Scientific Discoveries: What Is Required for Lasting Impact.

I have been involved in two scientific discoveries of some impact. One is the discovery of long-term potentiation (LTP), the phenomenon that brief, high-frequency impulse activity at synapses in the brain can lead to long-lasting increases in their efficiency of transmission. This finding demonstrated that synapses are plastic, a property thought to be necessary for learning and memory. The other discovery is that nerve-evoked muscle impulse activity, rather than putative trophic factors, controls the properties of muscle fibers. Here I describe how these two discoveries were made, the unexpected difficulties of reproducing the first discovery, and the controversies that followed the second discovery. I discuss why the first discovery took many years to become generally recognized, whereas the second caused an immediate sensation and entered textbooks and major reviews but is now largely forgotten. In the long run, discovering a new phenomenon has greater impact than falsifying a popular hypothesis.

Body temperature control in rats by muscle tone during rest or sleep.

AIM: To explore the role of tonic motor unit activity in body temperature control. METHODS: Motor unit activity in soleus and several other skeletal muscles was recorded electromyographically from adult rats placed in a climate chamber on a load sensitive floor, which, together with video monitoring, allowed detection of every successive period of movement and no movement. RESULTS: In the absence of movements during rest or sleep, motor unit activity was exclusively tonic and therefore equivalent to muscle tone as defined here. The amount of tonic activity increased linearly in the soleus as the ambient temperature decreased from 32°C to below 7°C, owing to progressive recruitment and increased firing rate of individual units. Brief movements occurred randomly and frequently during rest or sleep in association with brief facilitation or inhibition of motor neurons that turned tonic motor unit activity on or off, partitioning the tonic activity among the available motor units. Shivering first appeared when a falling ambient temperature reached ≤7°C in several muscles except soleus, which was as active between shivering bursts as during them. CONCLUSION: Muscle tone and overt shivering are strikingly different phenomena. Tonic motor unit activity in the absence of movements evokes isometric contractions and, therefore, generates heat. Accordingly, when the amount of tonic activity increases with falling ambient temperature, so must heat production. Consequently, graded muscle tone appears as an important and independent mechanism for thermogenesis during rest or sleep at ambient temperatures ranging from <7°C to at least 32°C.

Excitability changes within transverse lamellae of dentate granule cells and their longitudinal spread following orthodromic or antidromic activation.

The functional organization of the perforant path input to the dentate gyrus of the exposed hippocampus was studied in adult rabbits anesthetized with urethane and chloralose. Electrical stimulation of perforant path fibers caused excitation of granule cells along narrow, nearly transverse strips (lamellae) of tissue. Stimulation of granule cell axons (mossy fibers) in CA3 caused antidromic activation of granule cells along similar strips. Paired-pulse stimulation revealed marked changes in granule cell excitability both within a lamella (on-line) and for several mm off-line along the septo-temporal axis of the dentate gyrus. After the first pulse, granule cells were inhibited for up to about 100 ms and then facilitated for up to hundreds of ms. Feedback activity along mossy fiber collaterals exciting local inhibitory and excitatory neurons appeared to dominate in producing on- and off-line inhibition and facilitation. Neurons mediating these effects could be inhibitory basket cells and other inhibitory interneurons targeting granule cells on- and off-line. In addition, excitatory mossy cells with far reaching, longitudinally running axons could affect off-line granule cells by exciting them directly or inhibit them indirectly by exciting local inhibitory interneurons. A scheme for dentate gyrus function is proposed whereby information to the dentate gyrus becomes split into interacting transverse strips of neuronal assemblies along which temporal processing occurs. A matrix of neuronal assemblies thus arises within which fragments of events and experiences is stored through the plasticity of synapses within and between the assemblies. Similar fragments may then be recognized at later times allowing memories of the whole to be created by pattern completion at subsequent computational stages in the hippocampus.

Activity-dependent plasticity of transmitter release from nerve terminals in rat fast and slow muscles.

Neuromuscular junctions (NMJs) on fast and slow muscle fibers display different transmitter release characteristics that appear well adapted to the different patterns of nerve impulses that they transmit in vivo. Here, we ask whether the release properties of such NMJs, termed fast and slow, can be transformed by chronic nerve stimulation. In young adult rats, nerve impulse conduction in the sciatic nerve was blocked by TTX, and the nerve to the fast extensor digitorum longus (EDL) or the slow soleus (SOL) muscle stimulated directly below the block with slow (20 Hz for 10 sec every 30 sec) or fast (150 Hz for 1 sec every 60 sec) stimulus patterns, respectively. After 3-4 weeks, originally fast EDL-NMJs and slow SOL-NMJs had become almost fully transformed to slow and fast NMJs, respectively, with respect to maintenance of transmitter release during tonic 20 Hz stimulation in vitro and ratio of quantal content to vesicle pool size. TTX block alone had no such transforming effect. Vesicle recycle time was unaffected by the stimulation, whereas initial quantal content and vesicle pool size were reduced (by 49% and 57% in EDL and 33% and 67% in SOL). Muscle fiber diameter also declined (by 49% in EDL and 33% in SOL vs 46% in unstimulated SOL; unstimulated EDL was not examined). We conclude that fast and slow NMJs display marked plasticity by being able to adapt important release characteristics to the impulse patterns imposed on them.

