[Should dialysis be for all? Yes indeed!]. / Ma la dialisi deve essere per tutti? Certo che si'!

Clinically compromised patients who must undergo chronic dialysis are, in general, at risk because the procedure can be difficult to perform and give poor results in terms of survival and of rehabilitation. However, it is dialysis of the very elderly which is routinely characterized by misgivings about the indication for and limits of the technique. Patients older than 75 years of age currently represent more than 35% of the population that begin dialysis in most European registries. In our center at least 30 very old patients begin dialysis every year, which represents 45% of the total incident patients. About 30% of these patients, because of severe physical and/or mental disability, often associated with a situation of social deprivation, rarely achieve true clinical stability and depend upon outside caregivers in order to survive. The treatment of these patients strains the resources of the health and social structure, as well as the Nephrology Division, whose organization can be disrupted by their urgent needs, such as hospitalization, transportation, convalescent care, etc. Despite these difficulties and a mean survival of only 28 months, the global clinical conditions of patients older than 75 years of age are not much different than patients in the age bracket of 65 to 75 years. In fact, excluding patients older than 85 years of age (a category which geriatricians consider separately), the survival and rehabilitation of the very elderly appear similar to those of patients 65 to 75 years of age. Many of the clinical problems of the dialyzed elderly, such as sensory, mental and functional impairment, are the result of advanced age per se rather than of uremia or of dialysis. Therefore, ethical considerations of dialysis and of health maintenance in the very elderly are similar to those presented by patients who are afflicted by other serious diseases such as cancer, heart failure, or extensive stroke. As a result of modern technology and the advancement of our clinical knowledge, it is difficult to conceive of a true motive to not dialyze a patient--whether very elderly or any other patient in critical conditions--except in situations of futility or the impossibility to attain a reasonable quality of life. Thus, the true nature of the debate regarding the indications or the limits of dialysis in developed countries is not economic, technical nor clinical, but ethical. The challenge for the Nephrologist is to balance the need to alleviate human suffering and the institutional support that society can offer, which is the "bottom line" which unifies dialysis for the very elderly with every other therapy which prolongs life in tenuous conditions.

Prevalence of home artificial nutrition in Italy in 2005: a survey by the Italian Society for Parenteral and Enteral Nutrition (SINPE).

AIM: To determine the prevalence (cases per million inhabitants) of home artificial nutrition (HAN), enteral (HEN) and parenteral (HPN), in Italy, grouped according to administrative regions, patient age and primary disease, and to analyze the impact both of the presence of an HAN regional regulation and of demographic characteristics. METHODS: In April 2005, the Regional Coordinators of the Italian Society for Parenteral and Enteral Nutrition (SINPE) recorded all the ongoing cases of HAN using a structured questionnaire and were asked to estimate the representativeness of the collected sample with respect to the total expected HAN. RESULTS: A total of 6955 cases of HAN (93.5% adults, 6.5% pediatric patients < or = 18 years) were recorded in 16 of the 20 Italian regions (80% of the Italian population; sample representativeness 78%). HAN prevalence 152.6 (83.9% HEN, 16.1% HPN); the HAN range among the regions was: prevalence 28.1-519.8; oncological disease 13.8-75.7%, neurological disease 15.5-79.9%, intestinal failure 1.3-14.0%. An HAN regulation was present in 11 regions. A positive association (P=0.012) was found between the number of years since the regulation was issued and the HAN prevalence, and also between the % neurological patients and the population density (P=0.130) and the % inhabitants > or = 75 years (P=0.040). CONCLUSIONS: The need for HAN regards a great number of patients throughout the country; there are substantial differences between the regions with respect to both the prevalence and the use of HAN in various disease categories. A specific regulation may favor the development of HAN.

ESPEN Guidelines on Enteral Nutrition: Adult renal failure.

Enteral nutrition (EN) by means of oral nutritional supplements (ONS) and tube feeding (TF) offers the possibility of increasing or ensuring nutrient intake in cases where normal food intake is inadequate. These guidelines are intended to give evidence-based recommendations for the use of ONS and TF in nephrology patients. They were developed by an interdisciplinary expert group in accordance with officially accepted standards and are based on all relevant publications since 1985. They were discussed and accepted in a consensus conference. Because of the nutritional impact of renal diseases, EN is widely used in nephrology practice. Patients with acute renal failure (ARF) and critical illness are characterized by a highly catabolic state and need depurative techniques inducing massive nutrient loss. EN by TF is the preferred route for nutritional support in these patients. EN by means of ONS is the preferred way of refeeding for depleted conservatively treated chronic renal failure patients and dialysis patients. Undernutrition is an independent factor of survival in dialysis patients. ONS was shown to improve nutritional status in this setting. An increase in survival has been recently reported when nutritional status was improved by ONS.

