RESUMO
INTRODUCTION: The World Health Organization (WHO) Department of Mental Health and Substance Abuse appointed a Working Group on Sexual Disorders and Sexual Health in order to revise and propose changes to ICD-10 categories. AIM: Analyze ethical and legal implications in Brazil of the proposed ICD-11 diagnostic criteria for paraphilic disorders. METHODS: A forensic working group of Brazilian experts in collaboration with representatives of WHO reviewed the proposed modifications to the classification of Disorders of Sexual Preference in ICD-10 (F65), which is recommended to be replaced by Paraphilic Disorders in ICD-11. Proposals were reviewed through a medicolegal lens, using a legal and policy analysis guide put forth by WHO. The premise of this review was to understand that, although the ICD classification is intended to provide a basis for clinical and statistical health interventions, medical diagnostics may also be entangled in the complex legal, normative, and political environment of various countries. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE: The most important proposed change to this section is to limit the concept of paraphilic disorders primarily to patterns of sexual arousal involving a focus on others who are unwilling or unable to consent, but this change has not affected the ethical and legal aspects of psychiatric functioning in the Brazil. RESULTS: Because Brazilian criminal law is directed toward criminal behavior and not to specific psychiatric diagnoses, the changes proposed for ICD-11 are not expected to create obstacles to health services or to modify criminal sentencing. CLINICAL IMPLICATIONS: Although ICD-11 has a number of changes in its content, there are no significant clinical implications in the Brazilian context, but a better clarity of conceptual definitions and diagnostic criteria. STRENGTHS & LIMITATIONS: The study is conducted with people from different Brazilian states, which is important for a comprehensive view. On the other hand, considering that it is a very heterogeneous country, there is the limitation that an even wider scope of the study is not possible. CONCLUSION: In the Brazilian context, the new guidelines for paraphilic disorders contribute to clinical utility and are not expected to create difficulties related to the legal, social, and economic consequences of sexual offenses in the country. Abdalla-Filho E, de Jesus Mari J, Diehl A, et al. Forensic Implications of the New Classification of ICD-11 Paraphilic Disorders in Brazil. J Sex Med 2019; 16:1814-1819.
Assuntos
Classificação Internacional de Doenças , Transtornos Parafílicos/classificação , Delitos Sexuais/legislação & jurisprudência , Comportamento Sexual/classificação , Brasil , Criminosos , Humanos , Transtornos Parafílicos/psicologia , Comportamento Sexual/psicologiaRESUMO
PURPOSE OF REVIEW: Ethics in forensic expertise has been the focus of important debates. After providing a brief history of the theme, a review is given of the articles published in the last 2 years. As this field is constantly changing, it is possible to identify significant differences and even opposing positions adopted till now by various researchers. RECENT FINDINGS: The review includes a discussion on the current ethical theories applied to the forensic field, the objective and subjective issues involved in forensic work, the care needed to prevent additional and unnecessary suffering to the examinees and, finally, future directions as indicated by the authors. SUMMARY: The authors conclude that the discussion on the ethics of forensic expertise should be more comprehensive. The debate should include the search for equilibrium between objectivity and subjectivity, inherent to forensic expertise work, and also the utilization of advanced technological resources, always bearing in mind the conditions to which the examiner and examinee are subjected.
Assuntos
Psiquiatria Legal/ética , Previsões , Psiquiatria Legal/tendências , HumanosRESUMO
The objective of this paper is to provide an update to psychiatrists regarding the new Brazilian Law for the Inclusion of People with Disabilities (BLI, Law 13,146 of 2015), and, specifically, to discuss potential implications of situations in which examination by a forensic psychiatrist points toward civil incompetence, while the above-mentioned law mandates full civil capacity for disabled persons. A study of Law 13,146/2015 was conducted, including a comparative analysis of legal and psychiatric approaches on the subject. This analysis revealed that the BLI has generated differences of opinion among legislators. However, the greatest difference seems to arise between the justice system and psychiatric expertise in relation to the difference of criteria adopted in the two approaches. The BLI is very recent; it should be revised in response to debates among psychiatrists and the criminal justice system, and especially as jurisprudence is formed over time.
