Anti-LFA-1 induces CD8 T-cell dependent allograft tolerance and augments suppressor phenotype CD8 cells.

The induction of tolerance to transplanted organs is a major objective in transplantation immunology research. Lymphocyte function-associated antigen-1 (LFA-1) interactions have been identified as a key component of the T-cell activation process that may be interrupted to lead to allograft tolerance. In mice, αLFA-1 mAb is a potent monotherapy that leads to the induction of donor-specific transferable tolerance. By interrogating important adaptive and innate immunity pathways, we demonstrate that the induction of tolerance relies on CD8+T-cells. We further demonstrate that αLFA-1 induced tolerance is associated with CD8+CD28-T-cells with a suppressor phenotype, and that while CD8 cells are present, the effector T-cell response is abrogated. A recent publication has shown that CD8+CD28- cells are not diminished by cyclosporine or rapamycin, therefore CD8+CD28- cells represent a clinically relevant population. To our knowledge, this is the first time that a mechanism for αLFA-1 induced tolerance has been described.

Ectopic expression of Fas Ligand on cardiomyocytes renders cardiac allografts resistant to CD4(+) T-cell mediated rejection.

Fas Ligand limits inflammatory injury and permits allograft survival by inducing apoptosis of Fas-bearing lymphocytes. Previous studies have shown that the CD4(+) T-cell is both sufficient and required for murine cardiac allograft rejection. Here, utilizing a transgenic mouse that over-expresses Fas Ligand specifically on cardiomyocytes as heart donors, we sought to determine if Fas Ligand on graft parenchymal cells could resist CD4(+) T-cell mediated rejection. When transplanted into fully immunocompetent BALB/c recipients Fas Ligand transgenic hearts were acutely rejected. However, when transplanted into CD4(+) T-cell reconstituted BALB/c-rag(-/-) recipients, Fas Ligand hearts demonstrated long-term survival. These results indicate that Fas Ligand over-expression on cardiomyocytes can indeed resist CD4(+) T-cell mediated cardiac rejection and suggests contact dependence between Fas Ligand expressing graft parenchymal cells and the effector CD4(+) T-cells.

Inhibition of autophagy increases apoptosis during re-warming after cold storage in renal tubular epithelial cells.

Prolonged cold storage and re-warming (CS/REW) of kidneys are risk factors for delayed graft function (DGF). Studies in renal tubular epithelial cells (RTECs) have determined apoptosis and autophagy in models of either cold storage (CS) or re-warming alone. The effect of both cold storage and re-warming on apoptosis and autophagy, in RTECS is not known and is relevant to DGF as the kidney is subjected to both CS and re-warming. We hypothesized that CS/REW of RTECs would induce autophagy that protects against apoptosis. In CS/REW, there was increased autophagic flux of RTECs. Autophagy inhibition using an Atg5 siRNA resulted in increased cleaved caspase-3 and increased apoptotic cells (on both morphology and annexin V staining) during CS/REW. The effect of autophagy inhibition on necrosis in RTECs is unknown. There were increased necrosis and caspase-1, a mediator of necrosis, during CS/REW, and the Atg5 siRNA had no effect on necrosis and caspase-1. In a kidney transplant model, there was an increase in LC3 II, a marker of autophagy, in kidneys transplanted after cold storage. In summary, autophagic flux is increased during CS/REW. Autophagy inhibition resulted in increased cleaved caspase-3 and increased apoptosis during CS/REW without an effect on necrosis or caspase-1. In conclusion, autophagy inhibition in RTECs after CS/REW induces apoptotic cell death and may be deleterious as a therapy to decrease DGF.

Deletion of TLR4 reduces apoptosis and improves histology in a murine kidney transplant model.

Acute kidney injury (AKI) after transplantation of human deceased donor kidneys is associated with upregulation of tubular toll like receptor 4 (TLR4), but whether TLR4 is required for AKI is unknown. We hypothesized that TLR4 knockout mice (TLR4KO) subjected to cold ischemia followed by kidney transplant (CI + Txp) would be protected from AKI. C57Bl/6J wild type or TLR4KO kidneys were subjected to CI + Txp into wild type recipients. Tubular cell apoptosis, tubular injury and cast formation were significantly improved in recipients of TLR4KO kidneys. TLR4KO kidneys also demonstrated significantly decreased expression of the effector caspase 8. Brush border injury scores and serum creatinine were not different in recipients of TLR4KO versus wild type kidneys. Phosphorylated RIP3 and MLKL through which TLR4 signals programmed necrosis were expressed in both recipient groups. In addition, TNF-α and TNFR1 expression were significantly increased in recipient serum and TLR4KO kidneys respectively after CI + Txp, suggesting continued activation of programmed necrosis despite TLR4 deletion. Our results suggest that TLR4 deletion decreases apoptosis via inhibition of the death receptor pathway and decreases tubular injury and cast formation.

