Are medical students influenced by preceptors in making career choices, and if so how? A systematic review.

INTRODUCTION: Increasingly medical students undertake clinical training in distributed learning environments. The driving factor for this is predominantly to address medical workforce shortages. In these environments students are often taught by private practitioners, residents, house staff and registrars, as well as faculty. Through a mix of short- and long-term preceptorships, clerkships and rotations, medical students are exposed to a wider range of preceptors, mentors and role models than has traditionally been the case. The aim of this systematic review was to understand if and how medical students' career choices are influenced by their interactions with preceptors. METHOD: A search of Ovid Medline, Scopus, ISI Web of Science, PubMed, Eric and CIHNAL was undertaken. The search was structured around the key terms: Medical Student, Career Choice and Preceptor, and variants of these terms. Search limits were set to English-language publications between 1995 and 2010. RESULTS: A total of 36 articles met the selection criteria from the 533 citations sourced from the search. Required preceptorships as short as 3 weeks' duration influence the career choice of students when they rate the preceptor as a high quality teacher. Preceptors who are judged (by students) as high quality teachers have the greatest influence on student career choice by up to four-fold. When students judged a preceptor as being a negative role model, a poor teacher or lacking discipline specific knowledge they will turn away from that field. The positive influence of relationships between preceptors and students on career choice is strongest where there is continuity of preceptors, continuity of care, and continuity of patient interactions. The longer the duration of the preceptorship the greater the influence on student career choice, particularly in primary cares environments. CONCLUSION: This review adds to the literature by identifying how differing components and combinations of components of a preceptorship influence medical student career choices. Multiple components of the preceptorship combined have a greater influence. In free choice, longitudinal integrated clerkships' duration of placement and continuity relationships with preceptors have the greatest influence on medical students in pursuing a primary care career. This information informs medical schools, curriculum designers and policy-makers in reforming medical education to address workforce shortages.

Developing the accredited postgraduate assessment program for Fellowship of the Australian College of Rural and Remote Medicine.

INTRODUCTION: Accreditation of the Australian College of Rural and Remote Medicine (ACRRM) as a standards and training provider, by the Australian Medical Council (AMC) in 2007, is the first time in the world that a peak professional organisation for rural and remote medical education has been formally recognised. As a consequence, the Australian Government provided rural and remote medicine with formal recognition under Medicare as a generalist discipline. This accreditation was based on the ability of ACRRM to meet the AMC's guidelines for its training and assessment program. METHODS: The methodology was a six-step process that included: developing an assessment blueprint and a classification scheme; identifying an assessment model; choosing innovative summative and formative assessment methods that met the needs of rural and remote located medical practitioner candidates; 21 rural doctors and academics developing the assessment items as part of a week-long writing workshop; investigating the feasibility of purchasing assessment items; and 48 rural candidates piloting three of the assessment items to ensure they would meet the guidelines for national accreditation. RESULTS: The project resulted in an innovative formative and summative assessment program that occurs throughout 4 years of vocational training, using innovative, reliable, valid and acceptable methods with educational impact. The piloting process occurred for 3 of the 6 assessment tools. Structured Assessment Using Multiple Patient Scenarios (StAMPS) is a new assessment method developed as part of this project. The StAMPS pilot found that it was reliable, with a generalisability coefficient of >0.76 and was a valid, acceptable and feasible assessment tool with desired educational impact. The multiple choice question (MCQ) examination pilot found that the applied clinical nature of the questions and their wide range of scenarios proved a very acceptable examination to the profession. The web based in-training assessment examination pilot revealed that it would serve well as a formative process until ACRRM can further develop their MCQ database. CONCLUSIONS: The ACRRM assessment program breaks new ground for assessing rural and remote doctors in Australia, and provides new evidence regarding how a comprehensive and contemporary assessment system can work within a postgraduate medical setting.

The impact of medical students on rural general practitioner perceptors.

INTRODUCTION: As universities rely more heavily on rural GPs to precept medical students, the formation of symbiotic partnerships benefiting students, universities and GPs, becomes imperative. In order to develop and consolidate these partnerships Universities must understand who their rural GP preceptors are and how precepting impacts on them. METHODS: A review of the literature was undertaken to determine the significant themes of student impacts from articles where conclusions were clearly based on empirical findings. RESULTS: Forty-three articles were included in the final review, but only nine specifically looked at impacts on rural GPs. Impacts were categorised into six domains: personal; time; patient care; professional relationships and professional development; business and infrastructure; and recognition and remuneration. CONCLUSIONS: Literature specifically addressing the impact of precepting on rural GPs is scarce. Further studies are required to evaluate the relationship between the quality of teaching delivered to students, the type and length of student attachments and the likely impacts on rural GPs.

