Prefrontal neuronal morphology in kindling-prone (FAST) and kindling-resistant (SLOW) rats.

The epileptogenic-prone (FAST) and epileptogenic-resistant (SLOW) rat strains have become a valuable tool for investigating neural plasticity. The strains were generated by breeding the rats that required the fewest amygdala stimulations to elicit a stage-5 convulsive seizure (FAST) and rats requiring the most stimulations (SLOW). Previous studies have shown differences in behavior and amygdala physiology in the two strains. This study examined the dendritic morphology of pyramidal neurons in the brains of adult male and female rats of the two strains. The brains were stained with the Golgi-Cox method and the length and branching from layer III pyramidal cells were measured in parietal cortex (Zilles Par1), medial frontal cortex (Zilles Cg3), and orbitofrontal cortex (Zilles AID) in these two strains of rats. We observed significantly longer dendrites in Cg3 in the FAST group but longer dendrites in the SLOW group in AID and Par1. There was also a sex difference (M > F) in Par1 in both strains. These morphological differences can provide insights into the neurobiological basis of the behavioral differences and suggest that localized changes in the amygdala do not occur independently of changes in other brain regions, and especially prefrontal cortex.

Postnatal epigenetic influences on seizure susceptibility in seizure-prone versus seizure-resistant rat strains.

The creation of seizure-prone (Fast) and seizure-resistant (Slow) rat strains via selective breeding implies genetic control of relative seizure vulnerability, yet ample data also advocates an environmental contribution. To investigate potential environmental underpinnings to the differential seizure sensitivities in these strains, the authors compared amygdala kindling profiles in adult male Fast and Slow rats raised by (a) their own mother, (b) a foster mother from the same strain, or (c) a foster mother from the opposing strain. Ultimately, strain-specific kindling profiles were not normalized by cross-fostering. Instead, both strains became more seizure-prone regardless of maternal affiliation (i.e., cross-fostered groups from both strains kindled faster than uncrossed controls). Interhemispheric seizure spread was also facilitated in cross-fostered Slow rat groups and was associated with increased commissural cross-sectional areas, giving them a Fast-like profile. It is important to note, however, that all Fast groups remained significantly more seizure-prone than Slow groups, suggesting that although the postnatal environment strongly influenced seizure disposition in both strains, it did not wholly account for their relative dispositions. Investigation into mechanisms fundamental to cross-fostering-induced seizure facilitation should help prevent postnatal worsening of pathology in already seizure-prone individuals.

Kindling as a model of human epilepsy.

The evidence supporting the suggestion that kindling is a good model of human temporal lobe epilepsy is briefly reviewed. Parallels between the human condition, involving both partial and secondarily generalized seizures, and kindling in rats and other animals are drawn and contrasted.

Differential noradrenergic influence on seizure expression in genetically Fast and Slow kindling rat strains during massed trial stimulation of the amygdala.

The involvement of alpha(2) noradrenergic receptors during amygdala 'massed' stimulation (MS) was examined in rats that were selectively bred to be seizure-prone (Fast) or seizure-resistant (Slow) to amygdala kindling. The selective alpha(2) noradrenergic agonist guanfacine, or the antagonist idazoxan, was intraperitoneally injected during the MS procedure to study subsequent changes in afterdischarge (AD) threshold, AD duration and behavioral seizure expression. These measurements were again assessed weekly for 2 weeks after the MS treatment. Daily kindling began immediately thereafter. Following 6 stage-5 once daily convulsive seizures, guanfacine or idazoxan were re-administered. With idazoxan, the Slow rats expressed greater numbers of convulsive seizures and longer AD durations compared to guanfacine or saline controls during MS treatment. This pro-convulsive property of idazoxan was absent in Fast rats. By contrast, Fast rats showed enhanced convulsive expression in the presence of guanfacine. In the fully kindled rat, idazoxan and guanfacine differentially impacted seizure duration and severity in the Slow rats, but again not in the Fast rats. These data suggest that some aspect(s) of the alpha(2) noradrenergic system in the Fast and Slow rats are dissimilar and the mechanisms by which these receptors govern seizure genesis and propagation may be genetically controlled and distinct.