Assuntos
Direitos Civis/legislação & jurisprudência , Pessoas com Deficiência/legislação & jurisprudência , Brasil , Direitos Civis/psicologia , Pessoas com Deficiência/psicologia , Psiquiatria Legal/legislação & jurisprudência , Humanos , Discriminação Social/legislação & jurisprudênciaRESUMO
OBJECTIVE: The study aims to approach forensic psychiatry within different contexts. It endeavors to show how this specific psychiatry science area is influenced by legal and cultural aspects. METHOD: The bibliography reviewed had in view understanding the different ways of how to deal with law within the psychiatric sphere, from a cultural point of view. RESULTS: there is a great heterogeneity, of different nature (legal, political, cultural, and religious) that enrich, but at the same time makes difficult, a debate about this issue. CONCLUSIONS: there are two great obstacles to achieve a good knowledge about the practice of forensic psychiatry all over the world. The first one is represented by a heterogeneity that makes difficult its description in a comprehensible way. The second is the lack of knowledge of the cultural diverse realities. These difficulties should be a stimulus for newer studies of this characteristic. Only in this way it becomes possible to gradually increase the comprehension of this issue.
Assuntos
Diversidade Cultural , Psiquiatria Legal/organização & administração , Saúde Global , Serviços de Saúde Mental/organização & administração , Saúde Mental , África , América , Brasil , Europa (Continente) , Psiquiatria Legal/legislação & jurisprudência , Reforma dos Serviços de Saúde , Humanos , Cooperação Internacional , Serviços de Saúde Mental/legislação & jurisprudência , OceaniaRESUMO
OBJECTIVE: To illustrate the basic characteristics of several specific personality disorders, focusing mainly in antisocial personality disorder. The differences between antisocial personality disorder and psychopathy are highlighted. Serial killers and its psychopathic aspects are also discussed. METHOD: A bibliographic review was completed in order to outline convergences and divergences among different authors about this controversial issue, especially those concerning the possibility of treatment. RESULTS: While anti-social personality disorder is a medical diagnosis, the term "psychopathy" (which belongs to the sphere of forensic psychiatry) may be understood as a "legal diagnosis". It is not still possible to identify an effective treatment for serial killers. CONCLUSION: Personality disorders, especially of the antisocial type, still represent a formidable challenge to forensic psychiatry today. Questions as yet unanswered include the best and most humane place for patients with this condition and the nature of a standardised treatment recommendation.
Assuntos
Transtorno da Personalidade Antissocial/psicologia , Psiquiatria Legal , Homicídio/psicologia , Transtorno da Personalidade Antissocial/diagnóstico , Transtorno da Personalidade Antissocial/terapia , Transtorno da Conduta/psicologia , Prova Pericial , Humanos , Competência Mental , Transtornos Mentais/complicações , Transtornos Mentais/psicologia , Delitos Sexuais/psicologiaRESUMO
The authors make a comparative analysis between the practice of forensic psychiatry in England and in Brazil. The purpose is to stimulate the debate about the conduction of this psychiatric specialization in both countries. It is a study specifically addressed to the criminal area and its approach is carried out based on the legal, clinical, and ethical points of view. The observations made in England may be also applied to Wales, but not to the United Kingdom as a whole, since different legislation is adopted in Scotland and Northern Ireland. It concludes that while in Brazil there is a need for a closer and more integrated relationship between Psychiatry and Law, it is equally significant to clearly define the scope and the boundaries of each of these areas, as ignoring the boundaries between the two specialties could result in the risk of their relationship becoming confused, as appears to be the case in the English context.
