Getting a handle on embryo limb development: Molecular interactions driving limb outgrowth and patterning.

Development of the vertebrate embryo involves multiple segmentation processes to generate a functional, articulated organism. Cell proliferation, differentiation and patterning involve spatially and temporally regulated gene expression and signal transduction mechanisms. The developing vertebrate limb is an excellent model to study such fine-tuned regulations, whereby cells proliferate and are differentially sculptured along the proximal-distal, anterior-posterior and dorsal-ventral axes to form a functional limb. Complementary experimental approaches in different organisms have enhanced our knowledge on the molecular events underlying limb development. Herein, we summarize the current knowledge of the main signaling mechanisms governing vertebrate limb initiation, outgrowth, specification of limb segments and termination.

Mechanisms of vertebrate embryo segmentation: Common themes in trunk and limb development.

Various ultradian rhythms ensure proper temporal regulations during embryo development. The embryo molecular clock, which was first identified in the presomitic mesoderm (PSM) underlying periodic somite formation, is one among them. Somites are the earliest manifestation of the segmented vertebrate body and they are formed with strict temporal precision. The tetrapod limb is also a segmented structure and the formation of limb bone elements have also been associated with a molecular clock, operating in the distal limb mesenchyme. In both the PSM and the distal limb mesenchyme, the molecular clock (MC) is influenced by FGF, SHH and RA, which are also the key regulators of the development of these tissues. While somitogenesis has been continuously scrutinized to understand the mechanisms of the MC, the limb bud has served as an outstanding paradigm to study how a cohort of undifferentiated cells is organized into functional 3D structures. The fact that both the trunk and limb development are shaped by the MC and by common signaling molecules has prompted the exciting possibility of establishing parallelisms between somitogenesis and limb development. Systematically correlating various parameters during trunk and limb development will help us to appreciate the common principles underlying segmented structure formation and allow the rise of new questions in order to fill the gaps in our present understanding. In this review we have established the parallelisms between somitogenesis and limb development at the level of gene expression patterns and their regulation. Finally, we have also discussed the most evident new avenues this exercise could open to the scientific community.

Sonic hedgehog in temporal control of somite formation.

Vertebrate embryo somite formation is temporally controlled by the cyclic expression of somitogenesis clock genes in the presomitic mesoderm (PSM). The somitogenesis clock is believed to be an intrinsic property of this tissue, operating independently of embryonic midline structures and the signaling molecules produced therein, namely Sonic hedgehog (Shh). This work revisits the notochord signaling contribution to temporal control of PSM segmentation by assessing the rate and number of somites formed and somitogenesis molecular clock gene expression oscillations upon notochord ablation. The absence of the notochord causes a delay in somite formation, accompanied by an increase in the period of molecular clock oscillations. Shh is the notochord-derived signal responsible for this effect, as these alterations are recapitulated by Shh signaling inhibitors and rescued by an external Shh supply. We have characterized chick smoothened expression pattern and have found that the PSM expresses both patched1 and smoothened Shh signal transducers. Upon notochord ablation, patched1, gli1, and fgf8 are down-regulated, whereas gli2 and gli3 are overexpressed. Strikingly, notochord-deprived PSM segmentation rate recovers over time, concomitant with raldh2 overexpression. Accordingly, exogenous RA supplement rescues notochord ablation effects on somite formation. A model is presented in which Shh and RA pathways converge to inhibit PSM Gli activity, ensuring timely somite formation. Altogether, our data provide evidence that a balance between different pathways ensures the robustness of timely somite formation and that notochord-derived Shh is a component of the molecular network regulating the pace of the somitogenesis clock.

Circadian clock genes Bmal1 and Clock during early chick development.

