Making sense of feelings.

Internal feeling states such as pain, hunger, and thirst are widely assumed to be drivers of behaviours essential for homeostasis and animal survival. Call this the 'causal assumption'. It is becoming increasingly apparent that the causal assumption is incompatible with the standard view of motor action in neuroscience. While there is a well-known explanatory gap between neural activity and feelings, there is also a disjuncture in the reverse direction-what role, if any, do feelings play in animals if not to cause behaviour? To deny that feelings cause behaviours might thus seem to presage epiphenomenalism-the idea that subjective experiences, including feelings, are inert, emergent and, on some views, non-physical properties of brain processes. Since epiphenomenalism is antagonistic to fundamental commitments of evolutionary biology, the view developed here challenges the standard view about the function of feelings without denying that feelings have a function. Instead, we introduce the 'sense making sense' hypothesis-the idea that the function of subjective experience is not to cause behaviour, but to explain, in a restricted but still useful sense of 'explanation'. A plausible framework is derived that integrates commonly accepted neural computations to blend motor control, feelings, and explanatory processes to make sense of the way feelings are integrated into our sense of how and why we do and what we do.

Chemoattractant axon guidance cues regulate de novo axon trajectories in the embryonic forebrain of zebrafish.

The development of axon tracts in the early vertebrate brain is controlled by combinations of soluble, membrane-bound and extracellular matrix molecules. How these multiple and sometimes conflicting guidance cues are integrated in order to establish stereotypical pathways remains to be determined. We show here that when interactions between the chemoattractive signal Netrin1a and its receptor Dcc are suppressed using a loss-of-function approach, a novel axon trajectory emerges in the dorsal diencephalon. Axons arising from a subpopulation of telencephalic neurons failed to project rostrally into the anterior commissure in the absence of either Netrin1a or Dcc. Instead these axons inappropriately exited the telencephalon and ectopically coursed caudally into virgin neuroepithelium. This response was highly specific since loss-of-function of Netrin1b, a paralogue of Netrin1a, generated a distinct phenotype in the rostral brain. These results show that a subpopulation of telencephalic neurons, when freed from long-range chemoattraction mediated by Netrin1a-Dcc interactions, follow alternative instructive cues that lead to creation of an ectopic axon bundle in the diencephalon. This work provides insight into how integration of multiple guidance signals defines the initial scaffold of axon tracts in the embryonic vertebrate forebrain.

Stimulation of olfactory ensheathing cell motility enhances olfactory axon growth.

Axons of primary olfactory neurons are intimately associated with olfactory ensheathing cells (OECs) from the olfactory epithelium until the final targeting of axons within the olfactory bulb. However, little is understood about the nature and role of interactions between OECs and axons during development of the olfactory nerve pathway. We have used high resolution time-lapse microscopy to examine the growth and interactions of olfactory axons and OECs in vitro. Transgenic mice expressing fluorescent reporters in primary olfactory axons (OMP-ZsGreen) and ensheathing cells (S100ß-DsRed) enabled us to selectively analyse these cell types in explants of olfactory epithelium. We reveal here that rather than providing only a permissive substrate for axon growth, OECs play an active role in modulating the growth of pioneer olfactory axons. We show that the interactions between OECs and axons were dependent on lamellipodial waves on the shaft of OEC processes. The motility of OECs was mediated by GDNF, which stimulated cell migration and increased the apparent motility of the axons, whereas loss of OECs via laser ablation of the cells inhibited olfactory axon outgrowth. These results demonstrate that the migration of OECs strongly regulates the motility of axons and that stimulation of OEC motility enhances axon extension and growth cone activity.

The carbohydrate CT1 is expressed in topographically fixed glomeruli in the mouse olfactory bulb.