Assuntos
Psiquiatria Legal , Brasil , Direito Penal , Comparação Transcultural , Inglaterra , Psiquiatria Legal/ética , Psiquiatria Legal/legislação & jurisprudência , Humanos , Transtornos da Personalidade/diagnóstico , Transtornos Relacionados ao Uso de Substâncias/diagnósticoRESUMO
The objective of this paper is to provide an update to psychiatrists regarding the new Brazilian Law for the Inclusion of People with Disabilities (BLI, Law 13,146 of 2015), and, specifically, to discuss potential implications of situations in which examination by a forensic psychiatrist points toward civil incompetence, while the above-mentioned law mandates full civil capacity for disabled persons. A study of Law 13,146/2015 was conducted, including a comparative analysis of legal and psychiatric approaches on the subject. This analysis revealed that the BLI has generated differences of opinion among legislators. However, the greatest difference seems to arise between the justice system and psychiatric expertise in relation to the difference of criteria adopted in the two approaches. The BLI is very recent; it should be revised in response to debates among psychiatrists and the criminal justice system, and especially as jurisprudence is formed over time.
Assuntos
Humanos , Direitos Civis/legislação & jurisprudência , Pessoas com Deficiência/legislação & jurisprudência , Psiquiatria Legal/legislação & jurisprudência , Brasil , Direitos Civis/psicologia , Pessoas com Deficiência/psicologia , Discriminação Social/legislação & jurisprudênciaAssuntos
Psiquiatria Legal , Bioética , Psiquiatria Legal/ética , Psiquiatria Legal/tendências , HumanosRESUMO
PURPOSE OF REVIEW: The existence of people with mental disorders in prisons is a reality found worldwide. The purpose of this article is not only to review the publications on this subject in 2009 but also to stimulate discussions that could contribute to its further scientific study. RECENT FINDINGS: Most studies published in 2009 related to drug use among inmates and its consequences made it clear that this kind of disorder has a closer relationship with the crime than with mental illness. SUMMARY: The existence of the mentally ill in prisons is a complex issue and the studies attempt to analyze aspects such as the type of disorder, sex of criminals, the opposition between incarceration and treatment, policy, harm reduction and stigma. A further study on the variables raised in this work is required, as well as examining others, to the extent that they are relevant to the various socio-economic and cultural realities.
Assuntos
Transtornos Mentais/epidemiologia , Prisioneiros/psicologia , Prisões/estatística & dados numéricos , Feminino , Humanos , Masculino , Transtornos Mentais/terapia , Prisioneiros/estatística & dados numéricos , Política Pública , Fatores Sexuais , Estereotipagem , Abuso de Substâncias por Via Intravenosa/epidemiologia , Abuso de Substâncias por Via Intravenosa/psicologia , Abuso de Substâncias por Via Intravenosa/terapia , Transtornos Relacionados ao Uso de Substâncias/epidemiologia , Transtornos Relacionados ao Uso de Substâncias/psicologia , Transtornos Relacionados ao Uso de Substâncias/terapiaRESUMO
PURPOSE OF REVIEW: The authors, after a brief historical review of the theme, review the articles published in the last year. The purpose is to verify how the field has moved on during this period, as a constant increase of legal and social controls on the medical profession is perceived. RECENT FINDINGS: Surprisingly, very few articles treating directly the theme reviewed were found. The better part of the articles examined legal aspects of the medical profession in a nonsystematic way. Among the ones selected those that dealt with internal controls (produced by the professional categories such as the Clinical Practice Guidelines) and those that dealt with external controls (produced by other social groups) could be identified. SUMMARY: The authors conclude that the existence of limits and internal and external controls is fundamental for a professional medical practice of quality. However, the excess of controls, which causes a defensive attitude, may negatively interfere in the quality of the care offered to patients.