BACKGROUND: The circadian clock is a well-described temporal organizer in adult organisms. Despite the particularly evident need for temporal control during embryo development, the effect of environmental cues is still greatly neglected. Few studies have reported circadian clock gene expression in early embryonic stages. However, nothing is known about circadian clock gene expression and function in the first stages of avian embryogenesis. RESULTS/CONCLUSIONS: In this work, the presence and spatial distribution of core circadian clock Bmal1 and Clock transcripts were thoroughly characterized during the first 50 hr of chick development using reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR), single and double whole-mount in situ hybridization and subsequent cross-section histology analysis. RT-PCR detected both Bmal1 and Clock transcripts since the egg is laid and until the embryo reaches the 22-somite stage. Whole-mount in situ hybridization showed that Bmal1 and Clock are expressed in the Hensen's node and primitive streak at early gastrula stage. Later, both mRNAs are present in the developing nervous system, optic vesicle, notochord, foregut, and somites. Clock was further identified in the developing heart. Noticeably, Bmal1 and Clock are expressed with a "salt and pepper" pattern, suggesting the existence of nonentrained oscillatory transcription which could play a nondependent dark/light function during chick embryo development.

Retinoic acid signaling regulates embryonic clock hairy2 gene expression in the developing chick limb.

Embryo development proceeds under strict temporal control and an embryonic molecular clock (EC), evidenced by cyclic gene expression, is operating during somite formation and limb development, providing temporal information to precursor cells. In somite precursor cells, EC gene expression and periodicity depends on Retinoic acid (RA) signaling and this morphogen is also essential for limb initiation, outgrowth and patterning. Since the limb EC gene hairy2 is differentially expressed along the proximal-distal axis as growth proceeds, concomitant with changes in flank-derived RA activity in the mesenchyme, we have interrogated the role of RA signaling on limb hairy2 expression regulation. We describe RA as a positive regulator of limb hairy2 expression. Ectopic supplementation of RA induced hairy2 in a short time period, with simultaneous transient activation of Erk/MAPK, Akt/PI3K and Gli3 intracellular pathways. We further found that FGF8, an inducer of Erk/MAPK, Akt/PI3K pathways, was not sufficient for ectopic hairy2 induction. However, joint treatment with both RA and FGF8 induced hairy2, indicating that RA is creating a permissive condition for p-Erk/p-Akt action on hairy2, most likely by enhancing Gli3-A/Gli3-R levels. Finally, we observed an inhibitory action of BMP4 on hairy2 and propose a model whereby RA shapes limb hairy2 expression during limb development, by activating its expression and counteracting the inhibitory action of BMP4 on hairy2. Overall, our work reports a novel role for RA in the regulation of limb clock hairy2 gene expression and elucidates the temporal response of multiple intracellular pathways to RA signaling in limb development.

Tissue regulation of somitic colloid-like1 gene expression.

Body skeletal muscles formation starts with somite differentiation, due to signals from surrounding tissues. Somite ventral portion forms the sclerotome while its dorsal fraction constitutes the dermamyotome, and later the dermatome and myotome. Relative levels of BMP activity have been proposed to control several aspects of somite development, namely the time and location of myogenesis within the somite. The fine-tuning of BMP activity is primarily achieved via negative regulation by diffusible BMP inhibitors, such as Noggin and Chordin, and on a secondary level by proteins cleaving these inhibitors, such as BMP1/Tolloid metalloprotease family members. Herein, we carefully described the somitic expression of colloid-like1, one of the chick BMP1/Tolloid homologues, and found that this gene is specifically expressed in the 10 most anterior somites, suggesting that it may be involved in neck muscle formation. By using in ovo microsurgery and tridimensional embryo tissue culture techniques we assessed the function of surrounding structures, neural tube, notochord, surface ectoderm and lateral plate mesoderm, on the maintenance of somitic colloid-like1 gene expression. We unveil that a signal coming from the neural tube is responsible for this expression and rule out the main candidate pathway, Wnt. By comparing the somitic colloid-like1 gene expression with that of related signaling partners, such as BMP4, Noggin and Chordin, we propose that colloid-like1 plays a role in the reinforcement of BMP4 activity in the medial portion of the 10 most anterior dermomyotomes, thus belonging to the molecular machinery controlling neck muscle development in the chick.

terra is a left-right asymmetry gene required for left-right synchronization of the segmentation clock.

To establish the vertebrate body plan, it is fundamental to create left-right asymmetry in the lateral-plate mesoderm to correctly position the organs. However, it is also crucial to maintain symmetry between the left and the right sides of the presomitic mesoderm, ensuring the allocation of symmetrical body structures, such as the axial skeleton and skeletal muscles. Here, we show that terra is an early left-sided expressed gene that links left-right patterning with bilateral synchronization of the segmentation clock.