Targeting functional subtypes of spinal motoneurons and skeletal muscle fibers in vivo by intramuscular injection of adenoviral and adeno-associated viral vectors.

We report that functional subtypes of spinal motoneurons and skeletal muscle fibers can be selectively transduced using replication-defective adenoviral (ADV) or adeno-associated (AAV) viral vectors. After intramuscular injection in adult rodents, ADV vectors transduced both fast-twitch and slow-twitch skeletal muscle fibers. Intramuscular injection of ADV vectors also caused transduction of spinal motoneurons and dorsal root ganglion cells. However, only neurons innervating the injected muscle were transduced, as shown by co-injection of a retrograde axonal tracer. In adult male rats it is therefore possible to transduce fast or slow spinal motoneurons and muscle fibers selectively since in these animals, the extensor digitorum longus and soleus muscles contain almost exclusively fast or slow motor units, respectively. In rats, AAV vectors transduced muscle fibers in the predominantly fast extensor digitorum longus but not in the predominantly slow soleus muscle. We did not observe any transduction of spinal motoneurons following intramuscular injection of AAV vectors. These results show that physiologically and clinically important subpopulations of cells in the neuromuscular system can be selectively transduced by viral vectors.

The Response of Denervated Muscle to Long-Term Stimulation (1985, Revisited here in 2014).

In 1985, at a meeting in Abano, I presented results showing that direct stimulation of skeletal muscles with appropriate stimulus patterns prevents the effects of denervation on non-junctional properties of muscle fibers. Hence, it appeared unnecessary to postulate that unknown nerve-derived trophic factors control such properties, as posited by the (anterograde) neurotrophic hypothesis. Here I discuss this conclusion in the light of what we know today, particularly with respect to the many lines of evidence that were then taken to support the trophic hypothesis, but which today have alternative interpretations consistent with control by evoked impulse activity. Despite much effort, no one has yet identified any nerve-derived factor consistent with the neurotrophic hypothesis. Reports favoring the existence of neurotrophic factors were numerous before 2000. Now they have essentially disappeared from the literature, including original research papers, textbooks and handbooks, suggesting that the hypothesis is no longer arguable. Thus, the results that I presented in our paper in 1985 seem to have held up rather well.

Updating the lamellar hypothesis of hippocampal organization.

Andersen et al. (1971) proposed that excitatory activity in the entorhinal cortex propagates topographically to the dentate gyrus, and on through a "trisynaptic circuit" lying within transverse hippocampal "slices" or "lamellae." In this way, a relatively simple structure might mediate complex functions in a manner analogous to the way independent piano keys can produce a nearly infinite variety of unique outputs. The lamellar hypothesis derives primary support from the "lamellar" distribution of dentate granule cell axons (the mossy fibers), which innervate dentate hilar neurons and area CA3 pyramidal cells and interneurons within the confines of a thin transverse hippocampal segment. Following the initial formulation of the lamellar hypothesis, anatomical studies revealed that unlike granule cells, hilar mossy cells, CA3 pyramidal cells, and Layer II entorhinal cells all form axonal projections that are more divergent along the longitudinal axis than the clearly "lamellar" mossy fiber pathway. The existence of pathways with "translamellar" distribution patterns has been interpreted, incorrectly in our view, as justifying outright rejection of the lamellar hypothesis (Amaral and Witter, 1989). We suggest that the functional implications of longitudinally projecting axons depend not on whether they exist, but on what they do. The observation that focal granule cell layer discharges normally inhibit, rather than excite, distant granule cells suggests that longitudinal axons in the dentate gyrus may mediate "lateral" inhibition and define lamellar function, rather than undermine it. In this review, we attempt a reconsideration of the evidence that most directly impacts the physiological concept of hippocampal lamellar organization.

A novel role for embigin to promote sprouting of motor nerve terminals at the neuromuscular junction.