Cell surface carbohydrates define subpopulations of primary olfactory neurons whose axons terminate in select glomeruli in the olfactory bulb. The combination of carbohydrates present on axon subpopulations has been proposed to confer a unique identity that contributes to the establishment of the olfactory topographic map. We have identified a novel subpopulation of primary olfactory neurons in mice that express blood group carbohydrates with GalNAc-ß1,4[NeuAcα 2,3]Galß1 residues recognised by the CT1 antibody. The CT1 carbohydrate has been shown to modulate adhesion of nerve terminals to the extracellular matrix and to synaptic proteins. The axons of the CT1-positive primary olfactory neurons terminate in a subpopulation of glomeruli in the olfactory bulb. Four lines of evidence support the view that CT1 glomeruli are topographically fixed. First, CT1 glomeruli were restricted predominantly to the dorsomedial olfactory bulb and were absent from large patches of the ventrolateral bulb. Second, similar distributions were observed for CT1 glomeruli on both the left and right olfactory bulbs of each animal, and between animals. Third, CT1 glomeruli were typically present as small clusters of 2-4 glomeruli. Fourth, a single CT1 glomerulus was always apposed to the glomeruli innervated by axons expressing the M72 odorant receptor. We also show that the CT1 carbohydrate is lost in gain-of-function transgenic mice over-expressing the blood group A glycosyltransferase in which there is aberrant targeting of M72 axons. Taken together, these results suggest that the CT1 carbohydrate, together with other carbohydrates, contributes to axon guidance during the establishment of the olfactory topographic map.

Correction of aberrant axon growth in the developing mouse olfactory bulb.

During development of the primary olfactory system, sensory axons project from the nasal cavity to the glomerular layer of the olfactory bulb. In the process axons can branch inappropriately into several glomeruli and sometimes over-shoot the glomerular layer, entering the deeper external plexiform layer. However in the adult, axons are rarely observed within the external plexiform layer. While chemorepulsive cues are proposed to restrict axons to the glomerular layer in the embryonic animal, these cues are clearly insufficient for all axons in the postnatal animal. We hypothesised that the external plexiform layer is initially an environment in which axons are able to grow but becomes increasingly inhibitory to axon growth in later postnatal development. We have determined that rather than having short localised trajectories as previously assumed, many axons that enter the external plexiform layer had considerable trajectories and projected preferentially along the ventro-dorsal and rostro-caudal axes for up to 950 µm. With increasing age, fewer axons were detected within the external plexiform layer but axons continued to be present until P17. Thus the external plexiform layer is initially an environment in which axons can extensively grow. We next tested whether the external plexiform layer became increasingly inhibitory to axon growth by microdissecting various layers of the olfactory bulb and preparing protein extracts. When assayed using olfactory epithelium explants of the same embryonic age, primary olfactory axons became increasingly inhibited by extract prepared from the external plexiform layer of increasingly older animals. These results demonstrate that primary olfactory axons can initially grow extensively in the external plexiform layer, but that during postnatal development inhibitory cues are upregulated that reduce axon growth within the external plexiform layer.

A First Principles Approach to Subjective Experience.

Understanding the neural bases of subjective experience remains one of the great challenges of the natural sciences. Higher-order theories of consciousness are typically defended by assessments of neural activity in higher cortical regions during perception, often with disregard to the nature of the neural computations that these regions execute. We have sought to refocus the problem toward identification of those neural computations that are necessary for subjective experience with the goal of defining the sorts of neural architectures that can perform these operations. This approach removes reliance on behaviour and brain homologies for appraising whether non-human animals have the potential to subjectively experience sensory stimuli. Using two basic principles-first, subjective experience is dependent on complex processing executing specific neural functions and second, the structure-determines-function principle-we have reasoned that subjective experience requires a neural architecture consisting of stacked forward models that predict the output of neural processing from inputs. Given that forward models are dependent on appropriately connected processing modules that generate prediction, error detection and feedback control, we define a minimal neural architecture that is necessary (but not sufficient) for subjective experience. We refer to this framework as the hierarchical forward models algorithm. Accordingly, we postulate that any animal lacking this neural architecture will be incapable of subjective experience.

Lamellipodia mediate the heterogeneity of central olfactory ensheathing cell interactions.

