genomic epidemiology (CHARGE) VTE consortium. The discovery GWAS comprised 1,618 incident VTE cases out of 44,499 participants from six community-based studies. Genotypes for genome-wide single-nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) were imputed to approximately 2.5 million SNPs in HapMap and association with VTE assessed using study-design appropriate regression methods. Meta-analysis of these results identified two known loci, in F5 and ABO. Top 1,047 tag SNPs (P ≤ 0.0016) from the discovery GWAS were tested for association in an additional 3,231 cases and 3,536 controls from three case-control studies. In the combined data from these two stages, additional genome-wide significant associations were observed on 4q35 at F11 (top SNP rs4253399, intronic to F11) and on 4q28 at FGG (rs6536024, 9.7 kb from FGG; P < 5.0 × 10(-13) for both). The associations at the FGG locus were not completely explained by previously reported variants. Loci at or near SUSD1 and OTUD7A showed borderline yet novel associations (P < 5.0 × 10(-6) ) and constitute new candidate genes. In conclusion, this large GWAS replicated key genetic associations in F5 and ABO, and confirmed the importance of F11 and FGG loci for VTE. Future studies are warranted to better characterize the associations with F11 and FGG and to replicate the new candidate associations.

Genetic variation associated with plasma von Willebrand factor levels and the risk of incident venous thrombosis.

In a recent genome-wide association study, variants in 8 genes were associated with VWF level, a risk factor for venous thrombosis (VT). In an independent, population-based, case-control study of incident VT, we tested hypotheses that variants in these genes would be associated with risk. Cases were 656 women who experienced an incident VT, and controls comprised 710 women without a history of VT. DNA was obtained from whole blood. Logistic regression was used to test associations between incident VT and single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) in 7 genes not previously shown to be associated with VT. Associations with P < .05 were candidates for replication in an independent case-control study of VT in both sexes. Two of the 7 SNPs tested yielded P < .05: rs1039084 (P = .005) in STXBP5, a novel candidate gene for VT, and rs1063856 (P = .04) in VWF, a gene whose protein level is associated with VT risk. Association results for the remaining 5 variants in SCARA5, STAB2, STX2, TC2N, and CLEC4M were not significant. Both STXBP5 and VWF findings were replicated successfully. Variation in genes associated with VWF levels in the genome-wide association study was found to be independently associated with incident VT.

Genetic predictors of fibrin D-dimer levels in healthy adults.

BACKGROUND: Fibrin fragment D-dimer, one of several peptides produced when crosslinked fibrin is degraded by plasmin, is the most widely used clinical marker of activated blood coagulation. To identity genetic loci influencing D-dimer levels, we performed the first large-scale, genome-wide association search. METHODS AND RESULTS: A genome-wide investigation of the genomic correlates of plasma D-dimer levels was conducted among 21 052 European-ancestry adults. Plasma levels of D-dimer were measured independently in each of 13 cohorts. Each study analyzed the association between ≈2.6 million genotyped and imputed variants across the 22 autosomal chromosomes and natural-log­transformed D-dimer levels using linear regression in additive genetic models adjusted for age and sex. Among all variants, 74 exceeded the genome-wide significance threshold and marked 3 regions. At 1p22, rs12029080 (P=6.4×10(-52)) was 46.0 kb upstream from F3, coagulation factor III (tissue factor). At 1q24, rs6687813 (P=2.4×10(-14)) was 79.7 kb downstream of F5, coagulation factor V. At 4q32, rs13109457 (P=2.9×10(-18)) was located between 2 fibrinogen genes: 10.4 kb downstream from FGG and 3.0 kb upstream from FGA. Variants were associated with a 0.099-, 0.096-, and 0.061-unit difference, respectively, in natural-log­transformed D-dimer and together accounted for 1.8% of the total variance. When adjusted for nonsynonymous substitutions in F5 and FGA loci known to be associated with D-dimer levels, there was no evidence of an additional association at either locus. CONCLUSIONS: Three genes were associated with fibrin D-dimer levels. Of these 3, the F3 association was the strongest, and has not been previously reported.

The effects of aging on the intimal region of the human saphenous vein: insights from multimodal microscopy and quantitative image analysis.

