Annual review of patients with sleep apnea/hypopnea syndrome--a pragmatic randomised trial of nurse home visit versus consultant clinic review.

BACKGROUND: This pragmatic randomised, controlled trial investigated annual review of patients with sleep apnea/hypopnea syndrome (SAHS). Clinical outcomes and costs were compared for consultant clinic review versus specialist nurse home visit. METHOD: One hundred and seventy-four patients were randomised to annual review by consultant clinic appointment or by specialist nurse home visit. SAHS symptoms, Epworth score, hospital anxiety and depression scale (HADS), Short Form-36 (SF-36) and hours of use of constant positive airway pressure (CPAP) were measured before and 3 months after review. The costs and patient preference for review were determined. RESULTS: After review, both groups significantly increased CPAP use (mean (SD) increase: nurse, 0.66 (1.71) h; consultant, 0.45 (1.69) h) and reduced symptom scores (nurse, -2 (7); consultant, -3 (9)), compared to baseline. There were no differences between groups in these improvements, or in HADS or SF-36 scores. Average duration of a nurse home visit, excluding travel time, was 26 (6) min. Total NHS cost per visit was 52.26 UK pounds (49.85) ($83.62 (79.76)), of which 6.57 UK pounds (1.43) ($10.51 (2.29)) reflected time spent with the patient and the remainder was travel cost. Average duration of consultant review was 10 (6) min, total NHS cost 6.21 UK pounds (3.99) ($9.94 (6.38)). However, the cost to the patient of attending the clinic was 23.63 UK pounds (23.21) ($37.81 (37.13)). Patient preference for review was nurse 16%, consultant 19%, and no preference 65%. CONCLUSION: Following annual review, use of CPAP increased and symptoms improved. Outcomes were similar for consultant and nurse led review. Home visits were expensive for the healthcare provider, whereas clinic attendance incurred substantial costs to the patient. The majority of patients would accept nurse review for their sleep apnea management.

Genetic testing for hereditary nonpolyposis colorectal cancer.

Approximately 80 per cent of patients with colorectal cancer have sporadic disease whereas the remaining 20 per cent seem to have a genetic component. Hereditary nonpolyposis colorectal cancer (HNPCC) is the most common autosomal dominant hereditary syndrome predisposing to colorectal cancer. Various methods have been described to screen for HNPCC and to directly test for mismatch repair gene mutations. This study evaluates the initial results of 1) microsatellite instability (MSI) and immunohistochemistry (IHC) staining of tumors and 2) genetic sequencing for mismatch repair gene mutations in patients suspected to have HNPCC. Appropriate patients for HNPCC testing were identified through a high-risk colorectal cancer clinic. Of those patients screened only those who met Amsterdam criteria (AC) for HNPCC or were young age onset (YAO) (<40 years of age) were eligible for testing. The tumors underwent testing for MSI and had IHC performed in those patients with available tumor specimens. MSI was performed on the five markers approved by the NIH consensus conference. MSI-High (MSI-H) was defined as two or more markers being unstable. IHC was done with commercially available stains for MLH1 and MSH2. All patients had sequencing of the MLH1 and MSH2 genes performed to search for mutations by a commercial laboratory. Genetic counseling was provided and written informed consent was obtained. Fourteen patients were part of kindreds that met the AC. An additional 10 patients were <40 years of age at diagnosis of colorectal cancer but lacked any family history. Testing for MSI and IHC was performed on those available tissue blocks. Of the AC patients five had MSH2 mutations and two had MLH1 variants. Of the five with MSH2 mutations three of four had MSI-H tumors and all four had loss of expression of MSH2 on IHC. Of the MLH1 variants only one had MSI-H tumor and lacked expression of MLH-1 on IHC. Of those patients with no mutation identified three of six had MSI-H tumors. For those patients YAO no genetic mutations were identified. Two of the seven had MSI-H tumors. Genetic testing for HNPCC even in those patients fulfilling the rigid AC yielded mutations in only five of 14 patients with variants of unknown significance being found in an additional two patients. Only one MSH2 variant of unknown significance was identified in the 10 YAO patients, which would suggest that screening in this group of patients with MSI and/or IHC would be appropriate.

Evaluation of welfare advice in primary care: effect on practice workload and prescribing for mental health.

AIMS: To determine Citizen's Advice Bureaux (CAB) and general practice staff perceptions on the impact of a CAB Health Outreach (CABHO) service on staff workload. To quantify the frequency of mental health issues among patients referred to the CABHO service. To measure any impact of the CABHO service on appointments, referrals and prescribing for mental health. BACKGROUND: GPs and practice managers perceive that welfare rights services, provided by CAB, reduce practice staff workload, but this has not been quantified. METHODS: Interviews with practice managers and GPs hosting and CAB staff providing an advisory service in nine general practices. Comparison of frequency of GP and nurse appointments, mental health referrals and prescriptions for hypnotics/anxiolytics and antidepressants issued before and after referral to the CABHO service, obtained from medical records of referred patients. FINDINGS: Most GPs and CAB staff perceived the service reduced practice staff workload, although practice managers were less certain. CAB staff believed that many patients referred to them had mental health issues. Data were obtained for 148/250 referrals of whom 46% may have had a mental health issue. There were statistically significant reductions in the number of GP appointments and prescriptions for hypnotics/anxiolytics during the six months after referral to CABHO compared with six months before. There were also non-significant reductions in nurse appointments and prescriptions for antidepressants, but no change in appointments or referrals for mental health problems. The quantitative findings therefore confirmed perceptions among both CAB and practice staff of reduced workload and in addition suggest that prescribing may be reduced, although further larger-scale studies are required to confirm this.