Ruling out postnatal origins to attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD)-like behaviors in a seizure-prone rat strain.

Adult Fast (seizure-prone) and Slow (seizure-resistant) kindling rat strains exhibit divergent behaviors in paradigms relevant to attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) in humans. Similar dissociations in rodent behavior have been linked to disparities in early life experience, suggesting that differential maternal care or postnatal interactions may underlie these behaviors. Consequently, the authors compared maternal behavior and preweaning pup weights in these 2 strains under control and cross-fostered conditions and examined its effects on subsequent adult offspring behavior. Ultimately, several distinct maternal behaviors were apparent between the 2 strains under control conditions, and some of those behaviors were then malleable by pup condition. Yet, in spite of the resultant complex maternal patterns across groups, all offspring showed behavioral phenotypes akin to their genetic strain. Thus, a specific postnatal environment is unlikely to underwrite ADHD-like behaviors in the seizure-prone Fast rats, which implicates a genetic or prenatal origin for the ADHD phenotype.

Temporal sequence of ictal discharges propagation in the corticolimbic basal ganglia system during amygdala kindled seizures in freely moving rats.

We used a multiple channel, single unit recording technique to investigate the neural activity in different corticolimbic and basal ganglia regions in freely moving rats before and during generalized amygdala kindled seizures. Neural activity was recorded simultaneously in the sensorimotor cortex (Ctx), hippocampus, amygdala, substantia nigra pars reticulata (SNr) and the subthalamic nucleus (STN). We observed massive synchronized activity among neurons of different brain regions during seizure episodes. Neurons in the kindled amygdala led other regions in synchronized firing, revealed by time lags of neurons in other regions in crosscorrelogram analysis. While there was no obvious time lag between Ctx and SNr, the STN and hippocampus did lag behind the Ctx and SNr in correlated firing. Activity in the amygdala and SNr contralateral to the kindling stimulation site lagged behind their ipsilateral counterparts. However, no time lag was found between the kindling and contralateral sides of Ctx, hippocampus and STN. Our data confirm that the amygdala is an epileptic focus that emits ictal discharges to other brain regions. The observed temporal pattern indicates that ictal discharges from the amygdala arrive first at Ctx and SNr, and then spread to the hippocampus and STN. The simultaneous activation of both sides of the Ctx suggests that the neocortex participates in kindled seizures as a unisonant entity to provoke the clonic motor seizures. Early activation of the SNr (before the STN and hippocampus) points to an important role of the SNr in amygdala kindled seizures and supports the view that different SNr manipulations may be effective ways to control seizures.

Play fighting between kindling-prone (FAST) and kindling-resistant (SLOW) rats.

Differences in the play behavior of 2 strains of rats suggest that different components of play fighting can be modified independently. The development of play fighting in cross-strain pairs of familiar and unfamiliar rats was examined to determine whether interacting with a non-congruent pair-mate would alter the pattern of play typical for each strain. In both strains, changes in play fighting were observed throughout development, but partner identity appeared to influence play fighting in different ways depending on age. These data suggest that some components of play may be more impervious to changes in social environment than other components.

Parahippocampal networks, intractability, and the chronic epilepsy of kindling.

Clearly, the root cause of intractability in epilepsy is currently unknown. Whereas the aforementioned findings may shed light on putative underpinnings, they are by no means an exhaustive list of possibilities. However, new and more effective animal models are continually being created or discovered that take into account genetic predisposition for seizure. At the moment, amygdala kindling appears to be the best choice of the intact animal models. In this vein, the genetically predisposed seizure-prone (Fast kindling) and seizure-resistant (Slow kindling) strains may help speak to many important remaining questions in human epilepsy. Hopefully, these models, to some degree, target correct human subpopulations that are prone or resistant to epilepsy and, when used appropriately, could expedite epilepsy research and future discoveries leading to pharmacoresistance and intractability.

