Commentary: Challenges and Opportunities for Women in Dental Research.

This commentary integrates and expands on the preceding articles in this issue that document and celebrate a century of women's achievements in the International Association for Dental Research (IADR). The increasing participation and leadership of women in dental and craniofacial research and within the IADR were viewed from the perspective of a changing culture of science. The steps that have been taken by the IADR to develop greater inclusiveness are acknowledged, and some of the challenges that remain are discussed in terms of obstacles that are most often social or cultural in origin. Comparisons are made across countries, and the social determinants that lead to differences in women's participation are described. Recommendations are made for developing strategies to change elements of our institutional cultures that have provided advantages to some groups of researchers more than to others. The unconscious biases and a lack of commitment to diversity, equity, and inclusion that limit the participation of members of some groups limit the progress and achievements of science in general.

Persistent and therapeutic concentrations of human factor IX in mice after hepatic gene transfer of recombinant AAV vectors.

Haemophilia B, or factor IX deficiency, is a X-linked recessive disorder that occurs in about one in 25,000 males, and severely affected people are at risk for spontaneous bleeding into numerous organs. Bleeding can be life-threatening or lead to chronic disabilities with haemophilic arthropathy. The severity of the bleeding tendency varies among patients and is related to the concentration of functional plasma factor IX. Patients with 5-30% of the normal factor IX have mild haemophilia that may not be recognized until adulthood or after heavy trauma or surgery. Therapy for acute bleeding consists of the transfusion of clotting-factor concentrates prepared from human blood and recombinant clotting factors that are currently in clinical trials. Both recombinant retroviral and adenoviral vectors have successfully transferred factor IX cDNA into the livers of dogs with haemophilia B. Recombinant retroviral-mediated gene transfer results in persistent yet subtherapeutic concentrations of factor IX and requires the stimulation of hepatocyte replication before vector administration. Recombinant adenoviral vectors can temporarily cure the coagulation defect in the canine haemophilia B model; however, an immune response directed against viral gene products made by the vector results in toxicity and limited gene expression. The use of recombinant adeno-associated virus (rAAV) vectors is promising because the vector contains no viral genes and can transduce non-dividing cells. The efficacy of in vivo transduction of non-dividing cells has been demonstrated in a wide variety of tissues. In this report, we describe the successful transduction of the liver in vivo using r-AAV vectors delivered as a single administration to mice and demonstrate that persistent, curative concentrations of functional human factor IX can be achieved using wild-type-free and adenovirus-free rAAV vectors. This demonstrates the potential of treating haemophilia B by gene therapy at the natural site of factor IX production.

Regulation of gene expression in vivo following transduction by two separate rAAV vectors.

Control of gene expression is important to gene therapy for purposes of both dosing and safety. In vivo regulation of gene expression was demonstrated following co-injection of two separate recombinant adeno-associated virus vectors, one encoding an inducible murine erythropoietin transgene and the other a transcriptional activator, directly into the skeletal muscle of adult immunocompetent mice. Transcription was controlled by systemic administration or withdrawal of tetracycline over an 18 week period, demonstrating that the two vectors were capable of transducing the same cell. Cellular or humoral immune responses against the transactivator protein were not detected.

High efficiency gene transfer into primary human tumor explants without cell selection.

Preclinical studies with murine tumor models have demonstrated that autologous tumor cell vaccines engineered to secrete certain cytokines in a paracrine fashion elicit systemic immune responses capable of eliminating small amounts of established tumor. These results have engendered much interest in developing this strategy for gene therapy of human cancer. The major limitation to creating genetically modified autologous human tumor vaccines is efficient gene transfer into primary tumor explants, since the majority of human tumors fail to proliferate in long-term culture. Using the retroviral vector MFG in conjunction with short-term culture techniques, we have achieved, in the absence of selection, a mean transduction efficiency of 60% in primary renal, ovarian, and pancreatic tumor explants, and we have developed an autologous granulocyte-macrophage colony-stimulating factor secreting tumor vaccine for clinical trials.

Bioactivity of autologous irradiated renal cell carcinoma vaccines generated by ex vivo granulocyte-macrophage colony-stimulating factor gene transfer.