The growth and guidance of primary olfactory axons are partly attributed to the presence of olfactory ensheathing cells (OECs). However, little is understood about the differences between the subpopulations of OECs and what regulates their interactions. We used OEC-axon assays and determined that axons respond differently to peripheral and central OECs. We then further purified OECs from anatomically distinct regions of the olfactory bulb. Cell behaviour assays revealed that OECs from the olfactory bulb were a functionally heterogeneous population with distinct differences which is consistent with their proposed roles in vivo. We found that the heterogeneity was regulated by motile lamellipodial waves along the shaft of the OECs and that inhibition of lamellipodial wave activity via Mek1 abolished the ability of the cells to distinguish between each other. These results demonstrate that OECs from the olfactory bulb are a heterogeneous population that use lamellipodial waves to regulate cell-cell recognition.

Neural Design Principles for Subjective Experience: Implications for Insects.

How subjective experience is realized in nervous systems remains one of the great challenges in the natural sciences. An answer to this question should resolve debate about which animals are capable of subjective experience. We contend that subjective experience of sensory stimuli is dependent on the brain's awareness of its internal neural processing of these stimuli. This premise is supported by empirical evidence demonstrating that disruption to either processing streams or awareness states perturb subjective experience. Given that the brain must predict the nature of sensory stimuli, we reason that conscious awareness is itself dependent on predictions generated by hierarchically organized forward models of the organism's internal sensory processing. The operation of these forward models requires a specialized neural architecture and hence any nervous system lacking this architecture is unable to subjectively experience sensory stimuli. This approach removes difficulties associated with extrapolations from behavioral and brain homologies typically employed in addressing whether an animal can feel. Using nociception as a model sensation, we show here that the Drosophila brain lacks the required internal neural connectivity to implement the computations required of hierarchical forward models. Consequently, we conclude that Drosophila, and those insects with similar neuroanatomy, do not subjectively experience noxious stimuli and therefore cannot feel pain.

Neogenin and RGMa control neural tube closure and neuroepithelial morphology by regulating cell polarity.

In humans, neural tube closure defects occur in 1:1000 pregnancies. The design of new strategies for the prevention of such common defects would benefit from an improved understanding of the molecular events underlying neurulation. Neural fold elevation is a key morphological process that acts during neurulation to drive neural tube closure. However, to date, the molecular pathways underpinning neural fold elevation have not been elucidated. Here, we use morpholino knock-down technology to demonstrate that Repulsive Guidance Molecule (RGMa)-Neogenin interactions are essential for effective neural fold elevation during Xenopus neurulation and that loss of these molecules results in disrupted neural tube closure. We demonstrate that Neogenin and RGMa are required for establishing the morphology of deep layer cells in the neural plate throughout neurulation. We also show that loss of Neogenin severely disrupts the microtubule network within the deep layer cells suggesting that Neogenin-dependent microtubule organization within the deep cells is essential for radial intercalation with the overlying superficial cell layer, thereby driving neural fold elevation. In addition, we show that sustained Neogenin activity is also necessary for the establishment of the apicobasally polarized pseudostratified neuroepithelium of the neural tube. Therefore, our study identifies a novel signaling pathway essential for radial intercalation and epithelialization during neural fold elevation and neural tube morphogenesis.

The cell surface carbohydrate blood group A regulates the selective fasciculation of regenerating accessory olfactory axons.

Cell surface carbohydrates are differentially expressed by discrete subpopulations of primary sensory axons in the mammalian main and accessory olfactory systems. It has been proposed that these carbohydrates provide a glycocode which mediates the sorting of these sensory axons as they project from the olfactory neuroepithelium to their central targets in the main and accessory olfactory bulbs during development. As the differential expression of cell surface carbohydrates on olfactory axons persists in the adult we have now investigated their role during regeneration. We have recently generated a line of transgenic mice, BGAT-Tg, that mis-express the blood group A (BGA) carbohydrate on all primary olfactory axons rather than just on accessory olfactory axons as in wild-type mice. Following unilateral bulbectomy, accessory and main olfactory axons regenerate and grow into the frontal cortex where they fill the cavity which remains after the olfactory bulb ablation. In wild-type mice, the regenerating BGA-expressing accessory olfactory axons selectively aggregated with each other in large bundles but clearly separated from the BGA-negative main olfactory axons. In contrast, in the BGAT-Tg transgenic mice in which all main and accessory axons express the BGA carbohydrate, the accessory olfactory axons failed to correctly separate from the main olfactory axons. Instead, these axons formed numerous small bundles interspersed with main olfactory axons. These data provide strong evidence that the restricted expression of BGA is in part responsible for the selective segregation of accessory olfactory axons.