A molecular clock operates during chick autopod proximal-distal outgrowth.

Temporal control can be considered the fourth dimension in embryonic development. The identification of the somitogenesis molecular clock provided new insight into how embryonic cells measure time. We provide the first evidence of a molecular clock operating during chick fore-limb autopod outgrowth and patterning, by showing that the expression of the somitogenesis clock component hairy2 cycles in autopod chondrogenic precursor cells with a 6 h periodicity. We determined the length of time required to form an autopod skeletal limb element, and established a correlation between the latter and the periodicity of cyclic hairy2 gene expression. We suggest that temporal control exerted by cyclic gene expression can be a widespread mechanism providing cellular temporal information during vertebrate embryonic development.

Development on time.

Temporal control is considered the fourth dimension in embryonic development and it sets the pace to attain the correct molecular patterning of the developing embryo. In this chapter we review one of the best-studied time dependent events in embryogenesis, which is the formation ofsomites. Somites are the basis of the future segmented framework of the vertebrate adult body and their reiterated appearance during the early stages of embryo development establishes the proper temporal and physical template from where other structures will develop and consequently shape the segmentation pattern of the embryo. Several models have been proposed over the last few decades to explain the mechanism(s) regulating somite periodicity, but no molecular evidence seemed to back up any of the postulated models. Remarkably, in 1997 the first evidence that the formation of the somites depended on an intrinsic molecular clock was at last provided through the description of oscillating gene expression in the tissue from which somites are generated. Since then, a huge amount of data has been and continues to be provided that is gradually revealing the ever more complex molecular mechanism underlying this segmentation clock. We are also beginning to learn about embryonic structures other than the somites which exhibit oscillations of gene expression suggesting they too are dependent upon a segmentation-like clock. This is in itself the clearest evidence that there is still a long way to go before we unveil the myriad of molecular mechanisms that lead to the time control of embryonic development.

Recent advances in understanding vertebrate segmentation.

Segmentation is the partitioning of the body axis into a series of repeating units or segments. This widespread body plan is found in annelids, arthropods, and chordates, showing it to be a successful developmental strategy for growing and generating diverse morphology and anatomy. Segmentation has been extensively studied over the years. Forty years ago, Cooke and Zeeman published the Clock and Wavefront model, creating a theoretical framework of how developing cells could acquire and keep temporal and spatial information in order to generate a segmented pattern. Twenty years later, in 1997, Palmeirim and co-workers found the first clock gene whose oscillatory expression pattern fitted within Cooke and Zeeman's model. Currently, in 2017, new experimental techniques, such as new ex vivo experimental models, real-time imaging of gene expression, live single cell tracking, and simplified transgenics approaches, are revealing some of the fine details of the molecular processes underlying the inner workings of the segmentation mechanisms, bringing new insights into this fundamental process. Here we review and discuss new emerging views that further our understanding of the vertebrate segmentation clock, with a particular emphasis on recent publications that challenge and/or complement the currently accepted Clock and Wavefront model.

Chick Hairy1 protein interacts with Sap18, a component of the Sin3/HDAC transcriptional repressor complex.

BACKGROUND: The vertebrate adult axial skeleton, trunk and limb skeletal muscles and dermis of the back all arise from early embryonic structures called somites. Somites are symmetrically positioned flanking the embryo axial structures (neural tube and notochord) and are periodically formed in a anterior-posterior direction from the presomitic mesoderm. The time required to form a somite pair is constant and species-specific. This extraordinary periodicity is proposed to depend on an underlying somitogenesis molecular clock, firstly evidenced by the cyclic expression of the chick hairy1 gene in the unsegmented presomitic mesoderm with a 90 min periodicity, corresponding to the time required to form a somite pair in the chick embryo. The number of hairy1 oscillations at any given moment is proposed to provide the cell with both temporal and positional information along the embryo's anterior-posterior axis. Nevertheless, how this is accomplished and what biological processes are involved is still unknown. Aiming at understanding the molecular events triggered by the somitogenesis clock Hairy1 protein, we have employed the yeast two-hybrid system to identify Hairy1 interaction partners. RESULTS: Sap18, an adaptor molecule of the Sin3/HDAC transcriptional repressor complex, was found to interact with the C-terminal portion of the Hairy1 protein in a yeast two-hybrid assay and the Hairy1/Sap18 interaction was independently confirmed by co-immunoprecipitation experiments. We have characterized the expression patterns of both sap18 and sin3a genes during chick embryo development, using in situ hybridization experiments. We found that both sap18 and sin3a expression patterns co-localize in vivo with hairy1 expression domains in chick rostral presomitic mesoderm and caudal region of somites. CONCLUSION: Hairy1 belongs to the hairy-enhancer-of-split family of transcriptional repressor proteins. Our results indicate that during chick somitogenesis Hairy1 may mediate gene transcriptional repression by recruiting the Sin3/HDAC complex, through a direct interaction with the Sap18 adaptor molecule. Moreover, since sap18 and sin3a are not expressed in the PSM territory where hairy1 presents cyclic expression, our study strongly points to different roles for Hairy1 throughout the PSM and in the prospective somite and caudal region of already formed somites.