Lipid-lowering effect of carnitine in chronically uremic patients treated with maintenance hemodialysis.

Hypertriglyceridemia is often present in chronically uremic patients treated with maintenance hemodialysis and has been considered a risk factor in the accelerated development of atheroma. Muscle carnitine content is low in hemodialyzed patients. This abnormality may help to explain the myopathy and cardiomyopathy often observed in these subjects. In addition, carnitine might play a role in the hypertriglyceridemia in renal failure. Carnitine, which is necessary for fatty acid oxidation, has been recently reported to lower serum triglycerides in patients with type IV hyperlipoproteinemia. Carnitine was administered intravenously three times weekly at the end of hemodialysis in eight patients. Carnitine was given in 0.5 g doses for 8 weeks and then in 1.0 g doses for 6 additional weeks. There was a significant decrease in serum triglycerides at the end of treatment. In contrast, serum lipids in eight hemodialysis patients receiving placebo did not change significantly. Carnitine administration does not cause any side effect except some euphoria. These results suggest that carnitine may be effective in the treatment of hypertriglyceridemia in dialysis patients.

Simple methods for nutritional assessment in hemodialyzed patients.

Uremic patients undergoing hemodialysis are often catabolic and malnourished. To treat malnutrition effectively, a preliminary nutritional assessment is needed. Available techniques should enable the clinician to readily detect the presence of malnutrition and to follow the response to nutritional therapy. In a group of chronic uremic patients undergoing maintenance hemodialysis, the authors evaluated the nutritional status with the following indices: 1) assessment of the somatic fat and protein compartments by means of anthropometric measurements (weight/height ratio, triceps and subscapular skinfold thickness, and arm muscle circumference); 2) assessment of the visceral protein compartment (serum total protein, albumin, transferrin, pseudocholinesterase, C3, and immunoglobulin content); 3) assessment of cell-mediated immunity by means of skin tests ("skin window," PPD and phytohemagglutinin) and blood lymphocyte content; and 4) assessment of the dietary intake of nutrients with dietary diaries. Anthropometric indices, serum protein content (except immunoglobulins), and the immune response was generally lower than in normal subjects, suggesting a mixed marasmus-like and kwashiorkor-like pattern of protein-calorie malnutrition. The protein intake was normal, whereas the energy intake tended to be low. Protein intake was significantly correlated with the predialysis serum urea nitrogen. Due to the difficulties in improving oral energy intake and the negative nitrogen balance reported during the days of dialysis therapy, patients were given intravenous supplements of essential or essential and nonessential amino acids for 2 months. The effects of this short-term supplementation were limited.

Slower activation of insulin action in hypertension associated with obesity.

OBJECTIVE: To determine whether kinetic abnormalities in the onset of insulin action contribute to the insulin resistance in obesity-associated hypertension. DESIGN: We monitored the rate of increase in glucose infusion during 6 h of hyperinsulinemic (40 mU/m2 per min) euglycemic clamps in hypertensive and normotensive obese subjects. The two groups of hypertensive (n=9) and normotensive (n=9) subjects were matched for age (48+/-2 versus 45+/-5 years), sex (five males and four females versus four males and five females) and body mass index (42+/-3 versus 40+/-2 kg/m2). RESULTS: In all subjects, the glucose infusion rate required to maintain euglycemia increased progressively during the clamp studies to achieve maximal, steady-state values within the fifth hour. During the first 2 h of the clamp, mean glucose infusion rate, the traditional approach to assessing insulin sensitivity, was lower in the hypertensive than in the normotensive obese patients (2.04+/-0.13 versus 3.29+/-0.41 mg/kg per min, respectively; P < 0.05). In contrast, the maximal steady-state glucose infusion rate, calculated as the mean value during the sixth hour of clamping, was similar in the hypertensive and in the normotensive obese patients (4.48+/-0.43 versus 4.81+/-0.45 mg/kg per min, respectively; NS). The time required to reach the half-maximal glucose infusion rate was greater in the hypertensive than normotensive obese patients (91+/-12 versus 38+/-5 min, respectively; P< 0.05). CONCLUSION: In obesity, hypertension was associated with a slower rate of activation of the insulin effect on glucose metabolism, whereas the maximal steady-state insulin effects were not altered by elevated blood pressure. Thus, the link between obesity and hypertension may be associated with the kinetics of onset of insulin action.