Conceptual, spatial, and cue learning in the Morris water maze in fast or slow kindling rats: attention deficit comorbidity.

Rat lines selectively bred for differences in amygdala excitability, manifested by "fast" or "slow" kindling epileptogenesis, display several comorbid features related to anxiety and learning. To assess the nature of the learning deficits in fast kindling rats, performance was evaluated in several variants of a Morris water-maze test. Regardless of whether the location of the platform was fixed or varied over days (matching-to-place task), the fast rats displayed inferior performance, suggesting both working and reference memory impairments. Furthermore, when the position of the platform was altered after the response was acquired, fast rats were more persistent in emitting the previously acquired response. The poor performance of fast rats was also evident in both cued and uncued tasks, indicating that their disturbed learning was not simply a reflection of a spatial deficit. Moreover, fast rats could be easily distracted by irrelevant cues, suggesting that these animals suffered from an attentional disturbance. Interestingly, when rats received several training trials with the platform elevated, permitting them to develop the concept of facile escape, the performance of fast rats improved greatly. The performance disturbance in fast rats may reflect difficulties in forming a conceptual framework under conditions involving some degree of ambiguity, as well as greater distractibility by irrelevant cues. These various attributes of the fast rats may serve as a potentially useful animal model of disorders characterized by an attention deficit.

Divergent GABA(A) receptor-mediated synaptic transmission in genetically seizure-prone and seizure-resistant rats.

Recent evidence suggests that abnormal expression of GABA(A) receptors may underlie epileptogenesis. We observed previously that rats selectively bred to be seizure-prone naturally overexpressed, as adults, GABA alpha subunits (alpha2, alpha3, and alpha5) seen at birth, whereas those selected to be seizure-resistant overexpressed the adult, alpha1 subunit. In this experiment, we gathered GABA miniature IPSCs (mIPSCs) from these strains and correlated their attributes with the subunit expression profile of each strain compared with a normal control strain. The mIPSCs were collected from both cortical pyramidal and nonpyramidal neurons. In seizure-prone rats, mIPSCs were smaller and decayed more slowly than in normal rats, which in turn were smaller and slower than in seizure-resistant rats. A detailed analysis of individual mIPSCs revealed two kinds of postsynaptic responses (those with monoexponential vs biexponential decay) that were differentially altered in the three strains. The properties of monoexponentially decaying mIPSCs did not differ between pyramidal and nonpyramidal neurons within a strain but differed between strains. In contrast, an interaction was observed between cell morphology and strain for biexponentially decaying mIPSCs. Here, the mIPSCs of pyramidal neurons in the seizure-resistant rats formed a distinct subpopulation compared with the seizure-prone rats; yet in the latter rats, it was the mIPSCs of the nonpyramidal neurons that were unique. Given these differences, we were surprised to find that the total inhibitory charge transfer between the strains was similar. This suggests that the timing of inhibition, particularly slow inhibitory neurotransmission between nonpyramidal neurons, may be a contributing factor in seizure genesis.

Animal models of limbic epilepsies: what can they tell us?

In this review, we have provided an overview of the implementation and characteristics of some of the most prevalent models of temporal lobe epilepsy in use in laboratories around the world today. These include spontaneously seizing models with status epilepticus as the initial precipitating injury (including the kainate, pilocarpine, and electrical stimulation models), kindling, and models of drug refractoriness. These models share various features with one another, and also differ in many aspects, providing a broader representation of the full spectrum of clinical limbic epilepsies. We have also provided a brief introduction into how animal models of temporal lobe epilepsy facilitate use of modern state-of-the-art techniques in neurobiology to address critical questions in the pathogenesis of epilepsy.

Activin mRNA induced during amygdala kindling shows a spatiotemporal progression that tracks the spread of seizures.

