Spatiotemporal patterns corresponding to phase synchronization and generalized synchronization states of thermoacoustic instability.

Thermoacoustic instability in turbulent combustion systems emerges from the complex interplay among the flame, flow, and acoustic subsystems. While the onset of thermoacoustic instability exhibits a global order, the characteristics of local interactions between subsystems responsible for this order are not well understood. Here, we utilize the framework of synchronization to elucidate the spatiotemporal interactions among heat release rate fluctuations in the flame, velocity fluctuations in the flow, and acoustic pressure fluctuations in a turbulent combustor, across the bluff-body stabilized flame. We examine two forms of thermoacoustic instability, characterized by phase synchronization and generalized synchronization of the acoustic pressure and global heat release rate oscillations. Despite the presence of global synchrony, we uncover a coexistence of frequency synchrony and desynchrony in the local interaction of these oscillations within the reaction field. In regions of frequency-locked oscillations, various phase-locking patterns occur, including phase synchrony and partial phase synchrony. We observe that the local formation of small pockets of phase synchrony and strong amplitude correlation between these oscillations is sufficient to trigger the state of global phase synchronization. As the global dynamics approach generalized synchronization, these local regions of synchrony expand in the reaction field. Additionally, through coupled analysis of acoustic pressure and local flow velocity fluctuations, we infer that the spatial region of flow-acoustic synchrony plays a significant role in governing thermoacoustic instabilities. Our findings imply that, in turbulent combustors, an intrinsic local balance between order, partial order, and disorder within the coupled subsystems sustains the global order during thermoacoustic instability.

Mitigation of limit cycle oscillations in a turbulent thermoacoustic system via delayed acoustic self-feedback.

We report the occurrence of amplitude death (AD) of limit cycle oscillations in a bluff body stabilized turbulent combustor through delayed acoustic self-feedback. Such feedback control is achieved by coupling the acoustic field of the combustor to itself through a single coupling tube attached near the anti-node position of the acoustic standing wave. We observe that the amplitude and dominant frequency of the limit cycle oscillations gradually decrease as the length of the coupling tube is increased. Complete suppression (AD) of these oscillations is observed when the length of the coupling tube is nearly 3 / 8 times the wavelength of the fundamental acoustic mode of the combustor. Meanwhile, as we approach this state of amplitude death, the dynamical behavior of acoustic pressure changes from the state of limit cycle oscillations to low-amplitude chaotic oscillations via intermittency. We also study the change in the nature of the coupling between the unsteady flame dynamics and the acoustic field as the length of the coupling tube is increased. We find that the temporal synchrony between these oscillations changes from the state of synchronized periodicity to desynchronized aperiodicity through intermittent synchronization. Furthermore, we reveal that the application of delayed acoustic self-feedback with optimum feedback parameters completely disrupts the positive feedback loop between hydrodynamic, acoustic, and heat release rate fluctuations present in the combustor during thermoacoustic instability, thus mitigating instability. We anticipate this method to be a viable and cost-effective option to mitigate thermoacoustic oscillations in turbulent combustion systems used in practical propulsion and power systems.

Anticipating synchrony in dynamical systems using information theory.

Synchronization in coupled dynamical systems has been a well-known phenomenon in the field of nonlinear dynamics for a long time. This phenomenon has been investigated extensively both analytically and experimentally. Although synchronization is observed in different areas of our real life, in some cases, this phenomenon is harmful; consequently, an early warning of synchronization becomes an unavoidable requirement. This paper focuses on this issue and proposes a reliable measure ( R), from the perspective of the information theory, to detect complete and generalized synchronizations early in the context of interacting oscillators. The proposed measure R is an explicit function of the joint entropy and mutual information of the coupled oscillators. The applicability of R to anticipate generalized and complete synchronizations is justified using numerical analysis of mathematical models and experimental data. Mathematical models involve the interaction of two low-dimensional, autonomous, chaotic oscillators and a network of coupled Rössler and van der Pol oscillators. The experimental data are generated from laboratory-scale turbulent thermoacoustic systems.

Dynamical states and bifurcations in coupled thermoacoustic oscillators.

The emergence of rich dynamical phenomena in coupled self-sustained oscillators, primarily synchronization and amplitude death, has attracted considerable interest in several fields of science and engineering. Here, we present a comprehensive theoretical study on the manifestation of these exquisite phenomena in a reduced-order model of two coupled Rijke tube oscillators, which are prototypical thermoacoustic oscillators. We characterize the dynamical behaviors of two such identical and non-identical oscillators by varying both system parameters (such as the uncoupled amplitudes and the natural frequencies of the oscillators) and coupling parameters (such as the coupling strength and the coupling delay). The present model captures all the dynamical phenomena-namely, synchronization, phase-flip bifurcation, amplitude death, and partial amplitude death-observed previously in experiments on coupled Rijke tubes. By performing numerical simulations and deriving approximate analytical solutions, we systematically decipher the conditions and the bifurcations underlying the aforementioned phenomena. The insights provided by this study can be used to understand the interactions between multiple cans in gas turbine combustors and develop control strategies to avert undesirable thermoacoustic oscillations in them.