Slower activation of insulin action in upper body obesity.

To determine the influence of body fat distribution on kinetic aspects of insulin action, we have monitored the rate of increase of glucose infusion during 6-hour hyperinsulinemic (40 mU/m2/min) euglycemic clamps in 10 patients with upper body obesity (body mass index [BMI], 41 +/- 3 kg/m2; waist-to-hip ratio [WHR], > 1.00 for men and > 0.85 for women), 12 patients with lower body obesity (BMI, 40 +/- 2 kg/m2; WHR, < 1.00 for men and < 0.85 for women), and 5 control subjects (BMI, < 30 kg/m2; WHR, < 1.00 for men and < 0.85 for women). In all subjects, glucose infusion rate (GIR) to maintain euglycemia increased during the clamp studies to achieve maximal, steady state values after the fourth to fifth hour. During the first 2 hours of clamp, mean GIR (GIR20-120min) (traditional approach to assess insulin sensitivity) was lower (P < 0.05) in the upper body obesity group than in the lower body obesity group (2.12 +/- 0.14 and 3.03 +/- 0.33 mg/kg per min, respectively). In contrast, the maximal steady-state GIR (GIRMAX) (calculated as mean GIR during the sixth hour of clamp) was similar in the upper body and in the lower body obesity groups (4.48 +/- 0.45 and 4.57 +/- 0.36 mg/kg per min, respectively). Control subjects exhibited higher values of both GIR20-120min and GIRMAX (5.57 +/- 0.67 and 7.05 +/- 0.59 mg/kg per min, respectively) than those of both groups of obese patients. The time to reach half-maximal GIR (T1/2) was greater (P < .05) in the upper body obesity (94 +/- 12 min) than that in the lower body obesity (41 +/- 5 min) and in the control group (30 +/- 5 min). In pooled subjects, BMI correlated with GIRMAX (n = 27, R = -.75, P < .001), but not with T1/2 (R = .21). Similarly, whole body percent fat mass, as assessed by bioelectrical impedance analysis, correlated with GIRMAX (n = 16, R = -.79, P < .001), but not with T1/2 (R = .10). In contrast, WHR closely correlated with T1/2 (n = 27, R = .78, P < .001), but not with GIRMAX (R = .11). We conclude that upper body obesity is associated with a slower rate of activation of insulin action on glucose metabolism, whereas total body adiposity selectively affects the maximal, steady-state insulin effect.

Contribution of the ubiquitin-proteasome pathway to overall muscle proteolysis in hypercatabolic patients.

The influence of the gene expression of critical components of the cytoplasmic and lysosomal proteolytic pathways on the rate of protein degradation was evaluated in the leg skeletal muscle of 8 severely traumatized patients. Muscle proteolysis was determined as the intramuscular phenylalanine rate of appearance by L-[ring-2H5]phenylalanine infusion and the leg arteriovenous catheterization technique combined with muscle biopsy. Muscle mRNA levels of UbB polyubiquitin and cathepsin B were determined by reverse transcriptase-competitive polymerase chain reaction and expressed as a percent of the mRNA level of the housekeeping gene glyceraldehyde-3-phosphate dehydrogenase (GAPDH). In the patients, individual values for UbB polyubiquitin mRNA levels directly correlated with the rate of muscle proteolysis (r = .76, P < .05), whereas no correlation (r = .10) was found between cathepsin B mRNA levels and proteolysis. Thus, after trauma, the rate of muscle proteolysis appears to be largely regulated by the ubiquitin-proteasome system at the level of gene transcription.

Mechanisms of malnutrition in uremia.

