RESUMO
AIM: The aim of the present study was to compare the Preece-Baines 1 (PB1) model fit between longitudinal and cross-sectional data in male soccer players and to adjust the height growth curve by maturity status. METHODS: A final sample of 57 male Portuguese soccer players from professional soccer academies was included. Longitudinal height records were measured between 8 and 17 times in each subject from 2-8 years to 14-17 years. Additionally, longitudinal height records were used as cross-sectional data along with 1087 cross-sectional height records taken from 602 Portuguese soccer players. Skeletal age was estimated by Tanner-Whitehouse III method from a left hand-wrist radiograph. Age at peak height velocity (PHV) was estimated by PB1 model for longitudinal and cross-sectional data and by maturity status. RESULTS: No significant differences were found between all the longitudinal estimates of 57 players and the random cross-sectional samples for, S1 parameter and for growth velocity at PHV, at TO, and for age at PHV. The age at PHV in early, on-time, and late maturers were 12.26, 12.9, and 13.58 years, respectively. CONCLUSION: PB1 adjusted the height growth of Portuguese male soccer players from cross-sectional data, obtaining an estimate PHV very similar to that found from longitudinal data. A maturity time difference of ≈0.6 years was found between the age at PHV of on-time, early, and on-time and late maturity state.
Assuntos
Futebol , Humanos , Masculino , Estudos TransversaisRESUMO
El porcentaje de estatura adulta (PEA) es un indicador del estado de maduración, que refleja la variación en la tasa y progreso de crecimiento. Existen diversos métodos para estimar la estatura adulta, sin haberse documentado en la literatura de manera concreta sus similitudes o diferencias. Los objetivos del presente trabajo fueron comparar tres métodos de estimación del PEA, identificar cambios seculares en niños y adolescentes y establecer valores de referencia del PEA para población portuguesa. Se midieron en 799 niños y 736 niñas, de 7,0 a 16,49 años, la edad ósea, el peso y la estatura, para estimar el porcentaje de estatura adulta por las metodologías TW3, KR y RWT. Los valores del método TW3 del presente estudio, fueron comparados con los reportados en décadas atrás para identificar cambios seculares. Se utilizó un ANOVA de medidas repetidas para estimar las diferencias entre los métodos en el presente estudio, así como gráficas de Bland y Altman. Se utilizó la prueba de Kruskal-Wallis para analizar las diferencias entre los valores encontrados en la presente investigación y los presentados en décadas atrás en otros estudios. No se encontraron diferencias entre los métodos TW3 y KR en los diferentes grupos de edad cuando se clasificaron los sujetos por edad cronológica, en ambos sexos (P>0,05). Así mismo, no se observaron cambios seculares en el PEA (P>0.05). Los métodos TW3 y KR pueden ser intercambiables entre sí, debido a que no presentan diferencias en la estimación a diferentes edades y en ambos sexos. Además, no existió cambio secular en la estimación de PEA por estas metodologías, lo que las hace útiles en la actualidad.
The adult height percentage (AHP) is an indicator of maturity state, which reflects variation in growth rate. Several methods estimates adult height; however, its similarities or differences have not been documented in a concrete way in literature. The aims of the present work were to compare three common methods of AHP estimation, to identify children and adolescents secular changes and to develop AHP reference values in Portuguese population. Skeletal age, weight and height were measure in 799 children and 736 girls from 7.0 to 16.5 years; in addition, parents height was self-reported by them to estimate the AHP by TW3, RWT and KR methods. ANOVA was used to estimate differences between TW3, KR and RWT methods, as well as Bland-Altman graphs. Also, Kruskal-Wallis test was applied. No differences were found between TW3 and KR methods in all age groups, in both sexes, when subjects were classified by chronological age (P> 0.05). Likewise, no secular changes were observed in AHP (P> 0.05). Not only TW3 and KR protocols can be interchangeable each other because they did not present differences in the AHP estimation at different ages and in both sexes. However, secular changes were not observed in AHP estimation by these methods.