Designing Brains for Pain: Human to Mollusc.

There is compelling evidence that the "what it feels like" subjective experience of sensory stimuli arises in the cerebral cortex in both humans as well as mammalian experimental animal models. Humans are alone in their ability to verbally communicate their experience of the external environment. In other species, sensory awareness is extrapolated on the basis of behavioral indicators. For instance, cephalopods have been claimed to be sentient on the basis of their complex behavior and anecdotal reports of human-like intelligence. We have interrogated the findings of avoidance learning behavioral paradigms and classical brain lesion studies and conclude that there is no evidence for cephalopods feeling pain. This analysis highlighted the questionable nature of anthropometric assumptions about sensory experience with increased phylogenetic distance from humans. We contend that understanding whether invertebrates such as molluscs are sentient should first begin with defining the computational processes and neural circuitries underpinning subjective awareness. Using fundamental design principles, we advance the notion that subjective awareness is dependent on observer neural networks (networks that in some sense introspect the neural processing generating neural representations of sensory stimuli). This introspective process allows the observer network to create an internal model that predicts the neural processing taking place in the network being surveyed. Predictions arising from the internal model form the basis of a rudimentary form of awareness. We develop an algorithm built on parallel observer networks that generates multiple levels of sensory awareness. A network of cortical regions in the human brain has the appropriate functional properties and neural interconnectivity that is consistent with the predicted circuitry of the algorithm generating pain awareness. By contrast, the cephalopod brain lacks the necessary neural circuitry to implement such an algorithm. In conclusion, we find no compelling behavioral, functional, or neuroanatomical evidence to indicate that cephalopods feel pain.

Potential Roles of Dental Pulp Stem Cells in Neural Regeneration and Repair.

This review summarizes current advances in dental pulp stem cells (DPSCs) and their potential applications in the nervous diseases. Injured adult mammalian nervous system has a limited regenerative capacity due to an insufficient pool of precursor cells in both central and peripheral nervous systems. Nerve growth is also constrained by inhibitory factors (associated with central myelin) and barrier tissues (glial scarring). Stem cells, possessing the capacity of self-renewal and multicellular differentiation, promise new therapeutic strategies for overcoming these impediments to neural regeneration. Dental pulp stem cells (DPSCs) derive from a cranial neural crest lineage, retain a remarkable potential for neuronal differentiation, and additionally express multiple factors that are suitable for neuronal and axonal regeneration. DPSCs can also express immunomodulatory factors that stimulate formation of blood vessels and enhance regeneration and repair of injured nerve. These unique properties together with their ready accessibility make DPSCs an attractive cell source for tissue engineering in injured and diseased nervous systems. In this review, we interrogate the neuronal differentiation potential as well as the neuroprotective, neurotrophic, angiogenic, and immunomodulatory properties of DPSCs and its application in the injured nervous system. Taken together, DPSCs are an ideal stem cell resource for therapeutic approaches to neural repair and regeneration in nerve diseases.

Neogenin: one receptor, many functions.

Neogenin is a multifunctional transmembrane receptor belonging to the immunoglobulin superfamily. It displays identical secondary structure to deleted in colorectal cancer (DCC), a netrin receptor that is involved in axon guidance and cell survival. Like DCC, neogenin is able to transduce signals elicited by netrin. These neogenin-netrin interactions have been implicated in tissue morphogenesis, angiogenesis, myoblast differentiation and most recently in axon guidance. Neogenin is also a receptor for repulsive guidance molecule, a glycosylphosphatidylinositol-linked protein involved in neuronal differentiation, apoptosis and repulsive axon guidance. Numerous studies have been started to elucidate the in vivo functions of neogenin, and its role in multiple aspects of development and homeostasis.