A Standardized Warm Ischemia Time for the Induction of Injury in Murine Kidney Transplants.

One of the cornerstone research models used in our laboratories is the induction of ischemic injury through cold ischemia followed by warm ischemia to donor kidneys to mimic the clinical realities of transplantation. The experimental design of the present study included bilateral nephrectomies on the day of syngeneic kidney transplant, with serum creatinine measured 24 hours postoperatively to measure acute function. Cold ischemia time in these experiments was always 30 minutes, and warm ischemia time was not standardized but always recorded. It became apparent that some transplanted kidneys that should have displayed injury were producing close to normal serum creatinine levels on postoperative day 1. In reviewing our data, we found a potential correlation between warm ischemia time and serum creatinine, in particular a significant proportion of low serum creatinine results (0.48 ± 0.26 mg/dL vs 1.99 ± 1.11 mg/dL; P < .05) was associated with warm ischemia times that were significantly shorter than our historical average (29.2 ± 2.7 min vs 35.7 ± 2.2 min; P < .05). The kidneys with lower serum creatinine also displayed lower apoptosis and brush border injury scores and fewer tubular casts. Therefore, we concluded that establishing a minimum warm ischemia time was just as important as standardized cold ischemia time to ensure consistent injury in this model.

The impact of Caspase-1 deletion on apoptosis and acute kidney injury in a murine transplant model.

BACKGROUND: Caspase-1 knockout mice (Casp1KO) are protected from Acute Kidney Injury (AKI) after warm ischemia/reperfusion injury in non-transplant models. Since Caspase-1 plays a central role as an inflammatory response initiator, we hypothesized that Casp1KO mice would be protected from AKI following transplant. METHODS: Renal tubular cells (RTECs) were subjected to cold storage and rewarming (CS/REW). C57Bl/6 J wild type or Casp1KO kidneys were subjected to CI for 30 min and then transplanted into wild type recipients (CI + Txp). The recipients underwent bilateral native nephrectomy at the time of transplant. Serum creatinine (sCr) was measured 24 h after native nephrectomy to assess transplant function. RESULTS: We found that RTECs subjected to CS/REW had significantly increased expression of the Caspase-1 and inflammasome protein NLRP1. Wild type kidneys subjected to CI + Txp into wild type recipients also demonstrated significantly increased Caspase-1 and NLRP1 protein expression compared to kidneys transplanted from Casp1KO donors into wild type recipients. Caspase-1 deletion results in significantly decreased RTEC apoptosis in transplanted Casp1KO vs WT kidneys. Surprisingly, however, renal function, ATN scores including brush border injury, cast formation and tubular simplification were similar in both groups and not significantly different. CONCLUSIONS: Our data suggest that other triggers of inflammation and programmed necrosis may need to be inhibited in addition to attenuating Caspase-1 to fully prevent AKI after kidney transplant. Importantly, requirements may be distinct for AKI induced by transplantation as opposed to other transient models such as the clamp model of AKI.

Injury Pathways That Lead to AKI in a Mouse Kidney Transplant Model.