The progressive development of seizures in rats by amygdala kindling, which models temporal lobe epilepsy, allows the study of molecular regulators of enduring synaptic changes. Neurotrophins play important roles in synaptic plasticity and neuroprotection. Activin, a member of the transforming growth factor-beta superfamily of growth and differentiation factors, has recently been added to the list of candidate synaptic regulators. We mapped the induction of activin betaA mRNA in amygdala and cortex at several stages of seizure development. Strong induction, measured 2 hours after the first stage 2 (partial) seizure, appeared in neurons of the ipsilateral amygdala (confined to the lateral, basal, and posterior cortical nuclei) and insular, piriform, orbital, and infralimbic cortices. Activin betaA mRNA induction, after the first stage 5 (generalized) seizure, had spread to the contralateral amygdala (same nuclear distribution) and cortex, and the induced labeling covered much of the convexity of neocortex as well as piriform, perirhinal, and entorhinal cortices in a nearly bilaterally symmetrical pattern. This pattern had filled in by the sixth stage 5 seizure. Induced labeling in cortical neurons was confined mainly to layer II. A similar temporal and spatial pattern of increased mRNA expression of brain-derived neurotrophic factor (BDNF) was found in the amygdala and cortex. Activin betaA and BDNF expression patterns were similar at 1, 2, and 6 hours after the last seizure, subsiding at 24 hours; in contrast, c-fos mRNA induction appeared only at 1 hour throughout cortex and then subsided. In double-label studies, activin betaA mRNA-positive neurons were also BDNF mRNA positive, and they did not colocalize with GAD67 mRNA (a marker of gamma-aminobutyric acidergic neurons). The data suggest that activin and BDNF transcriptional activities accurately mark excitatory neurons participating in seizure-induced synaptic alterations and may contribute to the enduring changes that underlie the kindled state.

Differential sensitivity of genetically Fast vs. Slow kindling rats strains to GABAergic convulsive agents.

Following selective breeding for seizure-proneness vs. seizure-resistance to amygdala kindling, two strains of rats were developed with non-overlapping kindling rates, i.e. the number of stimulations required to develop fully generalized convulsive seizures (Epilepsy Res. 35 (1999) 183). In the temporal cortices of these two strains, the local seizure thresholds to electrical stimulation have been reported to be approximately two times lower in the seizure-prone (Fast kindling) compared to the seizure-resistant (Slow kindling) strain (McIntyre et al., 1999). In the present experiment, the pharmacological sensitivities of the two strains to three GABAergic antagonists, pentylenetetrazol, bicuculline and picrotoxin, were determined, and compared to the glycine antagonist, strychnine. Paralleling kindling epileptogenesis, naïve rats of the Fast kindling strain developed convulsive seizures to doses of the GABAergic antagonists that were significantly (approximately 30%) lower than the naïve Slow kindling strain. In contrast, there were no strain differences in their response to strychnine. These data indicate substantial GABAergic sensitivity differences between the two strains with an emphasis on forebrain mechanisms, which is consistent with other physiological and molecular data related to their differential profiles of epileptogenesis.

Secondary generalization of hippocampal kindled seizures in rats: examining the role of the piriform cortex.

A primary feature of epilepsy is the potential for focal seizures to recruit distant structures and generalize into convulsions. Key to understanding generalization is to identify critical structures facilitating the transition from focal to generalized seizures. In kindling, development of a primary site leads progressively to secondarily generalized convulsions. In addition, subsequent kindling of a secondary site results in rapid kindling from that site, presumably because of its facilitated access to the primary kindled network. Here, we investigated the role of the piriform cortex in convulsive generalization from a secondary site kindled in the hippocampus after primary site amygdala kindling. In a necessarily complicated design, rats initially experienced forebrain commissurotomy to lateralize the experiment to one hemisphere. Then the amygdala was kindled and, 3 weeks later, it was electrically-triggered into status epilepticus, which destroyed the ipsilateral piriform cortex. This experience occurred several days before secondary site kindling of the dorsal hippocampus. In rats with complete piriform cortex loss, there was no disruption in kindling or convulsive seizure expression from the hippocampus. However, when damage also involved parts of the perirhinal, insular and entorhinal cortices, convulsive expression was blocked. Although other evidence suggests that piriform lesions affect generalization of primary site kindling, the present study shows that they do not alter secondary site kindling in the dorsal hippocampus. The additional involvement of parahippocampal cortical areas in convulsive expression suggests an important functional association between these cortical regions and the hippocampus in seizure propagation and clinical expression.