Granulocyte-macrophage colony-stimulating factor (GM-CSF) gene-transduced, irradiated tumor vaccines induce potent, T-cell-mediated antitumor immune responses in preclinical models. We report the initial results of a Phase I trial evaluating this strategy for safety and the induction of immune responses in patients with metastatic renal cell carcinoma (RCC). Patients were treated in a randomized, double-blind dose-escalation study with equivalent doses of autologous, irradiated RCC vaccine cells with or without ex vivo human GM-CSF gene transfer. The replication-defective retroviral vector MFG was used for GM-CSF gene transfer. No dose-limiting toxicities were encountered in 16 fully evaluable patients. GM-CSF gene-transduced vaccines were equivalent in toxicity to nontransduced vaccines up to the feasible limits of autologous tumor vaccine yield. No evidence of autoimmune disease was observed. Biopsies of intradermal sites of injection with GM-CSF gene-transduced vaccines contained distinctive macrophage, dendritic cell, eosinophil, neutrophil, and T-cell infiltrates similar to those observed in preclinical models of efficacy. Histological analysis of delayed-type hypersensitivity responses in patients vaccinated with GM-CSF-transduced vaccines demonstrated an intense eosinophil infiltrate that was not observed in patients who received nontransduced vaccines. An objective partial response was observed in a patient treated with GM-CSF gene-transduced vaccine who displayed the largest delayed-type hypersensitivity conversion. No replication-competent retrovirus was detected in vaccinated patients. This Phase I study demonstrated the feasibility, safety, and bioactivity of an autologous GM-CSF gene-transduced tumor vaccine for RCC patients.

Induction of immunity to prostate cancer antigens: results of a clinical trial of vaccination with irradiated autologous prostate tumor cells engineered to secrete granulocyte-macrophage colony-stimulating factor using ex vivo gene transfer.

Vaccination with irradiated granulocyte-macrophage colony-stimulating factor (GM-CSF)-secreting gene-transduced cancer vaccines induces tumoricidal immune responses. In a Phase I human gene therapy trial, eight immunocompetent prostate cancer (PCA) patients were treated with autologous, GM-CSF-secreting, irradiated tumor vaccines prepared from ex vivo retroviral transduction of surgically harvested cells. Expansion of primary cultures of autologous vaccine cells was successful to meet trial specifications in 8 of 11 cases (73%); the yields of the primary culture cell limited the number of courses of vaccination. Side effects were pruritus, erythema, and swelling at vaccination sites. Vaccine site biopsies manifested infiltrates of dendritic cells and macrophages among prostate tumor vaccine cells. Vaccination activated new T-cell and B-cell immune responses against PCA antigens. T-cell responses, evaluated by assessing delayed-type hypersensitivity (DTH) reactions against untransduced autologous tumor cells, were evident in two of eight patients before vaccination and in seven of eight patients after treatment. Reactive DTH site biopsies manifested infiltrates of effector cells consisting of CD45RO+ T-cells, and degranulating eosinophils consistent with activation of both Th1 and Th2 T-cell responses. A distinctive eosinophilic vasculitis was evident near autologous tumor cells at vaccine sites, and at DTH sites. B-cell responses were also induced. Sera from three of eight vaccinated men contained new antibodies recognizing polypeptides of 26, 31, and 150 kDa in protein extracts from prostate cells. The 150-kDa polypeptide was expressed by LNCaP and PC-3 PCA cells, as well as by normal prostate epithelial cells, but not by prostate stromal cells. No antibodies against prostate-specific antigen were detected. These data suggest that both T-cell and B-cell immune responses to human PCA can be generated by treatment with irradiated, GM-CSF gene-transduced PCA vaccines.

Retroviral particles produced from a stable human-derived packaging cell line transduce target cells with very high efficiencies.