Head-tail patterning of the vertebrate embryo: one, two or many unresolved problems?

When, where and how is the head-tail axis of the embryo set up during development? These are such fundamental and intensely studied questions that one might expect them to have been answered long ago. Not so; we still understand very little about the cellular or molecular mechanisms that lead to the orderly arrangement of body elements along the head-tail axis in vertebrates. In this paper, we outline some of the major outstanding problems and controversies and try to identify some reasons why it has been so difficult to resolve this important issue.

rdml: A Mathematica package for parsing and importing Real-Time qPCR data.

OBJECTIVE: The purpose and objective of the research presented is to provide a package for easy importing of Real-Time PCR data markup language (RDML) data to Mathematica. RESULTS: Real-Time qPCR is the most widely used experimental method for the accurate quantification of gene expression. To enable the straightforward archiving and sharing of qPCR data and its associated experimental information, an XML-based data standard was developed-the Real-Time PCR data markup language (RDML)-devised by the RDML consortium. Here, we present rdml, a package to parse and import RDML data into Mathematica, allowing the quick loading and extraction of relevant data, thus promoting the re-analysis, meta-analysis or experimental re-validation of gene expression data deposited in RDML format.

Molecular characterization of the rostral-most somites in early somitic stages of the chick embryo.

Segmentation consists on the progressive formation of repetitive embryonic structures, named somites, which are formed from the most rostral part of the presomitic mesoderm. Somites are subdivided into anterior and posterior compartments and several genes are differentially expressed in either compartment. This has provided evidence for the importance of establishing the anterior-posterior polarity within each somite, which is critical for the correct segmented pattern of the adult vertebrate body. Although all somites appear morphologically similar, fate map studies have shown that the first 4 somites do not give rise to segmented structures, in contrast to more posterior ones. Moreover, in several somitogenesis-related mutants the anterior somites are not affected while posterior somites present clear defects or do not form at all. Altogether these data suggest relevant differences between rostral and caudal somites. In order to check for molecular differences between anterior and posterior somites, we have performed a detailed expression pattern analysis of several Notch signalling related genes. For the first time, we show that the somitic expression pattern profile is not the same along the anterior-posterior axis and that the differences are not observed always at the same somite level.

Running after the clock.

The way we currently understand vertebrate development is undoubtedly associated with the research undertaken at the "Institut d'Embryologie Cellulaire et Moleculaire" at Nogent-sur-Marne during the last decades. Working in this Institute has been a privilege for many junior and senior researchers. Eight years ago, in this stimulating environment, an exciting observation followed by a series of revealing experiments gave rise to a novel field of research. This study provided evidence for the existence of a molecular clock underlying chick somite formation. In this review, we focus on the cascade of studies that have followed this discovery. Thus far, it has been demonstrated that the molecular clock is operating in several vertebrate models namely chick, mouse, zebrafish, frog and medaka, probably functioning to provide cells with multidimensional positional information. Loss and gain of function experiments and detailed gene promoter analyses have proved very useful in understanding how the clock machinery works. Recent data has also led to the fascinating hypothesis that the clock might not be an exclusive property of somitic cells, but rather a mechanism used by a wide range of embryonic tissues. Meanwhile, the clock "keeps ticking" and many questions are still waiting for an answer.

Patterning in time and space: HoxB cluster gene expression in the developing chick embryo.