Rijke tube: A nonlinear oscillator.

Dynamical systems theory has emerged as an interdisciplinary area of research to characterize the complex dynamical transitions in real-world systems. Various nonlinear dynamical phenomena and bifurcations have been discovered over the decades using different reduced-order models of oscillators. Different measures and methodologies have been developed theoretically to detect, control, or suppress the nonlinear oscillations. However, obtaining such phenomena experimentally is often challenging, time-consuming, and risky mainly due to the limited control of certain parameters during experiments. With this review, we aim to introduce a paradigmatic and easily configurable Rijke tube oscillator to the dynamical systems community. The Rijke tube is commonly used by the combustion community as a prototype to investigate the detrimental phenomena of thermoacoustic instability. Recent investigations in such Rijke tubes have utilized various methodologies from dynamical systems theory to better understand the occurrence of thermoacoustic oscillations and their prediction and mitigation, both experimentally and theoretically. The existence of various dynamical behaviors has been reported in single and coupled Rijke tube oscillators. These behaviors include bifurcations, routes to chaos, noise-induced transitions, synchronization, and suppression of oscillations. Various early warning measures have been established to predict thermoacoustic instabilities. Therefore, this review article consolidates the usefulness of a Rijke tube oscillator in terms of experimentally discovering and modeling different nonlinear phenomena observed in physics, thus transcending the boundaries between the physics and the engineering communities.

Bursting during intermittency route to thermoacoustic instability: Effects of slow-fast dynamics.

Intermittency observed prior to thermoacoustic instability is characterized by the occurrence of bursts of high-amplitude periodic oscillations (active state) amidst epochs of low-amplitude aperiodic fluctuations (rest state). Several model-based studies conjectured that bursting arises due to the underlying turbulence in the system. However, such intermittent bursts occur even in laminar and low-turbulence combustors, which cannot be explained by models based on turbulence. We assert that bursting in such combustors may arise due to the existence of subsystems with varying timescales of oscillations, thus forming slow-fast systems. Experiments were performed on a horizontal Rijke tube and the effect of slow-fast oscillations was studied by externally introducing low-frequency sinusoidal modulations in the control parameter. The induced bursts display an abrupt transition between the rest and the active states. The growth and decay patterns of such bursts show asymmetry due to delayed bifurcation caused by slow oscillations of the control parameter about the Hopf bifurcation point. Further, we develop a phenomenological model for the interaction between different subsystems of a thermoacoustic system by either coupling the slow and fast subsystems or by introducing noise in the absence of slow oscillations of the control parameter. We show that interaction between subsystems with different timescales leads to regular amplitude modulated bursting, while the presence of noise induces irregular amplitude modulations in the bursts. Thus, we speculate that bursting in laminar and low-turbulence systems occurs predominantly due to the interdependence between slow and fast oscillations, while bursting in high-turbulence systems is predominantly influenced by the underlying turbulence.

Recurrence analysis of slow-fast systems.

Many complex systems exhibit periodic oscillations comprising slow-fast timescales. In such slow-fast systems, the slow and fast timescales compete to determine the dynamics. In this study, we perform a recurrence analysis on simulated signals from paradigmatic model systems as well as signals obtained from experiments, each of which exhibit slow-fast oscillations. We find that slow-fast systems exhibit characteristic patterns along the diagonal lines in the corresponding recurrence plot (RP). We discern that the hairpin trajectories in the phase space lead to the formation of line segments perpendicular to the diagonal line in the RP for a periodic signal. Next, we compute the recurrence networks (RNs) of these slow-fast systems and uncover that they contain additional features such as clustering and protrusions on top of the closed-ring structure. We show that slow-fast systems and single timescale systems can be distinguished by computing the distance between consecutive state points on the phase space trajectory and the degree of the nodes in the RNs. Such a recurrence analysis substantially strengthens our understanding of slow-fast systems, which do not have any accepted functional forms.

Dynamical systems approach to study thermoacoustic transitions in a liquid rocket combustor.