Changes in extracellular levels of amygdala amino acids in genetically fast and slow kindling rat strains.

A neurochemical basis for many of the epilepsies has long been suspected to result from an imbalance between excitatory and inhibitory neurotransmitter mechanisms. Data supporting changes in extrasynaptic amino acid levels during epileptogenesis, however, remain controversial. In the present study, we used in vivo microdialysis to measure the levels of extracellular GABA (gamma-aminobutyric acid) and glutamate during seizure development in rats with a genetic predisposition for (Fast), or against (Slow), amygdala kindling. Dialysates were collected from both amygdalae before, during, and up to 12 min after a threshold-triggered amygdala afterdischarge (AD). One hour later, samples were again collected from both amygdalae in response to a hippocampal threshold AD. Daily amygdala kindling commenced the next day but without dialysis. After the rats were fully kindled, the same protocol was again employed. Amino acid levels were not consistently increased above baseline with triggered seizures in either strain. Instead, before kindling, a focal seizure in the Slow rats was associated with a large decrease in GABA in the non-stimulated amygdala, while amino acid levels in the Fast rats remained near baseline in both amygdalae. Similar results were seen after kindling. By contrast, before and after kindling, hippocampal stimulation caused large decreases in all amino acid levels in both amygdalae in both strains. These data suggest that, in response to direct stimulation, extracellular amino acid concentrations remain stable in tissues associated with either greater natural (Fast) or induced (kindled Fast/Slow) excitability, but are lowered with indirect stimulation (hippocampus) and/or low excitability.

Kindling: some old and some new.

A brief review of kindling is provided, which highlights some important points of historical interest often overlooked by researchers. These points include the fact that the original rating scale of convulsive seizures presented by Racine 'EEG Clin. Neurophysiol 32 (1972) 281'. was based on amygdala kindling, and may not be applicable to kindling from other sites. The functional anatomy of these convulsive seizures was similarly addressed. Also emphasized was the observation that kindling results ultimately in spontaneous seizures, seemingly identical to those seen in models of status epilepticus (SE), and can provide a unique perspective on those seizures because of its controlled natural history and minimal brain damage. Much of the recent work described here focused on genetic susceptibility versus resistance to kindling, as witnessed by the Fast and Slow kindling rat strains. The results of those studies indicated substantial strain differences in GABAergic function in different limbic structures associated with GABA(A) subunit expression, spontaneous miniature inhibitory postsynaptic currents (mIPCs) and behavioral comorbidities. We concluded the review with our recent attempt to discover consistent and unique gene profile differences associated with the different seizure predispositions of the Fast and Slow kindling rat strains.

Relation between startle reactivity and sucrose avidity in two rat strains bred for differential seizure susceptibility.

Rat strains selectively bred to be seizure-prone (Fast) versus seizure-resistant (Slow) show differing levels of anxiety, with Slow rats displaying relatively enhanced anxiety-like behaviors to aversive stimuli. Ample data has suggested that highly anxious rodents exhibit reduced avidity for sucrose and greater startle responses than rodents with relatively low anxiety levels. Thus, it was hypothesized that the Slow rats would have lower appetitive (sucrose consumption) and greater defensive (startle response) behaviors than Fast rats. Results confirmed that Slow rats consumed significantly less sucrose and exhibited greater acoustic startle responses than Fast rats. Startle response magnitude was not associated with water consumption, food consumption or body weight but was negatively correlated with sucrose consumption. These observations attest to the link between sucrose avidity and startle reactivity and further reveal that genetic selection for amygdala excitability lead to strain differences in appetitive and defensive behaviors. Thus, Fast and Slow rats may be two unique strains with which to further elucidate the genetic and neurobiological mechanisms underlying appetitive and defensive behaviors and their relation to anxiety and seizure sensitivity.