We hypothesized that structural remodeling associated with advancing age occurs in human saphenous veins. To address this hypothesis, we have identified structural remodeling in human saphenous veins by applying histochemistry, fluorescence staining and quantitative image analysis to specifically assess intimal area, intimal cellularity and intimal collagen content and organization. Saphenous veins were collected from patients undergoing coronary artery bypass graft surgery. Area measurements and cellularity were quantified using the image analysis software Stereo Investigator, employing planimetry and counting frames, respectively. Collagen content and organization were quantified in MetaMorph image analysis software based on measurements of color (hue, saturation, and intensity) from polarized light images. Intimal area and cellularity showed no statistically significant increases with age; in contrast, total collagen content showed a significant decrease with advancing age. Furthermore, collagen fiber types also demonstrated a statistically significant alteration with age; increases in age resulted in decreases in larger collagen fibers. No significant changes in small collagen fibers were identified. These results raise the possibility that age-associated structural alterations in total collagen content, specifically collagen fiber size, could be a factor in the etiology of age-associated venous diseases.

Cell adhesion molecule 1 (CADM1) is ubiquitously present in the endothelium and smooth muscle cells of the human macro- and micro-vasculature.

Cell adhesion molecule 1 (CADM1) is a member of the immunoglobulin cell adhesion molecule family. Recently, we identified CADM1 to be a novel risk factor for venous thrombosis in a large, protein C deficient, thrombophilic family and showed, for the first time, the expression of CADM1 in endothelial cells (Hasstedt et al. in Blood 114:3084-3091, 2009). To further investigate its role in venous thrombosis, as well as other vasculopathies, we undertook a systematic confocal microscopic investigation for the presence of CADM1 in the vasculature of 28 different human tissues. Paraffin embedded tissue sections were dual immunostained with an antibody against CADM1, together with an antibody against either von Willebrand factor (to identify endothelial cells), or α-smooth muscle actin (to identify smooth muscle cells). The results showed that CADM1 was ubiquitously present in endothelial cells and smooth muscle cells in the vasculature from all 28 tissues, though its representation in the various classes of vessels was tissue dependent.

Effect of ageing on the murine venous circulation.

The effect of ageing on the morphology of veins, venous valves and arteries was investigated in male wild-type mice using an adapted procedure with injection of a silicone polymer Microfil(®) that preserves morphology of the vasculature. Throughout the hind limb the arterial, but not the venous, lumen area and wall thickness were significantly greater in 24-month as compared to 10-week-old C57BL/6 mice. Venous valves were most frequently located at the sapheno-femoral vein junction in the lower extremities, and appeared thicker at the base supported by structurally intact collagen fibers, and thinner towards the proximal end of the valve leaflet, with less organized collagen. Overall, valves were less supported by structurally intact collagen at 24 months as compared to 10 weeks. Endothelial expression of CD31, endothelial protein C receptor or von Willebrand factor (VWF) was not affected by age, while thrombomodulin expression was lower in aged versus young arteries. At both ages, expression of VWF was lower at venous valves versus veins. Evaluation of the blood coagulation profile revealed that aged mice had shortened prothrombin time, elevated plasma levels of factor (F)VII, FVIII and VWF and increased neutrophil and platelet counts. Thus, our data indicate that in mice with ageing, venous valves become more fragile, in association with a procoagulant and inflammatory blood phenotype. Taken together, we found that the procoagulant state in ageing, is accompanied by mild vascular changes.

Novel associations of multiple genetic loci with plasma levels of factor VII, factor VIII, and von Willebrand factor: The CHARGE (Cohorts for Heart and Aging Research in Genome Epidemiology) Consortium.