BACKGROUND: Prolonged cold ischemia (CI) is a risk factor for acute kidney injury after kidney transplantation. We endeavored to determine the pathways involved in the development of tubular cell injury and death before and after transplantation. We hypothesized that ex vivo cold storage before transplant would produce a different injury phenotype to that seen after engraftment in kidney transplants with or without CI. METHODS: Four groups of mouse donor kidneys were studied: (1) nontransplanted control kidneys; (2) donor kidneys subjected to ex vivo cold ischemia (CI); (3) donor kidneys subjected to kidney transplant without CI (Txp); and (4) donor kidneys subjected to CI followed by transplantation (CI+Txp). RESULTS: Acute kidney injury only occurred in the CI+Txp group, which had significantly increased sCr versus the Txp group and the control mice. Histologically, the CI group demonstrated significantly increased tubular cell apoptosis and caspase-9 expression, whereas the Txp group demonstrated only mild brush border injury without apoptosis or necrosis. In contrast, the CI+Txp group had tubular cell apoptosis associated with expression of caspase-8, TNFR1, and increased serum TNF-α. CI+Txp also led to significantly higher ATN scores in association with increased RIP1, RIP3, pMLKL, and TLR4 expression. CONCLUSIONS: Our results suggest distinct therapies are needed at different times during organ preservation and transplantation. Prevention of apoptosis during cold storage is best achieved by inhibiting intrinsic pathways. In contrast, prevention of cell death and innate immunity after CI+Txp requires inhibition of both the extrinsic death receptor pathway via TNFR1 and caspase-8 and inhibition of programmed necrosis via TLR4 and TNFR1.

Caspase Inhibition During Cold Storage Improves Graft Function and Histology in a Murine Kidney Transplant Model.

BACKGROUND: Prolonged cold ischemia is a risk factor for delayed graft function of kidney transplants, and is associated with caspase-3-mediated apoptotic tubular cell death. We hypothesized that treatment of tubular cells and donor kidneys during cold storage with a caspase inhibitor before transplant would reduce tubular cell apoptosis and improve kidney function after transplant. METHODS: Mouse tubular cells were incubated with either dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO) or Q-VD-OPh during cold storage in saline followed by rewarming in normal media. For in vivo studies, donor kidneys from C57BL/6 mice were perfused with cold saline, DMSO (vehicle), or QVD-OPh. Donor kidneys were then recovered, stored at 4°C for 60 minutes, and transplanted into syngeneic C57BL/6 recipients. RESULTS: Tubular cells treated with a caspase inhibitor had significantly reduced capsase-3 protein expression, caspase-3 activity, and apoptotic cell death compared with saline or DMSO (vehicle) in a dose-dependent manner. Treatment of donor kidneys with a caspase inhibitor significantly reduced serum creatinine and resulted in significantly less tubular cell apoptosis, BBI, tubular injury, cast formation, and tubule lumen dilation compared with DMSO and saline-treated kidneys. CONCLUSIONS: Caspase inhibition resulted in decreased tubular cell apoptosis and improved renal function after transplantation. Caspase inhibition may be a useful strategy to prevent cold ischemic injury of donor renal grafts.

Spontaneous allograft tolerance in B7-deficient mice independent of preexisting endogenous CD4+CD25+ regulatory T-cells.

BACKGROUND: Acute cardiac allograft rejection requires host, but not donor, expression of B7-1/B7-2 costimulatory molecules. However, acute cardiac rejection requires direct antigen presentation by donor-derived antigen presenting cells to CD4 T-cells and does not require indirect antigen presentation to CD4 T-cells. Given this discrepancy in the literature and that the consequence of allograft exposure in B7-deficient mice is unknown; the goal of the study was to examine the antidonor status of allografted B7-1/B7-2-deficient hosts. METHODS: C57Bl/6 B7-1/B7-2-/- mice were grafted with heterotopic BALB/c hearts. Recipients bearing long-term surviving allografts were used to examine the status of antidonor reactivity in vitro and in vivo. Tolerance was examined in vivo through adoptive transfer of splenocytes from graft-bearing animals to secondary immune-deficient Rag-1-/- hosts bearing donor-type or third-party cardiac allografts and by regulatory T-cell depletion with anti-CD25 antibody. RESULTS: When transferred to B7-replete Rag-1-/- recipients, cells from naïve B7-1/B7-2-/- mice readily initiated cardiac allograft rejection. However, splenocytes transferred from long-term allograft acceptor B7-1/B7-2-/- hosts failed to reject donor-type hearts but acutely rejected third-party allografts. In addition, such cells did not reject (donorxthird-party) F1 allografts. Finally, in vivo depletion of regulatory T-cells did not prevent long-term acceptance. CONCLUSIONS: Results demonstrate that B7-deficient T-cells are capable of acute cardiac allograft rejection in a B7-replete environment. Importantly, results also show that B7-deficient hosts do not simply ignore cardiac allografts, but rather spontaneously develop transferable, donor-specific tolerance and linked suppression in vivo. Interestingly, this tolerant state does not require endogenous CD4+CD25+ regulatory T-cells.