The pathogenesis of protein wasting in chronic renal failure is multifactorial. Potential mediators of protein catabolism in chronic uremia include anorexia, low protein-energy intake, increased cortisol and parathyroid hormone secretion, insulin resistance, metabolic acidosis and unidentified uremic toxins. In non-acidotic uremic patients the rate of protein turnover (that is, synthesis and degradation) has often been found to be decreased. Malnutrition also decreases both protein synthesis and degradation. In contrast, during acidosis protein degradation is primarily accelerated and results in rapid loss of body proteins. Cytokine concentrations have often been found increased in both dialyzed and undialyzed chronically uremic patients. Our study determined the circulating levels of TNF-alpha and of type I (60 kDa) and type II (80 kDa) soluble TNF-alpha receptors in undialyzed uremic patients, and found that their plasma levels were greatly increased. Serum creatinine correlated with TNF-alpha soluble receptors but not with the TNF-alpha. Thus, TNF-alpha is potentially an important mediator of protein wasting in chronically uremic patients. Pharmacological therapy of protein catabolism in chronic uremia may include the administration of pentoxifylline, which has been shown to decrease protein degradation by interfering with the TNF-alpha system (that is, TNF-alpha and its soluble receptors) in experimental models. Growth hormone and insulin-like growth factor-1 administration may also be beneficial in these patients, but further evaluation of the hormone effects on glucose and glutamine metabolism is called for.

Muscle biopsy studies in chronically uremic patients: evidence for malnutrition.

Evidence for muscle protein wasting and abnormal muscle metabolism is common in uremia. Muscle DNA content is considered a reliable reference standard in normal and undernourished adults. Muscle RNA content rapidly changes during starvation and refeeding. The ratio of noncollagen alkali-soluble proteins (ASP) to DNA is considered to be an estimate of the cytoplasmic volume of a single cell, and the RNA: DNA ratio is an index of the ribosomal capacity for protein synthesis. Muscle DNA, RNA, ASP, water, and fat content were determined in muscle biopsy specimens from chronically uremic patients receiving conservative treatment (CT), maintenance hemodialysis (two centers), or CAPD. Nutrient intake was low and the anthropometric indices were decreased in all groups of patients, except in the hemodialysis patients from one center. Serum proteins and muscle ASP: DNA and RNA: DNA ratios were decreased. The nutritional status was reassessed in some malnourished CAPD patients after about one year of careful nutritional advice and was unchanged. These results suggest that chronically uremic patients on CT are often malnourished, primarily because of an inadequate protein and/or energy intake. Muscle nucleic acid and protein content are useful tools for nutritional assessment at a cellular level in humans with chronic renal failure and can be used to monitor the response to nutritional therapy.

Effect of intravenous supplementation of a new essential amino acid formulation in hemodialysis patients.

Protein energy undernutrition (PEU) and abnormalities of amino acid (AA) metabolism are common in maintenance hemodialysis patients (MHP). A new EAA formulation (BS695), enriched with valine and threonine, containing some histidine, and low in phenylalanine and methionine was recently developed. We randomly supplemented 11 MHP with this solution (treated group, TG) and 10 MHP with a standard AA solution containing both essential and non-essential AA (control group, CG). Both groups received 3.65 g of nitrogen, i.v. three times per week during hemodialysis for six months. During treatment, dietary intake remained stable in both groups. Before treatment, after three and six months of treatment, and six months after the end of treatment, we determined routine blood chemistries, anthropometry, serum protein levels (albumin, transferrin), delayed cutaneous sensitivity (Multi-test), protein catabolic rate (PCR), plasma AA content and motor nerve conduction velocity (MNCV). Before treatment PEU, predominantly of marasmic type, was common. After treatment anthropometry and immune response were unchanged in both groups; PCR increased more in CG than in TG; serum albumin levels decreased significantly only in CG; MNCV improved in TG and worsened in CG. These preliminary results suggest that this new EAA formulation may have beneficial effects on some nutrition related abnormalities of MHP. Better results might occur with long-term AA supplementation, particularly if it is associated with a higher energy intake.

Regulation of muscle cathepsin B proteolytic activity in protein-depleted patients with chronic diseases.