Assuntos
Ética Médica , Medicina , Autonomia Profissional , Prática Profissional , Controle Social Formal , Códigos de Ética , Ética Médica/história , Medicina Legal/legislação & jurisprudência , Medicina Legal/normas , História do Século XV , História do Século XVI , História do Século XVII , História do Século XVIII , História do Século XIX , História do Século XX , História Antiga , História Medieval , Humanos , Imperícia/legislação & jurisprudência , Medicina/normas , Guias de Prática Clínica como Assunto , Prática Profissional/normasRESUMO
Este artigo de pesquisa discute aspectos peculiares ao exercício da função de perito criminal, o qual, frequentemente, se depara com situações em que há contraposição entre seus deveres profissionais e seus princípios éticos. Por meio da aplicação de questionário aos peritoscriminais do Instituto de Criminalística da Polícia Civil do Distrito Federal, o presente estudo objetivou verificar a existência de diretrizes éticas adotadas atualmente por esses profissionais e examiná-las com o intuito de gerar reflexões bioéticas, além de propor ajustes consideradosnecessários. O estudo permitiu concluir que há insatisfação entre os profissionais a respeito das orientações éticas recebidas, bem como referente à opinião negativa sobre a abordagem ética de seus pares e, principalmente, quanto à necessidade de referenciais éticos específicos para a prática pericial criminal, especialmente quando do trato com o cadáver e seus familiares.
Assuntos
Humanos , Análise Ética/métodos , Polícia Judiciária , Ética Profissional , Ciências Forenses , Bioética , Crime , Prova Pericial , Pesquisa QualitativaRESUMO
OBJETIVO: Este estudo visa a uma abordagem da psiquiatria forense dentro de diferentes contextos, no sentido de mostrar como essa ciência é influenciada por aspectos legais e culturais. MÉTODO: Foi feita uma revisão bibliográfica com o objetivo de apreender formas culturalmente diferentes de se lidar com a lei dentro do campo médico-psiquiátrico. RESULTADOS: Existe uma enorme gama de fatores, de diversas naturezas (legal, política, cultural, religiosa), que enriquece e, simultaneamente, dificulta um debate sobre o tema. CONCLUSÕES: Existem dois grandes obstáculos para se adquirir um conhecimento sobre a prática, em todo o mundo, da psiquiatria forense. O primeiro diz respeito a uma heterogeneidade que dificulta sua descrição de forma clara, e o segundo se refere ao próprio desconhecimento de realidades culturalmente muito diferentes. Por outro lado, essas mesmas dificuldades devem representar um estímulo para novos estudos dessa natureza, objetivando a alcançar, pouco a pouco, uma maior compreensão da matéria
OBJECTIVE: The study aims to approach forensic psychiatry within different contexts. It endeavors to show how this specific psychiatry science area is influenced by legal and cultural aspects.METHOD: The bibliography reviewed had in view understanding the different ways of how to deal with law within the psychiatric sphere, from a cultural point of view. RESULTS: there is a great heterogeneity, of different nature (legal, political, cultural, and religious) that enrich, but at the same time makes difficult, a debate about this issue.CONCLUSIONS: there are two great obstacles to achieve a good knowledge about the practice of forensic psychiatry all over the world. The first one is represented by a heterogeneity that makes difficult its description in a comprehensible way. The second is the lack of knowledge of the cultural diverse realities. These difficulties should be a stimulus for newer studies of this characteristic. Only in this way it becomes possible to gradually increase the comprehension of this issue
Assuntos
Humanos , Diversidade Cultural , Psiquiatria Legal/organização & administração , Saúde Mental , Serviços de Saúde Mental/organização & administração , Saúde Global , África , América , Brasil , Europa (Continente) , Psiquiatria Legal/legislação & jurisprudência , Reforma dos Serviços de Saúde , Cooperação Internacional , Serviços de Saúde Mental/legislação & jurisprudência , OceaniaRESUMO