Can medical students learn specialist disciplines based in rural practice: lessons from students' self reported experience and competence.

INTRODUCTION: Medical schools in Australia are being funded by the Commonwealth Government Department of Health and Aging to move a considerable amount of undergraduate clinical education into rural and remote settings. There are concerns that these students may be disadvantaged in terms of exposure to appropriate clinical learning opportunities. This study compared learning opportunities for students undertaking an entire clinical year based in a rural primary care setting, a remote secondary hospital, or a traditional urban tertiary teaching hospital. METHODS: Twenty-nine students, six from rural primary care, eight from the remote secondary hospital, and 15 from the urban tertiary teaching hospital, completed a retrospective survey of their experience and perceived competence to manage 78 common procedural skills and 62 common conditions. RESULTS: Students in rural primary care reported a pattern of increased clinical exposure to common clinical conditions and procedures in comparison with their hospital-based peers. In comparing the two hospital-based programs, the students in the remote secondary care hospital reported increased exposure to common conditions and no significant difference in the opportunity to undertake common procedures. The data also demonstrated that there was a positive correlation between reported experience and self-perceived competence, and that this was greater for procedural skills than competence in managing common conditions. CONCLUSIONS: This study provides further evidence that rural primary care is an excellent setting for high quality clinical and educational experiences. These findings should serve to encourage students and staff involved with the new Rural Clinical School programs.

Collaboration in curriculum design: preparing educational programs for Australian rural medical practitioners.

Details of the process used by the authors, as curriculum design consultants, for the Rural Medicine Curriculum Design Project are presented. The process resulted in separate curricula in surgery, anaesthesia and obstetrics for use in advanced training within the Rural Training Program of the Faculty of Rural Medicine of the Royal Australian College of General Practitioners (RACGP). Key features of the design process are synthesised as a guide to projects where agreement across divergent groups is essential.

A "common" surgery curriculum: health care delivery and undergraduate surgical education in Australian teaching hospitals.

Undergraduate surgical education should focus on common surgical conditions and management principles. It has become increasingly difficult in Australia because of the changed patient mix in teaching hospitals. There has been an increased number of emergency admissions with a consequent reduction in elective surgery and pressure on inpatient and outpatient referrals. In addition, cost cutting has led to the intensification of staff workloads, thereby reducing potential time for teaching. Australian teaching hospitals are also tertiary referral centers. As such they have become more specialized with a more rapid turnover of acutely ill patients undergoing complex technologic treatments. More diagnosis and management of surgical conditions is conducted in ambulatory settings and through office and day surgery. The Heaslip Project at Flinders University was set up to evaluate and reform the undergraduate surgery curriculum. Graduate and student surveys revealed a need to concentrate on teaching about common surgical conditions, developing proficiency in skills and procedures and providing experience in the common principles of surgical care. These areas have now become the major components of changed surgery clerkships. Students also spend more time interacting with patients, participating in the planning and management of preoperative and postoperative care, and working in outpatient clinics. Although the reforms have addressed the identified concerns, they may not be sufficient if the patient mix in teaching hospitals continues to narrow. Teaching hospitals will continue to provide valuable educational experiences, but they should be supplemented and complemented with the experience of managing surgical patients in the wider community.

Changing face of medical curricula.

The changing role of medicine in society and the growing expectations patients have of their doctors means that the content and delivery of medical curricula also have to change. The focus of health care has shifted from episodic care of individuals in hospitals to promotion of health in the community, and from paternalism and anecdotal care to negotiated management based on evidence of effectiveness and safety. Medical training is becoming more student centred, with an emphasis on active learning rather than on the passive acquisition of knowledge, and on the assessment of clinical competence rather than on the ability to retain and recall unrelated facts. Rigid educational programmes are giving way to more adaptable and flexible ones, in which student feedback and patient participation have increasingly important roles. The implementation of sustained innovation in medical education continues to present challenges, especially in terms of providing institutional and individual incentives. However, a continuously evolving, high quality medical education system is needed to assure the continued delivery of high quality medicine.

Problem-based learning: its rationale and efficacy.

Problem-based learning (PBL) in medical education uses clinical cases as the context for students to study basic and clinical sciences. Its possible advantages over traditional approaches include its greater relevance to the practice of medicine, its ability to promote retention and application of knowledge, and its encouragement of self-directed life-long learning. Possible disadvantages include higher costs, both in resources and staff time. Although its efficacy is difficult to evaluate, the current enthusiasm for PBL seems justified and its use is likely to increase further.

The Consortium of Graduate Medical Schools in Australia: formal and informal collaboration in medical education.