Revised Arterial Anastomosis for Improving Murine Kidney Transplant Outcomes.

AIM: One of the most challenging research microsurgical techniques is the mouse kidney transplant however, very few laboratories have made use of this important model due to its difficulty. One of the main obstacles to utilizing this procedure is the high incidence of post-operative arterial thrombosis. We believe this is caused by the path in which blood is required to flow from the recipient abdominal aorta, via the donor recipient aorta and on into the renal artery creating a tortuous route and areas of turbulence, which are prone to thrombus formation and failure of the graft. METHODS: We describe revised methods of donor artery recovery, whereby the traditional transection of the donor aorta is replaced with a heel and toe cuff, which is created by dividing the donor abdominal aorta obliquely across the face of the renal arterial ostium, which then provides for an arterial end-to-side anastomosis of a scale similar to that used for the heterotopic heart model. This technique produces an anastomosis that facilitates free blood flow from the recipient abdominal aorta at less than 90° thereby reducing the likelihood of thrombus formation. RESULTS: Utilizing this new technique the incidence of arterial thrombosis has decreased from 35% to 0% (n = 20 and 24, respectively) with no change in ischemia times. CONCLUSION: We describe a revised method of performing the arterial anastomosis during mouse kidney transplantation, which facilitates improved fluid dynamics by straightening the flow path for blood to the graft resulting in significantly reduced thrombus formation, excellent graft function, histology, and post-transplant survival.

Murine Kidney Transplant Technique.

The first mouse kidney transplant technique was published in 1973(1) by the Russell laboratory. Although it took some years for other labs to become proficient in and utilize this technique, it is now widely used by many laboratories around the world. A significant refinement to the original technique using the donor aorta to form the arterial anastomosis instead of the renal artery was developed and reported in 1993 by Kalina and Mottram (2) with a further advancement coming from the same laboratory in 1999 (3). While one can become proficient in this model, a search of the literature reveals that many labs still experience a high proportion of graft loss due to arterial thrombosis. We describe here a technique that was devised in our laboratory that vastly reduces the arterial thrombus reported by others (4,5). This is achieved by forming a heel-and-toe cuff of the donor infra-renal aorta that facilitates a larger anastomosis and straighter blood flow into the kidney.

Murine heterotopic heart transplant technique.

It is now over forty years since this technique was first reported by Corry, Wynn and Russell. Although it took some years for other labs to become proficient in and utilize this technique, it is now widely used by many laboratories around the world. A significant refinement to the original technique was developed and reported in 2001 by Niimi. Described here are the techniques that have evolved over more than a decade in the hands of three surgeons (Plenter, Grazia, Pietra) in our center. These techniques are now being passed on to a younger generation of surgeons and researchers. Based largely on the Niimi experience, the procedures used have evolved in the fine details - details which we will endeavor to relate here in such a way that others may be able to use this very useful model. Like Niimi, we have found that a video aid to learning is a priceless resource for the beginner.

Four decades of vascularized heterotopic cardiac transplantation in the mouse.

Since the first clinical heart transplant in 1967, there has been a heightened need to understand immune and inflammatory responses to "foreign" tissues. Research efforts in those early days were based on species that would now be considered "large" and were typically out-bred individuals. While this closely mirrors the clinical scenario, where genetic mismatches of donors and recipients can only be minimized in the selection process, these were not ideal models for studying the complexities and nuances of the immune system. Even when the rat was considered the standard model those early endeavors were limited by a small number of rat strains. The mouse model has provided us with an overwhelming array of strains, knockouts, knockins and transgenics that allow us to investigate the many layers of the innate and adaptive immune systems leading to a much greater understanding of immune responses. Fully vascularized heterotopic cardiac transplantation in the mouse has now been with us for four decades; the original papers describing this technique being published by Corry in 1973. In the subsequent 40 years, this technique has been used by many laboratories, including our own, and has become a powerful tool for the investigation of transplant immunity and ischemia reperfusion injury. Given the modern availability of mouse strains and mouse-related reagents, our current understanding of transplant immunity undoubtedly would not exist without such a technique.

CD4 T cells mediate cardiac xenograft rejection via host MHC Class II.