Adult skeletal muscle accepts ectopic innervation by foreign motor axons only after section of its own nerve, suggesting that the formation of new neuromuscular junctions is promoted by muscle denervation. With the aim to identify new proteins involved in neuromuscular junction formation we performed an mRNA differential display on innervated versus denervated adult rat muscles. We identified transcripts encoding embigin, a transmembrane protein of the immunoglobulin superfamily (IgSF) class of cell adhesion molecules to be strongly regulated by the state of innervation. In innervated muscle it is preferentially localized to neuromuscular junctions. Forced overexpression in innervated muscle of a full-length embigin transgene, but not of an embigin fragment lacking the intracellular domain, promotes nerve terminal sprouting and the formation of additional acetylcholine receptor clusters at synaptic sites without affecting terminal Schwann cell number or morphology, and it delays the retraction of terminal sprouts following re-innervation of denervated endplates. Conversely, knockdown of embigin by RNA interference in wild-type muscle accelerates terminal sprout retraction, both by itself and synergistically with deletion of neural cell adhesion molecule. These findings indicate that embigin enhances neural cell adhesion molecule-dependent neuromuscular adhesion and thereby modulates neuromuscular junction formation and plasticity.

Development of tonic firing behavior in rat soleus muscle.

Tonic firing behavior in soleus muscle of unrestrained rats aged 7 to >or=100 days was studied by chronic single-motor-unit and gross-electromyographic (EMG) recordings. Median motor-unit firing frequency at 10 days was 19-26 Hz and did not change appreciably after this time, whereas interval-to-interval firing variability was reduced with age. Two units with median frequencies 40 and 59 Hz were encountered in one 7-day-old rat. Integrated rectified gross EMG developed from being phasic only to predominantly tonic during the second and third postnatal week. From the end of the third week, rather short tonic periods with irregular amplitude were replaced by longer lasting constant-amplitude periods. Quantitatively, median duration of gross-EMG activity episodes more than doubled, while 90th-percentile values for episode duration increased 19-fold, from 7.4 s at 7 days to 140 s in adults. The main part of this increase took place after 22 days. Previous work in adult rats has indicated that descending monoaminergic innervation is essential for maintained tonic motoneuron activity, which probably is caused by depolarizing plateau potentials. Such innervation of the lumbar spinal cord matures gradually to an adult pattern and density approximately 3-4 wk after birth. The present results, describing a concurrent considerable development of tonic firing behavior, support and extend these findings.

Early events of electroporation-mediated intramuscular DNA vaccination potentiate Th1-directed immune responses.

BACKGROUND: Application of electrical pulses after DNA injection into muscle increases expression of the encoded genes, and is shown to improve antigen-specific immune responses when used for DNA vaccination. In addition, electroporation causes tissue injury and inflammatory reactions. Together with immune stimulatory motifs in the injected DNA these factors may potentiate the immune response by acting as adjuvants for the antigen. Here, we have examined the role of these factors in promoting the efficiency of DNA vaccination. METHODS: We injected a plasmid DNA vector containing the gene Ag85B from M. tuberculosis into mouse quadriceps muscles followed by electroporation. Ag85B was under control of a Tet-responsive promoter, and was expressed either immediately or up to 28 days later by administrating doxycycline to the mice. Delayed expression was combined with injection of non-coding DNA or saline with or without electroporation to examine the ability of these factors to enhance the Ag85B-specific antibody response in the blood and cellular responses in the spleen. Blood samples were analysed with ELISA, while the number of Ag85B-specific IFN-gamma- and IL-4-producing spleenocytes was analysed with ELISpot. RESULTS: Delaying Ag85B expression by 5 or 28 days caused lower anti-Ag85B-specific IgG2a levels. In contrast, the IgG1 antibody response was not significantly affected. Injection of non-coding DNA followed by electroporation moderately increased the IgG2a response. Delaying the Ag85B expression by 28 days reduced the average number of Ag85B-specific IFN-gamma-producing spleenocytes by over 60%. No significant change in the number of IL-4-producing Ag85B-specific spleenocytes was observed. CONCLUSIONS: These results suggest that DNA and electroporation per se may act as good adjuvants in promoting efficient Th1-directed responses during DNA vaccination.

What controls the position, number, size, and distribution of neuromuscular junctions on rat muscle fibers?