CONTEXT: In 1996-97 three Australian medical schools adopted 4-year graduate medical courses. The schools formed a consortium to establish common admissions processes and to collaborate on curriculum and staff development. OUTCOMES: ADMISSIONS: Outcomes in admissions included the construction of an entry test and agreement on common application procedures. Structured interviews and measures of prior tertiary performance were adopted in each school with some local variations. Formal structures were put into place to manage the development of the test and admissions procedures. OUTCOMES: CURRICULUM AND STAFF DEVELOPMENT: No formal structures were put into place for curriculum and staff development. While the advantages of common approaches were recognised, it was accepted that it was also important to generate local ownership and commitment to the new courses. Outcomes of educational consortia should not be judged solely by the nature of joint ventures but by the way in which membership of the consortium changes the priorities and practices within the institutions. Examples of the operation of this principle within the three schools include: use of visiting experts to refine and modify approaches to problem-based learning; use of staff from partner institutions to facilitate implementation of the courses; sharing information technology expertise; cooperation in the construction of feedback mechanisms, and sharing advice on fulfilling accreditation requirements. CONCLUSION: The Consortium has had an important impact on Australian medical education. There is a need for further analysis of the two methods of operation of the consortium, formal and informal, and their relation to its overall functioning.

The comprehensibility of Australian educational literature for patients with asthma.

BACKGROUND: Education of patients with asthma is aimed at improving their knowledge, skills and attitudes, and thus compliance and control. Patient information pamphlets play a role in education, medication information and informed consent processes, and must be understood. We assessed the comprehensibility of Australian pamphlets on asthma. METHOD: 50 Australian pamphlets on asthma (written in English for adults) were selected from the Asthma Foundation, a teaching hospital in South Australia, the pharmaceutical industry, the National Asthma Campaign and specialist books and journal articles. The Australian Rix readability formula was used to estimate the grade of reading difficulty, and thus comprehensibility, of these patient information pamphlets (grade 1 = most comprehensible; grade 12 = most difficult). RESULTS: The mean grade of reading difficulty of the 50 patient information pamphlets was 8 (SD, 1.4; range, 6-11). One-third were written at or above grade 9 and two-thirds were at or above grade 8. CONCLUSION: As recent educational attainment data suggest that up to 52% of 15-69-year-olds in Australia comprehend text at or below grade 7, a substantial number of pamphlets on asthma are beyond the reading and comprehension abilities of many of their target population.

In-training assessment - its potential in enhancing clinical teaching.

CONTEXT: In-training assessment (ITA) has established its place alongside formative and summative assessment at both the undergraduate and postgraduate level. In this paper the authors aimed to identify those characteristics of ITA that could enhance clinical teaching. METHODS: A literature review and discussions by an expert working group at the Ninth Cambridge Conference identified the aspects of ITA that could enhance clinical teaching. RESULTS: The features of ITA identified included defining the specific benefits to the learner, teacher and institution, and highlighting the patient as the context for ITA and clinical teaching. The 'mapping' of a learner's progress towards the clinical teaching objectives by using multiple assessments over time, by multiple observers in both a systematic and opportunistic way correlates with the incremental nature of reaching clinical competence. CONCLUSIONS: The importance of ITA based on both direct and indirect evidence of what the learner actually does in the real clinical setting is emphasized. Particular attention is given to addressing concerns in the more controversial areas of assessor training, ratings and documentation for ITA. Areas for future research are also identified.

Recruiting problem-based learning (PBL) tutors for a PBL-based curriculum: the Flinders University experience.

OBJECTIVES: To examine the contribution made to problem-based learning (PBL) by individual teachers and by departments in years 1 and 2 of a new graduate-entry medical programme (GEMP) with a PBL-based curriculum. METHODS: We compiled a database on all PBL tutoring undertaken in years 1 and 2 during the first 3 years in which the GEMP was delivered. This allowed us to quantify and analyse the contribution made by individuals and by departments. RESULTS: At 3 years following introduction of the GEMP, 136 (25.9%) of the school's 525 staff had trained as PBL tutors and 98 (18.7%) had tutored. Both individuals and departments differed greatly in the amount of time devoted to PBL tutoring. Staff who tutored once tended to tutor again in subsequent years. Compared with staff in clinical departments, those in non-clinical departments (who constituted 12% of the total) made a greater relative contribution though a smaller absolute contribution to tutoring. CONCLUSIONS: These findings prompted us to develop a formula that distributes the PBL tutoring load more evenly across departments. This was successfully introduced in 1999. It recognizes the fact that only a minority of staff will volunteer to become PBL tutors. Strategies that might encourage more staff to tutor are briefly discussed.

The parallel rural community curriculum: an integrated clinical curriculum based in rural general practice.