BACKGROUND: Previous studies have shown that acute CD4 T-cell-mediated cardiac allograft rejection requires donor major histocompatibility complex (MHC) Class II expression and can be independent of "indirect" antigen presentation. However, other studies suggested that indirect antigen presentation to CD4 T cells may play a primary role in cellular xenograft immunity. Thus, the relative roles of direct/indirect CD4 T cell reactivity against cardiac xenografts are unclear. In this study we set out to determine the role for indirect CD4 T cell reactivity in cardiac xenograft rejection. METHODS: Rat hearts were transplanted heterotopically into wild-type and immunodeficient mice. Recipients were untreated, treated with depleting antibodies, or reconstituted with wild-type cells. RESULTS: Antibody depletion confirmed that rat heart xenograft rejection in C57Bl/6 mice was CD4 T-cell-dependent. Also, heart xenografts survived long term in B6 MHC Class II (C2D)-deficient mice. Graft acceptance in C2D mice was not secondary to CD4 T cell deficiency alone, because transferred B6 CD4 T cells failed to trigger rejection in C2D hosts. Furthermore, purified CD4 T cells were sufficient for acute rejection of rat heart xenografts in immune-deficient B6rag1(-/-) recipients. Importantly, CD4 T cells did not reject rat hearts in C2Drag1(-/-) hosts, in contrast to results using cardiac allografts. "Direct" xenoreactive CD4 T cells were not sufficient to mediate rejection despite vigorous reactivity to rat stimulator cells in vitro. CONCLUSIONS: Taken together, our results show that CD4 T cells are both necessary and sufficient for acute cardiac xenograft rejection and that host MHC Class II is critical in this process.

Acute cardiac allograft rejection by directly cytotoxic CD4 T cells: parallel requirements for Fas and perforin.

BACKGROUND: CD4 T cells can suffice as effector cells to mediate primary acute cardiac allograft rejection. Although CD4 T cells can readily kill appropriate target cells in vitro, the corresponding role of such cytolytic activity for mediating allograft rejection in vivo is unknown. Therefore, we determined whether the cytolytic effector molecules perforin (PFP) and/or FasL (CD95L) were necessary for CD4 T cell-mediated rejection in vivo. METHODS: Wild-type C3H(H-2) or Fas (CD95)-deficient C3Hlpr (H-2) hearts were transplanted into immune-deficient C57B6rag (H-2) mice. Then, recipients were reconstituted with naïve purified CD4 T cells from wild-type, PFP-deficient, or FasL (gld)-deficient T-cell donors. RESULTS: In vitro, alloreactive CD4 T cells were competent to lyse donor major histocompatibility complex class II+ target cells, largely by a Fas-dependent mechanism. In vivo, the individual disruption of donor Fas expression (lpr) or CD4 T-cell-derived PFP had no significant impact on acute rejection. However, FasL-deficient (gld) CD4 T cells demonstrated delayed allograft rejection. Importantly, the simultaneous removal of both donor Fas expression and CD4 T-cell PFP completely abrogated acute rejection, despite the persistence of CD4 T cells within the graft. CONCLUSIONS: Results demonstrate that the direct rejection of cardiac allografts by CD4 effector T cells requires the alternative contribution of graft Fas expression and T cell PFP expression. To our knowledge, this is the first demonstration that cytolytic activity by CD4 T cells can play an obligate role for primary acute allograft rejection in vivo.

A two-step model of acute CD4 T-cell mediated cardiac allograft rejection.

CD4 T cells are both necessary and sufficient to mediate acute cardiac allograft rejection in mice. This process requires "direct" engagement of donor MHC class II molecules. That is, acute rejection by CD4+ T cells requires target MHC class II expression by the donor and not by the host. However, it is unclear whether CD4+ T cell rejection requires MHC class II expression on donor hemopoietic cells, nonhemopoietic cells, or both. To address this issue, bone marrow transplantation in mice was used to generate chimeric heart donors in which MHC class II was expressed either on somatic or on hemopoietic cells. We report that direct recognition of hemopoietic and nonhemopoietic cells are individually rate limiting for CD4+ T cell-mediated rejection in vivo. Importantly, active immunization with MHC class II(+) APCs triggered acute rejection of hearts expressing MHC class II only on the somatic compartment. Thus, donor somatic cells, including endothelial cells, are not sufficient to initiate acute rejection; but they are necessary as targets of direct alloreactive CD4 T cells. Taken together, results support a two-stage model in which donor passenger leukocytes are required to activate the CD4 response while direct interaction with the somatic compartment is necessary for the efferent phase of acute graft rejection.