OBJETIVO: Apresentar as características básicas dos diversos transtornos específicos de personalidade, mas centrando-se no transtorno de personalidade anti-social, fazendo sua diferenciação com psicopatia. O estudo ainda se propõe a abordar a figura do serial killer, apontando a presença de aspectos psicopáticos no homicídio seriado. MÉTODO: Uma revisão bibliográfica foi feita no sentido de se abordar convergências e divergências entre diversos autores sobre um assunto tão polêmico, sobretudo quanto à viabilidade de tratamento dessa clientela forense. RESULTADOS: Enquanto o transtorno de personalidade anti-social é um diagnóstico médico, pode-se entender o termo "psicopatia", pertencente à esfera psiquiátrico-forense, como um "diagnóstico legal". Não se pode falar ainda de tratamento eficaz para os chamados "serial killers". CONCLUSÃO: Os transtornos de personalidade, especialmente o tipo anti-social, representam ainda hoje um verdadeiro desafio para a psiquiatria forense. O local mais adequado e justo para seus portadores, bem como recomendação homogênea e padronizada de tratamento são questões ainda não respondidas
OBJECTIVE: To illustrate the basic characteristics of several specific personality disorders, focusing mainly in antisocial personality disorder. The differences between antisocial personality disorder and psychopathy are highlighted. Serial killers and its psychopathic aspects are also discussed.METHOD: A bibliographic review was completed in order to outline convergences and divergences among different authors about this controversial issue, especially those concerning the possibility of treatment.RESULTS: While anti-social personality disorder is a medical diagnosis, the term "psychopathy" (which belongs to the sphere of forensic psychiatry) may be understood as a "legal diagnosis". It is not still possible to identify an effective treatment for serial killers.CONCLUSION: Personality disorders, especially of the antisocial type, still represent a formidable challenge to forensic psychiatry today. Questions as yet unanswered include the best and most humane place for patients with this condition and the nature of a standardised treatment recommendation
Assuntos
Humanos , Transtorno da Personalidade Antissocial/psicologia , Psiquiatria Legal , Homicídio/psicologia , Transtorno da Personalidade Antissocial/diagnóstico , Transtorno da Personalidade Antissocial/terapia , Transtorno da Conduta/psicologia , Prova Pericial , Competência Mental , Transtornos Mentais/complicações , Transtornos Mentais/psicologia , Delitos Sexuais/psicologiaRESUMO
A relação entre transtorno psiquiátrico e comportamento violento vem sendo investigada de forma cada vez mais criteriosa e novos instrumentos de avaliação de risco de violência vêm sendo desenvolvidos nas últimas décadas. Este estudo apresenta um panorama atualizado dos recursos utilizados neste tipo de avaliação, tanto clínicos quanto sistematizados, enfatizando o surgimento de novos instrumentos padronizados. O objetivo maior não está concentrado na apresentação de dados matemáticos ou pontos de corte dos checklists desenvolvidos, mas, sim, nos fatores de risco, além do transtorno mental, levantados nestes instrumentos, o que permitirá uma melhor compreensão da complexidade de tal avaliação e do grau de participação da existência de doença mental. A conclusão aponta para a importância de uma avaliação equilibrada entre o exame clínico e os fatores citados nos instrumentos padronizados, bem como para a adoção de uma postura igualmente equilibrada no sentido de não supervalorizar nem tampouco negligenciar a relação que existe entre transtorno psiquiátrico e comportamento violento.
Assuntos
Comportamento Perigoso , Psiquiatria Legal , Violência , Fatores de RiscoRESUMO
É desenvolvida uma análise comparativa entre a prática da Psiquiatria Forense na Inglaterra e no Brasil. O objetivo é promover reflexões sobre a condução desta especialidade psiquiátrica nos dois países. Trata-se de um estudo dirigido especificamente para a área criminal e sua abordagem é realizada sob os pontos de vista legal, clínico e ético. As observações realizadas na Inglaterra podem ser aplicadas também ao País de Gales, mas não ao Reino Unido como um todo, uma vez que legislações diferentes são adotadas na Escócia e Irlanda do Norte. Conclui-se que, enquanto no Brasil é necessário um relacionamento mais próximo e integrado entre Psiquiatria e Lei, é igualmente importante ter clareza do alcance e dos limites de cada um desses campos de abordagem para, assim, evitar o risco de se ignorar os limites dessa relação, que parece estar marcada por uma certa confusão no contexto inglês