BACKGROUND & AIMS: The lysosomal cathepsin system contributes to degrading cellular skeletal muscle proteins in many catabolic diseases. We have assessed the relationships between cathepsin B mRNA levels and the enzyme activity for this protease in the skeletal muscle of acutely ill patients with severe trauma (n=7) and in patients with a variety of chronic disease states (hemodialysis, n=3; nervous anorexia, n=1; type 2 diabetes, n=2; prolonged immobilization, n=1). METHODS: Muscle biopsies were taken from the vastus lateralis muscle in patients and controls to assess tissue levels of cathepsin B mRNA by competitive-quantitative polymerase chain reaction, cathepsin B proteolytic activity and myofibrillar protein content as alkali-soluble protein to DNA ratio (ASP/DNA). In the trauma patients, muscle protein loss was assessed by the arteriovenous balance technique as rate of phenylalanine release from leg muscle. RESULTS: The acute trauma patients exhibited a significant net phenylalanine release from leg muscle (33+/-4 nmol phenylalanine/min/100 ml leg volume) despite a continuous nutritional support. The muscle ASP/DNA ratio was lower (P<0.05) in the patients with chronic diseases (383+/-33) than in groups of healthy controls (554+/-41) or of uncomplicated, moderately obese subjects (525+/-26). Cathepsin B mRNA levels were 6-10 times greater (P<0.05) in the patients with acute trauma or chronic catabolic diseases than in the healthy subjects. Cathepsin B enzymatic activity were 2-3 times greater (P<0.05) in the chronic and acute patients than in the group of uncomplicated, moderately obese subjects. Regression analysis between cathepsin B mRNA and cathepsin B enzymatic activity indicates a significant direct correlation (r=0.84; P<0.05) in the chronic catabolic conditions, but not in the acute trauma patients (r=-0.05). CONCLUSIONS: In skeletal muscle of patients with stable chronic catabolic diseases, cathepsin B activity is directly related to cathepsin B mRNA levels, suggesting that in these patients this enzyme could be mainly regulated at the level of gene transcription.

Effects of growth hormone administration on skeletal muscle glutamine metabolism in severely traumatized patients: preliminary report.

We have investigated the effects of 24 h human recombinant growth hormone (hGH) administration on leg muscle glutamine exchange and protein kinetics in severely traumatized patients. Muscle amino acid exchange and protein balance were evaluated using the leg arteriovenous balance technique, whereas changes in skeletal muscle free amino acid concentrations were evaluated in biopsy specimens. hGH infusion decreased phenylalanine release from protein degradation by 56 +/- 14%, and the rate of branched chain amino acid catabolism by 51 +/- 10%. Glutamine release from leg muscle was suppressed by 58 +/- 12%. This latter effect was completely accounted for by a hGH-mediated suppression of glutamine synthesis in skeletal muscle. In conclusion, growth hormone administration in trauma patients may restrain protein and amino acid catabolism in skeletal muscle. However, the growth hormone-mediated suppression of glutamine production we have observed in this study could decrease the systemic availability of this amino acid. During growth hormone treatment, this potential side-effect could be prevented by an exogenous glutamine administration.

Metabolic response to injury and sepsis: changes in protein metabolism.

The metabolic response to trauma and sepsis involves an increased loss of body proteins. Specific sites of changes of protein and amino acid metabolism have been identified. In skeletal muscle, the rate of proteolysis is accelerated greatly. The rate of protein synthesis also may be increased but not enough to match the increase in degradation. Intramuscular glutamine concentration is decreased because of increased efflux and possibly decreased de novo synthesis. In the liver, the rate of synthesis of selected proteins (i.e., albumin, transferrin, prealbumin, retinol-binding protein, and fibronectin) is decreased, whereas acute phase protein synthesis is accelerated. Tissues characterized by rapidly replicating cells, such as enterocytes, immune cells, granulation tissue, and keratinocytes, exhibit early alterations in the case of decreased protein synthesis capacity. In these tissues, glutamine use is accelerated. Increased stress hormone (cortisol and glucagon) and cytokine secretion, as well as intracellular glutamine depletion, are potential mediators of altered protein metabolism in trauma and sepsis. However, the relative importance of these factors has not been clarified. Therapy of acute protein catabolism may include the use of biosynthetic human growth hormone, possibly in combination with insulin-like growth factor-1, and the administration of metabolites at pharmacologic doses. We recently studied the effects of carnitine and alanyl-glutamine administration in severely traumatized patients. We found that both carnitine and the glutamine dipeptide restrained whole-body nitrogen loss without affecting selected indices of protein metabolism in the skeletal muscle.