This review focuses on mechanisms that determine the position, number, size, and distribution of neuromuscular junctions (NMJs) on skeletal muscle fibers. Most of the data reviewed derive from studies of ectopic NMJ formation on soleus (SOL) muscle fibers in adult rats, which recapitulates essential aspects of NMJ formation in normal development. Transplanted axons induce acetylcholine receptor (AChR) aggregates, which are multiple and irregularly distributed initially but subsequently undergo massive reorganization such that one or a few winners survive and reach a certain size while the rest are eliminated (the losers). Results obtained by blocking nerve activity early and stimulating the SOL electrically show that evoked muscle impulse activity is responsible for the growth of winners to a given size and the creation of refractory zones, about 0.75 long, on each side of the winners, in which the elimination of losers occurs. Consequently, when two or more aggregates or NMJs survive on one fiber, they are, on average, at least 1.5 mm apart. Locally applied neural agrin induces comparable aggregation of AChRs and other postsynaptic proteins on denervated SOL fibers and such aggregates undergo similar activity-dependent selection for survival or elimination in refractory zones. In a dose-dependent way, neural agrin alone also induces expression of epsilon-AChR subunits and stabilizes AChRs to a half-life of 10 days, as found at normal NMJs. It is argued that signs of prepatterning of innervation sites by intrinsic muscle mechanisms may refer to epiphenomena that play no important role in NMJ formation. The conclusion is that neural agrin initiates and then maintains NMJs where motor axons happen to contact receptive muscle fibers and that evoked muscle impulse activity then ensures that the NMJs reach their appropriate size, efficiency and spatial distribution along each fiber.

The discovery of long-term potentiation.

This paper describes circumstances around the discovery of long-term potentiation (LTP). In 1966, I had just begun independent work for the degree of Dr medicinae (PhD) in Per Andersen's laboratory in Oslo after an eighteen-month apprenticeship with him. Studying the effects of activating the perforant path to dentate granule cells in the hippocampus of anaesthetized rabbits, I observed that brief trains of stimuli resulted in increased efficiency of transmission at the perforant path-granule cell synapses that could last for hours. In 1968, Tim Bliss came to Per Andersen's laboratory to learn about the hippocampus and field potential recording for studies of possible memory mechanisms. The two of us then followed up my preliminary results from 1966 and did the experiments that resulted in a paper that is now properly considered to be the basic reference for the discovery of LTP.

Electrical muscle activity pattern and transcriptional and posttranscriptional mechanisms regulate PKA subunit expression in rat skeletal muscle.

We have examined protein kinase A (PKA) subunit expression in adult rat skeletal muscles. Northern blots identified PKA catalytic alpha and regulatory (R) I alpha and RII alpha subunits as the major subunits expressed in slowly contracting soleus (SOL) and rapidly contracting extensor digitorum longus (EDL) muscles. In addition, the steady-state RNA levels of PKA subunit mRNAs and activities of RI alpha and RII alpha promoters are similar in SOL and EDL. These data indicate that posttranscriptional mechanisms account for the twofold differences in PKA subunit protein levels reported earlier. Electrical stimulation of denervated SOL with an EDL-like activity pattern (fast pattern) transformed SOL into an EDL-like muscle with regard to PKA protein levels. These experiments suggest that the posttranscriptional regulation is activity pattern-dependent. Denervation specifically increased RI alpha promoter activity and RI alpha mRNA levels in SOL and EDL. Further experiments indicated that the RI alpha 1a upstream sequences were activated following denervation. Direct electrical stimulation prevented the rise in RI alpha mRNA levels following denervation, demonstrating that electrical muscle activity regulates transcription.

NFAT is a nerve activity sensor in skeletal muscle and controls activity-dependent myosin switching.

Calcineurin (Cn) signaling has been implicated in nerve activity-dependent fiber type specification in skeletal muscle, but the downstream effector pathway has not been established. We have investigated the role of the transcription factor nuclear factor of activated T cells (NFAT), a major target of Cn, by using an in vivo transfection approach in regenerating and adult rat muscles. NFAT transcriptional activity was monitored with two different NFAT-dependent reporters and was found to be higher in slow compared to fast muscles. NFAT activity is decreased by denervation in slow muscles and is increased by electrostimulation of denervated muscles with a tonic low-frequency impulse pattern, mimicking the firing pattern of slow motor neurons, but not with a phasic high-frequency pattern typical of fast motor neurons. To determine the role of NFAT, we transfected regenerating and adult rat muscles with a plasmid coding for VIVIT, a specific peptide inhibitor of Cn-mediated NFAT activation. VIVIT was found to block the expression of slow myosin heavy chain (MyHC-slow) induced by slow motor neuron activity in regenerating slow soleus muscle and to inhibit the expression of MyHC-slow transcripts and the activity of a MyHC-slow promoter in adult soleus. The role of NFAT was confirmed by the finding that a constitutively active NFATc1 mutant stimulates the MyHC-slow, inhibits the fast MyHC-2B promoter in adult fast muscles, and induces MyHC-slow expression in regenerating muscles. These results support the notion that Cn-NFAT signaling acts as a nerve activity sensor in skeletal muscle in vivo and controls nerve activity-dependent myosin switching.