Caloric restriction alters seizure disposition and behavioral profiles in seizure-prone (fast) versus seizure-resistant (slow) rats.

Caloric restriction (CR), primarily known for extending life span, has proven anticonvulsant in several seizure models and antiepileptogenic in a strain of inherently seizure susceptible mice. Our animal model consisted of a seizure-prone (Fast) strain that naturally exhibits attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD)-like behaviors and a comparison seizure-resistant (Slow) strain; we evaluated CR's effect on the typical seizure sensitivities and behavioral profiles of each strain. Fast and Slow rats were fed ad libitum or were calorically restricted to 80% of free-feeding body weight. Rats were then tested in the open field (hyperactivity), Morris water maze (learning and attention), and restraint (impulsivity) paradigms and finally kindled from the amygdala. Ultimately, CR abolished signs of abnormal hyperactivity in the Fast strain and retarded their kindling rates, making it the first manipulation to demonstrate an antiepileptogenic effect in this animal model. CR also shortened seizure durations in fully kindled Slow rats but had no effect on their kindling rates, implying a differential effect of CR on genotype. These results clearly endorse further investigation into the potential benefits of CR for both epilepsy and ADHD.

Assessment of anxiety-like behaviors in female rats bred for differences in kindling susceptibility and amygdala excitability.

Two rat lines bred for kindling susceptibility were previously observed to engage in different behavioral strategies in tests of emotionality. In order to extend past research on defensive behaviors in these strains which largely used males, Fast- and Slow-kindling females were assessed for anxiety-like behaviors in a number of aversive paradigms. Fast rats entered and spent more time in the open arms and spent less time in the closed arms of the elevated plus-maze (EPM) compared to Slow animals. Fast rats had higher conditioned suppression ratios across testing days, defecated less often during conditioning, and successfully disinhibited suppression during extinction in the conditioned emotional response (CER) paradigm compared to Slow-kindlers. In order to pursue these differences in emotional reactivity between the strains and differentiate negative affect from motivational, learning, and impulsive explanations, a separate group of animals were assessed in the light-enhanced acoustic startle chamber, a test of anxiety. When initially exposed to a bright-light, Slow rats significantly increased their startle response while this was not observed in the Fast strain. In combination with previous research on these strains, the present data tentatively suggest that Fast and Slow animals utilize different neural systems in tests of fear and anxiety which may have been co-selected with the direct selection of amygdala-kindling susceptibility.

Mapping seizure pathways in the temporal lobe.

Interest in temporal lobe seizure pathways has a long history based initially on the human condition of temporal lobe epilepsy (TLE). This interest in TLE has extended more recently into explorations of experimental models. In this review, the network structures in the temporal lobe that are recruited in animal models during various forms of limbic seizures and status epilepticus are described. Common to all of the various models is recruitment of the parahippocampal cortices, including the piriform, perirhinal, and entorhinal areas. This cortical involvement is seen in in vitro and in vivo electrophysiological recordings throughout the network, in trans-synaptic neuroplastic changes in associated network structures manifest at the molecular level, in network energy utilization visualized by 14C2-deoxyglucose uptake, and finally, in the behavioral consequences of network lesions. The conclusions of the animal models reviewed here are very similar to those described for the human condition presented recently in the 2006 Lennox lecture by Warren Blume, and addressed 53 years ago in the quadrennial meeting of the ILAE in 1953 by Henri Gastaut.