BACKGROUND: Plasma levels of coagulation factors VII (FVII), VIII (FVIII), and von Willebrand factor (vWF) influence risk of hemorrhage and thrombosis. We conducted genome-wide association studies to identify new loci associated with plasma levels. METHODS AND RESULTS: The setting of the study included 5 community-based studies for discovery comprising 23 608 European-ancestry participants: Atherosclerosis Risk In Communities Study, Cardiovascular Health Study, British 1958 Birth Cohort, Framingham Heart Study, and Rotterdam Study. All subjects had genome-wide single-nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) scans and at least 1 phenotype measured: FVII activity/antigen, FVIII activity, and vWF antigen. Each study used its genotype data to impute to HapMap SNPs and independently conducted association analyses of hemostasis measures using an additive genetic model. Study findings were combined by meta-analysis. Replication was conducted in 7604 participants not in the discovery cohort. For FVII, 305 SNPs exceeded the genome-wide significance threshold of 5.0x10(-8) and comprised 5 loci on 5 chromosomes: 2p23 (smallest P value 6.2x10(-24)), 4q25 (3.6x10(-12)), 11q12 (2.0x10(-10)), 13q34 (9.0x10(-259)), and 20q11.2 (5.7x10(-37)). Loci were within or near genes, including 4 new candidate genes and F7 (13q34). For vWF, 400 SNPs exceeded the threshold and marked 8 loci on 6 chromosomes: 6q24 (1.2x10(-22)), 8p21 (1.3x10(-16)), 9q34 (<5.0x10(-324)), 12p13 (1.7x10(-32)), 12q23 (7.3x10(-10)), 12q24.3 (3.8x10(-11)), 14q32 (2.3x10(-10)), and 19p13.2 (1.3x10(-9)). All loci were within genes, including 6 new candidate genes, as well as ABO (9q34) and VWF (12p13). For FVIII, 5 loci were identified and overlapped vWF findings. Nine of the 10 new findings were replicated. CONCLUSIONS: New genetic associations were discovered outside previously known biological pathways and may point to novel prevention and treatment targets of hemostasis disorders.

Valves of the deep venous system: an overlooked risk factor.

Deep venous valves are frequent sites of deep venous thrombosis initiation. However, the possible contribution of the valvular sinus endothelium has received little attention in studies of thrombosis risk. We hypothesized that the endothelium of valve sinus differs from that of vein lumen with up-regulation of anticoagulant and down-regulation of procoagulant activities in response to the local environment. In pursuit of this hypothesis, we quantified endothelial protein C receptor (EPCR), thrombomodulin (TM), and von Willebrand factor (VWF) by immunofluorescence in great saphenous veins harvested at cardiac bypass surgery. We found significantly increased expression of EPCR and TM in the valvular sinus endothelium as opposed to the vein lumenal endothelium, and the opposite pattern with VWF (paired t test for TM and EPCR, each P < .001; for VWF, P = .01). These data support our hypothesis and suggest that variation in valvular sinus thromboresistance may be an important factor in venous thrombogenesis.

Cell adhesion molecule 1: a novel risk factor for venous thrombosis.

Protein C (PC) deficiency increases the risk of venous thrombosis (VT) among members of Kindred Vermont II but fails to fully account for the inheritance pattern. A genome scan of the pedigree supported the presence of a prothrombotic gene on chromosome 11q23 (nominal P < .0001), with weaker support on chromosomes 10p12 (P < .0003) and 18p11.2-q11 (P < .0007). Resequencing of 109 genes in the linkage regions identified 5030 variants in a sample of 20 kindred members. Of 16 single nucleotide polymorphisms in 6 genes tested in the larger family set, only single nucleotide polymorphisms in cell adhesion molecule 1 (CADM1) associated with VT. Among the 8 CADM1 single nucleotide polymorphisms genotyped in the complete sample, rs6589488 was most strongly supported (P < .000007), but the association was limited to the PC-deficient subset of the sample (P < .000001). Haplotype analysis narrowed the region containing the causative variant to the coding region of the CADM1 gene. CADM1 gene expression analyzed in blood outgrowth endothelial cells cultured from family members was decreased compared with control subjects, lending phenotypic support to this conclusion. Finally, we have for the first time demonstrated CADM1 in endothelial cells, where it appears to be selectively involved in endothelial cell migration, suggesting a role in endothelial barrier repair.

Lipoprotein-associated phospholipase A2 and risk of venous thrombosis in older adults.