The goal of this work was to determine whether a stable 293 amphotropic packaging line, which we have designated 293-SPA, is useful for the production of high-titer stable virus by comparison to the murine psiCRIP line. Here, we report our unexpected findings that particles derived from the 293-SPA line transduce target cells (both NIH-3T3 cells and primary melanoma cells) with greatly enhanced efficiencies (at least 10-fold) compared to particles derived from the psiCRIP packaging line. We show that the presence of a transferable inhibitor in the psiCRIP line at least partially accounts for this dramatic difference in transduction efficiency. This work has important implications for improving the efficiency of retrovirus-mediated gene transfer in general as well as in the design of new packaging cell lines.

Sustained expression of high levels of human factor IX from human cells implanted within an immunoisolation device into athymic rodents.

Immunoisolation of allogeneic cells within a membrane-bound device is a unique approach for gene therapy. We employed an immunoisolation device that protects allograft, but not xenograft, cells from destruction, to implant a human fibroblast line (MSU 1.2) in athymic rodents. Cells, transduced with the MFG-human factor IX retroviral vector, and expressing 0.9 microg/10(6) cells/day in vitro, were implanted in rats (four 40-microl devices, each containing 2 x 10(7) cells, two subcutaneously, two in epididymal fat) and in mice (two 20-microl devices, each containing 2 x 10(6) cells, subcutaneously). Plasma factor IX levels increased for 50 days, reaching maxima of 203 ng/ml (rat) and 597 ng/ml (mouse), and both continued at greater than 100 ng/ml for more than 140 days. A clone derived from the transduced cells, making 5 microg of factor IX/10(6) cells/day, was implanted within a device (one 20-microl device containing 2.5 x 10(6) cells), or without a device (1 x 10(7) cells implanted freely), either subcutaneously or in epididymal fat. The freely implanted cells expressed transiently, reaching more than 100 ng/ml in each site by day 4, but dropped to zero by day 20 (subcutaneous) or day 90 (epididymal fat). In devices, levels gradually increased to 100 ng/ml (subcutaneous) or 300 ng/ml (epididymal fat), remaining high for more than 100 days. These results show long-term, high-level expression of a human protein: (1) when cells are implanted within a cell transplantation device, but not when the cells are freely implanted, and (2) from a transgene driven by a viral promoter. An alloprotective device will enable the use of cloned cell lines that can be subjected to stringent quality control assessment that is impossible to achieve with autologous approaches.

Efficient and stable adeno-associated virus-mediated transduction in the skeletal muscle of adult immunocompetent mice.

Recombinant adeno-associated virus (rAAV) vectors were evaluated for gene transfer into the skeletal muscle of adult immunocompetent mice. A study using a vector encoding nuclear localized beta-galactosidase (rAAV-nls-lacZ) examined: (i) the efficiency and duration of transgene expression; (ii) the status of the AAV genome in the transduced fibers; and (iii) the possibility of improving gene transfer by inducing muscle regeneration. In the absence of regeneration, the injection of 1.7 x 10(7) particles in the quadriceps resulted in gene transfer to 10-70% of myofibers. Histological analysis indicated that the vector was able to reach myofiber nuclei distant from the injection point. Cellular infiltrates were absent at early time points but became conspicuous in the vicinity of some positive fibers at 4-8 weeks and subsided by 26 weeks. Southern analysis indicated that one to three copies of the vector genome were present per cell genome equivalent. They were associated with high-molecular-weight DNA in the form of tandem oligomers or interlocked circles. Gene transfer was not facilitated in the regenerating muscle. Rather, an early inflammatory response resulted in the elimination of most positive fibers after 8 weeks. The presence of regenerated fibers with beta-galactosidase-positive nuclei suggested that myoblasts had been transduced and were able to fuse to form new fibers. Gene transfer in the absence of immune reactions against the transgene product was studied by injecting mice with a rAAV carrying the murine erythropoietin (mEpo) cDNA. Dose-dependent elevation in the hematocrit was measured for over 200 days and corresponded to 5- to 20-fold increases in plasma Epo levels. We conclude that AAV vectors efficiently and stably transduce post-mitotic muscle fibers and myoblasts in vivo.

Formation of lentivirus particles by mammalian cells infected with recombinant fowlpox virus.