Knockdown of zebrafish crim1 results in a bent tail phenotype with defects in somite and vascular development.

The Crim1 gene encodes a transmembrane protein containing six cysteine-rich repeats similar to those found in the BMP antagonist, chordin (chd). To investigate its physiological role, zebrafish crim1 was cloned and shown to be both maternally and zygotically expressed during zebrafish development in sites including the vasculature, intermediate cell mass, notochord, and otic vesicle. Bent or hooked tails with U-shaped somites were observed in 85% of morphants from 12 hpf. This was accompanied by a loss of muscle pioneer cells. While morpholino knockdown of crim1 showed some evidence of ventralisation, including expansion of the intermediate cell mass (ICM), reduction in head size bent tails and disruption to the somites and notochord, this did not mimic the classically ventralised phenotype, as assessed by the pattern of expression of the dorsal markers chordin, otx2 and the ventral markers eve1, pax2.1, tal1 and gata1 between 75% epiboly and six-somites. From 24 hpf, morphants displayed an expansion of the ventral mesoderm-derived ICM, as evidenced by expansion of tal1, lmo2 and crim1 itself. Analysis of the crim1 morphant phenotype in Tg(fli:EGFP) fish showed a clear reduction in the endothelial cells forming the intersegmental vessels and a loss of the dorsal longitudinal anastomotic vessel (DLAV). Hence, the primary role of zebrafish crim1 is likely to be the regulation of somitic and vascular development.

The shape of the olfactory bulb influences axon targeting.

Each primary olfactory neuron in the mouse expresses a single type of odorant receptor. All neurons expressing the same odorant receptor gene typically project to two topographically fixed glomeruli, one each on the medial and lateral surfaces of the olfactory bulb. While topographic gradients of guidance receptors and their ligands help to establish the retinotectal projection, similar orthogonal distributions of cues have not yet been detected within the olfactory system. While odorant receptors are crucial for the final targeting of axons to glomeruli, it is unclear whether the olfactory bulb itself provides instructive cues for the establishment of the topographic map. To begin to understand the role of the olfactory bulb in the formation of the olfactory nerve pathway, we developed a model whereby the gross shape of the bulb in the P2-IRES-tau-LacZ line of mice was radically altered during postnatal development. We have shown here that the topography of axons expressing the P2 odorant receptor is dependent on the shape of the olfactory bulb. When the dorsoventral axis of the olfactory bulb was compressed during the early postnatal period, newly developing P2 axons projected to multiple inappropriate glomeruli surrounding their normal target site. These results suggest that the distribution of local guidance cues within the olfactory bulb is influenced by the shape of the olfactory bulb and that these cues contribute to the topographic positioning of glomeruli.

Epidermal YAP2-5SA-ΔC Drives ß-Catenin Activation to Promote Keratinocyte Proliferation in Mouse Skin In Vivo.

The epidermis is a highly regenerative tissue. YAP is a pivotal regulator of stem/progenitor cells in tissue regeneration, including in the epidermis. The molecular mechanisms downstream of YAP that activate epidermal cell proliferation remain largely unknown. We found that YAP and ß-catenin co-localize in the nuclei of keratinocytes in the regenerating epidermis in vivo and in proliferating HaCaT keratinocytes in vitro. Inactivation of YAP in HaCaT keratinocytes resulted in reduced activated ß-catenin and reduced keratinocyte numbers in vitro. In addition, we found that in the hyperplastic epidermis of YAP2-5SA-ΔC mice, the mutant YAP2-5SA-ΔC protein was predominantly localized in the keratinocyte nuclei and caused increased expression of activated nuclear ß-catenin. Accordingly, ß-catenin transcriptional activity was elevated in the skin of live YAP2-5SA-ΔC/TOPFLASH mice. Lastly, loss of ß-catenin in basal keratinocytes of YAP2-5SA-ΔC/K14-creERT/CtnnB1-/- mice resulted in reduced proliferation of basal keratinocytes and a striking rescue of the hyperplastic abnormalities. Taken together, our work shows that YAP2-5SA-ΔC drives ß-catenin activity to promote basal keratinocyte proliferation in the mouse skin in vivo. Our data shine new light on the etiology of regenerative dermatological disorders and other human diseases that display increased YAP and ß-catenin activity.