Lipoprotein-associated phospholipase A2 (Lp-PLA2) is an enzyme involved in inflammation and platelet function. Inherited deficiency and elevated levels are associated with atherosclerosis. Given potential common etiologies of atherosclerosis and venous thrombosis (VT), we hypothesized that low and high Lp-PLA2 would be associated with VT risk. Lp-PLA(2) mass and activity were measured in baseline samples of Cardiovascular Health Study participants (5,888 men and women age > or =65), excluding 354 reporting pre-baseline VT. The study endpoint was VT unrelated to cancer after 11.6 years follow-up. Hazard ratios were estimated using Cox proportional hazard models, adjusting for age, race, sex, and body-mass index. With 129 cases of VT, there was no association of Lp-PLA2 activity with risk. Adjusted hazard ratios were 1.19 (CI 0.62, 2.29) and 0.87 (CI 0.43, 1.76) for the lowest and highest decile, respectively, compared to the 10-25th percentile. Corresponding hazard ratios for Lp-PLA2 mass were 1.63 (CI 0.79, 3.34) and 1.33 (CI 0.61, 2.87). Results were robust to several definitions of low or high Lp-PLA2. While the association of Lp-PLA(2) levels with arterial disease events implies a role for this enzyme in atherogenesis, our findings suggest that it is not prothrombotic.

Novel isoforms of intracellular platelet activating factor acetylhydrolase (PAFAH1b2) in human testis; encoded by alternatively spliced mRNAs.

Platelet activating factor acetylhydrolase (paf-ah), a potent regulator of platelet activating factor activity, plays an important role in various physiological and pathophysiological functions including development, reproduction, inflammation, hemostasis, and apoptosis. Intracellular paf-ah (paf-ah-Ib) is composed of a regulatory subunit, Pafah1b1, and two highly conserved but non-identical catalytic subunits, Pafah1b2 and Pafah1b3. The present study identifies new splice variants of the Pafah1b2 gene transcript. The splice variants retain exons 1-5 and replace exon 6 with alternative exons derived from genomic sequence 3' to exon 6. Splice variants encode two proteins with different novel carboxy termini. One of the isoforms is expressed exclusively in testis. These new isoforms of pafah1b2 retain the ability to form higher order complexes while replacing known key catalytic residues, which raises the possibility that they may alter the subunit composition and catalytic function of paf-ah-Ib.

Exclusion of the alpha2 subunit of platelet-activating factor acetylhydrolase 1b (PAFAH1B2) as a prothrombotic gene in a protein C-deficient kindred and population-based case-control sample.

Protein C deficiency increases the risk of venous thromboembolic disease among members of Kindred Vermont II, but fails to fully account for the inheritance pattern. A genome scan of the pedigree supported the presence of a prothrombotic gene on chromosome 11q23 (107-119 Mb, nominal P < 0.0001), with weaker support on chromosomes 10p12 (11-25 Mb, P < 0.0003) and 18p11.2-q11 (12-24 Mb, P < 0.0007). The 11q23 region contains the alpha(2) subunit (gene name PAFAH1B2) of platelet-activating factor acetylhydrolase 1b, a candidate prothrombotic gene. Re-sequencing of the PAFAH1B2 regulatory region in 137 pedigree members, including 25 thrombosis cases, revealed 12 variants; eight were present in only 0-2 affected individuals; the other four assorted into three haplotypes and included three variants predicted to destroy transcription factor-binding sites. More extensive re-sequencing of the PAFAH1B2 gene in 11 affected and five unaffected pedigree members revealed an additional 13 variants that assorted into the same three haplotypes. We rejected as thrombosis risk factors each of the three presumed destructive variants as well as each of the three haplotypes. We also rejected (odds ratio = 1.31 CI: 0.91-1.88) one of the three variants in 469 cases and 472 controls from the Leiden Thrombophilia Study (LETS). Therefore, PAFAH1B2 is not the gene responsible for the linkage evidence on chromosome 11q23.

SELDI-TOF plasma profiles distinguish individuals in a protein C-deficient family with thrombotic episodes occurring before age 40.