INTRODUCTION: In an attempt to address the rural medical workforce maldistribution and the concurrent inappropriate caseload at the urban tertiary teaching hospitals, Flinders University and the Riverland Division of General Practice decided to pilot, in 1997, an entire year of undergraduate clinical curriculum in Australian rural general practice. This program is called the Parallel Rural Community Curriculum (PRCC). This paper is a discussion of the aims of the programme; student selection; practice recruitment; curriculum structure, and academic content, together with lessons learnt from the evaluation of the first cohort of students' experience of the course. METHODS: Independent external evaluators undertook a thematic analysis of a series of structured interviews of students and faculty involved in both the PRCC and the traditional curriculum. The mean examination results were determined and a rank order comparison of student academic performance was undertaken. RESULTS: The eight selected volunteer students reported greater access to patients and clinical learning opportunities than their mainstream counterparts and learned clinical decision making in the context of the whole patient, their family, and the available community resources. They identified patients with 'core' clinical conditions and had a longitudinal exposure to common diseases, whereas hospital-based peers had a cross-sectional exposure to highly filtered illness. The PRCC students' academic performance improved in comparison with that of their tertiary hospital peers' and in comparison to their own results in previous years. CONCLUSION: The PRCC curriculum has cut across the traditional clinical discipline boundaries by teaching in an integrated way in rural general practice. It has affirmed the potential role of true generalist physicians in undergraduate medical education.

Country report: Australia.

The last 10 years has been an interesting time for Australian medical education despite reduced funding. WORKFORCE: There are five main workforce trends: a rural/urban maldistribution, a need for more specialists, public hospital staffing difficulties, increasing female practitioners and under-representation of indigenous practitioners. ISSUES FACING THE DEANS: Lack of resources is a problem facing Deans, with pressure for clinical service in teaching hospitals. Entrepreneurial activities have been undertaken including the enrollment of overseas students. Medical schools have also responded to important government initiatives. DEVELOPMENTS IN MEDICAL EDUCATION: Australia's 11 medical schools have undergone significant reform in the last decade. There is a mix of four (graduate), five and six year courses. AUSTRALIA'S NEW MEDICAL SCHOOL: James Cook University opened the first medical school in northern Australia in 2000. The School admits students from rural, northern Australian and indigenous backgrounds. It has a strong regional mission. RURAL AND COMMUNITY-BASED EDUCATION: Government funding to address the maldistribution of the workforce has led to the establishment of rural clubs, Departments of Rural Health and community-based programs. THE FIRST TWO POSTGRADUATE YEARS: There have been recent moves to improve education in the two years following graduation. This includes the initiation of national projects in curriculum and assessment. POSTGRADUATE AND CONTINUING MEDICAL EDUCATION: Postgraduate programs in Australia are being reformed to build on the changes in undergraduate education. CME is also under review. CONCLUSION: Australian medical educators should build on the recent reforms and take on some of the new directions in medical education.

Why we should teach undergraduate medical students in rural communities.

In the eyes of many, the critical shortage of doctors in rural areas is the only reason for providing rural experiences for medical students. This article reviews the body of evidence supporting rural placements as a long-term medical workforce strategy and additional evidence regarding the apparent educational benefits of such placements. By enabling medical students to learn for significant periods of time in rural communities, it is now possible for universities to address the medical workforce imperatives of the communities they serve at the same time as providing intrinsic educational advantages to their students.

Clinical teaching: maintaining an educational role for doctors in the new health care environment.

CONTEXT AND OBJECTIVES: Good clinical teaching is central to medical education but there is concern about maintaining this in contemporary, pressured health care environments. This paper aims to demonstrate that good clinical practice is at the heart of good clinical teaching. METHODS: Seven roles are used as a framework for analysing good clinical teaching. The roles are medical expert, communicator, collaborator, manager, advocate, scholar and professional. RESULTS: The analysis of clinical teaching and clinical practice demonstrates that they are closely linked. As experts, clinical teachers are involved in research, information retrieval and sharing of knowledge or teaching. Good communication with trainees, patients and colleagues defines teaching excellence. Clinicians can 'teach' collaboration by acting as role models and by encouraging learners to understand the responsibilities of other health professionals. As managers, clinicians can apply their skills to the effective management of learning resources. Similarly skills as advocates at the individual, community and population level can be passed on in educational encounters. The clinicians' responsibilities as scholars are most readily applied to teaching activities. Clinicians have clear roles in taking scholarly approaches to their practice and demonstrating them to others. CONCLUSION: Good clinical teaching is concerned with providing role models for good practice, making good practice visible and explaining it to trainees. This is the very basis of clinicians as professionals, the seventh role, and should be the foundation for the further development of clinicians as excellent clinical teachers.