Lineup identification in young and older witnesses: does describing the criminal help or hinder?

The world population is getting older and, as a result, the number of older victims of crime is expected to increase. It is therefore essential to understand how ageing affects eyewitness identification, so procedures can be developed that enable victims of crime of all ages to provide evidence as accurately and reliably as possible. In criminal investigations, witnesses often provide a description of the perpetrator of the crime before later making an identification. While describing the perpetrator prior to making a lineup identification can have a detrimental effect on identification in younger adults, referred to as verbal overshadowing, it is unclear whether older adults are affected in the same way. Our study compared lineup identification of a group of young adults and a group of older adults using the procedure that has consistently revealed verbal overshadowing in young adults. Participants watched a video of a mock crime. Following a 20-min filled delay, they either described the perpetrator or completed a control task. Immediately afterwards, they identified the perpetrator from a lineup, or indicated that the perpetrator was not present, and rated their confidence. We found that describing the perpetrator decreased subsequent correct identification of the perpetrator in both young and older adults. This effect of verbal overshadowing was not explained by a change in discrimination but was consistent with participants adopting a more conservative criterion. Confidence and response time were both found to predict identification accuracy for young and older groups, particularly in the control condition.

When memory does not fail: familiarity-based recognition in mild cognitive impairment and Alzheimer's disease.

Recognition can be guided by familiarity, a restricted form of retrieval devoid of contextual recall, or by recollection, which occurs when retrieval is sufficient to support the full experience of remembering an episode. Recollection and familiarity were disentangled by testing recognition memory using silhouette object drawings, high target-foil resemblance, and both yes-no and forced-choice procedures. Theoretically, forced-choice recognition could be mediated by familiarity alone. Alzheimer's disease and its preclinical stage, mild cognitive impairment (MCI), were associated with memory impairments that were greater on the yes-no test. Remarkably, forced-choice recognition was unequivocally normal in patients with MCI compared with age-matched controls. Neuropathology in hippocampus and entorhinal cortex, known to be present in MCI, presumably disrupted recollection while leaving familiarity-based recognition intact.

Long-term amnesia: a review and detailed illustrative case study.

Long-term amnesia is a slowly developing form of anterograde amnesia accompanied by retrograde amnesia of variable severity (Kapur, 1996; 1997) often associated with damage to the anterior temporal neocortex and epileptic seizures. The precise neural and functional deficits that underlie this condition are unknown. A patient, JL, who has this condition following a closed-head injury, is described in detail. Her injury caused bilateral anterior temporal neocortex damage that was more extensive on the left and right-sided damage to the perirhinal and orbitofrontal cortices. The hippocampus appeared to be intact bilaterally. Epilepsy developed within two years of JL's injury. Apart from her memory impairments, JL's cognitive functions, including high-level visual perception, attention, semantic memory and executive functions were well preserved. Her memory also seemed well preserved for at least 30 minutes following encoding. The one exception was the patient's relatively greater impairment at difficult visual recognition tests for which verbalization may not have been an effective strategy. This problem may have been caused by JL's right-sided perirhinal and orbitofrontal cortex damage. Her recall and recognition was clearly impaired after a three-week delay. She also showed a retrograde amnesia, which appeared to be milder than her remote post-morbid memory deficit. JL's remote memory was preserved for information first encountered in either the pre- or post-morbid period provided the information had received sufficient rehearsal over long periods of time. Her long-term amnesia may have been caused by anterior temporal neocortex damage, possibly in association with her epileptic seizures. Whether the condition is heterogeneous, involves a deficit in slow consolidation, disruption of unconsolidated memories, or blockage of maintenance or disruption of insufficiently rehearsed memories whether or not these have been slowly consolidated is discussed.

Long-term accelerated forgetting of verbal and non-verbal information in temporal lobe epilepsy.

INTRODUCTION: We investigated whether pre-surgical patients with temporal lobe epilepsy (TLE) forget verbal and non-verbal material faster than healthy controls over retention intervals of an hour and 6 weeks, and whether any observed memory loss was associated with structural changes to the hippocampus and/or seizure frequency. METHODS: A mixed factorial design compared the performance of 27 patients with TLE and 22 healthy control participants, matched for IQ, age and gender, on tests of story recall and complex figure recall at three delays: immediate, 1 h and 6 weeks. Performance of the patient and control groups was matched at the immediate delay, which enabled comparisons of forgetting rate over the longer delays. RESULTS: We found that TLE can affect the acquisition and retention of new memories over a relatively short delay of 1h. This deficit was associated with structural hippocampal abnormality, with a material-specific effect that was particularly evident for the verbal task. We also found evidence of accelerated long-term forgetting in both patient groups, for the verbal and non-verbal tasks. It was demonstrated most strongly on the verbal task by the patients with right lateralized hippocampal sclerosis whose verbal recall was normal at the 1-h delay. Accelerated long-term forgetting was not associated with hippocampal pathology, but was associated with the frequency of epileptic seizures. DISCUSSION: The findings from the verbal task in particular provide evidence consistent with an extended period of memory consolidation that can be disrupted by both left and right TLE. The material-specific effects at the 1-h delay only, suggest that the initial consolidation of verbal and non-verbal, information depends on the integrity of the left and right hippocampus, respectively.