Recombinant fowlpox viruses (FPV) containing the env or gag-pol genes of simian immunodeficiency virus from macaques (SIVmac) were constructed. The env, gag, and pol-encoded polypeptides were efficiently expressed and processed in avian cells productively infected with FPV as well as in mammalian cells, in which FPV infection is abortive. In addition, the recombinant FPV expressing the gag-pol genes directed the formation of defective, lentivirus-like particles which were released into the culture medium of infected cells. Coinfection of cells with the env and gag-pol recombinant viruses resulted in the generation of particles containing SIVmac envelope glycoprotein. The applications of this system to vaccine development are discussed.

Cancer cells engineered to secrete granulocyte-macrophage colony-stimulating factor using ex vivo gene transfer as vaccines for the treatment of genitourinary malignancies.

When irradiated and administered intradermally as vaccines, cancer cells engineered to secrete high levels of granulocyte-macrophage colony-stimulating factor (GM-CSF) by gene transfer elicit potent anticancer immune responses in a variety of animal tumor models. Upon vaccination, antigens present in the cancer cells are phagocytosed and processed by skin dendritic cells. These dendritic cells then prime anticancer immune responses by presenting antigenic peptides to T cells. The immune responses generated are capable of eradicating small but lethal cancer cell inocula with minimal toxicity in preclinical animal tumor studies. To develop this vaccination strategy for the treatment of human genitourinary cancers, we have conducted phase I clinical trials using human genitourinary cancer cells as sources of cancer cell antigens. In the first human clinical trial of genetically engineered cancer cell vaccines, a phase I clinical trial of kidney cancer cell vaccines (n = 18), kidney cancer cells were removed at surgery, propagated briefly in vitro, and then genetically modified to secrete high levels of GM-CSF via ex vivo transduction with the retrovirus MFG-GM-CSF. After irradiation, the kidney cancer cells were administered as vaccines to 18 patients with advanced kidney cancers. Vaccine treatment, which caused few side effects, nonetheless appeared to trigger anticancer immune responses manifest as conversion of delayed-type hypersensitivity (DTH) skin responses against irradiated autologous cancer cells after vaccination. Biopsies of vaccine sites yielded findings reminiscent of biopsies from preclinical animal model studies, with evidence of vaccine cell recruitment of dendritic cells, T cells, and eosinophils. One patient with measurable kidney cancer metastases treated at the highest vaccine dose level experienced a partial treatment response. The bioactivity of GM-CSF-secreting autologous cancer cell vaccines was confirmed in a phase I clinical trial for prostate cancer (n = 8). Vaccine cells were prepared from surgically harvested prostate tumors by ex vivo transduction with MFG-GM-CSF in a manner similar to that used for the kidney cancer trial. Vaccine treatment was well tolerated and associated with induction of anticancer immunity as assessed using DTH skin testing. In addition, new antiprostate cancer cell antibodies were detected in serum samples from treated men as a consequence of vaccination. These first clinical trials of GM-CSF-secreting cancer cell vaccines for the treatment of genitourinary cancers have demonstrated both safety and bioactivity, in that very few side effects have been seen and anticancer immune responses have been detected. Future clinical studies will be required to assess vaccine treatment efficacy, refine vaccination dose and schedule, define the appropriate clinical context for the use of such vaccines, and ascertain optimal combinations involving vaccines and other local or systemic anticancer treatments.

Social sciences research: ethical and policy implications.

Ethical issues are raised about the conduct of social research in the dental field particularly with respect to the use of survey methodology and aggregated data. Problems associated with respondent identifiers, open-ended and probing questioning, privacy of subject-matter, community contamination and burden, group stereotyping, knowledge of law violations, mis-use of data banks, re-use of data, effects of disclosure, and referral for treatment are discussed. The natural and the contrived social experiments are reviewed as well as the issue of needed research on the effects of regulation on science and on the protection of privacy.

Converting unmet need for care to effective demand.

Strategies to lower the barriers to both the receipt of personal dental services and to self-care are discussed in the light of the supporting body of socio-dental research. Planning to reach populations in need of care but who have not obtained such care involves both external marketing strategies as well as subsequent internal marketing strategies. Modifications of elements in the dental care delivery system, and approaches which impact on personal lifestyles of populations in need of care as well as on their environments, constitute a comprehensive marketing plan.