[Antibiotic therapy and renal insufficiency. Pharmacokinetics of pivampicillin, cephaloridin and streptomycin in chronic uremic patients undergoing conservative or hemodialytic treatment]. / Terapia antibiotica ed insufficienza renale. Rilievi intorno alla farmacocinetica di alcuni antibiotici (pivampicillina, cefaloridina, streptomicina) in pazienti con uremia cronica in terapia conservativa od emodialitica

The plasma kinetics of some antibiotics (pivampicillin, cephaloridine, streptomycin) has been studied in patients with chronic renal failure. The oral administration of pivampicllin promptly increases the plasma levels of the antibiotic, without any toxic side effect: this antibiotic is to be chosen in chronic uremic patients, also during regular dialytic treatment (R.D.T.). Cephaloridine has some renal toxic effects in high concentration; in the renal failure it is advisable to calculate the exact dose of the antibiotic by the use of nomograms when the creatinine clearance is known. These nomograms must absolutely be employed when administrating some toxic antibiotics, as gentamycin and streptomycin in chronic uremic patients. Some formulas have been experimentally determined, which allow a calculation of the exact dose of the antibiotic, also during R.D.T. If a kidney or urinary tract infection is present in patients with low G.F.R. (creatinine-clearance less than 30 ml/min.), it is necessary to administer only those antibiotics which can reach an active urinary concentration (i.e. penicillin and derivatives, cephaloridine).

[Frail elderly in hemodialysis]. / L'anziano fragile in dialisi.

A new category of patients aged >75 yrs, namely the elderly, is now being freely admitted to hemodialysis (HD) and this category is becoming predominant. The absence of systematic studies makes this patient category almost indistinguishable from other categories, even though its peculiarity is now evident. At least 30-40% of individuals in this age bracket are expected to be dependent and/or frail, but the incidence of frailty is likely to be higher in the elderly undergoing HD. Due to severe physical and/or mental impairment and often because of strong social hardships, these patients rarely experience clinical stability and are dependent on third parties for their survival. Their care produces complex problems for welfare services and this has proved responsible for modifying the organization of renal care units. These repeated patient admissions to hospital are filling nephrology facilities, and the dialysis management -- mainly concerning outpatients -- requires a much greater use of facilities and staff than normal if compared to average dialysis patients. In 112 elderly patients consecutively admitted to the dialysis program over a period of 10 yrs, we identified 35 dependent or frail patients (31.2%), even taking into consideration only extreme degrees of infirmity. Dependence proved to be the only clinical parameter associated with survival (mortality at 6 months 23.6 vs. 10.6%, p<0.01; Kaplan-Meier survival curves, p<0.03 log-rank test), while comorbidities -- in particular cardiovascular -- that usually affect dialysis mortality rates, did not seem to be discriminating risk factors in the elderly. More precisely, with the confirmation of these data through wider case studies, the idea will be reinforced that, also in dialysis, the elderly must be constantly monitored for dependence and frailty, as is the case in any exclusively geriatric field. Prevention, as well as a therapeutic approach specifically modeled on these conditions, could help to improve the prognosis of this patient category, which is particularly difficult to deal with and is becoming predominant in dialysis units.

[Survey on the ability to prescribe antibiotic therapy among Italian residents in geriatrics and internal medicine]. / Indagine sulla capacità deglispecializzandi in geriatriae in medicina interna diprescrivere terapia antibioticain Italia.

Antibiotic therapy is a crucial and often life-saving strategy. This study assessed the ability to prescribe antibiotic therapy among a series of Italian postgraduate students in geriatrics and internal medicine. Participants were administered an anonymous questionnaire consisting of self-assessment of their ability to prescribe antibiotics and then manage a case of community-acquired pneumonia. The Wilcoxon test for comparisons between two independent samples was used for statistical analysis. Almost half the 70 students considered their knowledge of antibiotic therapy insufficient and were not satisfied with the notions received during their studies. Indeed, the change in antibiotic therapy required to control acute exacerbation of pneumonia was correctly identified by only 36% of students. Moreover, 38% of them gave the correct answer on factors influencing the duration of antibiotic therapy in the presence of definite improvement of pneumonia. No significant difference was found between the responses of residents in geriatrics and internal medicine. Overall, our study shows that nearly half of our students think they have inadequate antibiotic prescribing skills. This is confirmed by a low ability to establish the best management of the clinical case. To repair this severe shortcoming, different training methods need to be compared and more effective forms of instruction adopted.