Liquid rockets are prone to large amplitude oscillations, commonly referred to as thermoacoustic instability. This phenomenon causes unavoidable developmental setbacks and poses a stern challenge to accomplish the mission objectives. Thermoacoustic instability arises due to the nonlinear interaction between the acoustic and the reactive flow subsystems in the combustion chamber. In this paper, we adopt tools from dynamical systems and complex systems theory to understand the dynamical transitions from a state of stable operation to thermoacoustic instability in a self-excited model multielement liquid rocket combustor based on an oxidizer rich staged combustion cycle. We observe that this transition to thermoacoustic instability occurs through a sequence of bursts of large amplitude periodic oscillations. Furthermore, we show that the acoustic pressure oscillations in the combustor pertain to different dynamical states. In contrast to a simple limit cycle oscillation, we show that the system dynamics switches between period-3 and period-4 oscillations during the state of thermoacoustic instability. We show several measures based on recurrence quantification analysis and multifractal theory, which can diagnose the dynamical transitions occurring in the system. We find that these measures are more robust than the existing measures in distinguishing the dynamical state of a rocket engine. Furthermore, these measures can be used to validate models and computational fluid dynamics simulations, aiming to characterize the performance and stability of rockets.

Oscillation quenching and phase-flip bifurcation in coupled thermoacoustic systems.

Oscillatory instabilities, although ubiquitous in nature, are undesirable in many situations such as biological systems, swaying of bridges and skyscrapers, aero-acoustic flutter, prey-predator and disease spread models, and thermoacoustic systems, where they exhibit large amplitude periodic oscillations. In the present study, we aim to study the suppression mechanism of such undesired oscillations in a pair of thermoacoustic oscillators, also known as horizontal Rijke tubes. These oscillators are coupled through a connecting tube whose length and diameter are varied as coupling parameters. With the variation of these parameters, we show the first experimental evidence of rich dynamical phenomena such as synchronization, amplitude death, and phase-flip bifurcation in coupled identical thermoacoustic oscillators. We discover that when frequency and amplitude mismatch are introduced between these oscillators, quenching of oscillations in one or both the oscillators occurs with further ease, through the mechanisms of amplitude death and partial amplitude death. Finally, we show that the effectiveness of coupling is sensitive to the dimensions of the connecting tube which can be directly correlated with the time delay and coupling strength of the system.

Characterization of forced response of density stratified reacting wake.

The hydrodynamic stability of a reacting wake depends primarily on the density ratio [i.e., ratio of unburnt gas density (ρu) to burnt gas density (ρb)] of the flow across the wake. The variation of the density ratio from high to low value, keeping ρu/ρb>1, transitions dynamical characteristics of the reacting wake from a linearly globally stable (or convectively unstable) to a globally unstable mode. In this paper, we propose a framework to analyze the effect of harmonic forcing on the deterministic and synchronization characteristics of reacting wakes. Using the recurrence quantification analysis of the forced wake response, we show that the deterministic behaviour of the reacting wake increases as the amplitude of forcing is increased. Furthermore, for different density ratios, we found that the synchronization of the top and bottom branches of the wake with the forcing signal is dependent on whether the mean frequency of the natural oscillations of the wake (fn) is lesser or greater than the frequency of external forcing (ff). We notice that the response of both branches (top and bottom) of the reacting wake to the external forcing is asymmetric and symmetric for the low and high density ratios, respectively. Furthermore, we characterize the phase-locking behaviour between the top and bottom branches of the wake for different values of density ratios. We observe that an increase in the density ratio results in a gradual decrease in the relative phase angle between the top and bottom branches of the wake, which leads to a change in the vortex shedding pattern from a sinuous (anti-phase) to a varicose (in-phase) mode of the oscillations.

Effect of time-delay and dissipative coupling on amplitude death in coupled thermoacoustic oscillators.

We here systematically investigate amplitude death (AD) phenomenon in a thermoacoustic system using a mathematical model of coupled prototypical thermoacoustic oscillators, the horizontal Rijke tubes. AD has recently been identified as a relatively simple phenomenon, which can be exploited to stop the unwanted high amplitude pressure oscillations resulting from the occurrence of thermoacoustic instability. We examine the effect of time-delay and dissipative couplings on a system of two Rijke tubes when they are symmetrically and asymmetrically coupled. The regions where appropriate combinations of delay time, detuning, and the strengths of time-delay and dissipative coupling lead to AD are identified. The relative ease of attaining AD when both the couplings are applied simultaneously is inferred from the model. In the presence of strong enough coupling, AD is observed even when the oscillators of dissimilar amplitudes are coupled, while a significant reduction in the amplitudes of both the oscillators is observed when the coupling strength is not enough to attain AD.

Effect of noise amplification during the transition to amplitude death in coupled thermoacoustic oscillators.