Transactions of an international conference. Worldwide concern: better dental care for more people. An international collaborative study. How the study was designed.

The study originated from the common need felt by the United States Public Health Service and the World Health Organization for objective information about various national dental care delivery systems and their effectiveness in the societies in which they were used. The relationships between consumers, providers and administrators within each system were emphasized rather than the comparison between systems since each operated within a specific biological and ecological environment. Six systems all of which had been in existence for at least twenty years were originally selected for study to encompass those dependent on a majority of government or private enterprise, use or non-use of auxiliaries, differeing systems of financing and of definition of target groups for receipt of services. The countries originally taking part were Australia, the Federal Republic of Germany, Japan, New Zealand, Norway and Bulgaria, though Bulgaria withdrew early in 1975.

Promoting oral health: guidelines for dental associations.

Dental associations throughout the world face many new challenges. For example, many industrial countries confront the potential of excess manpower to meet current demands, while developing countries try to cope with scarce resources to control existing and increasing disease levels. This guide is intended to facilitate the development of oral promotion programmes in both situations. In industrialized countries, an oral health promotion programme should increase awareness and interest among consumers, thus facilitating the conversion of unmet need to demand. In developing countries, the oral health promotion guidelines demonstrate ways to extend resources to meet a broader base of need. In all countries, oral health promotion can demonstrate the benefit of self-care and emphasize the consumer's responsibility for personal health. Dental associations enjoy a long history of promoting oral health, yet developing a coherent programme or realizing the results of these efforts can sometimes be disappointing or frustrating. The guide is organized around a recommended sequence of activities: policy formation and dissemination; planning group; information gathering; goal setting; strategic planning; implementation; and evaluation. This document presents guidelines, not recipes. Given the range of economic, social and health needs of the Fédération Dentaire Internationale member countries, a recipe would be inappropriate. These guidelines can be tailored to the needs of your association based on the oral health needs of your population. They can be used to determine new or modified policies, to assess long- and short-term goals, to monitor progress and to educate the membership. Case studies derived from actual experiences of dental associations as they planned and analysed their efforts to promote oral health are presented. This information is included to highlight different approaches as well as problems encountered. The case studies illustrate various parts of the planning implementation and evaluation process, while the text should serve as a comprehensive review of all these components.

Leadership role of dental associations: oral health promotion.

'Promoting Oral Health: Guidelines for Dental Associations' is the product of Working Group 3 on Oral Health Promotion of the Commission on Oral Health, Research and Epidemiology of the FDI. This paper describes the guidelines document, its rationale and its potential utility. An organized planned sequence of activities, including policy formation and dissemination, planning group structure and function, information gathering, goal setting, strategic planning of objectives and interventions, implementation as well as monitoring and evaluation, are reviewed. Relevant to both industrialized and developing countries, these oral health promotion guidelines can be used to develop programmes to demonstrate the benefit of self-care and appropriate demand for dental services.

Women as leaders.

The role of women as leaders has undergone considerable review in recent years, both outside and within the dental profession. Growing awareness of gender as an issue in leadership has focused attention on leadership styles and qualities with particular emphasis on the differences between male and female approaches. Further research is proposed, specifically on leadership within the dental profession. Trends are identified which lead to optimistic conclusions as to the future involvement of women in leadership in dentistry.

Toward the formulation of sociodental indicators.

The bases for the construction of sociodental indicators is discussed in the paper, considering several available indexes of oral health status (dental caries, periodontal disease, malocclusion, oral hygiene, and other oral conditions) as well as measures of quality of services. Very little research exists relating any of the above measures to social indicators such as personal life-style or cultural and ecological factors. Such expansion would enable dental indicators to be useful for purposes of policy decisions. Combining any dental indicators or set of indicators with a potential global social health index is discussed in terms of potential problems obscuring dentistry's cost to society. Dentistry, in addition, is offered as a system in microcosm-one which can be useful for purposes of polishing methodology for the social health indicator movement.