Septal organ of Grüneberg is part of the olfactory system.

The olfactory system in rodents and many other mammals is classically divided into two anatomically separate, and morphologically distinct, sensory systems: the main olfactory system and the accessory olfactory system. We have now identified a novel third population of olfactory marker protein-expressing sensory neurons that is located in a discrete pocket of the rostral nasal septum, which we refer to as the septal organ of Grüneberg (SOG). Neurons in this region of the septum are located in the submucosa, in small grape-like clusters, rather than in a pseudostratified neuroepithelium, as seen in both the olfactory and vomeronasal neuroepithelia. Despite their unusual location, axons projecting from the SOG neurons fasciculate into several discrete bundles and terminate in a subset of main olfactory bulb glomeruli. These glomeruli most likely represent a subset of atypical glomeruli that are spatially restricted to the caudal main olfactory bulb. The unique rostral position of the SOG suggests that the SOG may be functionally specialized for the early detection of biologically relevant odorants.

Implantation of a scaffold following bulbectomy induces laminar organization of regenerating olfactory axons.

Primary olfactory axons expressing different odorant receptors are interspersed within the olfactory nerve. However, upon reaching the outer nerve fiber layer of the olfactory bulb they defasciculate, sort out, and refasciculate prior to targeting glomeruli in fixed topographic positions. While odorant receptors are crucial for the final targeting of axons to glomeruli, it is unclear what directs the formation of the nerve fiber and glomerular layers of the olfactory bulb. While the olfactory bulb itself may provide instructive cues for the development of these layers, it is also possible that the incoming axons may simply require the presence of a physical scaffold to establish the outer laminar cytoarchitecture. In order to begin to understand the underlying role of the olfactory bulb in development of the outer layers of the olfactory bulb, we physically ablated the olfactory bulbs in OMP-IRES-LacZ and P2-IRES-tau-LacZ neonatal mice and replaced them with artificial biological scaffolds molded into the shape of an olfactory bulb. Regenerating axons projected around the edge of the cranial cavity at the periphery of the artificial scaffold and were able to form an olfactory nerve fiber layer and, to some extent, a glomerular layer. Our results reveal that olfactory axons are able to form rudimentary cytoarchitectonic layers if they are provided with an appropriately shaped biological scaffold. Thus, the olfactory bulb does not appear to provide any tropic substance that either attracts regenerating olfactory axons into the cranial cavity or induces these axons to form a plexus around its outer surface.

Olfactory marker protein modulates primary olfactory axon overshooting in the olfactory bulb.

Olfactory marker protein (OMP) is expressed by mature primary olfactory sensory neurons during development and in adult mice. In mice that lack OMP, olfactory sensory neurons have perturbed electrophysiological activity, and the mice exhibit altered responses and behavior to odor stimulation. To date, defects in axon guidance in mice that lack OMP have not been investigated. During development of the olfactory system in mouse, primary olfactory axons often overshoot their target glomerular layer and project into the deeper external plexiform layer. These aberrant axonal projections are normally detected within the external plexiform layer up to postnatal day 12. We have examined the projections of primary olfactory axons in OMP-tau:LacZ mice and OMP-GFP mice, two independent lines in which the OMP coding region has been replaced by reporter molecules. We found that axons overshoot their target layer and grow into the external plexiform layer in these OMP null mice as they do in wild-type animals. However, in the absence of OMP, overshooting axons are more persistent and remain prominent until 5 weeks postnatally, after which their numbers decrease. Overshooting axons are still present in these mice even at 8 months of age. In heterozygous mice, axons also overshoot into the external plexiform layer; however, there are fewer axons, and they project for shorter distances, compared with those in a homozygous environment. Our results suggest that perturbed electrophysiological responses, caused by loss of OMP in primary olfactory neurons, reduce the ability of primary olfactory axons to recognize their glomerular target.