We present a systematic investigation of the effect of external noise on the dynamics of a system of two coupled prototypical thermoacoustic oscillators, horizontal Rijke tubes, using a mathematical model. We focus on the possibility of amplitude death (AD), which is observed in the deterministic model of coupled thermoacoustic oscillators as studied by Thomas et al. [Chaos 28, 033119 (2018)], in the presence of noise. Although a complete cessation of oscillations or AD is not possible in the stochastic case, we observe a significant reduction in the amplitude of coupled limit cycle oscillations (LCOs) with the application of strong coupling. Furthermore, as we increase the noise intensity, a sudden drop in the amplitude of pressure oscillations at the transition from LCO to AD, observed in the noise free case, is no longer discernible because of the amplification of noise in AD state. During this transition from LCO to AD, we notice a qualitative change in the distribution of the pressure amplitude from bimodal to unimodal. Furthermore, in order to demarcate the boundary of the transition from LCO and AD in the noisy case, we use 80 % suppression in the amplitude of LCO, which generally occurs in the parameter range over which this qualitative change in the pressure distribution happens, as a threshold. With the help of bifurcation diagrams, we show a qualitative change as well as a reduction in the size of amplitude suppression zones that happen due to the increase in noise intensity. We also observe the relative ease of suppressing the amplitude of LCO with time-delay coupling when detuning and dissipative couplings are introduced between the two thermoacoustic oscillators in the presence of noise.

Coupled interaction between unsteady flame dynamics and acoustic field in a turbulent combustor.

Thermoacoustic instability is a result of the positive feedback between the acoustic pressure and the unsteady heat release rate fluctuations in a combustor. We apply the framework of the synchronization theory to study the coupled behavior of these oscillations during the transition to thermoacoustic instability in a turbulent bluff-body stabilized gas-fired combustor. Furthermore, we characterize this complex behavior using recurrence plots and recurrence networks. We mainly found that the correlation of probability of recurrence ( C P R ), the joint probability of recurrence ( J P R ), the determinism ( D E T ), and the recurrence rate ( R R ) of the joint recurrence matrix aid in detecting the synchronization transitions in this thermoacoustic system. We noticed that C P R and D E T can uncover the occurrence of phase synchronization state, whereas J P R and R R can be used as indices to identify the occurrence of generalized synchronization (GS) state in the system. We applied measures derived from joint and cross recurrence networks and observed that the joint recurrence network measures, transitivity ratio, and joint transitivity are useful to detect GS. Furthermore, we use the directional property of the network measure, namely, cross transitivity to analyze the type of coupling existing between the acoustic field ( p ' ) and the heat release rate ( q ˙ ' ) fluctuations. We discover a possible asymmetric bidirectional coupling between q ˙ ' and p ' , wherein q ˙ ' is observed to exert a stronger influence on p ' than vice versa.

Experimental investigation on the susceptibility of minimal networks to a change in topology and number of oscillators.

Understanding the global dynamical behavior of a network of coupled oscillators has been a topic of immense research in many fields of science and engineering. Various factors govern the resulting dynamical behavior of such networks, including the number of oscillators and their coupling schemes. Although these factors are seldom significant in large populations, a small change in them can drastically affect the global behavior in small populations. In this paper, we perform an experimental investigation on the effect of these factors on the coupled behavior of a minimal network of candle-flame oscillators. We observe that strongly coupled oscillators exhibit the global behavior of in-phase synchrony and amplitude death, irrespective of the number and the topology of oscillators. However, when they are weakly coupled, their global behavior exhibits the intermittent occurrence of multiple stable states in time. We report the experimental discovery of partial amplitude death in a network of candle-flame oscillators, in addition to the observation of other dynamical states including clustering, chimera, and weak chimera. We also show that closed-loop networks tend to hold global synchronization for longer duration as compared to open-loop networks.

Synchronization route to weak chimera in four candle-flame oscillators.

Synchronization and chimera are examples of collective behavior observed in an ensemble of coupled nonlinear oscillators. Recent studies have focused on their discovery in systems with least possible number of oscillators. Here we present an experimental study revealing the synchronization route to weak chimera via quenching, clustering, and chimera states in a single system of four coupled candle-flame oscillators. We further report the discovery of multiphase weak chimera along with experimental evidence of the theoretically predicted states of in-phase chimera and antiphase chimera.

Experimental Evidence of Amplitude Death and Phase-Flip Bifurcation between In-Phase and Anti-Phase Synchronization.

Nonlinear phenomena emerging from the coupled behaviour of a pair of oscillators have attracted considerable research attention over the years, of which, amplitude death (AD) and phase-flip bifurcation (PFB) are two noteworthy examples. Although theoretical research has postulated the coexistence of AD and PFB upon variation of different control parameters, such an occurrence has not been reported in practical systems. Here, we provide the first experimental evidence of the coexistence of AD and PFB in a physical system, comprising of a coupled pair of candle-flame oscillators. As the strength of coupling between the oscillators is increased, we report a decrease in the span of AD region between the states of in-phase and anti-phase oscillations, leading up to a point of PFB. Understanding such a switching of phenomena between AD and PFB helps us to evade their undesirable occurrences such as AD in neuron and brain cells, oscillatory state in prey-predator systems, oscillatory spread of epidemics and so forth.