We tested the hypothesis that differences in the low-molecular-weight (500-20,000 Da) proteomic profile of plasma may be detectable between members of a protein C-deficient family who have suffered thrombotic events before age 40 compared to family members without a history of venous thrombosis. Unfractionated plasma samples from members of a previously described large thrombophilic kindred with type I protein C deficiency were applied to ProteinChip weak cation exchange interaction arrays (WCX2; Ciphergen Biosystems, Fremont, CA, USA) and subjected to SELDI-TOF (surface-enhanced laser desorption/ionization time-of-flight) mass spectrometry using the Ciphergen PBSII ProteinChip System (Ciphergen Biosystems). Profiles were analyzed by a boosted decision-tree algorithm. When individuals who had presented with deep venous thrombosis (DVT) before the age of 40 (n = 21) were compared to age-matched, healthy family members (n = 50), the proteomic patterns defined by the decision-tree analysis could classify the entity of DVT before age 40 with 67% sensitivity, at a specificity of 86%. When a small group of cases with history of superficial venous thrombosis (n = 6) was added to the case group, the sensitivity was 87.5% at a specificity of 80%. These data support the hypothesis that members of the protein C deficient Vermont kindred II who suffer a thrombotic event before age 40 display significant differences in low-molecular-weight proteomics profile compared to those who remain disease-free. This is the first study to apply SELDI-TOF technology in conjunction with a bioinformatics tool to analyze low-molecular-weight proteomic patterns in patients with venous thrombosis.

First experience with direct factor Xa inhibition in patients with stable coronary disease: a pharmacokinetic and pharmacodynamic evaluation.

BACKGROUND: Thrombin generation is critical to the formation of an arterial thrombus after rupture of an atherosclerotic plaque. In patients with stable coronary disease receiving standard medical therapy, we evaluated the pharmacokinetics, pharmacodynamics, and safety profile of DX-9065a, a novel small-molecule anticoagulant that directly, selectively, and reversibly inhibits factor Xa. METHODS AND RESULTS: In a double-blind trial, 73 patients (median age, 63 years; 29% women) were randomly assigned to receive a fixed-dose intravenous bolus, followed by a 72-hour infusion of placebo or 1 of 4 weight-adjusted regimens of DX-9065a. Plasma samples were collected during infusion and a 24-hour elimination period. Only minor bleeding occurred, predominantly ecchymoses at infusion sites, and its incidence did not differ significantly among the groups, including placebo. Median hemoglobin, platelet count, serum creatinine level, and liver function tests did not change significantly from baseline during infusion or elimination. Significant predictors of pharmacokinetic response included infusion dose and weight. At 60 hours into the DX-9065a infusion, plasma drug levels correlated strongly with anti-factor Xa activity (r=0.97), prothrombin time (r=0.77), and international normalized ratio (r=0.72) but less so with activated partial thromboplastin time (r=0.56; all P<0.001). CONCLUSIONS: This is the first study of a selective, reversible, and direct small-molecule factor Xa inhibitor in patients with stable coronary disease. These data lay the foundation for further investigation of factor Xa inhibitors in the treatment of patients with coronary atherothrombosis.

Normal retinal vasculature despite familial protein C deficiency.

PURPOSE: It is unclear whether protein C deficiency is associated with retinal venous occlusive disease. DESIGN: We performed a cross-sectional study. METHODS: Members of a protein C-deficient family, either deficient or nondeficient, with a history of nonocular venous thrombosis were included. All participants completed questionnaires regarding their medical and ophthalmic histories. Each subject underwent dilated direct ophthalmoscopic and binocular indirect ophthalmoscopic examinations by a single vitreoretinal specialist. RESULTS: None of the 18 family members with a known history of nonocular thrombosis-12 with and 6 without protein C deficiency- manifested stigmas of recent or chronic retinal vascular occlusive disease. CONCLUSIONS: This study showed no evidence of involvement of the retinal vascular bed in a family with an increased risk of nonocular venous thrombosis attributable to the deficiency of protein C.

The impact of venous thrombosis on quality of life.

Quality of life (QOL) is increasingly seen as an important outcome in clinical care. Etiology, diagnosis, and management of venous thrombosis have been studied extensively, but only few studies have examined the impact of venous thrombosis on quality of life. The purpose of this study was to examine the impact of venous thrombosis on quality of life in a well-defined population of patients with venous thrombosis, by using both a generic and a disease-specific quality of life measure. A total of 45 patients from the thrombosis clinic of the University of Vermont in Burlington, VT, returned a mailed questionnaire including the Short-Form 36 (SF-36) and a disease-specific venous thrombosis-quality of life (VT-QOL) questionnaire about the problems faced by patients with venous thrombosis. The sample consisted of 13 men (28.9%) and 32 women (71.1%). The mean age was 44.1 years, with a range from 21 to 80 years. Compared with population norms of a general U.S. population that were adjusted for age and sex (N= 2463), venous thrombosis patients scored significantly lower (p < 0.05) on all subscales of the SF-36. Patients with the postthrombotic syndrome (PTS) appeared to have more impairment in their quality of life as measured by both the SF-36 and the disease-specific questionnaire. All correlations between the SF-36 subscales and the subscales of the VT-QOL were significant, most of them on a p < 0.01 level. Given the impact of venous thrombosis and the postthrombotic syndrome on quality of life, assessment of QOL should be included in future studies on the outcome of venous thrombosis.