The developing embryo is a paradigmatic model to study molecular mechanisms of time control in Biology. Hox genes are key players in the specification of tissue identity during embryo development and their expression is under strict temporal regulation. However, the molecular mechanisms underlying timely Hox activation in the early embryo remain unknown. This is hindered by the lack of a rigorous temporal framework of sequential Hox expression within a single cluster. Herein, a thorough characterization of HoxB cluster gene expression was performed over time and space in the early chick embryo. Clear temporal collinearity of HoxB cluster gene expression activation was observed. Spatial collinearity of HoxB expression was evidenced in different stages of development and in multiple tissues. Using embryo explant cultures we showed that HoxB2 is cyclically expressed in the rostral presomitic mesoderm with the same periodicity as somite formation, suggesting a link between timely tissue specification and somite formation. We foresee that the molecular framework herein provided will facilitate experimental approaches aimed at identifying the regulatory mechanisms underlying Hox expression in Time and Space.

Limb patterning: from signaling gradients to molecular oscillations.

The developing forelimb is patterned along the proximal-distal and anterior-posterior axes by opposing gradients of retinoic acid and fibroblast growth factors and by graded sonic hedgehog signaling, respectively. However, how coordinated patterning along both axes is accomplished with temporal precision remains unknown. The limb molecular oscillator hairy2 was recently shown to be a direct readout of the combined signaling activities of retinoic acid, fibroblast growth factor and sonic hedgehog in the limb mesenchyme. Herein, an integrated time-space model is presented to conciliate the progress zone and two-signal models for limb patterning. We propose that the limb clock may allow temporal information to be decoded into positional information when the distance between opposing signaling gradients is no longer sufficient to provide distinct cell fate specification.

Timing embryo segmentation: dynamics and regulatory mechanisms of the vertebrate segmentation clock.

All vertebrate species present a segmented body, easily observed in the vertebrate column and its associated components, which provides a high degree of motility to the adult body and efficient protection of the internal organs. The sequential formation of the segmented precursors of the vertebral column during embryonic development, the somites, is governed by an oscillating genetic network, the somitogenesis molecular clock. Herein, we provide an overview of the molecular clock operating during somite formation and its underlying molecular regulatory mechanisms. Human congenital vertebral malformations have been associated with perturbations in these oscillatory mechanisms. Thus, a better comprehension of the molecular mechanisms regulating somite formation is required in order to fully understand the origin of human skeletal malformations.

Monocarboxylate transporters (MCTs) in gliomas: expression and exploitation as therapeutic targets.

BACKGROUND: Gliomas exhibit high glycolytic rates, and monocarboxylate transporters (MCTs) play a major role in the maintenance of the glycolytic metabolism through the proton-linked transmembrane transport of lactate. However, their role in gliomas is poorly studied. Thus, we aimed to characterize the expression of MCT1, MCT4, and their chaperone CD147 and to assess the therapeutic impact of MCT inhibition in gliomas. METHODS: MCTs and CD147 expressions were characterized by immunohistochemistry in nonneoplastic brain and glioma samples. The effect of CHC (MCT inhibitor) and MCT1 silencing was assessed in in vitro and in vivo glioblastoma models. RESULTS: MCT1, MCT4, and CD147 were overexpressed in the plasma membrane of glioblastomas, compared with diffuse astrocytomas and nonneoplastic brain. CHC decreased glycolytic metabolism, migration, and invasion and induced cell death in U251 cells (more glycolytic) but only affected proliferation in SW1088 (more oxidative). The effectiveness of CHC in glioma cells appears to be dependent on MCT membrane expression. MCT1 downregulation showed similar effects on different glioma cells, supporting CHC as an MCT1 inhibitor. There was a synergistic effect when combining CHC with temozolomide treatment in U251 cells. In the CAM in vivo model, CHC decreased the size of tumors and the number of blood vessels formed. CONCLUSIONS: This is the most comprehensive study reporting the expression of MCTs and CD147 in gliomas. The MCT1 inhibitor CHC exhibited anti-tumoral and anti-angiogenic activity in gliomas and, of importance, enhanced the effect of temozolomide. Thus, our results suggest that development of therapeutic approaches targeting MCT1 may be a promising strategy in glioblastoma treatment.