The protein C system in placental massive perivillous fibrin deposition.

Massive perivillous fibrin deposition (MPFD) is associated with intrauterine growth retardation and first-trimester and second-trimester spontaneous abortion. Histologically, villi near the maternal interface are completely surrounded by fibrinoid material. This work compared the expression of thrombomodulin (TM) and endothelial protein C receptor (EPCR) in early miscarriage specimens with and without MPFD. Ten specimens with a gestational age of 7-12 weeks (mean 10 weeks) and 10 age-matched miscarriage specimens lacking MPFD were sampled. Formalin-fixed paraffin-embedded sections were stained with monoclonal antibodies against TM and EPCR using an immunoperoxidase method. The slides were independently reviewed by two pathologists using a semiquantitative grading system. Among unaffected villi, there was no difference in staining for TM or EPCR in cases of massive perivillous fibrin deposition compared with the control group. In the MPFD cases, loss of membrane positivity was noted for both TM and EPCR at the junction between normal villous epithelium and villous epithelium with deposition of fibrin. This could imply an underlying defect of trophoblastic protein C activation. Alternatively, it may represent a degenerative change secondary to impedence of oxygen and nutrient supply to the trophoblastic epithelium.

No effect of the prothrombin G20210A mutation on protein C activation in a large kindred with type I protein C deficiency.

Previously, we observed a positive association of prothrombin concentrations with thrombin generation (fragment 1 + 2) and thrombin activity (fibrinopeptide A), but no association with protein C activation peptide levels. We further evaluated a potential beneficial effect of increased prothrombin concentrations on activated protein C generation by assessing the plasma concentration of activated protein C in complex with protein C inhibitor (APC-PCI). Blood samples were used from 195 family members of a large French-Canadian kindred with type I protein C deficiency due to a 3363C insertion in the protein C gene. We utilized a new and highly sensitive assay for measuring the concentration of APC-PCI complex as a measure of the level of activation of protein C. Means of the plasma concentrations of the APC-PCI complex were compared among carriers and non-carriers of the prothrombin G20210A mutation. Protein C activity levels were positively associated with APC-PCI complex plasma concentrations; however, APC-PCI complex levels were not different for carriers of the prothrombin G20210A mutation than for non-carriers. Thus, carriers of the prothrombin G20210A mutation do not have increased protein C activation despite the increased thrombin generation resulting from the higher prothrombin concentrations associated with the G20210A mutation.

A review of the technical, diagnostic, and epidemiologic considerations for protein S assays.

OBJECTIVES: To review the state of the art relating to protein S deficiency as a risk factor for thrombosis and to make recommendations regarding the use of protein S measurements in the assessment of thrombotic risk in individual patients and families. DATA SOURCES, EXTRACTION, AND SYNTHESIS: Selection criteria were developed for the inclusion of publications from 1985 to 2001 based on the relevant literature concerned with the systematic review of diagnostic tests. Minimal selection criteria were agreed on and the articles stratified into level 1 if they met these criteria and level 2 if they did not meet these criteria. The included articles were reviewed by the authors and abstracted onto predetermined data collection forms. These forms were then scored and recommendations based on level 1 studies. As described elsewhere, results of discussions at the College of American Pathologists Conference XXXVI on Diagnostic Issues in Thrombophilia were used to revise the manuscript into its final form. CONCLUSIONS: Consensus was reached on 16 recommendations for the use of protein S assays in the assessment of thrombotic risk in individuals and families. Two themes run through the conclusions. First, protein S assays are the most technically problematic of the assays reviewed at this conference. Second, only 2 papers evaluating the diagnostic use of protein S assays met our level 1 inclusion criteria. These 2 problems point out the need for better standardized assays and rigorous studies of the diagnostic utility of these assays.